ACH1.000007.000 ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RADIATION EXPERIMENTS MEETING BRIEFING BOOK VOL. 7 OCTOBER 11-13, 1994 THE PRESS CLUB OF SAN FRANCISCO 555 POST STREET SAN FRANCISCO, CA . ._ ACH?.000007.001 ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RADIATION EXPERIMENTS (- PUBLIC MEETING - OCTOBER 11-13,1994 BRIEFING BOOK (VOLUME 7) TABLE OF CONTENTS TAB A Agenda Federal Register Notice of Meeting TAB B Advisory Committee Roster Subcommittee Rosters TAB C Advisory Committee Staff & Consultant Roster Advisory Committee Staff& Consultant Bios (New hires only) TAB D Meeting Timetable and Report Deadlines Meeting Locations ( TAB E Reports and Proposals &om Subcommittees I - TAB F Current Ethics Policies and Primices TAB G StaEMemorandum - Case Study Overview StafFMemorandum - Case Study: Plutonium Injections TAB H StafFMemorandum - Institutional Case Study Selection TAB I StafFMemorandum - Biomedical Research - Selection of Case Studies TAB J StaE Memorandum - Remedies TAB K Working List of Acronyms A Tab A Agenda Federal Register Notice of Meeting c Agenda L-1-- ACH 1.000007.00 1 a October 4,1994 ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RADIATION EXPERIMENTS PUBLIC MEETING OCTOBER 11-13,1994 The Press Club of San Francisco 4 555 Post Street + San Francisco, CA TENTATIVE AGENDA Tuesdsv October 11 2:OO PM Call to Order 2:05 Opening Remarks Rurh Faden, Chair 2:15 Approval of Minutes of September 12-13, 1994 Meeting Ruth Faden 2:20 Agency Updates L Rulh Faden I 2:40 Reports from Subcommittees 3:45 Break 4:OO Reports from Subcommittees (continued) 530 Meeting Adjourned Wednesdav. October 12,1994 8:OO AM Opening Remarks Ruth Faden, Chair 8:05 Public Comments 1o:oo Break 10:15 Public Comments (continued) 12:15 PM Lunch . , Staff Report - Contemporary Ethics PoIicies and Practices Jef Kahn and Jonathan Moreno 2:oo Staff Repori - Case Study: Plutonium Injections Gregg Herken, John Harbert, and Jonathan Moreno 3:30 Break 3:45 Staff Report - Institutional Case Study Selection ~ Donald Weightman and Barbara Berney I 4:30 Meeting Adjourned Thursdav. 0 ctober 13 8:OO AM Opening Remarks Ruth Faden, Chair 8:05 Discussion of Interim Report 1o:oo Break 10:15 Discussion of Committee Strategy and Direction Ruth Faden 11:45 Meeting Adjourned I 2 r- I Federal Register Notice of Meeting -3 .' .. f, .: A~H1.000007.001b, I . c .. 1. '. !LI i L 1 ..... ..... ....... ..-......-.... ..... ~~ ..... Tab B Advisory Committee Roster Subcommittee Rosters September 1,1994 , ADVISORY COMMJ3TEE ON HUMAN RADIATION EXPERIMENTS .. .. COMMITTEE ROSTER ACHl.000007.002a I. Ruth R Faden. Ph.D.. M.P.H. - Chair LoisL. Norris Dircctof, Program in Law, Ethics and Health ., Sccond Vice Fresident of Omaha National Bank .. Pmfesor, Dcpt. of Hdth Policy & Mgmt. * andOmahaNatiodCorporation~. .'