GROTHENDIECK SPACES: THE LANDSCAPE AND PERSPECTIVES MANUEL GONZÁLEZ AND TOMASZ KANIA Abstract. In 1973, Diestel published his seminal paper Grothendieck spaces and vector measures that drew a connection between Grothendieck spaces (Banach spaces for which weak- and weak*-sequential convergences in the dual space coincide) and vector measures. This connection was developed further in his book with J. Uhl Jr. Vector measures. Addi- tionally, Diestel’s paper included a section with several open problems about the structural properties of Grothendieck spaces, and only half of them have been solved to this day. The present paper aims at synthetically presenting the state of the art at subjectively selected corners of the theory of Banach spaces with the Grothendieck property, describ- ing the main examples of spaces with this property, recording the solutions to Diestel’s problems, providing generalisations/extensions or new proofs of various results concern- ing Grothendieck spaces, and adding to the list further problems that we believe are of relevance and may reinvigorate a better-structured development of the theory. arXiv:2102.03838v3 [math.FA] 7 Jul 2021 Date: July 8, 2021. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary: 46A35; 46B20. Key words and phrases. Grothendieck space, G-space, property (V ), property (V1), Banach space, Gro- thendieck operator, C*-algebra, Banach lattice, positive Grothendieck property, quantitative Grothendieck property, pseudo-intersection number, locally convex Grothendieck space, twisted sum, push-out. Research of M. González was partially supported by MICINN (Spain), Grant PID2019-103961GB-C22. T. Kania acknowledges with thanks funding received from SONATA 15 No. 2019/35/D/ST1/01734. 1 2 M. GONZÁLEZ AND T. KANIA Contents Chapter 1. Introduction 3 Chapter 2. Preliminaries 3 2.1. Lp-spaces and related concepts 5 2.2. Direct sums and ultraproducts 5 2.3. Ordered normed spaces 6 2.4. Exact sequences, twisted sums, and three-space properties 7 2.5. Spaces of continuous functions 8 2.6. Semigroups of operators 8 2.7. The pseudo-intersection number 9 Chapter 3. Isomorphic properties of Grothendieck spaces 9 3.1. Characterisations and first properties 9 3.2. Further properties of Grothendieck spaces 14 3.3. M-bases and Schauder decompositions 17 3.4. Norm-attaining functionals on Grothendieck spaces 19 Chapter 4. Classes of Banach spaces with the Grothendieck property 20 4.1. Spaces of continuous functions 20 4.2. C∗-algebras 25 4.3. L1-spaces 26 4.4. Spaces of analytic and differentiable functions 28 4.5. Banach lattices and ordered vector spaces 29 4.6. Dual Grothendieck spaces 31 Chapter 5. Stability properties of Grothendieck spaces 32 5.1. Subspaces of separable codimension 32 5.2. Non-trivial twisted sums 34 5.3. Tensor products and spaces of bounded operators 36 5.4. Direct sums and spaces of vector-valued functions 40 5.5. Ultrapowers and ultraproducts 42 Chapter 6. Miscellanea 44 6.1. Grothendieck operators 44 6.2. Quantification of the Grothendieck property 45 6.3. Positive Grothendieck property 46 6.4. C0-semigroups of operators on Grothendieck spaces 47 6.5. Locally convex Grothendieck spaces 48 Chapter 7. List of open problems 49 References 51 GROTHENDIECK SPACES: THE LANDSCAPE AND PERSPECTIVES 3 Chapter 1. Introduction A Banach space X is Grothendieck whenever every weakly* convergent sequence in the dual space X∗ converges weakly. The notion of a Grothendieck space was coined after Grothendieck proved that for any index set Γ the space of bounded functions on Γ, `1(Γ), and more generally, the space C(K) of continuous functions on a compact, extremally disconnected (Stonean) space K have this property ([66, Théorème 9]). Without a doubt, reflexive spaces are Grothendieck, and from the point of view of the dual space, the Grothendieck property may be indeed viewed as a form of ‘sequential re- flexivity’. The Grothendieck property may be regarded as complementary to being weakly compactly generated—in particular, these two properties together imply reflexivity. Gro- thendieck property is of relevance in summability theory in Banach spaces (see [63] and references therein) or in the theory of C0-semigroups of operators, where many features available for semigroups of operators on reflexive spaces may be emulated. In [42], Diestel explained the relevance of the Grothendieck property in the study of finitely additive vector-valued measures; the paper itself includes a section of open problems concerning this property, most of which to this day remain open. Even though many particular examples (and non-examples) of Grothendieck spaces have been identified since, little progress on stability properties of Grothendieck spaces has been obtained so far. The present paper aims at synthetically presenting various corners of the theory of