Brooklyn Law School BrooklynWorks Faculty Scholarship 4-2019 Afrofuturism, Critical Race Theory, and Policing in the Year 2044 I. Bennett aC pers Brooklyn Law School, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://brooklynworks.brooklaw.edu/faculty Part of the Law and Race Commons Recommended Citation 94 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 1 (2019) This Article is brought to you for free and open access by BrooklynWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Scholarship by an authorized administrator of BrooklynWorks. NEW YORK UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW VOLUME 94 APRIL 2019 NUMBER 1 ARTICLES AFROFUTURISM, CRITICAL RACE THEORY, AND POLICING IN THE YEAR 2044 I. BENNETr CAPERS* In 2044, the United States is projected to become a "majority-minority" country, with people of color making up more than half of the population. And yet in the public imagination-from Robocop to Minority Report, from Star Trek to Star Wars, from A Clockwork Orange to 1984 to Brave New World-the future is usu- ally envisioned as majority white. What might the future look like in year 2044, when people of color make up the majority in terms of numbers, or in the ensuing years, when they also wield the majority of political and economic power? And specifically, what might policing look like? This Article attempts to answer these questions by examining how artists, cybertheorists, and speculative scholars of color-Afrofuturists and Critical Race Theorists-have imagined the future. What can we learn from Afrofuturism, the term given to "speculative fiction that treats African-American themes and addresses African-American concerns [in the con- text of] techno culture?" And what can we learnfrom Critical Race Theory and its "father" Derrick Bell, who famously wrote of space explorers to examine issues of race and law? What do they imagine policing to be, and what can we imagine policing to be in a brown and black world? * Copyright @ 2019 by I. Bennett Capers, Stanley A. August Professor of Law, Brooklyn Law School. B.A. Princeton University; J.D. Columbia Law School. Assistant U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York 1995-2004. Email: Bennett.capers@ brooklaw.edu. This Article benefited from presentations at Buffalo Law School and at the CrimFest Colloquium at Cardozo Law School. For comments, suggestions, and feedback, I am especially grateful to Christopher Slobogin, Kate Levine, Lauren Ouziel, India Thusi, Alexis Karteron, Ric Simmons, Julia Simon-Kerr, Jordan Woods, Jocelyn Simonson, Ekow Yankaw, Adnan Zulfiqar, Craig Konnoth, Grace E. Howard, Yehonatan Givati, Guyora Binder, Luis Chiesa, Michael Boucai, John Schlegel, Athena Mutua, Allan Eggleston, Roger Ross, Seth Michael Forman, Narciso Saavedra, and Carl Mandlebaum. Hdctor A. Mel6ndez-Franco provided invaluable research assistance. I also owe a special thanks to Sarah M. Taitz and the staff of the New York University Law Review for their outstanding editorial assistance. This article also benefited from a generous research grant from Brooklyn Law School. 1 Imaged with Permission of N.Y.U. Law Review 2 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW [Vol. 94:1 INTRODUCTION ................................................. 2 I. AFROFUTURISM ......................................... 6 A. Afrofuturism: A Primer.......................... 7 B. Wakanda Forever! ............................. 17 II. CRITICAL RACE THEORY AND ITS CHRONICLES ........ 20 III. THE YEAR 2044 AND BEYOND..................... 30 A. Black to the Future, or Fear of a Black Planet ...... 30 B. Policing in the Year 2044 and Beyond .............. 39 1. Societal Changes ................................ 39 2. Technology ..................................... 40 3. Policing ......................................... 48 C ONCLUSION ................................................... 58 INTRODUCTION By 2044, the United States will likely be a "majority-minority" country, with people of color making up more than half of the popula- tion.1 And yet in the public imagination-from Robocop to Minority Report, from Star Trek to Star Wars, from A Clockwork Orange to 1984 to Brave New World-the future is usually envisioned as majority white. What might the future look like in the year 2044, when people of color make up the majority in terms of numbers, or in the ensuing years, when they also wield the majority of political and eco- nomic power? And specifically, what might policing look like? This Article attempts to answer these questions by examining how artists, cybertheorists, and speculative scholars of color-Afrofuturists and Critical Race Theorists-have imagined the future. What can we learn from Afrofuturism, the term given to "speculative fiction that treats African-American themes and addresses African-American concerns in the context of . .. technoculture?" 