Deterministic remote entanglement of superconducting circuits through microwave two-photon transitions P. Campagne-Ibarcq,1, ∗ E. Zalys-Geller, A. Narla, S. Shankar, P. Reinhold, L. Burkhart, C. Axline, W. Pfaff, L. Frunzio, R. J. Schoelkopf,1 and M. H. Devoret1, † 1Department of Applied Physics, Yale University (Dated: December 19, 2017) Large-scale quantum information processing networks will most probably require the entanglement of distant systems that do not interact directly. This can be done by performing entangling gates between standing information carriers, used as memories or local computational resources, and flying ones, acting as quantum buses. We report the deterministic entanglement of two remote transmon qubits by Raman stimulated emission and absorption of a traveling photon wavepacket. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 73%, well explained by losses in the transmission line and decoherence of each qubit. INTRODUCTION to shuffle information between the nodes of a network. However, the natural emission and absorption temporal envelopes of two identical nodes do not match as one Entanglement, which Schroedinger described as “the is the time-reversed of the other. Following pioneering characteristic trait of quantum mechanics” [1], is instru- work in ion traps [15], many experiments in circuit-QED mental for quantum information science applications have sought to modulate in time the effective coupling such as quantum cryptography and all the known of the emitter to a transmission channel in order to pure-state quantum algorithms [2]. Two systems Alice shape the “pitched” wavepacket [16–20]. Indeed, a rising and Bob that do not interact directly can be entangled if exponential wavepacket could be efficiently absorbed they interact locally with a third traveling system acting [21–24] by the receiver. However, such a wavepacket in as a mediator. Since they can travel over long distances, principle requires infinite dynamic range on the emitter photons are natural candidates for this role [3]. coupling. A simpler approach consists of modulating Remote entanglement was first demonstrated between both the emitter and receiver couplings in time to release two atomic clouds [4] traversed by a light beam mea- and catch a time-symmetric wavepacket [14, 25]. While suring non-destructively a joint property. This type of efforts were made in that direction [26–28], deterministic scheme was also used recently to entangle two super- entanglement between distant nodes has not been conducting circuits [5] but suffers from the difficulty demonstrated with such a scheme so far [47]. to match both measurements to make the extracted In this letter, we report entanglement generation be- information from one or the other system indistinguish- tween two distant transmon superconducting qubits able. Another scheme, widely used in atomic clouds [6], by faithful release and capture of a time-symmetric trapped ions [7], solid-state spin qubits [8], quantum wavepacket. Our scheme uses microwave pumps to dots [9] and superconducting circuits [10] relies on the concurrently and coherently create a transmon excita- simultaneous emission of photons by both Alice and tion and a photon in a buffer resonator coupled to a Bob, either through fluorescence or stimulated Raman transmission line [10, 19]. The photon is released, and emission. Entanglement is then heralded by detection after traveling along a ∼ 1 m cable and through mi- of one of these photons, whose origin is erased by crowave components, is captured by a second transmon recombining them on a beam-splitter. This scheme is qubit with a similar scheme. The entanglement purity robust, in particular against photon losses, as long as is limited by photon losses in the line, which could arXiv:1712.05854v1 [quant-ph] 15 Dec 2017 the photons are made indistinguishable by matching be corrected for by purification [29, 30], and intrinsic the overlap of their wavepackets with the detector decoherence of each qubit, which could also be improved. bandwidth. It should be possible to entangle in this way two arbitrary nodes of a network for modular quantum computing [11–13]. But can we build an even simpler remote entangler, which would not require a which-path eraser and detector? DRIVING A TWO-PHOTON TRANSITION As depicted in Fig. 1a, a minimal protocol consists of entangling Alice with a propagating electromagnetic field The experimental setup is schematically depicted in whose state is then swapped to Bob [14]. For instance, we Fig. 1b. Two superconducting transmon qubits [31], can stimulate an excitation of Alice that is conditional Alice and Bob, are embedded in two indium-plated upon emission of a