POPULATION STATUS, REPRODUCTIVE ECOLOGY, AND TROPHIC RELATIONSHIPS OF SEABIRDS IN NORTHWESTERN ALASKA by Alan M. Springer, Edward C. Murphy, David G. Roseneau, and Martha 1. Springer LGL Alaska Research Associates, Inc. P. O. BOX 80607 Fairbanks, Alaska 99708 Final Report Outer Continental Shelf Environmental Assessment Program Research Unit 460 April 1982 127 TABLE OF CONTENTS ~ I. SUMMARY OF OBJECTIVES, CONCLUSIONS, AND IMPLICATIONS WITH RESPECT TO OCS OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT. 131 II. INTRODUCTION. 131 III. CURRENT STATEOFKNOWLEDGE . 133 IV. STUDY AREAS. 133 Va. MURRE NUMBERS - METHODS. 135 VIa. MURRE NUMBERS-RESULTS.. 140 VIIa. MURRE NUMBERS-DISCUSSION . 145 VIIb. FOOD HABITS-METHODS. 162 VIIb . FOOD HABITS-RESULTS. 163 VIIb . FOOD HABITS -DISCUSSION. , . 168 VIIc . KITTIWAKES -METHODS. 203 VIIc . KITTIWAKES -RESULTS. 204 VIIC . KITTIWAKES -DISCUSSION. 206 VIId . OTHER SPECIES-METHODS.. 209 VId & VIId. OTHER SPECIES - RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . 209 VIII. CONCLUSIONS. 231 IX. NEEDS FORFUTURESTUDY . 232 x. LITEMITURECITED. 233 129 I. SUMMARY OF OBJECTIVES, CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS WITH REGARD TO OCS OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT A. Objectives The objective of RU 460 is to describe important components of the biology of seabirds in northern Alaska, including relationships among seabirds, their supporting food webs and the physical environment. To accomplish this objective we have concentrated on studies of thick-billed murres (Uris lomvia), common murres (U. aazge) and black-legged kittiwakes (Rissa tridactyZa), the most wide-spread, and among the most numerous, of all seabird species in the region. Moreover, murres and kittiwakes are easily studied compared to other species, and are sensitive indicators of environmental change. B: Conclusions Our principal conclusions are that numbers of murres at two major breeding colonies in northern Alaska are declining and that annual vari- ability is high in a variety of elements of murre and kittiwake breeding biology. Two possibilities that could account for declining murre numbers are decreases in natality and/or increases in winter mortality. Annual variability in murre and kittiwake breeding biology is a function of prey availability, and is predictable from conditions in the physical environ- ment during spring and summer. c. Implications with respect to OCS Oil and Gas Development Seabirds are very sensitive indicators of environmental change. They are easily and economically studied by comparison to other high- profile marine vertebrates. Studies of seabirds can yield a great amount of information on changes in marine food webs important to many top-level consumers. Such information will be necessary in order to identify possi- ble effects of oil and gas development on regional marine ecosystems. II. INTRODUCTION A. General Nature and Scope of Study Seabirds occupy top positions in marine food webs and therefore integrate many elements of regional ecosystems. Among the many species of seabirds breeding in Alaska , murres and kittiwakes are easily studied and are sensitive to changes in the environment. Our studies take advan- tage of these characteristics to examine spatial and temporal differences in several important marine food webs, and relationships among these food webs, regional physical processes and seabird biology. Substantial declines in murre populations that we have documented during recent years in northern Alaska have demonstrated the need for a system that will permit future monitoring of colonies as resource exploration and development increases on Alaska’s outer continental shelf. Therefore, our studies are designed to provide information on the popula- 131 tion status of murres and on methods to reliably census them, thus estab- lishing useful indices of numbers at major breeding colonies in Alaska. B. Specific Objectives The specific objectives are to: 1. Census murres and black-legged kittiwakes at major colonies in Northern Alaska. 2. Establish permanent census plots for monitoring numbers in future years. 3. Examine sources of variability in census methodologies that affect the bias and precision in estimates of numbers. 4. Determine levels of reproductive success and breeding phenol- ogies of murres and kittiwakes. 5. Measure growth rates of kittiwake chicks. 6. Collect specimens of murres and kittiwakes for food habits information, and as a way to sample local marine fishes and invertebrates. 