DOCSLIB.ORG

Water Law and Climate Change in the United States: a Review of the Scholarship

Water Law and Climate Change in the United States: a Review of the Scholarship

SJ Quinney College of Law, University of Utah Utah Law Digital Commons Utah Law Faculty Scholarship Utah Law Scholarship 2020 Water Law and Climate Change in the United States: A Review of the Scholarship Robin Kundis Craig Follow this and additional works at: https://dc.law.utah.edu/scholarship Part of the Environmental Law Commons, and the Natural Resources Law Commons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lectronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract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`2(,3#&'(9!2$7&2$&+$.%<a!L#02$9&8!"&#$/02+$&8!&+9!S&1&$$!90!+0'! /$'!+(&'#:!$+'0!($'*(2!)&'(,02:8!5()&3.(!(&)*!0/!'*(.(!.'&'(.!)0%5$+(.!72$02!&772072$&'$0+!&+9! 2$7&2$&+!2$,*'.!$+!$'.!01+!3+$O3(!1&:E!S&1&$$!&#.0!$+/3.(.!$'.!.'&'(!1&'(2!#&1!1$'*!H&'$4(!S&1&$$&+! Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract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b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b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

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    24 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us