LETTER doi:10.1038/nature10372 An earlier origin for the Acheulian Christopher J. Lepre1,2,He´le`ne Roche3, Dennis V. Kent1,2, Sonia Harmand3, Rhonda L. Quinn2,4, Jean-Philippe Brugal5, Pierre-Jean Texier6, Arnaud Lenoble6 & Craig S. Feibel2 The Acheulian is one of the first defined prehistoric techno- the nearly 170-m-thick Kaitio member. Six of those sites have been complexes and is characterized by shaped bifacial stone tools1–3. tested or largely excavated but many other potential sites have been It probably originated in Africa, spreading to Europe and Asia pinpointed. Most of these Kokiselei sites contain typical core/flake perhaps as early as 1 million years (Myr) ago4–6. The origin of Oldowan assemblages12. Kokiselei 4 (KS4), however, holds an excep- the Acheulian is thought to have closely coincided with major tional lithic assemblage that confirms the co-occurrence of the changes in human brain evolution, allowing for further technolo- Oldowan and Acheulian at this site complex, indicating that the beha- gical developments7,8. Nonetheless, the emergence of the Acheulian vioural repertoire of early hominins in the area incorporated both remains unclear because well-dated sites older than 1.4 Myr ago are technologies. scarce. Here we report on the lithic assemblage and geological con- The KS4 assemblage (Supplementary Fig. 2) is characterized by the text for the Kokiselei 4 archaeological site from the Nachukui forma- presence of pick-like tools with a trihedral or quadrangular section, tion (West Turkana, Kenya) that bears characteristic early Acheulian unifacially or bifacially shaped crude hand-axes, and a few cores and tools and pushes the first appearance datum for this stone-age tech- flakes, all derived from the same mudstone bed. A single subsurface, in nology back to 1.76 Myr ago. Moreover, co-occurrence of Oldowan situ origin for KS4 is ensured by excavations at the main test trench that and Acheulian artefacts at the Kokiselei site complex indicates that recovered several spectacular sets of refitted lithic artefacts (Sup- the two technologies are not mutually exclusive time-successive com- plementary Fig. 3). To the exception of a few cores made on basalt, ponents of an evolving cultural lineage, and suggests that the the rest of the assemblage has been knapped from large cobbles or Acheulian was either imported from another location yet to be iden- tabular clasts of locally available aphiric phonolite13. No vertebrate tified or originated from Oldowan hominins at this vicinity. In remains have been found within the test trenches, but the mudstone either case, the Acheulian did not accompany the first human dis- bed has yielded numerous non-human vertebrate fossils. The most persal from Africa9,10 despite being available at the time. This may frequent taxon is the large-sized hippopotamus Hippopotamus gorgops indicate that multiple groups of hominins distinguished by separate (adult and juvenile), but suids (Kolpochoerus, Metridiochoerus, stone-tool-making behaviours and dispersal strategies coexisted in Notochoerus?), rhinoceros (Ceratotherium sp.), equids (Equus and Africa at 1.76 Myr ago. Hipparion) and a few carnivores (Panthera, Hyaenidae aff. Crocuta) Sediments of the Nachukui formation exposed along the northwest are also present.Some isolated teeth and post-cranial elements represent shoreline of modern Lake Turkana in Kenya11 (Fig. 1 and Supplemen- bovids, and it is possible to identify Bovini (aff. Syncerus), Reduncini tary Fig. 1) preserve several rich archaeological site complexes, among (Kobus sp.) and medium-sized Tragelaphini and Alcelaphini. which is Kokiselei. Thus far, this complex is defined by ten sites, eight Broadly speaking, the Acheulian tools of KS4 come from a 15–20-m- of which are found within a discrete 5-m interval of the middle part of thick interbedded series of gravels, sands and mudstones colloquially ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ SEC. 7400 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Study site/section ~ ~ ~ 4° 0' 55" N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ and coordinates ~ ~ ~ ~ 35° 46' 20" E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Town of ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Nachukui ′ ′′ Outcrop traces ~~ ~ SEC. 7000 top 4° 3 50 N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ′ ′′ and contacts ~ ~ ~ 4° 4 39 N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ′ ′′ ~~ ~ 35° 49 2 E Ephemeral ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ SEC. 7000 base ~ ~ stream ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ′ ′′ ~ 4° 4 9 N ~ ~ ~ ~ Unpaved ~~ ~ 35° 49′ 32′′ E ~ ~ ~ road ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ETHIOPIA ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Kokiselei Stratigraphic units ~ ~ ~ a ~ Age (Myr) ~ ~ SEC. 7400 k ~ ~ ~ ~ ′ ′′ N { ~ 4° 0 55 N Lake r ~ ~ ~ ~ Alluvium, collvium ′ ′′ N 3º N 5º <0.8 ~ ~ ~ 35° 46 20 E SOMALIA u ~ Turkana and other sediments ~ ~ ~ ~ T Mogadishu ~ ~ ~ { ~ ~ ~ e ~ Natoo to ~ N 1º ~ ~ KENYA 1.6–0.8 ~ k ~ ~ Nariokotome mbrs ~ 0º ~ { ~ a SEC. 7100 ~ ~ ′ ′′ Kalochoro to 4° 0 20 N L 2.3–1.6 ~ ~ Nairobi S 1º Kaitio mbrs ~ 35° 46′ 33′′ E ~ ~ 0 km 2.5 { ~~ N Lomekwi to Nachukui Fm. 3.4–2.3 Lokalalei mbrs ~ S 3º (excepting basal mbrs) TANZANIA 500 km { Rift-related volcanics >4.0 35° 52′ 50′′ E and other rocks E 35º E 37º E 39º E 41º E 43º E 45º E 47º E 49º S 5º Figure 1 | Geological11 and location map. Note the latitude and longitude base and top are given. The other two—SEC. 7100 and SEC. 7400 (the latter of coordinates provided for each place of investigation. Section 7000 (SEC. 7000) which is where the Acheulian site KS4 was excavated)—derive from sheer was surveyed ,200 m along the ephemeral stream; hence the indications of the outcrops, and the coordinates for only the top of the sections are given. 1Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Palisades, New York 10964, USA. 2Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Rutgers University, Piscataway, New Jersey 08854, USA. 3UMR CNRS 7055, Universite´ Paris Ouest Nanterre, 92023 Nanterre Cedex, France. 4Department of Sociology, Anthropology, and Social Work, Seton Hall University, South Orange, New Jersey 07079, USA. 5UMR CNRS 6636, Maison Me´diterrane´enne des Sciences de l’Homme, BP 647-F-13094, Aix-en-Provence Cedex 2, France. 6UMR CNRS 5199-PACEA, Universite´ de Bordeaux1, 33405 Talence, France. 82|NATURE|VOL477|1SEPTEMBER2011 ©2011 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved LETTER RESEARCH referred to as the bird cliff beach complex (BCBC). Outcrops of the as the siltstone, can be very poorly sorted in places and include volcanic BCBC are part of a nearly continuous band of sediments belonging to granules/pebbles. Such lithostratigraphic and sedimentary patterns the Kalochoro and Kaitio members that extends for over 7 km from suggest a dynamic environment along a palaeo-lakeshore. northeast to southwest along the modern northwest shoreline of Lake In the Kokiselei region the erosive base of the BCBC occurs varyingly Turkana, Kenya (Fig. 1). These members of the Nachukui formation at 1–15 m above the Kaitio member’s lowermost stratigraphic level, record a transition from predominantly fluvial to lacustrine sedi- which is the KBS tuff11 dated by 40Ar/39Ar to 1.869 6 0.021 Myr ago15. mentation in the Pleistocene Turkana basin during which the rest The KBS tuff lies 78 m above the Kalochoro tuff, dated by 40Ar/39Ar to of East Africa is thought to have undergone ecosystem turnover in 2.331 6 0.015 Myr ago16, which defines the base of the Kalochoro response to global climate forcing14. A first indication of lacustrine member11. No direct numerical age constraints have been determined deposits occurs ,35 m above the base of the Kalochoro member, for the BCBC; however, regional geological mapping and tephrostrati- marked by the appearance of silty/clayey, often thinly bedded and graphic studies indicate that it is ,150 m below the base of the Lower finely laminated, ostracod-rich lacustrine mudstones, which coarsen Koobi Fora tuff11 dated by 40Ar/39Ar to 1.476 6 0.013 Myr ago15. upwardly into poorly sorted massive mudstones (Supplementary Figs Linear extrapolation from the Kalochoro and KBS tuffs and linear 8–11). Thin lenticular units of gravel and sand become apparent near interpolation from the KBS and Lower Koobi Fora tuffs broadly con- the top of the Kalochoro member, which heralds the appearance of the strain the KS4 Acheulian assemblage to between 1.72 and 1.81 Myr BCBC in the Kaitio member. Lithological units of the BCBC form ago. Other dated tuffaceous beds between the KBS and Lower Koobi metre-thick, coarsening-upward cycles of claystone, siltstone and sand Fora tuffs in the Turkana basin that would further refine stratigraphic and/or gravel. At KS4, the coarsest layers of the BCBC consist of position have not been found in the Kokiselei region. To place the KS4 gravelly sands that preserve abundant rhizoconcretions at their tops artefacts within a more constrained age context, we collected 148 (Supplementary Figs 10 and 11). Claystones of the cycles contain thin orientated samples for palaeomagnetic analysis (see Supplementary lenses of mollusc shells and are dissected by slickensided fractures that Methods and Supplementary Figs 4–7) from sections of outcrop define wedge-shaped aggregates of palaeosols. These claystones, as well exposed at this archaeological site and adjacent locations (Fig. 1). Stratigraphy Lithology VGP lat. (°) Polarity KS4 Acheulian GPTS Site Significance Age (Myr ago) Front Back negative negative Konso, Early 1.4 0–04 45 900–90–45 110 Ethiopia Acheulian (m) artefacts 20 cm 1.5 105 cortex cortex 100 1.6 Matuyama Oldest-known 95 Koobi Fora, SEC. 7400 cranium of African 1.7 Kenya Homo erectus 90 Kokiselei, World’s oldest- Kenya known Acheulian 1.8 Kaitio member Vrica 85 Earliest out-of-Africa ‘envelope’ (e.g., Dmanisi, Java) 1.9 SEC. 7100 KBS tuff 80 Olduvai 1.87 Myr ago 75 2.0 70 2.1 Matuyama 65 Reunion 2.2 60 Oldest-known stone tools in Lokalalei, Nachukui formation 2.3 55 Kenya Multiple, World’s oldest-known including fossils of early Homo 50 2.4 Lokalalei Matuyama 45 Gona, World’s oldest- 2.5 SEC. 7000 Nachukui formation Ethiopia known stone tools 40 2.6 35 2.7 30 Kalochoro member Kalochoro Gauss 25 2.8 20 2.9 15 3.0 10 5 Kalochoro tuff 0 2.33 Myr ago Figure 2 | Summary diagram.