Virginia LaVOLw. 62/NO. y5 • DeECEMrBER 2013 The Official Publication of the Virginia State Bar Special section inside on the Virginia Law Foundation: Forty years of philanthropy, justice, education, and the rule of law. feature articles by the Virginia Association of Law Libraries www.vsb.org Appeals When it comes time to appeal or to resist an appeal, call Steve Emmert at (757) 965-5021. L. STEVEN EMMERT Rated AV www.virginia-appeals.com by Martindale Hubbell [email protected] SYKES, BOURDON, AHERN & LEVY VIRGINIA BEACH Virginia Lawyer The Official Publication of the Virginia State Bar December 2013 Volume 62 / Number 5 Features LAW LIBRARIES 15 Law Libraries and Options Galore 45 Increasing Your “App”titude: Legal Research Apps by Gail F. Zwirner for Virginia Practitioners by Marie Summerlin Hamm 16 Appellate Research Lessons from the Judges by Benjamin A. Doherty 49 A Much Debated Debt: The Virginia –West Virginia Debt Controversy 20 Discovering E-Discovery: a Resources Guide by Gregory H. Stoner by Timothy L. Coggins 53 Virginia CLE Sources: Important Practitioner 24 Solving Your Ethical Conundrums: Researching Tools for Forty Years the Rules of Professional Conduct by Gail F. Zwirner by Joyce Manna Janto VIRGINIA LAW FOUNDATION 30 The VLF Celebrates Forty Years of Philanthropy 39 VLF Grant Fuels JusticeServer Expansion by James V. Meath and Manuel A. Capsalis by Alexandra S. Fannon 32 One Barn at a Time (Being Good and Doing Great) 41 Public Service Internship Program: An Investment by Raymond M. White in the Community and Future Lawyers by Dana M. Fallon 34 Center Spreads the Rule of Law Project by G. Michael Pace Jr. 42 2013 Oliver Hill/Samuel Tucker Pre-Law Institute by Latoya C. Asia and Providence E. Napoleon 36 Museum Exhibit Represents the Greatest Example of Rule of Law in History 43 Virginia CLE Helps Attorneys to Help Others by Irving M. Blank by Raymond M. White 38 VLF Grant Has Powered Critical Virginia Capital 44 The Arc of Opportunity Defense Training by Manuel A. Capsalis by David I. Bruck Access to Legal Services Departments 56 Harrisonburg Attorneys Honored for Pro Bono Work 63 Forum 64 An Effective Model for Misdemeanor Courts and the Noteworthy Mentally Ill Defendant VSB NEWS ET AL. by the Hon. Joseph A. Migliozzi Jr. 67 CLE Calendar 57 Highlights of the October 4, 59 Task Force Offers 2013, Virginia State Bar Recommendations to Improve 69 Professional Notices Council Meeting Legal Writing 70 Classified Ads 57 Weiner Is President-elect 60 Supreme Court Exhibit Designee of the VSB Highlights the History of the PEOPLE VSB and VBA Columns 60 Trees for Virginia 58 In Memoriam 8 President’s Message 58 Local and Specialty Bar 10 Executive Director’s Message Elections 61 Consultus Electronica Cover: Among the many beneficiaries supported by the Virginia Law Foundation during its forty-year history is the Court Appointed Special Advocacy program. (Photo courtesy of National CASA Association) Virginia Lawyer Virginia State Bar The Official Publication of the Virginia State Bar 2013–14 OFFICERS 17th Circuit Sharon D. Nelson, Fairfax, President Raymond B. Benzinger, Arlington http://www.vsb.org Kevin E. Martingayle, Virginia Beach, President- John H. Crouch, Arlington elect Harry A. Dennis, III, Arlington Editor: W. David Harless, Richmond, Immediate Past Adam D. Elfenbein, Arlington Rodney A. Coggin President David A. Oblon, Arlington Karen