Minutes of a Meeting of the Industrial Commission of North Dakota Held on December 8, 2016 beginning at 1:00 p.m. Governor’s Conference Room State Capitol Present: Governor Jack Dalrymple, Chairman Attorney General Wayne Stenehjem Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring Also Present: Jaret Wirtz, WAWSA Doug Burgum, Governor-Elect JoDee Hanson, Governor Burgum Elect’s Staff Jason Nisbet, Governor’s Office Bonnie Storbakken, Governor’s Office Jessica Pfaff, Agriculture Department Pat Nagel, Housing Finance Agency Mindy Piatz, Brady Martz Don Larson, Odney Craig Hanson, Bank of North Dakota Members of the Press Governor Dalrymple called the Industrial Commission meeting to order at 1:00 p.m. and the Commission took up Western Area Water Supply Authority (WAWS) business. Ms. Karlene Fine, Industrial Commission Executive Director/Secretary, presented the Western Area Water Supply Authority November Financial Report and Debt Reduction Report as follows: (The complete report is available in the Commission files.) RE: Western Area Water Supply Authority - Industrial Sales - November, 2016 & Debt Repayment Report Attached is the Western Area Water Supply Authority (WAWS) financial information for the month of November, 2016. Page 1 prepared by the Bank of North Dakota, reflects debt service payments through the month of November, 2016. In November interest was paid on the two BND loans and two Water Commission loans and principal was paid on the $40 million BND loan. In addition a principal payment of $5,123.00 was made on BND Loan #1 as a result of the higher sales revenue in the month of October. The next 3 pages (pages 2, 3 & 4) I prepared based on the information provided by WAWS staff reflecting November revenues and expenses and net income. On page 2 you will see there was one capital improvement disbursement (highlighted in orange) which you previously approved. There were two principal payments made in November and they are highlighted in yellow. Net income for the month of November was $2,369.56 before making their principal payments. No baseline sales payments were paid and those deferred costs are reflected on the line item titled Deferred Expense Asset. (As you will recall from the overall Debt Service spread sheet the breakeven sales monthly number is $871,750 without the baseline sales payments. With WAWS sales for the month of November being $684,026.06 they were under that number by $187,724.) Page 5 is the balance sheet prepared by WAWS staff as of November 30, 2016. As noted on the Balance Sheet the Accounts Receivables are $1,837,436.46 which is included in the assets of $6,206,012.91 Note: The assets include a deferred expense line item which reflects the deferred expenses for the Baseline Sales. Governor Dalrymple welcomed Governor-Elect Doug Burgum to the Commission meeting. Minutes - Page 2 December 8, 2016 Mr. Jaret Wirtz, WAWS Executive Director, said November sales of $684,026.06 were lower than what he had previously indicated they would be. That is because they have not billed the operator for the water that they had purchased for two frack jobs that are going on right now. They will be billed when the jobs are finished so there will be a spike in the December or January numbers. The operators prefer that it is done in this manner so WAWS tries to accommodate that. He indicated that they hope to finish strong this year. In response to a question Mr. Wirtz indicated that the industrial sales account is not charged for the related expenses of those frack jobs--expenses are charged only when the revenues are reflected on the financial statements. Whatever WAWS shows on the revenue side is what WAWS expenses out on the industrial side. Mr. Wirtz commented on some opportunities WAWS has for potential sales with the number of uncompleted wells in the area. Ms. Fine said for the month of November the net income was $2,370; year-to-date is $2.4 million and for the biennium would be $2.1 million. In response to a question regarding if WAWS feels the debt they have to the State will someday be repaid, Mr. Wirtz said yes. WAWS has every intention of paying it back and he believes they have the ability to do that. WAWS has already paid approximately $35 million to the State in five years. He noted, however, that there will need to be some modifications to the interest rates and terms because of the slowdown in the oil industry. He indicated that last month WAWS began discussions with the Bank of North Dakota on loan terms and interest rates. He reviewed the interest rates on the various loans -- one loan has an interest rate of 5% which is unheard of in the water business--normally it would be less than 3%. If there are some adjustments