. ' The Johns Hopkins University . Oda,NE School of Hygiem and Public HeaIth .. Baltimore,MD - Nancy L. Oleinick, Ph.D. and . Profcssor of Radiation Biochemistry Senior Research Scholar DiGision of Radiation Biology ' Kcnnedy Institute of Ethics Case Western Reserve University Georgetown University School of Medicine Washington, Dc Cleveland, OH Kenneth R Feinbere. J.D. i . Henry D. Royal. M.D. Kenneth R Feinbcrg & Associates Professor of Radiology . Washington, DC Associate Director Division of Nuclear Medicine Eli Glatstein, M.D. Malhckrodt Institute of Radiology Professor and Chairman . Washington University Medical Center Department of Radiation Oncology St, Louis, MO The University of Texas Ph%D K. Russell. M.D. I Southwestern Medical.. Cktcr at Dallas Dallas, Tx . Professor, Department of International Health The Johns Hopkins University Jav Katz. M.D. School of Hygiene and Public Health Elizabeth K. Dollard Professor Emeritus of Law, Baltimore,MD * M&&e and Psychiaw, and Hmey L. Karp Professorial Lecturer Law ManAnn Stevenson, M.D., Ph.D. and Psychoanalysis Assistant Professor of Radiation Oncology Yale Law School Joint Center for Radiation Therapy New Haven, CT Haward Medical School Boston, MA Patricia A. Kine. J.D. .and Professor of Law Deputy Chief Georgetown University Law Center . New England Deaconess Hospital Washifigton, DC Department of Radiation Oncology Boston, MA Susan E. Lederer, Ph.D. Associate Professor Duncan C. Thomas. Ph.D. Department of Humanities .. Professor The Pennsylvania State Univwsity University of Southern California Collcge of Medicine , School of Medicine Hershey, PA Department of Preventive Medicine Los Angeles, CA Ruth Macklin. I'h.D. Professor of Bioethics . peed V. Tuckson, M.D. Department of Epidemiology & Social Medicine Pnsident Albert Einstein College of Medicine , Charles R Drew University of Medicine & Science I Bro&NY - Los Angeles, CA .. L Subcommittee Rosters ACHl.000007.002b TAB B October 5, 1994 SUBCOMMITTEES (Active) BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH Committee: Staff: Mary Ann Stevenson (Co-Chair) *Ron Neumann Henry Royal (Co-Chair) *Gil Whittemore Ruth Faden Don Weightman Eli Glatsfein Jonathan Engel Nancy Oleinick Philip Russell Duncan Thomas (sampling) INTENTIONAL RELEASES AND EXPOSURES/EXPERIMENTS OF OPPORTUNITY Committee: Staff: Nancy Oleinick (Co-Chair) *Barbara Berney Duncan Thomas (Co-Chair) * Mark Goodman Ken Feinberg Faith Bulger Jay Katz Gregg Herken Ruth Macklin Gil Whittemore ORAL HISTORY (Contemporarv) Committee: Staff: Susan Lederer (Chair) *Jeff Kahn Ruth Macklin *Jonathan Moreno Philip Russell Sara Chandros Jonathan Engel Jon Harkness Suzanne White Junod OUTREACH committee; Staff; Reed Tuckson (Chair) *Steve Klaidman Ruth Macklin Kris Crotty Lois Norris Lanny Keller Henry Royal c:\wpwin60\wpdocs\newsub.wpd (lcs) 10/5/94 3:03 pm SUBJECT INTERVIEWS (Contemporary) Committee; Staff; Ruth Faden (Chair) *.Jeremy Sugarman Susan Lederer Sara Chandros Nancy Kass RESEARCH PROPOSAL REVIEW (Contemporary) Comrni ttee: Staff; Jay Katz (Co-Chair)* * *Jeff Kahn Ruth Macklin (Co-Chair)** *Jonathan Moreno Ruth Faden** Barbara Berney Eli Glatstein Sara Chandros Lois Norris Nancy Kass Henry Royal Kathy Taylor Mary Ann Stevenson** Duncan Thomas (sampling)* * **signifies preliminary work on methodology REMEDlES Committee; Staff; Ken Feinberg (Chair) *Gary Stem Patricia King Faith Bulger Duncan Thomas ' Steve Klaidman SUBJECT SELECTION - CHILDREN Comrni ttee: Staff; Ruth Faden (Chair) Gil Mittemore* Pat King Sandra Thomas* Susan Lederer Ron Neumann Mary Ann Stevenson "signifies lead staff contact person SUBCOMMITTEES c.