Item 5 North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee 16 January 2020 Miscellaneous Items (a) Development Management Please note that the appeal documentation for each of the applications listed below can be found by clicking on the application reference number. Hearings and Inquiries None Appeals Received Reference Number Appellants Name and Description Location NYM/2019/0062/AGRP Mr J Martin - c/o agent Erection of agricultural livestock Mrs Cheryl Ward building Land and barn to the east of Whorlton House Farm, Whorlton Lane, Whorlton Appeals Determined None (b) Enforcement Appeal documentation relating to an enforcement matter is currently only available on request. Hearings and Inquiries None Appeals Received None Appeals Determined None (c) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 1. [NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given]. (d) List of Enforcement Matters Determined by the Director of Planning A list of enforcement matters determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 2. Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer) Chris France Director of Planning Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports - dates as given 3022/1 2. Signed letter - dates as given 3024/1 Location North York Moors National Park Authority The Old Vicarage, Bondgate, Helmsley, York, YO62 5BP Appendix 1 List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 19/11/2019 to 18/12/2019 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 2015 Please note that the decision notice for each of the Authority’s applications listed in this report can be found by clicking on the application reference number. York Potash/Sirius Minerals Delegated Applications None Applications Hambleton NYM/2018/0324/FL Approved 22/11/2019 alterations and extensions to domestic building to form residential annexe accommodation together with construction of double garage at 14 North End, Osmotherley for Mrs P Duggan NYM/2019/0626/FL Approved 02/12/2019 alterations and construction of garden room following demolition of existing conservatory together with installation of replacement timber windows at Brook House, Swainby for Ms Fiona Smith NYM/2019/0665/FL Approved 04/12/2019 alterations, construction of two storey rear extension and detached garage (revised scheme following withdrawal of NYM/2017/0494/CU/FL) at Beech House, Carlton Village, Carlton In Cleveland for Mr Marcus Ramsden NYM/2019/0666/LB Granted 04/12/2019 Listed Building Consent for internal and external alterations together with construction of two storey rear extension and repointing of the front elevation (revised scheme following refusal of NYM/2017/0495/LB) at Beech House, Carlton Village, Carlton In Cleveland for Mr Marcus Ramsden NYM/2019/0677/FL Approved 26/11/2019 alterations and construction of single storey rear extension at Winander, Carlton Village, Carlton In Cleveland for Mr & Mrs M Cinderey NYM/2019/0679/FL Approved 03/12/2019 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2018/0031/FL to allow alterations to internal layout, roof pitch, rooflights, windows and doors at Watson Scout Centre, Carlton in Cleveland for North Yorkshire County Scout Council NYM/2019/0682/FL Approved 02/12/2019 alterations to front porch, construction of single storey extension and replacement dormer window together with alterations to garage to enable use as additional living accommodation (revised scheme following refusal of NYM/2019/0492/FL) at Rivendell, Kirk Ings Lane, Over Silton for Mr & Mrs Wells NYM/2019/0699/LB Granted 03/12/2019 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of Listed Building consent NYM/2018/0032/LB to allow alterations to internal layout, roof pitch, rooflights, windows and doors at Watson Scout Centre, Carlton Village for North Yorkshire County Scout Council NYM/2019/0701/FL Approved 04/12/2019 change of use of land to form manege for hobby use and siting of a horse walker at Garbutt Farm, Cold Kirby for Miss Amy Ryan NYM/2019/0714/FL Approved 12/12/2019 construction of extensions, installation of replacement and additional windows together with rendering/stone cladding at Overbeck Cottage, Kildale for Mr & Mrs Bettinson NYM/2019/0719/FL Approved 10/12/2019 installation of interpretation board at land near The Warren, Hill Road, Kirkby in Cleveland for Kirkby-in-Cleveland Parish Council NYM/2019/0722/FL Approved 03/12/2019 variation of condition 5 of planning approval NYM/2018/0800/FL to allow a change in roof material from clay pantile to fibre cement sheeting at Clay House, Chopgate for Mr Michael O'Neill NYM/2019/0753/FL Approved 17/12/2019 installation