2 And what can we learn from Critical Race Theory (CRT) and its "father" Derrick Bell, who 1 See SANDRA L. COLBY & JENNIFER M. ORTMAN, U.S. CENSUS BUREAU, REPORT No. P25-1143, PROJECTIONS OF THE SIZE AND COMPOSITION OF THE U.S. POPULATION: 2014 To 2060, at 9 (2015), https://census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2015/ demo/p25-1143.pdf (projecting a majority-minority country by the year 2044). Projections further indicate that by the year 2060, whites will make up just 44% of the U.S. population, while people of color will make up 56%. Id. Specifically, Hispanics will make up 29% of the population, blacks will make up 14%, Asians will make up 9.3%, Native Americans and Pacific Islanders will make up 1%, and multiracial individuals will make up 6.2%. Id. at 9-10. The Census Bureau also projects that by 2060, 64% of all children in the United States will be children of color. Id. at 10-11. 2 See Mark Dery, Black to the Future: Interviews with Samuel R. Delany, Greg Tate, and Tricia Rose, in FLAME WARS: THE DISCOURSE OF CYBERCULTURE 179, 180 (Mark Dery ed., 1994). Imaged with Permission of N.Y.U. Law Review April 2019] AFROFUTURISM, CRITICAL RACE THEORY, AND POLICING 3 famously wrote of space explorers 3 to examine issues of race and law? 4 What do they imagine policing to be, and what can we imagine policing to be in a brown and black world? As should be apparent by now, this is not a typical law review article, identifying a discrete problem in the law and offering a norma- tive solution.5 This Article aspires to accomplish something different, and in a sense, more ambitious. Rather than imagining how things could be different in the near term, this Article imagines how things could be different decades from now. It offers not just a vision of the future, but something truly visionary. To be sure, there have been a handful of speculative legal articles before. There is George Thomas's oft-cited article Time Travel, Hovercrafts, and the Framers.6 And there is Derrick Bell's The Space Traders.7 There was once even a vibrant movement to usher in a decidedly new type of scholarship-futurist scholarship-to engage seriously with nascent and yet-to-be technologies with the goal of imagining the distant future, and the law's role in that future.8 While my hope is that this Article will revive interest in futurist scholarship, my particular interest is in a subset of futurism: Afrofuturism. There are two reasons for this. One, most artistic visions of the future have been majority white, and given projected demographic shifts showing that America will likely be majority minority by the year 2044, it makes sense to consider how black and brown people have imagined the future. As one commentator has noted, "while our collective imaginings too often fall far short of a convincing alternative future, Afrofuturism has been proposing ways forward for decades." 9 The 3 DERRICK BELL, The Space Traders, in FACES AT THE BoTTOM OF THE WELL: THE PERMANENCE OF RACISM 158 (1992). 4 For a discussion of Derrick Bell's influence on Critical Race Theory (CRT), see Patricia Williams, Tribute to Derrick Bell, 69 N.Y.U. ANN. SURv. AM. L. 7 (2013). 5 Not that there is anything wrong with typical law review articles. 6 George C. Thomas HI, Time Travel, Hovercrafts, and the Framers: James Madison Sees the Future and Rewrites the Fourth Amendment, 80 NOTRE DAME L. REv. 1451 (2005). 7 BELL, supra note 3. Other legal futurist articles include Anthony J. Casey & Anthony Niblett, The Death of Rules and Standards, 92 IND. L.J. 1401 (2017); James E. Jones, Jr., Equal Employment Law in the Twenty-First Century, 39 OMO ST. L.J. 700 (1978); Daniel Martin Katz, Quantitative Legal Prediction-or-HowI Learned to Stop Worrying and Start Preparingfor the Data-Driven Future of the Legal Services Industry, 62 EMORY L.J. 909 (2013); Richard M. Re, Imagining Perfect Surveillance, 64 UCLA L. REv. DISCOURSE 264 (2016); Barton Beebe, Note, Law's Empire and the Final Frontier: Legalizing the Future in Early Corpus Juris Spatialis, 108 YALE L.J. 1737 (1999). 8 See generally David A. Funk, Legal Futurology: The Field and Its Literature, 73 LAW LIBR. J. 625 (1980) (offering an early bibliography of legal futurist writing). 9 Amah-Rose McKnight-Abrams, The New Afrofuturism, VICE: GARAGE (Feb. 9, 2018, 12:08 PM), https://garage.vice.com/en-us/article/437wq3/the-new-afrofuturism. Imaged with Permission of N.Y.U. Law Review 4 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW [Vol. 94:1 second reason is more personal. Like Patricia Williams, I readily acknowledge that "subject position is everything in my analysis of the law." 10 Afrofuturism, like Critical Race Theory, speaks to me as a black man. Indeed, one could even argue that my blackness invites speculation.