\wpwin60\wpdocs\newsub,wpd(tcs) 10/5/94 3:03 pm (Dormant) COLD WAR DATA COLLECTION Committee: Staff: Mary Ann Stevenson (Chair) Gil Whitternore Eli Glatstein Patricia King Nancy Oleinick Philip Russell ETHICS DATA COLLECTION Committee: Staff: Ruth Macklin (Chair) Jonathan Moreno Ruth Faden Eli Glatstein Susan Lederer Philip Russell SCOPE and PRIORITIES Committee: Staff: Duncan Thomas (Chair) *Anna Mastroianni Ruth Faden Faith Bulger Ken Feinberg Jay Katz Henry Royal c:\wpwin60\wpdocs\newsub wpd (tcs) 10/5/94 3:03 pm --- Advisory Committee Staff Roster C Tab C (-7 Advisory Committee Staff Roster Advisory Committee Staff Bios ACHl.000007.003a TAB C Staff-Designate Roster (Includes full and part-time staff and consultants) MANAGEMENT: Special Assistant for Committee and Staff Dan Guttman Affairs Executive Director Jeny Garcia Jeanne Kepper Jeffrey Kahn Associate Director Information Services David Saumweber Anna Mastroianni Director Associate Director Robin Cochran Stephen Klaidman Librarian Director of Communications Counselor to the Committee Tom Wisner Senior Technology Consultant PROFESSIONAL STAFF: Public Mairs Oficer Senior Policy and Research Analyst Lanny Keller Barbara Berney James David Coordinator for Congressional P elations aid John Harbert Public AfEairs Gregg Herken Kristin Crotty Jonathan Moreno Ronald Neurnann CONSULTANTS: Gary Stern Jeremy Sugarman Allen Buchanan Donald Weightman Gail Geller* Gilbert Whittemore Jon Harkness Suzanne White Junod Research Ana& Nancy Kass Faith Bulger Charles McCarthy* Jonathan Engel E.W. Webster Patrick Fitzgerald Mark Goodman ADMINISTRATIVE AND SUPPORT Deborah Holland STAFF: Denise Holmes Gail Javi tt Sally Rhoadarmer Kathy Taylor Oflice Managcr Sandra Thomas *New hires since September 12-13 meeting Research Associate Miriam Bowling* Sara Chandros John Kruger Noel Theodosiou October 3, 1994 l j Advisory Committee Staff Bios ACHI .000007.003b TAB C ,--;. Biographical Sketches New StafflConsultant Hires since September 30,1994 MIRIAM BOWLING Research Associate Before joining the Advisory Committee Staff, Ms. Bowling spent a year in Europe as a Thomas J. Watson Fellow, researching the implementation of sustainable energy resources and advances for renewable energy sources. She received her BA in physics from Swarthmore College in 1993, where she was inducted into Sigma Xi Scientific Research Honor Society for research published in Physical Review. While at Swarthmore she served as Resident Assistant for two years, planning and coordinating educational activities, student events, and residential policies. During the summers of 199 1 and 1992, Ms. Bowling served as a research and fieldmedia intern for the Union of Concerned Scientists' Energy, Arms Control, and Nuclear Safety Programs. ROBIN COCHRAN, M.L.I.S. Librarian Ms. Cochran recently received her M.L.I.S. from the University of Texas at Austin. Previously, she has worked as a senior information specialist at Congressional Research Service, a press secretary to a member of Congress, and a newspaper reporter. She received her Bachelor of Science in mass communications Lrom East Tennessee State University. GAIL GELLER, Sc.D. Consultant Gail Geller is an Assistant Professor