of replacement windows and doors and enlargement of door opening to extension to allow the installation of bi-fold doors at The Old Mill, Osmotherley for Mr Steven Denos NYM/2019/0770/FL Approved 17/12/2019 installation of flue at Laundry Cottage, Boltby for Mrs Sarah Ashby Ryedale NYM/2019/0013/LB Granted 28/11/2019 Listed Building consent for internal alterations and installation of replacement windows and doors at Brook Farm House, Brook Lane, Thornton-Le-Dale for Mr A Foster & Ms R Buckley NYM/2019/0456/FL Approved 26/11/2019 construction of 7 no. additional log cabins for holiday purposes at Studford Luxury Lodges, High Street, Ampleforth for Mr Fawcett NYM/2019/0527/LB Granted 21/11/2019 Listed Building consent for repointing, re-rendering, installation of soil vent pipe, works to the roof, installation of replacement timber double glazed windows, demolition of lean-to structure to west elevation and internal alterations to dwelling together with refurbishment works to link extension and outbuildings at Park Gate Farmhouse, Blansby Park Lane, Pickering for Mr Ian Bartlett NYM/2019/0540/FL Refused 26/11/2019 construction of porch at Low Harland Cottage, Daleside Road, Farndale for Mr Stephen Hall NYM/2019/0592/FL Approved 21/11/2019 installation of oil tank and erection of picket fence and landscaping works at Park Gate Farmhouse, Blansby Park Lane, Pickering for Duchy of Lancaster NYM/2019/0600/FL Approved 17/12/2019 improvement works to entrance and car parking area, restoration of footpath and replacement interpretation at nature reserve west of A169 and south of Ellerbeck for Yorkshire Wildlife Trust NYM/2019/0656/FL Approved 13/12/2019 installation of 4 no. replacement uPVC windows at 23 Castle Court, Helmsley for Mrs Patricia Farmer NYM/2019/0683/FL Approved 28/11/2019 erection of boundary fence and garden shed to rear at 46 Ashwood Close, Helmsley for Mr & Mrs N Ridley NYM/2019/0694/FL Refused 03/12/2019 construction of 1 no. open market dwelling with attached double garage, access, parking, amenity space and landscaping works at land off Hallgarth Lane, Thornton-le-Dale for A & D Sturdy Ltd NYM/2019/0698/FL Approved 13/12/2019 construction of replacement garage/utility room at Westbourne, Roxby Road, Thornton le Dale for Paul Charles NYM/2019/0701/FL Approved 04/12/2019 change of use of land to form manege for hobby use and siting of a horse walker at Garbutt Farm, Cold Kirby for Miss Amy Ryan NYM/2019/0715/FL Approved 09/12/2019 construction of single storey side extension at Kirkfield House, South Lane, Thornton le Dale for Mrs Alison Williams NYM/2019/0721/FL Approved 13/12/2019 construction of pitched roof over existing store at Feversham Arms, Mill Lane, Church Houses, Kirkbymoorside for Feversham Arms NYM/2019/0734/FL Approved 17/12/2019 alterations to building, siting of 6 no. caravans to provide overflow accommodation and access improvements at Former School Building, Stape Road, Pickering for North Yorkshire Moors Railway NYM/2019/0742/FL Approved 27/11/2019 installation of replacement windows at Brick Cottage, Daleside Road, Rosedale East for Mrs Shirley Drew Scarborough NYM/2019/0377/FL Approved 22/11/2019 demolition of detached outbuilding existing toilets and construction of single storey side extension to Church Rooms at Methodist Church, Bridge Green, Danby for Danby Methodist Chapel Committee NYM/2019/0556/FL Approved 21/11/2019 replacement material to roof of 3 no. dormer windows at 38 Main Road, Aislaby for Mr Mark Sheen NYM/2019/0608/FL Approved 21/11/2019 erection of agricultural storage building following demolition of existing structures at Ripleys Farm, Ripleys Road, Cloughton for G R Turnbull & Sons LTD NYM/2019/0627/FL Approved 26/11/2019 alterations and construction of two storey extension, enlargement of covered entrance, recladding of dwelling and alterations to garage and replacement store at Trinket Wood, Ellergates, Lealholm for Mr M Dorman NYM/2019/0634/FL Approved 26/11/2019 construction of single storey side extension and replacement conservatory at 8 Hinderwell Lane, Runswick Bay for Mr & Mrs C Pouncey NYM/2019/0640/FL Refused 29/11/2019 alterations and construction of two storey extension at Little Shortwaite, Lealholm for Mr C Davies NYM/2019/0646/LB Granted 20/11/2019 Listed Building consent for removal of existing vent and replacement vent in cellar wall at Goathland Station House, Goathland for North York Moors Historical Railway Trust NYM/2019/0669/FL Approved 20/11/2019 construction of porch at Rake Cottage, Thorney Waite, Glaisdale for Mr & Mrs Yendall NYM/2019/0673/FL Refused 25/11/2019 conversion of garage/stores to 1 no.