Godspell Jr. Cast List CHARACTER NAME First Name Last Name RAINBOW GROUP Jesus Daniel Christian Judas William Argall John the Baptist Hunter Franke Day By Day Soloist/King Narrator 1 Bella Becker Day by Day Soloist/King Narrator 2 Denali Kraemer Day by Day Soloist Katherine Stoneman Learn Your Lessons Well Soloist/Samaritan Narrator 1 Kayla Wagner Learn Your Lessons Well Soloist/Samaritan Narrator 2 Elise Benz Learn Your Lessons Well Soloist/Samaritan Narrator 3 Sarah Strube O, Bless The Lord, My Soul Soloist/Rich Man Narrator 1 Ellie Gerndt O, Bless The Lord, My Soul Soloist/Rich Man Narrator 2 Grace DeCroix All Good Gifts Soloist/Shy Child Nathan Heil All Good Gifts Soloist Peter Nowka All Good Gifts Jack Nowka We Beseech Thee Soloist/Son of Man Henry Gabrielski We Beseech Thee Soloist Alex Christy Light Of The World Soloist/First Narrator Allison Ferrigno Light Of The World Soloist/Second Narrator Jori Gasser Beautiful City Soloist #1 Jillian Sytsma Beautiful City Soloist #2 Abigail Sperger RED GROUP Judge Holden Farrell Widow Sydney Steidl King Brennan Pelletier Debtor Tyler Hrabina Debtor's Wife Abby Arciszewski Debtor's Child Maizy Auger Fellow SerVant Eva Perez Other SerVant #1 Sophia Hopp Other SerVant #2 Amelia Heil Other SerVant #3 Brooke Rhoads Others Ella Arciszewski Alyssa Konrad Addison Roswold BLUE GROUP Man Brady Rhoads Robber #1 Morty Arnol Priest Allyson Barth Judge Sarah Reichard Samaritan Natalie Popp Beast Brett Fleming Innkeeper Elisha Cullen Fighting Cast Member #1 Benjamin Hughes Fighting Cast Member #2/Awestruck Cast Member Claire Gibbons Slave Kyleigh Chu Master #1 Tia Waterbury Master #2 Maddie Hoida Rich Man Matthew Jordan YELLOW GROUP Falling Seed Sarah Rhoads Rock Seed Anastasia Leffel Good Seed Isabella Mancusi Weed Seed #1 Alexa Schaefer Weed Seed #2 Jaya Carlson Good Soil Leader Aailyah Johnson DeVil Logan Hopp Good Soil Group Kate Bjorklund Aria Johnson Reese Roswold Alexa Rupnow GREEN GROUP Lost Sheep Lanee Joe Sheep 1 Madeline Moll Sheep 2 Maya Witkowski Sheep 3 Gabi Kiefert Sneaky Goat Jenna Heil Goat Leader Lita Traino Other Goats Annika Curran Sierra Davenport ViVian Neher Evelyn Rinaldo Juliet Hefty Other Sheep Maddie Dahlen Ellie McKillips Lizzie Owens Jocelyn Schuepbach Eleanor Steger Mia VanderMause PURPLE GROUP Father Alex Kiefert Younger Brother Jackson Vilker Elder Brother Will Popp Landowner Gabe Graf SerVant Eric Swartz Pigs Nathan Armstrong Payton Key Dylan McKillips Will Rinaldo Chris Woller Party Goers Amanda Armstrong Emma Collins Anna Meyer Claire Rozeski.