to the interest rates and the terms of the loans he believed WAWS would be able to make the debt payments. Mr. Wirtz and the Commission discussed the interest rates and terms that need to be adjusted and whether those changes could be made by the Bank of North Dakota, Water Commission or if the Legislature had to make the changes. He indicated that they would be talking to the Legislature about lowering the 5% interest rate loans down to 2%. He provided the Commission with a chart that showed some options that they are discussing regarding debt service payments. They are trying to find the best option, which is agreeable to everyone, based on $12 million in revenue annually. The goal is to make the payments and pay the entire $190 million in principal plus all the interest costs over time. There was discussion regarding how domestic water sales fit into the picture and whether they should be paying a portion of the debt. Mr. Wirtz provided some background information on legislative actions related to the structuring of the debt for industrial sales and for domestic sales. He pointed out the loans that the domestic water sales have taken on to match grant dollars from the Water Commission following the most recent legislative sessions. In response to a question, Mr. Wirtz indicated that they will have provided rural water hook ups to over 600 residences. There are another 600 waiting for rural water service that will take continued funding which they hope will come during the 2017 legislative session -- the $29 million that is in the Governor’s Budget. There will then still be a couple hundred rural users to reach in areas like Squaw Gap and north of Bowbells where the users are few and far between. The costs for some of those users will be in the $200,000 to $300,000 range compared to the $40,000 to $60,000 range that is more palatable. Those projects may not get done for three or four biennium just because the costs are so high. The end goal is to get everybody water that wants it and that takes a lot of money to get to some of those users. Ms. Fine discussed the Authority’s recommendation for the 2017 Industrial Reimbursement Rate as follows: (The chart is available in the Commission files.) Minutes - Page 3 December 8, 2016 RE: WAWS 2017 Industrial Reimbursement Rate North Dakota Century Code §61-40-10 states in part: 61-40-10. Industrial water depot and lateral sales. ….. b. Reimburse the authority for industrial water depot capital improvements and the cost for delivery of potable or nonpotable water sold at industrial water depots and lateral lines, at a cost no greater than the participating member, or submember, if applicable, entity rate at the location of the depot or lateral line. The Western Area Water Supply Authority (WAWS) Board has recommended that the industrial reimbursement rate for CY 2017 be established as outlined on the attached table. This is a 2% increase from CY 2016. It is my recommendation that you accept the WAWS Board recommendation. Mr. Wirtz reviewed the chart and the map that showed the rates and explained how the rates were determined. (Copies of the map and chart are available in the Commission files.) He indicated that these numbers reflect the WAWS Board 2% increase to the wholesale rates to the member entities. It was moved by Commissioner Goehring and seconded by Attorney General Stenehjem that the Industrial Commission, in accordance with §61-40-10(1)(b) directs the Western Area Water Supply Authority (Authority) to reimburse the Authority and its member entities from the Industrial Account for the cost of delivery of potable or nonpotable water sold from the industrial water depots and laterals for the year 2017 as follows: Minutes - Page 4 December 8, 2016 On a roll call vote, Governor Dalrymple, Attorney General Stenehjem and Commissioner Goehring voted aye. The motion carried unanimously. Ms. Fine discussed the Authority’s recommendation for the 2017 Industrial Water Rate as follows: Minutes - Page 5 December 8, 2016 RE: WAWS 2017 Industrial Rate North Dakota Century Code §61-40-11 states: 61-40-11. Water rates. The authority shall develop an industrial water depot and lateral retail rate and present the rate to the industrial commission for approval. Any industrial water depot and lateral rate adjustment must have approval of the industrial commission before going into effect. The authority shall develop domestic water rates that must include all costs for operation, maintenance, and operating and capital reserves, and debt repayment of all infrastructure managed or constructed by the authority, with the exception of the costs identified in section 61-40-10 which are paid for by industrial water depot and lateral sales.