Astron. Nachr. / AN 999, No.88, 789–797 (2006) / DOI please set DOI! Precovery of near-Earth asteroids by a citizen-science project of the Spanish Virtual Observatory. E. Solano1,2,⋆, C. Rodrigo1,2, R. Pulido1,2, and B. Carry3 1 Centro de Astrobiolog´ıa (INTA-CSIC), Departamento de Astrof´ısica. Campus Villafranca. P.O. Box 78, E-28691 Vil- lanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain 2 Spanish Virtual Observatory 3 IMCCE, Observatoire de Paris, UPMC, CNRS, 77 Av. Denfert Rochereau 75014 Paris, France Received xx Dec 2012, accepted xxxxx Published online later Key words Asteroids – astronomical databases: miscellaneous This article describes a citizen-science project conducted by the Spanish Virtual Observatory (SVO) to improve the orbits of near-Earth asteroids (NEAs) using data from astronomical archives. The list of NEAs maintained at the Minor Planet Center (MPC) is checked daily to identify new objects or changes in the orbital parameters of already catalogued objects. Using NEODyS we compute the position and magnitude of these objects at the observing epochs of the 938 046 images comprising the Eigth Data Release of the Sloan Digitised Sky Survey (SDSS). If the object lies within the image bound- aries and the magnitude is brighter than the limiting magnitude, then the associated image is visually inspected by the project’s collaborators (the citizens) to confirm or discard the presence of the NEA. If confirmed, accurate coordinates and, sometimes, magnitudes are submitted to the MPC. Using this methodology, 3,226 registered users have made during the first fifteen months of the project more than 167,000 measurements which have improved the orbital elements of 551 NEAs (6% of the total number of this type of asteroids). Even more remarkable is the fact that these results have been obtained at zero cost to telescope time as NEAs were serendipitously observed while the survey was being carried out. This demonstrates the enormous scientific potential hidden in astronomical archives. The great reception of the project as well as the results obtained makes it a valuable and reliable tool for improving the orbital parameters of near-Earth asteroids. c 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH& Co. KGaA, Weinheim 1 Introduction Although the first NEA was not discovered until 1898 (Eros) and the first NEA that actually crosses Earth’s or- Small Solar System bodies were defined in 2006 by the IAU bit (Apollo) was not found until 1932, already in the 17th as those objects that are neither planets nor dwarf planets, century Edmond Halley raised the danger of a potential im- nor satellites of a planet or dwarf planet1. They are rem- pact with the Earth (Chapman 2004). The discovery in the nants of the early stages of the solar system formation pro- late 1980s of NEAs passing by the Earth at distances com- cess and the vast majority of them can be found in two dis- parable to that of the Moon or the impact of the comet tinct areas: the asteroid belt and the Edgeworth-Kuiper belt. Shoemaker-Levy 9 to Jupiter in July 1994 led to an in- Nevertheless, due to the Yarkovsky effect, some main-belt creased awareness of the potential threat of these objects. In 1998 NASA set the goal of discovering within one decade arXiv:1302.5375v1 [astro-ph.IM] 21 Feb 2013 asteroids can be thermally drifted from their source loca- tions to chaotic resonance zones capable of injecting them 90% of NEAs with diameters greater than > 1 km. This ob- into the inner Solar System (Bottke et al. 2006). jective was extended in 2005 to detect, track, catalogue and Near-Earth asteroids (NEAs) are small bodies whose or- characterize the physical properties of 90% of NEAs equal bits bring them into close proximity with the Earth (perihe- to or greater than 140 meters in diameter before 2020. The lion distance q < 1.3 AU)2. Potentially Hazardous Asteroids projects that came up to fulfil these mandates gave rise to (PHAs) are defined based on parameters that measure the a significant increment in the number of NEAs. A detailed object’s potential to make threatening close approaches to description of the main NEA discovery programmes can be the Earth. NEAs having a minimum orbital intersection dis- found in Vaduvescu et al. (2011). The resolution approved tance (MOID) < 0.05 AU and an absolute magnitudes H < in the IAU General Assembly held in Beijing in August 22 (which corresponds to objects larger than about 100 m) 2012 to “coordinate and collaborate on the establishment are considered PHAs. of an International near-Earth objects (NEO) early warn- ing system, relying on the scientific and technical advice of ⋆ Corresponding author: e-mail: [email protected] the relevant astronomical community, whose main purpose is the reliable identification of potential NEO collisions with 1 http://www.iau.org/static/resolutions/Resolution GA26-5-6.pdf the Earth, and the communication of the relevant parame- 2 