Alan Seeger: Medievalism As an Alternative Ideology

View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by K-State Research Exchange This is the author’s final, peer-reviewed manuscript as accepted for publication. The publisher-formatted version may be available through the publisher’s web site or your institution’s library. Alan Seeger: medievalism as an alternative ideology Tim Dayton How to cite this manuscript If you make reference to this version of the manuscript, use the following information: Dayton, T. (2012). Alan Seeger: Medievalism as an alternative ideology. Retrieved from <a href="/goto?url=http://krex.ksu.edu" target="_blank">http://krex.ksu.edu </a>Published Version Information Citation: Dayton, T. (2012). Alan Seeger: Medievalism as an alternative ideology. First World War Studies, 3(2), 125-144. Copyright: © 2012 Taylor & Francis Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi:10.1080/19475020.2012.728698 Publisher’s Link<a href="/goto?url=http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/19475020.2012.728698" target="_blank">: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/19475020.2012.728698 </a>This item was retrieved from the K-State Research Exchange (K-REx), the institutional repository of Kansas State University. K-REx is available at <a href="/goto?url=http://krex.ksu.edu" target="_blank">http://krex.ksu.edu </a>0Ala n Seeger: Medieva lism a s a n Alterna tive Ideology Tim Da yton* Depa rtment of English Ka nsa s Sta te University Ma nha tta n, KS USA 66502 * E-ma il: ta da [email protected]; Tel. 785-532-2155 1Ala n Seeger: Medieva lism a s a n Alterna tive Ideology Abstra c t The Americ a n poet Ala n Seeger ima gined the First World Wa r a s a n opportunity to rea lize medieva l va lues, whic h were embodied for him in Sir Philip Sidney. Sidney epitomized Seeger’s three idea ls: “Love a nd Arms a nd Song,” whic h c ontra sted with the ma teria lism a nd sophistic a tion of modernity. His embra c e of “Arms” a nd the desire for intense, a uthentic experienc e led Seeger, who wa s living in Pa ris in August 1914, to enlist in the Frenc h Foreign Legion, in whic h he served until his dea th in c omba t in July 1916. As a n infa ntryma n Seeger ha d extensive experienc e of the Western front. This c onc rete experienc e of the wa r, of the indignities of life in the trenc hed a nd the domina nc e of tec hnology, c ontra sted in signific a nt wa ys with wa r a s c onstruc ted in Seeger’s medieva list ima gina tion. Seeger, however, rec onc iled this c ontra dic tion by seeing the wa r a s pa rt of the elementa l Strife of na ture. By this mea ns, Seeger a voided the potentia lly unsettling c onsequenc es of c onfronting the profoundly modern na ture of the wa r. Interpreting the wa r a s a form of “Strife” a nd a s a n a ssertion of medieva l va lues a llowed Seeger to ima gine himself a nd his c omra des to be living outside the world of industria l c a pita list modernity. Seeger sha red with others involved in the wa r this medieva lism a nd the belief tha t the wa r offered relief from the va lues of modernity, even if Seeger’s medieva lism wa s more intense, more thoroughgoing, tha n wa s c ommon. However, Seeger’s dea th a s a result of wounds rec eived from ma c hine gun fire vividly displa ys the c ontra dic tion between his ima gina tion a nd the rea lity of industria lized wa rfa re. The exa mple of Seeger thus suggests tha t the Americ a n effort in the First World Wa r wa s underwritten in pa rt by a n ideology through whic h a modern, industria lized wa r wa s embra c ed in terms derived from the ima gined medieva l pa st. Insofa r a s this is true medieva lism func tioned to provide a n ideology tha t c onstruc ted, in the terminology of Ra ymond Willia ms, a n a lterna tive to the industria l c a pita list modernity from whic h the wa r emerged, a n a lterna tive ideology tha t a llowed the wa r to be ima gined differently from wha t it wa s, but whic h posed no substa ntive c ha llenge to the wa r’s soc ia l a nd