Case 5:18-cv-06164-EJD Document 88-4 Filed 09/28/20 Page 1 of 11 Exhibit 4 Case 5:18-cv-06164-EJD Document 88-4 Filed 09/28/20 Page 2 of 11 All dollar amounts are in millions Primary Cross-Check % of Common Multiplier Case Name Cite Judge Fee Order Date Case Type Fee $ Approved Calculation Common Fund $ Lodestar $ Method Fund Approved Approved Method Craft v. Cty. of San 1 Bernardino,, 1124 624 F. Supp. 2d 1113 Stephen G. Larson April 1, 2008 Civil Rights $ 6.375 CF Lodestar $ 25.648 25% $ 1.200 5.20 2 Kurihara v. Best Buy Co. 2010 WL 11575623 Marilyn Hall Patel April 1, 2010 Wage & Hour $ 0.898 Lodestar $ 5.000 6% $ 0.718 1.25 Garner v. State Farm Breach od 3 Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. 2010 WL 1687829 Claudia Wilken April 22, 2010 Contract $ 4.500 CF Lodestar $ 15.000 30% <2 4 Briggs v. United States 2010 WL 1759457 William Alsup April 30, 2010 debt collection $ 1.120 Lodestar $ 7.400 $ 1.119 1.00 Privay/Data 5 Lane v. Facebook, Inc. 2010 WL 2076916 Richard Seeborg May 24, 2010 Breach $ 2.322 Lodestar $ 9.510 24% $ 1.161 2.00 6 In re LDK Solar Sec. Litig. 2010 WL 3001384 William Alsup July 29, 2010 Securities $ 16.000 $ 16.000 13.75% $ 7.600 0.29 In re WAL–MART STORES, INC. WAGE AND 7 HOUR LITIGATION 2011 WL 31266 Saundra Brown Armstrong January 5, 2011 Wage & Hour $ 23.220 CF Lodestar $86-$43 27% of ceiling ~$16.6 1.40 Chu v. Wells Fargo 8 Investments, LLC 2011 WL 672645 Marilyn Hall Patel February 16, 2011 Wage & Hour $ 1.725 CF Lodestar $ 6.900 25% $ 1.175 1.47 Waters v. AT & T Servs., 9 Inc. 2011 WL 672636 Beth Labson Freeman February 17, 2011 Wage & Hour $ 2.519 Lodestar CF $ 17.000 15% $ 1.260 2.00 10 Kanawi v. Bechtel Corp., 2011 WL 782244 Charles R. Bryer March 1, 2011 ERISA $ 4.860 CF Lodestar $ 18.500 30% $ 10.800 0.45 In re Mercury Interactive 11 Corp. Sec. Litig. 2011 WL 826797 Jeremy Fogel March 3, 2011 Securities $ 25.850 CF Lodestar $ 117.500 22% #REF! 3.08 In re CHARLES SCHWAB CORPORATION 12 SECURITIES LITIGATION 2011 WL 1481424 William Alsup April 19, 2011 Securities $ 21.704 CF Lodestar $ 235.000 9% $ 7.080 2.68 Wren v. RGIS Inventory 13 Specialists 2011 WL 1230826 Joseph C. Spero May 13, 2011 FLSA $ 11.300 Lodestar CF $ 27.000 42% $ 11.300 1.00 In re Wachovia Corp. "Pick-A-Payment" Mortg. Mktg. & Sales Practices 14 Litig. 2011 WL 1877630 Jeremy Fogel May 17, 2011 TILA $ 25.000 CF lodestar $ 75.000 33% $ 11.000 2.20 15 In re Apple Inc. Sec. Litig. 2011 WL 1877988 Jeremy Fogel May 17, 2011 Securities $ 1.966 CF $ 16.500 12% In re Google Buzz Privacy Privacy/Data 16 Litig. 2011 WL 7460099 James Ware June 2, 2011 Breach $ 2.125 $ 6.065 35% Buccellato v. AT & T 17 Operations, Inc. 2011 WL 3348055 Lucy H. Koh June 30, 2011 $ 13.000 Buccellato v. AT&T 18 Operations, Inc. 2011 WL 3348055 Lucy H. Koh June 30, 2011 FLSA $ 3.125 CF $ 12.500 25% 4.30 In re Nuvelo, Inc. Sec. 19 Litig. 