APPENDIX 1 NUMBER OF CONTRACT HIGHEST DAILY RATE LOWEST DAILY RATE TENDERS RECOMMENDED AWARD NO RECEIVED A1 BANK-FAULDIEHILL-ARBRILOT PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 34.50 3 AWARD TO: REIDS TAXIS alternative bid see note 1 A2 GRANGE OF BARRY-WOODHILL-BURNSIDE PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 36.00 3 AWARD TO:LINKS CABS A3 LOCHINDORES-PIPERDAM-BIRKHILL PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 73.50 5 NOT AWARDED See Combined bid A3 & A44 LOCHINDORES-PIPERDAM-BIRKHILL PRIMARY SCHOOL BALSHANDO-PIPERDAM-LIFF PRIMARY SCHOOL TO CONNECT WITH A39 138.21 102.35 4 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS A4 PITLIVIE-EASTHAVEN-CARLOGIE PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 69.80 2 AWARD TO: MORRISONS COACHES A5 DUNVEGAN HOUSE-NEW MAINS OF GUYND-CARMYLLIE PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 98.00 2 AWARD TO: JP MINICOACHES A6 PARADISE-LETHAM GRANGE-COLLISTON PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 145.00 2 AWARD TO: G & N WISHART A7 BLAIR'S GARAGE-GREENS OF GARDYNE-FRIOCKHEIM PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 89.00 3 AWARD TO: JP MINICOACHES A8 KNOCKHILL JUNCTION-BOYSACK FARM-FRIOCKHEIM PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 90.00 3 AWARD TO: JP MINICOACHES A9 LEGASTON COTTAGES-HEUGHHEAD HOUSE-FRIOCKHEIM PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 24.26 3 AWARD TO:K P NICOL A12 MUIRLOCH FARM-BALRUDDERY MEADOWS-LIFF PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 73.50 3 AWARD TO: MORRISONS COACHES A12 & A44 MUIRLOCH FARM-BALRUDDERY MEADOWS-LIFF PRIMARY SCHOOL FOWLIS VILLAGE-PIPERDAM-LIFF PRIMARY SCHOOL 114.80 1 NOT AWARDED See Alternative Combined bid A13 FAIRNEYFAULDS R/E-MONIKIE PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 83.21 2 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS A13a FAIRNEYFAULDS R/E-MONIKIE PRIMARY SCHOOL (includes serving Murroes Out of School Club PM) NO BIDS RECEIVED see note 3 A14 CRAIGTON HOUSE-HOGSTON FARM-MONIKIE PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 80.00 2 AWARD TO: JP MINICOACHES A15 BARNS OF WEDDERBURN-KELLAS BRIDGE-MURROES PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 135.00 2 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS See Note 4 A15a BALLUMBIE CASTLE ESTATE-KELLAS BRIDGE-MURROES PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 100.00 2 NOT AWARDED See Note 4 A16 BARNS OF WEDDERBURN-WESTHALL TERRACE-MURROES PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 85.00 3 NOT AWARDED See Note 4 A17 SOUTH KINGENNIE-DRUMSTURDY-NEWBIGGING PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 120.00 2 NOT AWARDED See Note 5 A18 BROOMFIELD COTTAGE, S KINGENNIE-NEWBIGGING PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 30.00 2 AWARD TO: FAREWAY TAXIS A18a DRUMSTURDY ROAD COTTAGES-NEWBIGGING PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 9.00 3 AWARD TO: PREMIER TAXIS A19 FRIOCKHEIM-ARBROATH-ST THOMAS PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 40.00 2 AWARD TO: REIDS TAXIS alternative bid see note 6 A20 AUCHMITHIE-ST THOMAS PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 10.00 4 AWARD TO: ARBROATH TAXIS See Note 7 A21 OLD BALKELLO FARM-INVERALDIE-TEALING PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 