Ba- nach spaces with the Grothendieck property with the perspective of putting it on a more systematic footing. For this reason, we describe the main isomorphic properties of Grothen- dieck spaces, collect the answers that have been obtained for some of Diestel’s problems, revisit the stubbornly open ones as well as raise a number of new ones. Occasionally, we generalise certain facts concerning Grothendieck spaces. In order to properly motivate the problems by related results, we have stated them along the text, as well as we have included a comprehensive list of open problems in the final section. Let us briefly describe the contents of the paper. Chapter 2 is devoted to introducing concepts that will be used throughout our exposition. Chapter 3 includes several characterisations and properties of Grothendieck spaces. In Chapter 4 we exemplify Grothendieck spaces within certain familiar classes of Banach ∗ spaces such as C(K)-spaces, C -algebras, L1-spaces, Banach lattices, etc. as well as we provide sufficient conditions for spaces in these classes to be Grothendieck. Chapter 5 touches upon preservation of the Grothendieck property via various constructions and discusses methods of building new Grothendieck spaces from the already known ones. This includes twisted-sums, tensor products, ultraproducts, and more. In Chapter 6 we briefly describe some additional results on the Grothendieck property, and Chapter 7 provides a concise list of the problems that we have collected in the previous chapters. Chapter 2. Preliminaries The Banach spaces we consider are either real or complex, however when we talk about C∗-algebras, the underlying Banach spaces are always complex. An operator is a continuous linear operator between Banach spaces (unless we explicitly state otherwise). We denote 4 M. GONZÁLEZ AND T. KANIA by BX the closed unit ball of a Banach space X. The symbol B(X; Y ) stands for the space of all operators between Banach spaces X and Y ; the spaces of compact operators K(X; Y ) and weakly compact operators W(X; Y ) are closed subspaces thereof; and we write B(X), K(X), and W(X) when X = Y . We write X ∼= Y , whenever two Banach spaces X and Y are isomorphic and X ≡ Y in the case where they are isometrically isomorphic. When X and Y are isomorphic, we denote the (multiplicative) Banach–Mazur distance between X and Y by −1 dBM(X; Y ) = inf kT k: T 2 B(X; Y ) is a norm-one isomorphism : The density character of a Banach space X, denoted dens X, is the least cardinal λ for which X has a dense subset of cardinality λ. A Banach space X is weakly compactly generated (WCG, for short) if it contains a weakly compact subset that spans a dense subspace. Every separable Banach space, every reflexive Banach space, and spaces of the form c0(Γ) for any set Γ are WCG. A Banach space X has weak∗ sequentially compact dual ball (has W∗SC dual ball, for ∗ short) whenever every sequence in BX∗ has a weak -convergent subsequence; we refer to [44, Chapter XIII] for systematic study of spaces with this property. Each subspace of a WCG Banach space has W∗SC dual ball [44, Theorem XIII.4]. Also the spaces whose dual spaces contain no copies of `1, and the spaces isomorphic to the dual of a separable space ∗ containing no copies of `1. Clearly, a Grothendieck space with weak sequentially compact dual ball is reflexive. We refer to [44, Chapter XIII] for additional information. 1 An operator T : X ! Y is weakly pre-compact if for every bounded sequence (xn)n=1 in 1 X, (T xn)n=1 has a weakly Cauchy subsequence; equivalently, by Rosenthal’s `1-theorem [44, Chapter XI], if there exists no subspace of X isomorphic to `1 on which the operator T is an isomorphism. We denote by R(X; Y ) the space of weakly pre-compact operators from X into Y . P1 ∗ A series n=1 xn in X is weakly unconditionally converging if for every f 2 X one P1 has n=1 jhf; xnij < 1. An operator T : X ! Y is unconditionally converging if for each P1 P1 weakly unconditionally converging series n=1 xn in X, the series n=1 T xn is uncondi- tionally converging in Y ; equivalently, if there is no subspace of X isomorphic to c0 on which T is an isomorphism [69, Chapter III, Lemma 3.3.A]. We denote by U(X; Y ) the space of unconditionally converging operators from X into Y . A Banach space X has property (V ), whenever every unconditionally converging operator T : X ! Y is weakly compact; i.e., when U(X; Y ) ⊂ W(X; Y ) for every Banach space Y . Reflexive spaces and C(K)-spaces have property (V ). Moreover, property (V ) is inherited by quotients (but not by closed subspaces). We refer to [69, Section III.3] for additional information on this property. A Banach space X has the Dunford–Pettis property, when for every Banach space Y every weakly compact operator T : X ! Y takes weakly convergent sequences of X into convergent sequences of Y .