2011 WL 2650592 Charles R. Bryer July 6, 2011 Securities $ 2.491 CF Lodestar $ 8.900 30% $ 7.000 0.36 In re Wells Fargo Loan Processor Overtime Pay 20 Litig. 2011 WL 3352460 Edward M. Chen August 2, 2011 Wage & Hour $ 1.558 CF Lodestar $ 7.218 22% $ 1.800 0.87 In re TD AMERITRADE ACCOUNT HOLDER 21 LITIGATION 2011 WL 4079226 Saundra Brown Armstrong September 13, 2011 Data Breach $ 0.500 CF Lodestar 2.5-6.5 7.70% $ 1.295 <1 22 Paulsen v. CNF, Inc. 2011 WL 13286132 James Ware October 24, 2011 ERISA $ 2.530 CF Lodestar $ 9.200 27.50% $ 2.796 0.90 Hofstetter v. Chase 23 Home Fin., LLC 2011 WL 5545912 William Alsup November 14, 2011 Insurance $ 2.250 Lodestar CF $ 10.137 23% $ 1.100 2.00 In re Wells Fargo Mortgage-Backed Certif. CF (terse, no 24 Litig. 11-cv-01376-LHK Lucy H. Koh November 14, 2011 Securities $ 24.509 discussion) $ 125.000 19.75 Case 5:18-cv-06164-EJD Document 88-4 Filed 09/28/20 Page 3 of 11 In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) 25 Antitrust Litig. 2011 WL 7575003 Susan Illston December 27, 2011 Antitrust $ 121.507 CF Lodestar $ 405.022 30% #REF! 1.10 Taylor v. FedEx Freight, Labor 26 Inc. 10-cv-02118-LHK Lucy H. Koh January 27, 2012 Employment $ 1.750 N/A $ 5.250 33% In re Cadence Design Sys., Inc. Sec. & Derivative Litig., No. 08- 27 4966, , at *2 (N.D. Cal. ) 2012 WL 1414092 Samuel Conti April 23, 2012 Securities $ 7.200 CF Lodestar $ 38.000 19% $ 2.529 2.88 28 Standiford v. Palm, Inc. 09-cv-05719-LHK Lucy H. Koh May 31, 2012 CF $ 0.640 25% $ 226,305.000 Li v. A Perfect Day 29 Franchise, Inc. 2012 WL 2236752 Lucy H. Koh June 15, 2012 FLSA $ 1.344 LS (default jmt) $ 11.141 N/A Lemus v. H&R Block Privacy/Data 30 Enterprises LLC. 2012 WL 12946714 Richard Seeborg September 10, 2012 Breach $ 4.978 CF Lodestar $ 19.915 25% $ 5.391 1.08 31 Arthur v. Sallie Mae, Inc. 2012 WL 4076119 James L. Robart September 17, 2012 TCPA $ 4.830 CF $ 21.900 20% Vallabhapurapu v. Burger King Corp., No. C 11- 00667 WHA,, at *3 (N.D. 32 Cal. ) 2012 WL 5349389 William Alsup October 29, 2012 ADA $ 4.592 Lodestar CF $ 14.250 25% $ 3.547 1.29 In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) 33 Antitrust Litig. 2013 WL 149692 Susan Illston January 14, 2013 Antitrust $ 20.400 CF Lodestar $ 68.000 30% $ 23.688 0.86 Hopkins v. Stryker Sales 34 Corp. 2013 WL 496358 Lucy H. Koh February 6, 2013 Wage & Hour CF $ 4.500 30% $ 0.460 2.76 35 Vincent v. Reser 2013 WL 621865 Charles R. Bryer February 19, 2013 ERISA $ 1.281 CF Lodestar $ 5.125 25% #REF! 1.09 36 In re Netflix Privacy Litig. 