7. Obtain data on other species of seabirds that would provide useful information on regional marine ecosystems. c. Relevance to Problems of Oil Development The success of OCSEAP will depend in part on the ability to detect changes in marine biological systems and, in part, on the ability to separate naturally occurring changes from changes that might result from resource development in Alaskan waters. OCSEAP sponsored studies of sea- birds in the Bering and Chukchi Seas have shown that population parameters such as numbers, breeding phenology and reproductive success can vary considerably between years. Such marked natural variation could make it difficult to determine if developmental activities were involved in bio- logical changes that might be detected in future years. Our studies have shown that the annual variability in seabird biology is not random, but is predictable from annual changes in the physical environment and in regional food webs. Information of this kind is rele- vant to problems of OCS development because it provides the means to more clearly differentiate between natural phenomena and changes resulting from resource development. This aspect of our work is acquiring added import- ance because of the recent declines in murre numbers that we have documen- ted at two major colonies, one in the eastern Chukchi Sea and the other in the northeastern Bering Sea. Seabirds are appropriate species to study not only because they are sensitive indicators of changes in the environment, but also because they are relatively easy to study, especially by comparison to other high profile marine vertebrates such as seals and whales. They also offer an excellent means of sampling lower trophic levels that often defy scientific sampling methodologies. Therefore, seabird studies can provide a great amount of relatively inexpensive information on marine ecosystem dynamics. The monitoring of seabird populations at strategic locations in Alaska may be one of the most efficient ways,of detecting significant changes resulting from OCS development. III. CURRENT STATE OF KNOWLEDGE The first serious attempt to study a large seabird colony in north- western Alaska was made by L.G. Swartz at Cape Thompson in 1959-1961. We returned there in 1976, and upon completing that first field season we were faced with two interesting questions. They were 1) What happened to all the murres, and 2) What happened to all the kittiwakes? Murre numbers were about half large as in 1960, and instead of laying nearly two eggs per clutch, the majority of kittiwakes failed to lay any eggs at all. Because other species of seabirds that nest at Cape Thompson were few in number and we saw little change in their populations compared to 1960, we devoted most of our time in the following years to studies of murres and kittiwakes. In this report, our current state of knowledge, we describe changes we saw in murre and kittiwake populations at Cape Thompson and other colonies in northwestern Alaska in the years following 1976, and discuss reasons for the changes including man-induced and natural changes in the environment. IV. STTJDY AREAS The locations of seabird colonies visited during this study are shown in Figure 1. Also shown is the location of the Owalit Mountain study area on St. Lawrence Island which we visited in 1981. Details concerning the colonies at Bluff, Cape Thompson and Cape Lisburne have been reviewed in our previous annual reports. Additional information on St. Lawrence Island can be found in our annual report for the FY81 field season. 133 180° I 78*W 176”W 174”W 172*W I 70”W 166*w 166*W 164*w 162*W 160”W 158$W ~--~ * / ‘-’f ● ✌ ☞ CHUKCH/ ✌ SEA ●f , Cape Llsburnt Point HOPI) A’ ‘seuR&E —-.~ -—---- 50 50 + . %SUL ~ KILOMETERS Cope Thompscq ● k Kivalino ‘ . , ‘) abs n2cuasu cabs kDPL6 (J Cobs MQI6 ● ✎ ✌ lodmoO MOWG Dpnoovo Bin" ,tLiowQ rnDtrwoM . , * , ● Yukon River Delta ///” .172”w I 70”W 16~”w 166SW 164”w 162”w 160”w 158”W 156aW Figure 1. Study areas in northwestern Alaska. 134 Va. MURRE NUMBBRS - SOURCES, METHODS, AND RATIONALE OF DATA COLLECTION Cape Thompson Swartz (1966) first censused the murres at the Cape Thompson colonies in 1960. In conducting the census, he subdivided each of the five colonies into census plots to facilitate counting and recorded the boundaries on photographs (Swartz, unpublished data). Plot boundaries were generally defined in accordance with geomorphic features such as cracks and deep ravines. In 1961, Swartz’s field crews counted Colony 1 three times and Colony 4 once as well as some of the census plots at the other three colonies. In each census of murres that we conducted at Cape Thompson we generally used the same plot boundaries as did Swartz”s field crews. The principal exception was at Colony 5 in 1976 when we lacked photographs showing the original plot designations. In addition, in several instances we had difficulty discerning the boundaries in the photographs and counted adjacent plots as a single unit. In 1979 all five colonies were censused on 7 or 8 August; several additional counts of Colony 1 and randomly selected plots at the other four colonies were made during the incubation and chick periods. All censuses at Cape Thompson have been made between the completion of egg-laying and the onset of sea-going of chicks , i.e.$ within the appropriate period for censusing as defined by Birkhead and Nettleship (1980). In 1979 at Cape Thompson some of the additional counts were made either shortly before the completion of egg-laying or shortly after the first sea-going of chicks. Here we include any plot counts made during the period commencing one week before the day hatching was first obse~ed and end ing one week after the first date chicks successfully left the cliffs.