ec onomic rea lities. Keywords: wa r poetry; Ala n Seeger; medieva lism; ideology; modernity 2Ala n Seeger: Medieva lism a s a n Alterna tive Ideology Even prior to US entry into World Wa r One, Ala n Seeger wa s seen a s the a rc hetypa l Americ a n soldier-poet of the wa r. This sta tus mislea ds slightly: Seeger wa s idiosync ra tic in the intensity a nd c onsistenc y of his c ommitment to medieva l a nd ma rtia l va lues. Yet, ultima tely, those sa me medieva l a nd ma rtia l va lues Seeger espoused c onsc iously a nd delibera tely a ppea r in a more diffuse form in the broa der c ulture of the era . Thus Seeger a nd, the a va ila ble c ultura l evidenc e suggests, the United Sta tes a s a whole, enga ged in the wa r on a pa ra doxic a l or perha ps c ontra dic tory ba sis: the wa r wa s ima gined a s the opportunity to a ssert va lues ec lipsed in, a t the sa me time tha t the wa r itself took pla c e a t the c utting edge of, c a pita list modernity. Fought using the most rec ent developments of the sec ond industria l revolution, propelled by the c onflic t between the “unlimited dyna mism” impa rted to G erma ny by “the impera tive to expa nd of a ma ssive c a pita list ec onomy wa tc hing its sta tistic a l c urves soa ring upwa rd” a nd the United Kingdom, a ttempting to preserve its globa l ec onomic a nd politic a l domina nc e,1 this strikingly modern wa r wa s ima gined in terms strikingly a na c hronistic . Tha t Seeger wrote a bout the wa r in terms derived from a n ima gined premodern pa st is unsurprising: his ba c kground formed him in suc h a wa y tha t it would be a stonishing ha d he not sha red in the post-Roma ntic poetic c ulture a na lyzed by Pa ul Fussell, Ted Boga c z, Sa muel Hynes, a nd others. Born into a n old 3New Engla nd fa mily, Seeger a ttended the Ha c kley Sc hool in Ta rrytown, NY prior to entering Ha rva rd a s a member of the c la ss of 1910. At Ha rva rd, Seeger would eventua lly room with T.S. Eliot in his senior yea r, while Eliot wa s working on his Ma ster’s degree.2 After gra dua ting from Ha rva rd, Seeger lived in G reenwic h Villa ge for a short time before moving to Pa ris, where he wa s living a t the outbrea k of the wa r.3 Shortly a fter the wa r bega n Seeger enlisted in the Frenc h Foreign Legion, motiva ted in pa rt by his love for Fra nc e but a lso by a deepsea ted desire to experienc e wa r: a fter Seeger died from wounds rec eived in c omba t in July 1916, a friend wrote tha t Seeger fought on the side of the Frenc h bec a use he ha d been living in Fra nc e, a s he would doubtless ha ve fought on the side of the G erma ns ha d he been living in G erma ny.4 The poetry Seeger produc ed out of the fulfillment of his desire for milita ry experienc e c ontra sts sha rply in form a nd c ontent with the rea c tion a ga inst the wa r in muc h of the c a nonic a l Americ a n litera ture, most prominently the work of E.E. C ummings, John Dos Pa ssos, a nd Ernest Hemingwa y. Yet this desire for milita ry experienc e, whic h for Seeger wa s c losely rela ted to the desire to be a poet, wa s c ommon in the la te 19th a nd ea rly 20th c enturies in the U.S., pa rtic ula rly a mong the middle a nd upper c la sses; indeed, C ummings, Dos Pa ssos, Hemingwa y, et a l. ha d experienc es to rea c t a ga inst b ec a u se they sha red, to a grea t extent, Seeger’s c ultura l forma tion. But C ummings’, Dos Pa ssos’, a nd Hemingwa y’s writing a bout the wa r rejec ts signific a nt elements of tha t forma tion, a nd is thus less typic a l of the Americ a n c ulture tha t underpinned 4the wa r effort in 1917 a nd 1918 tha n is tha t of Seeger, whose c ollec ted P o ems were a non-fic tion best seller in those yea rs.5 Understa nding Seeger helps one to understa nd more fully these c a nonic a l writers by illumina ting their c ultura l situa tion, while a lso revea ling the powerfully a na c hronistic qua lity of the underlying c ulture mobilized in support of US intervention into the wa r. I. Seeger before the war In the spring of 1908 