2013 WL 1120801 Edward J. Davila March 18, 2013 data breach $ 2.250 CF Lodestar $ 9.000 25% $ 1.352 1.66 LaGarde v. Support.com, 37 Inc. 2013 WL 1283325 Jacqueline Scott Corley March 26, 2013 Consumer Fraud $ 0.481 Lodestar $ 8.595 5.60% $ 0.481 1.00 In re TFT–LCD (FLAT PANEL) ANTITRUST 38 LITIGATION 2013 WL 1365900 Susan Illston April 3, 2013 Antitrust $ 309.725 $ 1,008.000 28.60% 2.4-2.6 Breach of Marolda v. Symantec contract/consu 39 Corp. 2013 WL 12310821 Edward M. Chen April 5, 2013 mer $ 1.700 CF Lodestar $ 39.535 4.30% $ 0.800 2.00 40 Pecover v. Elec. Arts Inc. 2013 WL 12121865 Claudia Wilken May 30, 2013 Antitrust $ 7.290 CF Lodestar $ 27.000 27% #REF! 1.15 41 Pimental v. Google Inc. 2013 WL 12177158 Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers June 26, 2013 TCPA $ 1.500 CF Lodestar $ 6.000 25% $ 0.820 1.83 Vedachalam v. Tata breach of 42 Consultancy Servs., Ltd 2013 WL 3941319 Claudia Wilken July 18, 2013 contract $ 8.925 CF Lodestar $ 29.750 30% $ 4.840 1.84 43 Pokorny v. Quixtar, Inc. 2013 WL 3790896 Samuel Conti July 18, 2013 RICO $ 15.000 $ 55.000 27.30% $ 6.818 2.20 LS (Cal stat, Consumer agreed blended X 44 Ferrington v. Mcafee 2013 WL 12308314 Lucy H. Koh July 22, 2013 Protection $ 0.455 .39) $ 1.625 25.67% $ 1.042 0.39 Ralston v. Mortg. Inv'rs 45 Grp., Inc. 2015 WL 5027603 Lucy H. Koh September 19, 2013 Consumer Fraud $ 25.037 CF Lodestar $ 100.150 25% $ 8.653 2.89 Ralston v. Mortg. Inv'rs 46 Grp., Inc. 2013 WL 5290240 Jeremy Fogel September 19, 2013 Fraud $ 25.037 CF Lodestar $ 100.150 25% $ 8.654 2.80 Debt Collection & Breach of 47 Bottoni v. Sallie Mae, Inc. 2013 WL 12312794 Laurel Beeler November 21, 2013 contract $ 1.200 Lodestar CF $76 in debt relief 1.50% ~$0.93 1.29 48 Bottoni v. Sallie Mae, Inc. 2013 WL 12312794 Laurel Beeler November 21, 2013 debt collection $ 1.200 Lodestar CF $ 76.000 2% $ 0.927 1.29 Walsh v. Kindred 49 Healthcare 2013 WL 6623224 Jeffrey S. White December 16, 2013 Elder abuse $ 2.489 $ 8.250 30% $ 2.566 0.97 Consumer Breach of 50 Ross v. Trex Co., Inc. 2013 WL 12174133 Jeffrey S. White December 16, 2013 Contract $ 1.321 Lodestar $ 9.800 13% $ 1.776 0.74 Case 5:18-cv-06164-EJD Document 88-4 Filed 09/28/20 Page 4 of 11 CF (request is less labor than 25% 51 Lofstrom v. Miasole 12-cv-05184-LHK Lucy H. Koh December 27, 2013 employment $ 0.058 benchmark) In re Diamond Foods, 52 Inc., Sec. Litig. 2014 WL 106826 William Alsup January 10, 2014 Securities $ 1.445 CF $ 11.000 breach of unkown but could 53 Nwabueze v. AT&T Inc., 2014 WL 324262 Susan Illston January 29, 2014 contract $ 5.500 Lodestar exceed 100 million $ 6.035 0.91 54 Johnson v. Sky Chefs, Inc. 11-cv-05619-LHK Lucy H. Koh February 6, 2014 FLSA $ 0.116 CF $ 0.350 $ 0.361 0.32 Moore v. Verizon Unknown at time 16 - 55 Commc'ns Inc.