107.86 3 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS A22 LUMLEY DEN-TODHILLS-TEALING PRIMARY SCHOOL 180.00 35.00 4 AWARD TO: LES GIBSON TAXIS L1 Analysis APPENDIX 1 A30 KNOCKHILL-FRIOCKHEIM-ARBROATH ACADEMY 170.00 145.00 2 AWARD TO: G & N WISHART A34 DRUMSTURDY-CROMBIE PARK-CARNOUSTIE HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 125.00 2 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS A35 BANKHEAD HS-MONIKIE-CARNOUSTIE HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 125.00 2 AWARD TO: FISHER TOURS A36 BALHUNGIE FARM-WOODHILL-CARNOUSTIE HIGH SCHOOL 180.00 31.00 3 AWARD TO: LINKS CABS alternative bid see note 8 A37 BALLUMBIE CASTLE-MURROES-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 77.15 3 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS A38 WESTHALL TCE-WELLBANK-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 84.09 2 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS A39 MUIRCROFT-FOWLIS-LIFF-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL (70 SEATER) 170.00 106.00 3 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS A39a MUIRCROFT-FOWLIS-LIFF-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL (53 SEATER) 170.00 100.00 2 NOT AWARDED see note 9 A40 LIFF HOSPITAL-MUIRHEAD-BIRKHILL-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 100.00 3 NOT AWARDED see note 9 A41 BIRKHILL PRIMARY SCHOOL-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 100.00 4 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS (alternative) See note 9 A42 NEWTYLE-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 166.42 2 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS A43 AUCHTERHOUSE-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 170.00 166.42 2 AWARD TO:FISHER TOURS A44 BALSHANDO-PIPERDAM-LIFF PRIMARY SCHOOL 170.00 75.00 5 NOT AWARDED See Combined bid A46 WHITE HOUSE LETHAM MILL-ARBROATH HIGH SCHOOL 180.00 11.00 2 AWARD TO: ABBEY TAXIS A50 PIPERDAM-BIRKHILL-MENZIESHILL HIGH SCHOOL 180.00 30.00 5 AWARD TO: DUNDEE TAXI CAB CO ASP/2 DISHLANDTOWN ST-ARBROATH HIGH SCHOOL 9.00 1 AWARD TO: ABBEY TAXIS ASP/8 HILL TERRACE, MENMUIR-MAP FRIOCKHEIM 52.70 51.10 2 AWARD TO: L J NICOL TAXIS ASP/11 JUBILEE PARK, LETHAM-FORFAR ACADEMY 72.00 16.84 3 AWARD TO: L J NICOL TAXIS ASP/12 CORRIES COURT-CHARLES AVENUE-LADYLOAN PRIMARY SCHOOL NO BIDS RECEIVED RETENDER ASP/13 A92/PANLATHY R/E-CARNOUSTIE HIGH SCHOOL 44.00 40.00 2 AWARD TO: FAREWAY TAXIS ASP/14 LOCHEND ROAD, CARNOUSTIE-CARNOUSTIE HIGH SCHOOL 52.00 1 AWARD TO: FAREWAY TAXIS See note 10 ASP/15 BUCKLERS WYND, KELLAS-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 48.25 20.00 4 AWARD TO: FAREWAY TAXIS ASP/18 EMMOCK FARM-TEALING-MORGAN ACADEMY 65.30 38.00 2 AWARD TO: TAY TAXIS ASP/29 MCGREGORS WALK, ARBROATH-ARBROATH ACADEMY 10.00 1 AWARD TO: ABBEY TAXIS ASP/34 MONTROSE-FRIOCKHEIM-CARLOGIE PRIMARY SCHOOL 126.00 50.00 8 CONTRACT WITHDRAWN See Note 11 ASP/38 GRANGEHILL DRIVE, MONIFIETH-MONIFIETH HIGH SCHOOL 40.00 26.00 2 AWARD TO: TAY TAXIS ASP/50 MARKET STREET, BRECHIN-MAP FRIOCKHEIM 39.74 25.00 6 AWARD TO: MS K V MARTIN L1 Analysis APPENDIX 1 ASD/1 GRANARY TERRACE, MONIKIE-CRAIGIE HIGH SCHOOL, DUNDEE 30.00 21.00 4 AWARD TO: PREMIER TAXIS XSP/1 ARBROATH-CAMPHILL RUDOLPH STEINER SCHOOL, ABERDEEN 134.00 45.00 Mon & Fri 9 AWARD TO: ARBROATH TAXIS 50.00 Thurs L1 Analysis.