Seeger, then a sophomore a t Ha rva rd, wrote a n essa y, “Suggestions for a Disserta tion on the Historic a l Development of the Fa ustmotive.” His professor for C ompa ra tive Litera ture 7, M.A. Potter, responded fa vora bly to Seeger’s essa y, pa rt of whic h wa s c onc erned with the historic a l na ture of the Rena issa nc e, whic h Seeger presents a s a pla y of new a nd old: It is simple enough to see the new impulses, but wha t sha ll be sa id of the things tha t a re no more, of the spiritua l light tha t ha s va nished out of men’s hea rts? I suppose tha t it is only within rec ent yea rs tha t the sophistic a tion of three c enturies ha s so fa r a ba ted a s to a llow of a more c orrec t a nd sympa thetic estima te of the media eva l world. In this pla y of new a nd old, Seeger prefers the old: for him a ba leful “sophistic a tion” ha s overwhelmed the “spiritua l light” of the medieva l, a spiritua lity tha t a ppea red to rea ssert itself before retrea ting onc e a ga in: 5there wa s the spora dic impulse of the Roma ntic Reviva l, but not a ppa rently ba sed upon a ma ture enough selfc onsc iousness to a tta in tha t perfec tion towa rd whic h it wa s progressing when blighted under the grea t returning tide of ma teria lism tha t ha s a fflic ted the la st ha lf-c entury. 6 Seeger wa nts to reverse this “tide of ma teria lism” so tha t the “spiritua l light” ema na ting from the medieva l world might shine a ga in. Medieva l settings or themes a re prominent in Seeger’s prewa r poetry: “Vivien,” “Broc elia nde,” a nd “Lyonesse,” a ll work with tra ditiona l Arthuria n ma teria l, while “C ouc y” c onc erns a c a stle in Fra nc e tha t wa s home to severa l c rusa ders. Less obviously medieva list his poem “The Rendezvous” c onc erns a lover a wa iting his beloved in a C a tholic c hurc h. He seeks out her fa c e a mong the c ongrega nts: But the long vespers c lose. The priest on high Ra ises the thing tha t C hrist's own flesh enforms; And down the G othic na ve the c rowd flows by And through the porta l's c a rven entry swa rms. Ma ddened he peers upon ea c h pa ssing fa c e Till the long dra b proc ession termina tes. No princ ess pa sses out with proud ma jestic pa c e. She ha s not c ome, the woma n tha t he wa its.7 6The setting in this poem derives its fla vor in la rge pa rt from the C a tholic reviva l movement, a c omponent of Vic toria n medieva lism. The “G othic na ve” a nd the “porta l’s c a rven entry” provide a ba c kdrop intended to ma ke the lover’s disa ppointment a ll the more poigna nt. This penc ha nt for the medieva l, for role-pla ying, a nd for a pec ulia r a nd c ruc ia l form of a bstra c tion ma y be seen in a Februa ry 1916 letter tha t Seeger wrote while he rec overed from a respira tory infec tion c ontra c ted in the trenc hes. He expla ins to his mother tha t in his first yea rs a t Ha rva rd he wa s a devotee of Lea rning for Lea rning's sa ke… . The events of tha t life were positive a dventures to me. Few, I a m sure, ha ve known more tha n I did then the employ of intellec t a s a n instrument of plea sure. I shut myself off c ompletely from the life of the University, so full, nevertheless, of plea sures. I sc offed a t these plea sures tha t were no more to me tha n froth. I felt no need of c omra deship. I led the life of a n a nc horite. The c hoic e of terms is signific a nt: while not a n exc lusively medieva l phenomenon, a nc horites a re strongly a ssoc ia ted with the medieva l. As a sort of a nc horite, Seeger devoted himself to “Lea rning for Lea rning’s sa ke.” The c a pita liza tion is typic a l of Seeger, who tended to a bstra c t a nd to a llegorize. This Lea rning of his produc ed not, a ppa rently, knowledge or understa nding, but plea sure; Seeger’s sensibility wa s funda menta lly, a lthough c omplexly, 7hedonistic , a s is seen further in his a c c ount in the sa me letter of his turning a wa y from Lea rning. C ompa ring himself to c ha ra c ters in Ba lza c , Seeger sa ys, “Obsessed by the burning vision