Toronto City Council: Gardiner East Debate Vote/Support PROJECTION Based on public statements/voting history. Subject to change. And then change again. For novelty purposes only. Got a tip or correction? Email [email protected] or get me at @GraphicMatt. 2015-06-10 Preferred option for Gardiner Expressway Team Tory Member of Council Notes between Jarvis St. and Percentage Don Valley Parkway PROJECTION Dec 2014 - May 2015 John Tory Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly stated his support 01 Mayor of Toronto Stephen Holyday Maintain/Modify 100.00% Officially endorsed "hybrid." 02 Ward 3 Etobicoke Centre Norman Kelly Maintain/Modify 100.00% Not 100% confirmed but supported maintaining Leslie stub in 03 Ward 40 Scarborough-Agincourt 1999. Likely Maintain/Modify. Denzil Minnan-Wong Maintain/Modify 100.00% 100% Maintain/Modify. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 04 Ward 34 Don Valley East 1999. Frances Nunziata Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly announced her support on June 3. Supported removing 05 Ward 11 York South-Weston east-of-DVP spur in 1999. Jaye Robinson Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly announced her support on June 4 06 Ward 25 Don Valley West Gary Crawford Maintain/Modify 94.74% Publicly announced support for Maintain on June 2 07 Ward 36 Scarborough Southwest Christin Carmichael Greb Maintain/Modify 94.44% Support for Maintain/Modify here: http://carmichaelgreb.com/can- 08 Ward 16 Eglinton-Lawrence toronto-afford-to-remove-the-gardiner-expressway-east/ James Pasternak Maintain/Modify 93.33% Has talked about tolling non-residents to pay for Maintain/Modify 09 Ward 10 York Centre option. Unclear if he'd support Hybrid cost without tolls. Still, a likely Maintain/Modify vote. Raymond Cho Maintain/Modify 89.47% Signed letter urging council to support hybrid on June 8. Supported 10 Ward 42 Scarborough-Rouge River removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999. Cesar Palacio Maintain/Modify 89.47% Publicly announced his support on June 4 11 Ward 17 Davenport Jon Burnside Maintain/Modify 88.24% Signed letter urging council to support hybrid on June 8. 12 Ward 26 Don Valley West Ron Moeser Unknown 88.24% No public statement. Asked about ramifications of deferral at PWIC. 13 Ward 44 Scarborough East David Shiner Maintain/Modify 87.50% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. Supported the 14 Ward 24 Willowdale Spadina Expressway growing up. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999. John Campbell Unknown 84.21% Wildcard. Has also talked about road tolls. 15 Ward 4 Etobicoke Centre Josh Matlow Boulevard 84.21% Supporting Boulevard. Rationale here: 16 Ward 22 St. Paul's http://joshmatlow.ca/component/content/article/11-issues/1673-the- gardiner-expressway-east.html Josh Colle Maintain/Modify 83.33% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. 17 Ward 15 Eglinton-Lawrence Justin Di Ciano Maintain/Modify 83.33% Released statement supporting hybrid: 18 Ward 5 Etobicoke-Lakeshore http://twitter.com/reporterdonpeat/status/606189205136515073 Vincent Crisanti Maintain/Modify 82.35% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. 19 Ward 1 Etobicoke North Mark Grimes Maintain/Modify 78.95% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. 20 Ward 6 Etobicoke-Lakeshore Frank Di Giorgio Maintain/Modify 77.78% Publicly announced his support on June 3 21 Ward 12 York South-Weston Jim Karygiannis Unknown 77.78% Wildcard. I'd expect Maintain/Modify, but he asked the Star to be 22 Ward 39 Scarborough-Agincourt listed as Undecided: http://twitter.com/dmrider/status/606434960350642177 Michael Thompson Unknown 75.00% No public statement. 23 Ward 37 Scarborough Centre Paul Ainslie Boulevard 73.68% Not definitive, but tweets seem to lean heavily toward Boulevard e.g.: 24 Ward 43 Scarborough East https://twitter.com/cllrainslie/status/595755399208370176 Michelle Berardinetti Maintain/Modify 73.33% Publcly announced her support for maintain on June 2. 25 Ward 35 Scarborough Southwest Giorgio Mammoliti Maintain/Modify 73.33% No public statement, likely to vote with mayor or maybe not. 26 Ward 7 York West Supported replacing the Gardiner with public garden in 2010 mayoral campaign. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999. Rob Ford Maintain/Modify 71.43% Bit of a wildcard, but steadfast in belief that Gardiner must stay up. 27 Ward 2 Etobicoke North Glenn De Baeremaeker Unknown 68.42% Seems to argue he'd only support Hybrid if paid for with tolls here: 28 Ward 38 Scarborough Centre http://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2015/04/26/battle-shaping-up- over-east-gardiner-options.html Ana Bailão Boulevard 64.71% Her staff stated in an email to Metro that she is "leaning toward the 29 Ward 18 Davenport 'remove' option." John Filion Boulevard 61.11% Leaning toward Boulevard; Supported removing east-of-DVP spur 30 Ward 23 Willowdale in 1999. Mary-Margaret McMahon Boulevard 57.89% Confirmed her support for Boulevard in newsletter to constituents. 31 Ward 32 Beaches-East York Chin Lee Unknown 53.33% Seems undecided: https://chinlee41.wordpress.com/tag/gardiner- 32 Ward 41 Scarborough-Rouge River expressway/ Shelley Carroll Boulevard 52.63% Publicly stated she supports Boulevard. 33 Ward 33 Don Valley East Pam McConnell Boulevard 47.37% Supports Boulevard. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 34 Ward 28 Toronto Centre-Rosedale 1999. Joe Mihevc Boulevard 47.06% Publicly stated he supports Boulevard. Supported removing east-of- 35 Ward 21 St. Paul's DVP spur in 1999. Maria Augimeri Boulevard 44.44% Stated support for Boulevard in email.Supported removing east-of- 36 Ward 9 York Centre DVP spur in 1999. Mary Fragedakis Boulevard 44.44% Confirmed support to Jonathan Goldsbie: 37 Ward 29 Toronto-Danforth http://twitter.com/goldsbie/status/606133234330664960 Sarah Doucette Boulevard 42.11% Supports Boulevard. Statement here: http://www.ward13.ca 38 Ward 13 Parkdale-High Park Anthony Perruzza Unknown 41.18% Wildcard. 39 Ward 8 York-West Kristyn Wong-Tam Boulevard 35.29% Supports Boulevard. 40 Ward 27 Toronto Centre-Rosedale Mike Layton Boulevard 33.33% Supports Boulevard. 41 Ward 19 Trinity-Spadina Paula Fletcher Boulevard 31.58% Supports Boulevard. 42 Ward 30 Toronto-Danforth Joe Cressy Boulevard 27.78% Supports Boulevard. 43 Ward 20 Trinity-Spadina Janet Davis Boulevard 26.32% Supports Boulevard. 44 Ward 31 Beaches-East York Gord Perks Boulevard 26.32% Supports Boulevard. 45 Ward 14 Parkdale-High Park Projected Result Maintain/Modify Total Maintain/Modify 21 Total Boulevard 17 Total Unknown 7 Version 11: June 8, 2015.