“A truly engrossing chronicle.” Clive Cussler JAMES P. DELGADO SILENT KILLERS SUBMARINES AND UNDERWATER WARFARE FOREWORD BY CLIVE CUSSLER © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com SUBMARINES AND UNDERWATER WARFARE JAMES P. DELGADO With a foreword by Clive Cussler © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com CONTENTS Foreword 6 Author’s Note 7 Introduction: Into the Deep 11 Chapter 1 Beginnings 19 Chapter 2 “Sub Marine Explorers”: Would-be Warriors 31 Chapter 3 Uncivil Warriors 45 Chapter 4 Missing Links 61 Chapter 5 Later 19th Century Submarines 73 Chapter 6 Transition to a New Century 91 Chapter 7 Early 20th Century Submariness 107 Chapter 8 World War I 123 Chapter 9 Submarines Between the Wars 143 Chapter 10 World War II: the Success of the Submarine 161 Chapter 11 Postwar Innovations: the Rise of Atomic Power 189 Chapter 12 The Ultimate Deterrent: the Role of the 207 Submarine in the Modern Era Chapter 13 Memorializing the Submarine 219 Notes 239 Sources & Select Bibliography 248 Index 260 © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com FOREWORD rom the beginning of recorded history the inhabitants of the earth have had a Fgreat fascination with what exists under the waters of lakes, rivers, and the vast seas. They also have maintained a great fear of the unknown and very few wished to actually go under the surface. In the not too distant past, they had a morbid fear and were deeply frightened of what they might find. Only three out of one hundred old-time sailors could swim because they had no love of water. Yet the concept of the submarine and its protection from creatures of the deep began to emerge, and as such, began to be designed and built. Few were successful and took their creators to the bottom and never returned, but as it evolved, the submarine revolutionized naval warfare and waged brutal battles beneath the waves that sent hundreds of thousands of men to an early death. James Delgado, a distinguished pioneer of sea history, prolific writer, and author of over 20 books on ships and sea, and one of the world’s foremost marine archaeologists, takes us through a fascinating history of the submarine; from David Bushnell’s Tur tle that made the first underwater war mission in 1776 to the Confederate submarine Hunley that became the first submarine to sink a warship, through the notorious German U-boat battles to the huge nuclear-powered behemoths and the deep sea submersibles that explore the abyss. Revealed in fascinating detail, Silent Killers creates a truly engrossing chronicle of the intriguing world of undersea vehicles. Clive Cussler November 2010 © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com AUTHOR’S NOTE he premise and promise of the submarine as a means to reach Earth’s last Tfrontier, the depths of the ocean, has grasped public attention for hundreds of years, and in the last century the potential of the submarine as an instrument of war has increasingly commanded the attention of military minds. From hand-cranks, steam, electrical batteries and diesel to nuclear power, and from hand-set explosive charges to nuclear missiles, the submarine and the armaments it can deploy have made it the world’s ultimate naval weapon. The earliest wooden submarines have given rise to modern, titanium-hulled, fast, deep-diving, and stealthy “silent killers” that can strike from anywhere in the world where there is deep water – even through thick Arctic ice. As an archaeologist with an interest in the role of technology in shaping society, I have long been fascinated by the development of the submarine. That interest has been honed by incredible experiences and opportunities to work with submarines. This has included archaeological and historical research into the Type A Japanese Midget submarines of the 1930s and 1940s and the detailed analysis of a misidentified Japanese submarine in the Mariners’ Museum in Newport News, Virginia (US), said to be a sponge-diving craft but actually one of Japan’s top secret prewar prototypes for its Midget submarine force. Following these earlier projects, I was later privileged to lead the effort to document and study the 1865 Sub Marine Explorer after encountering this forgotten and anonymous submarine wreck off Panama’s Pacific coast. I was also able to lead, while director of the Vancouver Maritime Museum in Canada, the reassembly and restoration of Jacques Piccard’s famous PX-15, Ben Franklin – something that meant a great deal of physical labor on my part and that of the staff and volunteers, scraping, bolting, and rigging heavy machinery to be lifted by a crane. Which meant really getting to know the sub. Other submarine archaeological adventures and projects have included diving on the atomic-bombed submarine Pilotfish at Bikini Atoll, site © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com of the 1946 naval nuclear tests, and participating in three National Geographic projects to dive on and film the lost submarines U-21 in the North Sea and U-215 off Roberts Banks in the North Atlantic as well as the archaeological identification of the British submarine L-26 off