A. Gould, Executive Director and Chief ([email protected]) 18th Circuit Operating Officer Alan S. Anderson, Alexandria Assistant Editor: EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE Foster S. B. Friedman, Alexandria Gordon Hickey Sharon D. Nelson, Fairfax, President Carolyn M. Grimes, Alexandria ([email protected]) Kevin E. Martingayle, President-elect 19th Circuit W. David Harless, Richmond, Immediate Past Susan M. Butler, Fairfax Advertising: President Peter D. Greenspun, Fairfax Linda McElroy Alan S. Anderson, Alexandria Paul W. Hammack, Jr., Fairfax Doris H. Causey, Richmond ([email protected]) Joyce M. Henry-Schargorodski, Fairfax Donna Sue Baker Cox, Wise Sean P. Kelly, Fairfax Tracy A. Giles, Roanoke Graphic Design and Production: Daniel B. Krisky, Fairfax Ray W. King, Norfolk Luis A. Perez, Falls Church Caryn B. Persinger William L. Schmidt, Fairfax ([email protected]) William B. Porter, Fairfax Kenneth L. Alger, II, Luray, YLC President Dennis J. Quinn, Vienna Eugene M. Elliott, Jr., Roanoke, CLBA Chair Catherine M. Reese, Fairfax John M. Oakey, Richmond, SLC Chair Michael W. Robinson, Tysons Corner VIRGINIA LAWYER (USPS 660-120, ISSN 0899-9473) Rupen R. Shah, Staunton, DC Chair William L. Schmidt, Fairfax is published ten times a year in alternating COUNCIL Melinda L. VanLowe, Fairfax James A. Watson, II, Fairfax formats by the Virginia State Bar, Eighth & Main 1st Circuit Building, 707 East Main Street, Suite 1500, Richmond, Nancy G. Parr, Chesapeake 20th Circuit Christine H. Mougin-Boal, Leesburg Virginia 23219-2800; Telephone: (804) 775-0500. 2nd Circuit T. Huntley Thorpe, III, Warrenton Subscription Rates: $18.00 per year for non-members. William Drinkwater, Virginia Beach Judith L. Rosenblatt, Virginia Beach 21st Circuit This material is presented with the understanding that Daniel M. Schieble, Virginia Beach Joan Ziglar, Martinsville the publisher and the authors do not render any legal, 3rd Circuit 22nd Circuit accounting, or other professional service. It is intended Nicholas D. Renninger, Portsmouth Lee H. Turpin, Chatham for use by attorneys licensed to practice law in Virginia. 4th Circuit 23rd Circuit Because of the rapidly changing nature of the law, infor - I. Lionel Hancock, III, Norfolk Mark K. Cathey, Roanoke Tracy A. Giles, Roanoke mation contained in this publication may become out - Ray W. King, Norfolk David W. Lannetti, Norfolk dated. As a result, an attorney using this material must 24th Circuit David B. Neumeyer, Lynchburg always research original sources of authority and update 5th Circuit Carl Phillips “Phil” Ferguson, Suffolk 25th Circuit information to ensure accuracy when dealing with a 6th Circuit Roscoe B. Stephenson, III, Covington specific client’s legal matters. In no event will the Peter D. Eliades, Hopewell 26th Circuit authors, the reviewers, or the publisher be liable for any 7th Circuit W. Andrew Harding, Harrisonburg direct, indirect, or consequential damages resulting from Leonard C. Heath, Jr., Newport News 27th Circuit the use of this material. The views expressed herein are 8th Circuit Richard L. Chidester, Pearisburg not necessarily those of the Virginia State Bar. The inclu - Lesa J. Yeatts, Hampton 28th Circuit sion of an advertisement herein does not include an 9th Circuit Roy F. Evans, Jr., Marion endorsement by the Virginia State Bar of the goods or John Tarley, Jr., Williamsburg 29th Circuit services of the advertiser, unless explicitly stated other - 10th Circuit Joseph M. Bowen, Tazewell wise. Periodical postage paid at Richmond, Virginia, and Robert E. Hawthorne, Kenbridge 30th Circuit other offices. 