of Ha ppiness they left the quiet groves of the Ac a demy a nd went down into the c ity in sea rc h of it." He c ontinues: But my hedonism, if suc h it ma y be c a lled, wa s not superfic ia l like tha t of so ma ny, to whom the emotiona l mea ns only the sexua l. I wa s sublimely c onsistent. For seeing, in the ma c roc osm, a ll Na ture revolve a bout the twin poles of Love a nd Strife, of a ttra c tion a nd repulsion, so no less in the mic roc osm of my individua l being I sa w the emotiona l life equa lly divided between these two c a rdina l princ iples . . . . [M]y a spira tion wa s to go a ll the ga mut, to "drink life to the lees." My interest in life wa s pa ssion, my objec t to experienc e it in a ll ra re a nd refined, in a ll intense a nd violent forms. The wa r ha ving broken out, then, it wa s na tura l tha t I should ha ve sta ked my life on lea rning wha t it a lone c ould tea c h me.8 The c a pita liza tion c ontinues in this pa ssa ge, but now Seeger’s a bstra c tion a nd a llegoriza tion ta kes on a slightly different c a st. First, the melodra ma tic qua lity of Seeger’s ima gina tion bec omes even more prominent. But beyond this, his move into the a bstra c t sta nds in c urious rela tion to the desire for experienc e Seeger expresses in the letter. But then a ga in, however c onc rete a nd pa rtic ula r a ny given experienc e ma y be, nothing is more a bstra c t tha n Experienc e. 8This is not a ll. In his movement from wha tever the pa rtic ula rs of a given experienc e ma y be to the terms in whic h he understa nds it (Love, Na ture, Strife) Seeger elides the rea lms of the soc ia l a nd politic a l: in his wa r poetry, the wa r will rema in la rgely a ma tter, on the one ha nd, of sense experienc e a nd, on the other, of remote a bstra c tion. Thus the wa r ra rely a ppea rs in his writing, either poetry or prose, a s a p o l itic a l c onflic t. While this elision typic a lly a llows Seeger to a void types of ideology c ommon in muc h of the Americ a n poetry of 1914-1918, it a lso displa c es ideology to those levels tha t a r e presented, most c lea rly but not exc lusively onto the a bstra c tions, Love, Na ture, Strife, Roma nc e, etc ., through whic h Seeger proc esses the pa rtic ula rs of experienc e. Seeger thus a lso displa c es ideologic a l c onflic t to the level of the ima gina tive, a s when he ma kes a n ima gined medieva l world or ima gined medieva l figures repositories of a ntimodern va lues. While Seeger a ttempts to expla in the va rying pa tterns of his life in this letter to his mother, empha sizing the brea k between his existenc e a s a n a nc horite a nd a s a n a c tive pa rtic ipa nt in the world, a strong c ontinuity underlies his c onc erns: the medieva l func tions in the sa me ma nner in both the “Fa ustmotive” essa y of 1908 a nd in his wa rtime writing. In the essa y, Seeger ima gines a brea k with “the sophistic a tion of three c enturies,” with c a pita list modernity. C lea rly, suc h a c ha nge would be epoc ha l, a nd Seeger bec omes simulta neously a poc a lyptic a nd prophetic a s he ima gines the possibility: “Now we a re dwelling in the unc erta in lull a nd sultriness tha t prec edes a storm. Now we ha ve rea c hed 9the issue when ma teria lism ha s been weighted a nd found wa nting.”9 Apoc a lypse a nd prophec y enter here in the figure of the wa iting storm, a storm tha t would indeed brea k six yea rs la ter with the a dvent of the wa r. For Seeger, this storm promises to end the era of ma teria lism tha t ha s so fa r defea ted the roma ntic return to the spiritua l. Wha t is to be the c olor of the da wning spirit? I fa nc y this: it is to be a new roma ntic ism, a roma ntic ism ba sed on a truer perfec tion of ma n’s rela tion to Na ture; it will be tha t renova tion whic h sha ll be the dea th of a ll our sha llow refinement tha t so unduly empha sizes the psyc hologic a l in huma n interc ourse, whic h sha king off the tra mmels of a dea dening sophistic a tion sha ll return to those purer idea ls when