the coast of Nova Scotia. During my tenure with the US National Park Service, and as head of the US Government’s national historic maritime preservation program, I had occasion to learn more about many of America’s historic submarines in depth – if you will pardon the pun – with many detailed tours of one of the Nishimura prototype midgets, as well as HA-19, U-505, USS Bowfin, USS Cavalla, USS Pampanito, USS Lionfish, USS Albacore, USS Becuna, USS Clamagore, USS Cobia, USS Croaker, USS Drum, USS Torsk, USS Requin, USS Nautilus, and USS Silversides. In this capacity, I also personally conducted the US National Historic Landmark studies for HA-19 and USS Clamagore. Since my Government days, my interest in submarines has extended to other tours (including some where I was very kindly given interior access) of museum-displayed craft in the US and abroad, including those of HA-14 and HA-21 and HMAS Onslow in Canberra and Sydney, Australia, HMS Alliance and Holland No. 1 in Gosport, UK, Vesikko in Helsinki, Finland, Peral in Cartagena, Spain, Fenian Ram and Intelligent Whale in Paterson and Sea Girt, New Jersey, USS Blueback in Portland, Oregon, and RV Deep Quest and Trieste II in Keyport, Washington. I have also had great tours of the submersible Nautile at IFREMER in Toulon, France, rode in Mir 2 to the bottom of the Atlantic, 2½ miles down, and attended submarine flight school to drive (or fly) the new Super Aviator submersible. Obviously, submarines are more than an interest – they are a passion. As an archaeologist, historian, and writer, I know first-hand from these experiences, as well as research in the archives, how the submarine has changed warfare and humanity’s ability to reach all parts of the planet. A number of colleagues and institutions have provided information, advice, reviews, and support through the years. I would like to thank the late Russ Booth, a dear friend whose passion for USS Pampanito was infectious, as well as Clive Cussler, Warren F. Lasch, Pete Capelotti, Mark K. Ragan, Michael “Mack” McCarthy, Captain Alfred S. McLaren, Ph.D USN (ret.), P. H. Nargeolet, David Jenkins, David Baumer, the late Toshiharu Konada of the Kaiten corps, Mike Mair, Gene Carl Feldman, Donald Kazimir, Selçuk Kolay, Oguz Aydemir, Savas Karakas, the late Jacques Piccard, Daniel Lenihan, Larry Murphy, Kevin Foster, Dave Conlin, Hank Silka, Bob Mealings, Eugene B. Canfield, Rich Wills, Lisa Bower, Clyde Paul Smith, John B. Davis, Mike Fletcher, Warren Fletcher, Bob Neyland, Chris Amer, Maria Jacobsen, Paul Mardikian, John McKee, Bob Schwemmer, Doug DeVine, Carlos Velasquez, Todd Croteau, John Wagner, Joe Hoyt, and John McKay. The following organizations and institutions were also a great help: the Australian National Maritime Museum, Sydney; the Estonian Maritime Museum, Tallinn; the Rahmi M. Koç Museum, Istanbul; the Museo Naval, Cartagena, Spain; the Royal Navy Submarine Museum, Gosport; the Imperial War Museum, London; the Chicago 8 Silent Killers © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com Museum of Science and Industry, Chicago, Illinois; Baltimore Maritime Museum, Baltimore, Maryland; the Warren F. Lasch Conservation Center, Charleston, South Carolina; The Friends of the Hunley, Charleston, South Carolina; Buffalo Naval & Military Park, Buffalo, New York; Battleship Memorial Park, Mobile, Alabama; Battleship Cove Museum, Fall River, Massachusetts; the Paterson Museum, Paterson, New Jersey; Independence Seaport Museum, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; the Naval & Maritime Museum, Muskegon, Michigan; the Oregon Museum of Science and Industry, Portland, Oregon; the Vallejo Naval and Historical Museum, Vallejo, California; the USS Bowfin Museum and Park, Honolulu, Hawaii; the Connecticut River Museum, Essex, Connecticut; the Vancouver Maritime Museum, Canada; Patriots Point Maritime Museum, Mount Pleasant, South Carolina; the Wisconsin Maritime Museum, Manitowoc, Wisconsin; the US Navy Submarine Force Library & Museum, Groton, Connecticut; the Naval Undersea Museum, Keyport, Washington; the Mariners’ Museum, Newport News, Virginia (US); the National Museum of the Pacific War, Fredericksburg, Texas; the National Maritime Museum, San Francisco; the National Guard Militia Museum at Sea Girt; the US National Archives, Military Branch and Still Pictures Branch, Washington, DC and the US Naval History and Heritage Command, Washington, DC; the Library of Congress, Washington, DC; and the US Naval Institute, Annapolis, Maryland. The review and editing of my assistant, Kathy Smith, once again made the task of writing easier. I owe her my usual debt of gratitude. I also wish to thank the Osprey team, especially Kate Moore and Emily Holmes. Last, but not least, I thank my wife, Ann, for her constant support and love. James P. Delgado August 2010 Author’s Note 9 © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com © Osprey Publishing • www.ospreypublishing.com Introduction INTO THE DEEP t the advent of the 21st century, the sea holds the unfortunate distinction of Abeing humanity’s largest battlefield, the result of millennia of naval warfare.