11th Circuit William E. Bradshaw, Big Stone Gap Dale W. Pittman, Petersburg 31st Circuit 12th Circuit Gifford R. Hampshire, Manassas POSTMASTER: Graham C. Daniels, Chester MEMBERS AT LARGE D. Sue Baker Cox, Wise Send address changes to 13th Circuit Paula S. Beran, Richmond Michael HuYoung, Richmond Virginia State Bar Membership Department Guy C. Crowgey, Richmond Beverly P. Leatherbury, Eastville Eighth & Main Building Doris Henderson Causey, Richmond Darrel Tillar Mason, Manakin Sabot Nancy C. Dickenson, Abingdon 707 East Main Street, Suite 1500 Christy E. Kiely, Richmond George W. Marget, III, Richmond Todd A. Pilot, Alexandria Richmond, Virginia 23219-2800 Eric M. Page, Richmond Savalle C. Sims, Silver Spring, MD O. Randolph Rollins, Richmond Lorrie A. Sinclair, Leesburg Edna R. Vincent, Fairfax 14th Circuit Thomas A. Edmonds, Richmond Senior Lawyers Conference Chair John M. Oakey, Richmond Daniel L. Rosenthal, Richmond William J. Viverette, Richmond Young Lawyers Conference President Kenneth L. Alger, II, Luray 15th Circuit Virginia State Bar Staff Directory Grayson S. Johnson, Rockville Conference of Local Bar Associations Chair Eugene M. Elliott, Jr., Roanoke Frequently requested bar contact 16th Circuit information is available online at Bruce T. Clark, Culpeper Diversity Conference Chair James M. Hingeley Jr., Charlottesville Rupen R. Shah, Staunton www.vsb.org/site/about/bar-staff . 4 VIRGINIA LAWYER | December 2013 | Vol. 62 www.vsb.org As the philanthropic arm of Virginias’ legal profession, the Virginia Law Foundation has provided over $23 million in grants since its inception in 1974. We would like to thank the following benefactors for their generous support in our 2013 scal year (October 2012—September 2013). Without them, our important work would not be possible. 1974 Society Fletcher, Paul E. Tashjian-Brown, Eva Harp, III, Reno Schakelford, Jane L. ($10,000+ lifetime) Goodman, Robert C. Thomas, III, Frank A. Hester, Elizabeth G. Sergent, Hon. Birg E. Keith, John A.C. Hettrick, George Thomas, William G. Hingeley, James M. Slate, William K. Estate of Ken McFarlane Hopper, Leila Baum Walker, III, John L. Hodge, Glenn M. Slaughter, Alexander and Smith Hudson, Cynthia E. White, Carolyn A. Jennings, Jr., James W. Mary Street, III, W. Scott King, Ray W. Whittemore, Anne M. Johnston, Jr., F. C. Slaughter, Jr., Edward R. Lacy, Hon. Elizabeth B. Wiley, Jr., Roger C. Kearfott, Joseph C. Somerville, George A. Trustee ($5,000+) Landin, David C. Williams, J. Page Kent, Donald South, Rhysa Griffith Robins Foundation Light, Angelica D. Wood III, Robert C. Kirby, William L. Spahn, Thomas E. Partner ($1,000-$2,499) Malone, Christopher M. Lacey, Kevin C Spruill, Jr., Hon. Joseph E. Mastracco, Jr., Vincent Mentor (up to $249) Lannetti, David Stephens, E. Ford Capsalis, Manuel A. Ackerly, Benjamin C. McGavin, John Ledbetter, Susan Stephens, Hon. J. Warren Gould, Karen A. Aloupas, Carmelou G. McPhillips, Charles V. Martin, Jr., Howard W. Stone, Phillip C. Penrod, David Austin, James Meath, James V. Matthews, Jr., Joseph A. Sullivan, Ann K. Sheridan, Hon. Paul F. Betts, J. Edward Memmer, C. Kailani McCandlish & Lillard, PC Sullivan, Richard C. Weinberg, Jay M.