photon, which is then routed and copper cavities, anchored to the base stage of a dilution absorbed by Bob. Such a scheme could also be used refrigerator (see [10, 32] for device fabrication and setup 2 details). The photon damping rate κ = 2π × 1 MHz a Alice H C for the lowest energy mode of each cavity is set by half-pitch C’ relaxation through a well-coupled port into a common Bob catch microwave transmission line, which dominates over both b the internal losses and relaxation through a second JPC port. This last port is used to apply resonant microwave drives to perform control operations on a single mode, Alice Bob such as qubit rotations at ωqA,qB/2π ∼ 5 GHz, or cavity displacements at ω /2π ∼ 7.5 GHz. Interestingly, cA,cB c e1 we can also directly drive common two-excitation ω e1 2B ω˜ω˜qBqB transitions of these modes such as |g0i ↔ |e1i or ω˜ χ ω2A ω1B cA − A |g1i ↔ |e0i [33]. Here |0i and |1i designate Fock states g1 g1 of the cavity and |gi and |ei the ground and first excited e0 ω e0 ω˜cB states of the qubit. This is done by simultaneously ω˜qA 1A applying a sideband pump at ω1A,1B detuned from the qubit frequency by ∆/2π = 100 MHz (purple and orange g0 g0 waves on Fig 1) and another at ω detuned from the 2A,2B FIG. 1: a) Minimal logical circuit for remote entangle- cavity frequency by ±∆ (light blue and pink waves). ment. Alice is entangled with the ancillary system C by a Hadamard and a CNOT gate. The information propagates Let us consider separately each system Alice or Bob. to C’ (green wave) where it is swapped to Bob. b) Setup One can show [32, 34, 35] that in a displaced frame and schematics and c) energy level diagram. Two transmon qubits using a rotating wave approximation, the system Hamil- Alice (in dark blue, dressed frequencyω ˜qA, see text for de- tonian in presence of pumps at ω and ω reads tails) and Bob (in red, dressed frequencyω ˜qB ) are disper- 1 2 sively coupled to two resonant cavities (in green, dispersive couplings χA,B ). The cavities lowest energy modes are fre- H † † α † 2 † † =˜ωq(t)q q +ω ˜c(t)c c − (q q) − χq qc c quency matched (˜ωcA − χA ' ω˜cB ) and are strongly coupled ~ 2 to a directional transmission line routing photons from Al- −i(ω1+ω2)t † † (1) + e gs(t) q c + h.c. ice to Bob. By simultaneously driving Alice (Bob) with the −i(ω1−ω2)t † detuned purple microwave at ω1A (orange, at ω1B ) and her + e gc(t) q c + h.c. cavity with the detuned light blue microwave at ω2A (light pink, at ω ), we drive a Raman-type two-photon transi- where c and q are the annihilation operators for the cavity 2B tion. For Alice, we choose ω1A + ω2A =ω ˜qA +ω ˜cA − χA and qubit modes, α is the anharmonicity of the transmon to resonantly drive |g0i ↔ |e1i (see (c) left diagram). A pho- mode, χ the dispersive shift [36], andω ˜q(t) andω ˜c(t) ton can eventually be emitted in the line (green wave). The are the Stark shifted frequencies of the transmon and wavepacket is shaped by modulating the pump amplitude. cavity modes in presence of the pumps. These dressed This photon is absorbed by Bob by driving |g1i ↔ |e0i with frequencies and the squeezing and conversion strengths ω2B − ω1B =ω ˜cB − ω˜qB (right diagram). After a full photon g (t) and g (t) are slow varying compared to ∆ and read pitch and catch, the system is in |e0iA|e0iB (in magenta). s c After a “half” pitch, the qubits are entangled. 2 2 ω˜q = ωq − χ|ξ2| − 2α|ξ1| (2a) 2 in driving the two-photon transition. The resonance ω˜c = ωc − χ|ξ1| (2b) condition Eq. (3a) is used for Alice. As shown by the g = χξ ξ (2c) s 1 2 energy-level diagram of Fig. 1, this pumping, combined ∗ gc = χξ1ξ2 (2d) with the cavity dissipation, eventually brings the system to the state |e0i (highlighted in magenta). If the Here, ωq and ωc are the frequencies in the absence of qubit is initially in |gi, a photon is emitted in the the pumps. ξ1 and ξ2 are the effective pump amplitudes line (green wave). Conversely, the resonance condition -which correspond to the frame displacements used to Eq. (3b) is used for Bob, and if the qubit is initially get to Eq. (1)- and are proportional to the amplitude of in |gi, it can absorb the incoming photon and excite the pump tones. Note that since the cavity mode is only to |ei (level highlighted in magenta), provided that the weakly anharmonic, we have neglected a frequency shift 2 photon is resonant with the cavity frequency. This is of the cavity mode proportional to |ξ2| [32] . made possible by designing the two cavities so that their The conversion or squeezing process (red or blue side- transition nearly match ((ωcA −χ−ωcB)/2π = 600 kHz), band) can be selected by setting either and compensating for the remaining mismatch with appropriately modulated pumps (see Fig.