ma nkind wa s only a rtistic a lly a dmissible in so fa r a s entered into his proper rela tion to the universa l a nd enc ompa ssing Bea uty.10 Here, in this sophomore term pa per, muc h of the ba sis of Ala n Seeger’s c a reer a s a poet ma y be seen. Both Seeger’s poetry a nd his embra c e of the wa r emerge from his rejec tion of the ma teria lism a nd sophistic a tion c ha ra c teristic of life in the modern era . Seeger’s progra m opposes wha t Fussell sees a s c ha ra c teristic of the response to the wa r. Fussell’s “irony” is a sophistic a ted response to the wa r. Seeger, even a s a n undergra dua te, c a lls for a return to a na ïve sensibility. Seeger will a dvoc a te, a nd a ttempt to embody, a kind of new 10 roma ntic ism tha t revives the va lues of the medieva l world a nd a spires to the idea l. Seeger intends his medieva lism, then, foremost a s a rupture with modernity.11 II. The Storm Breaks The deep-lying na ture of Seeger’s sensibility is glimpsed in the terminologic a l c onsistenc y between the “Fa ust-motive” essa y a nd his wa rtime writing. In a n essa y published in the N e w Y o r k Sun in 1915 a nd la ter inc orpora ted into his posthumously published L e t t e r s a n d D i a r y, Seeger refers to his unit’s enc a mpment a s “roma ntic .” 12 In a la ter a rtic le for the Sun, Seeger refers to going on a night rec onna issa nc e pa trol a s “the one brea th of true roma nc e” to be found in “the monotonous routine of trenc h wa rfa re” (L e t t e r s a n d D i a r y, 92). In one of his wa rtime sonnets, one in whic h he, a typic a lly, ima gines life a fter the wa r, he sees a future in whic h … the grea t c ities of the world sha ll yet Be golden fra mes for me in whic h to set New ma sterpiec es of more ra re roma nc e. (P o em s, 156) Roma nc e promises to restore to life the spiritua lity lost during three hundred yea rs of “sophistic a tion,” three hundred yea rs tha t c orrespond roughly to the era of c a pita list modernity. Between 1914 a nd 1916, Seeger looked to the wa r to usher in the revived roma ntic ism he ima gines in the “Fa ust-motive” essa y, a roma ntic ism whose va lues opposed the “ma teria lism” of c a pita list modernity. But a s ma y be 11 glea ned even in the brief quota tion in whic h he refers to “the monotonous routine of trenc h wa rfa re,” the wa r does not offer the prospec t of this roma ntic ism in a ny unproblema tic wa y. If pa trols a nd ra ids offer the “one brea th of true roma nc e,” then the norm of wa rfa re experienc ed by Seeger a nd his c omra des is tha t of “monotonous routine.” Seeger desc ribed this routine a t some length in a n ea rlier a rtic le for the Sun. Trenc h wa rfa re, domina ted by a rtillery, “is extremely modern, a nd for the a rtilleryma n is doubtless very interesting, but for the c ommon soldier, is a nything but roma ntic ” (L e t t e r s a n d Di a r y, 29). The wa r threa tens to be a nother version of the very modernity tha t Seeger hopes to see ended by the storm tha t is the wa r. Indeed, trenc h wa rfa re tra nsforms soldiers into the very embodiments of monotonous routine: industria l workers. Seeger writes tha t a s a fternoon sha des into evening, a nd the a rtillery fire ends, “Everybody turns out like fa c tory workmen a t 5 o’c loc k” (L e t t e r s a n d D i a r y, 37). This most unspiritua l experienc e of wa r empha sizes the ba sic ma teria l a spec ts of existenc e, a nd threa tens to provide the ba sis not of a new roma ntic ism, but of a kind of ultra -ma teria lism. Seeger a llows this c ritic ism of modern wa rfa re to be voic ed most powerfully by a Serbia n c omra de: It is ignoble, this style of wa rfa re, he exc la ims. Instea d of bringing out a ll tha t is noble in a ma n, it brings out only his worse self—mea nness a nd greed a nd ill temper. We a re not, in fa c t, lea ding the lives of men a t a ll, but tha t of a nima ls,

Alan Seeger: Medievalism As an Alternative Ideology

Details

Download

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

Support