http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/neo/groups.html c 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH& Co. KGaA, Weinheim 790 E. Solano, C. Rodrigo, R. Pulido & B. Carry: Using the Virtual Observatory to precover near-Earth asteroids ters to suitable decisions makers of the nation(s) involved”, astronomical archives. Information in digital format can be is a significant step further to highlight the importance of analysed by computers and can be accessible remotely.Nev- having an accurate knowledge of the number, size and or- ertheless, the high degree of heterogeneity and the lack of bital behaviour of the small objects that populate the Earth’s interoperability among astronomical services (different ac- vicinity. cess procedures, data representation, retrieval methods,...) Discovery alone is not enough to quantify the thread hinders the scientific analysis of combined information level of a NEA. Above all, it is necessary to compute re- from more than one astronomical resource and just very liable orbits through accurate astrometric positions cov- few projects (e.g., Boattini et al. 2001, Vaduvescu 2011 and ering a period of time as long as possible. This can be references therein) have been devoted so far to mine astro- achieved using two complementary approaches: performing nomical archives. These drawbacks can be overcome if the follow-up observations after discovery or mining astronom- discovery, gathering and analysis of the information is car- ical archives with information (images, catalogues) prior to ried out in the framework of the Virtual Observatory6, an the discovery date. Precovery (short for “pre-discovery re- international initiative designed to provide the astronomical covery”) is the term that describes the process of identifying community with the data access and the research tools nec- an object in archive data whose presence was not detected at essary to enable the exploration of the digital, multiwave- the time the observation was made. Although different valu- length universe resident in the astronomical data archives. able results obtained by precovery searches can be found Every single image taken by the most important ground in the literature (e.g., the improvements of the orbital so- and space-based astronomical observatories eventually end lutions of the Hale-Boop (McNaught & Cass 1995) and up in open archives, freely available on the web. This repre- Swift-Tuttle comets (Marsden et al. 1992)), the importance sents an immensely data-rich field where the general public of this approach was not clearly proved until the discovery can significantly contribute, in particular in projects related of Apophis in December 2004. Follow-up observations per- to classification, pattern recognition and outlier identifica- formed within one week after its discovery rose Apophis to tion where the visual inspection has proved exceptionally an unprecedented level of hazard alert in the Torino Scale, good. Although the huge amount of data available in as- which describes and quantifies the risks associated with as- tronomical archives and services make visual analysis by a teroid collisions according to the probability of impact and single individual or reduced group of collaborators impos- size of the impactor (Binzel 2000).The level of 4 reached by sible, this problem can be overcome if a crowdsourcing sce- Apophis was due to its non-negligible probability of 2.6% nario is considered. This is the basis of the citizen-science to hit the Earth in 2029 and to cause localized destruction: projects whose most popular examples in Astrophysics are with a diameter of about 300 m, Apophis would have cre- Galaxy Zoo7 and its extension to Zooniverse8. The discov- ated an impact crater of about 3 km. It was not until the use ery of extrasolar planet candidates using the Kepler Public of precovery positions taken in March 2004 (nine months Archive (Fischer et al. 2012) or the identification of a new before discovery) when the impact could be ruled out. In class of compact star-forming galaxies (The Green Peas, parallel to an accurate determination of the risk of impact, Cardamone et al. 2009) are excellent examples of the abil- extending the observed arc of the orbit through precovery ity of human classifiers to recognize unusual patterns which observations also allows other types of studies like, for in- computer search algorithms are unable to spot. stance, orbital evolution (Asher & Steel 1993). Despite its potential, very few projects have been de- In this paper we describe a citizen-science project de- 9 voted to look for asteroids in astronomical archives. Some signed by the Spanish Virtual Observatory (SVO) to pre- pioneering initiatives started in the nineties using photo- cover NEAs in the Data Release 8 of the Sloan Digital Sky graphic plates: AANEAS3, AANEOPP4 or DANEOPS5, to Survey (SDSS, Hiroaki et al. 2011). Through visual inspec- name a few.