Appendix 9.1 Schedule of Significant Historic Heritage Places 18 September 2015 Council's proposed changes are shown in strikethrough and underline Black text changes record amendments proposed in first mediation session Green text changes record amendments proposed and agreed to in mediation Red text changes record amendments proposed in rebuttal evidence Blue text changes record amendments proposed post hearing (e.g. right of reply) Yellow highlighted text changes record amendments that are considered to be outside the scope of submissions. Grey highlight text changes record consequential amendments. [all provisions in this appendix are: rcp/dp] Heritage values The sSchedule of Significant hHistoric hHeritage pPlaces identifies historic heritage places in Auckland which have significant historic heritage value. The heritage value evaluation criteria against which historic heritage places are evaluated are set out in the RPS - Historic Heritage. They are The evaluation criteria that are relevant to each scheduled historic heritage place are identified in the schedule using the following letters: A: historical B: social C: Mana Whenua D: knowledge E: technology F: physical attributes G: aesthetic H: context. The values that are evident within scheduled historic heritage places (at the time of scheduling) are identified in the column headed ‘Known heritage values’ in the schedule. Applicability of rules Rules controlling the subdivision, use, and development of land and water within scheduled historic heritage places are set out in the Historic Heritage overlay rules. - Historic Heritage. The rules in the historic heritage overlay activity tables apply to all scheduled historic heritage places. They apply to all land and water within the extent of the scheduled historic heritage place, including the public realm, land covered by water and any body of water. Where the ‘extent of place’ entry for a scheduled historic heritage place is annotated with a # symbol in the schedule, no geographic extent of place has been delineated. Deborah Rowe ! 10/7/15 2:52 PM for the place. The In this case the rules in J2 activity tables 1 and 2 apply to all land Comment [1]: Consequential amendments made to this paragraph to align wording with similar wording in the introduction to J2 rules. Page 1 of 3 1 or water within 50m of any feature identified in the place name or description annotated with a # in the schedule. In most cases, the extents of scheduled historic heritage places are shown on the planning maps. In some instances figures in Appendix 9.3 of the Schedule provide Deborah Rowe ! 9/8/15 9:31 AM greater specificity as to the extent of place of certain scheduled historic heritage Comment [2]: SCOPE: University of places. Where the extent of place for a scheduled historic heritage place is shown in Auckland (5662-18) a figure in Appendix 9.3, it shall prevail over the extent shown on the planning maps. Category A* The scheduled historic heritage places that are identified as Category A* are the most significant scheduled historic heritage places from legacy plans where total or Deborah Rowe ! 10/7/15 2:59 PM substantial demolition or destruction was a discretionary or non-complying activity Comment [3]: Consequential amendments (rather than a prohibited activity). This is an interim category and a comprehensive made to this paragraph to align wording with re-evaluation of these places is a priority. in the schedule are subject to different similar wording in the introduction to E2 rules about the demolition of the primary feature within that place. Refer to the objectives and policies. overlay rules - Historic Heritage for more details. Place name and/or description In some instances, a reference to the site number in the New Zealand Archaeological Association Site Recording Scheme has been included in this column, for example R10_709. Exclusions The exclusions column identifies any features or elements within the place that are excluded from the rules that apply to scheduled historic heritage places. Features Deborah Rowe ! 9/8/15 5:20 PM included in the exclusions column are subject to specific rules set out in the Historic Comment [4]: SCOPE: Auckland Council Heritage overlay activity tables 1-3. (5716-530) Additional management controls – archaeological sites or features Additional controls apply to scheduled historic heritage places with archaeological values. These places are identified in the schedule in the column headed ‘Additional Controls for Archaeological Sites or Features’. The additional controls are set out in the Historic Heritage overlay rules. - Historic Heritage. Other plan provisions Scheduled historic heritage places may also include sites or places of significance to Mana Whenua, notable trees, geological features or significant ecological areas and may therefore be subject to other provisions in the Unitary Plan. Places identified as being of Māori interest or significance are additionally subject to the objectives and policies in the overlays - Mana Whenua section. Heritage orders Historic heritage places that are subject to Heritage Orders are identified in appendix 8. New Zealand Historic Places Trust (NZHPT) Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga (Heritage NZ) Page 2 of 3 2 The NZHPT Heritage NZ maintains the New Zealand Heritage List/Rārangi Kōrero, which is a register of historic places, historic areas and wahi tapu areas. Heritage NZ is also required to establish and maintain the list of National Historic Landmarks/Ngā Manawhenua o Aotearoa me ōna Kōrero Tūturu. Some scheduled historic heritage places identified in this schedule the Unitary Plan may also be registered by the NZHPT Heritage NZ. Some places may be registered by the NZHPT Heritage NZ, but may not be identified in this schedule. The NZHPT Heritage NZ should be contacted prior to starting work or making an application for resource consent under the provisions of the Unitary Plan that affect a scheduled historic heritage place to confirm whether the place is included on the NZHPT Heritage NZ register. The provisions of the Historic Places Act 1993 (HPA) Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga Act 2014 (HNZPTA) require any person seeking to damage, modify or destroy or modify any archaeological site meeting the criteria set out in that Act as defined in the HPA to obtain an ‘authority to modify’ from the NZHPT Heritage NZ. If works are proposed to a scheduled historic heritage place, and that place meets the definition of an ‘archaeological site’ in the HPA HNZPTA, the works will be subject to the provisions of the Unitary Plan as well as the requirements of the HPA HNZPTA. Some places may fall under the definition of an ‘archaeological site’ under the HPA HNZPTA, but will not be included in this schedule. It is recommended that advice be sought from the NZHPT Heritage NZ to confirm whether an authority to modify an archaeological site is required for a particular proposal. Page 3 of 3 3 Topic 032 - Council's Proposed Amendments to the Proposed Auckland Council Unitary Plan - Schedule of Significant Historic Heritage Places - Part 1: Historic Heritage Places Additional Place of Known Controls for Schedule Verified Legal Maori Submission Place Name and/or Description Verified Location Category Primary Feature Heritage Extent of Place Exclusions Archaeological Submitter name ID Description Interest or point Values Sites or Significance Features Roe's (Cornwallis) Mill R11_119, R11_1018 Kakamatua Stream, Pt Allotment 1 PSH R11_1088 & R11_1064 Waitakere Ranges OF Karangahape; Pt 00001 B A,D,H Refer to planning maps Yes OOS Site of timber mill with earth holding dam, overflow Regional Park, Huia Allotment 5 PSH OF tunnel, settlement, tramway and wharf Road, Cornwallis Karangahape Lot 199 DP 447211; Lot 1 DP 71841; CMA; Road reserve; 2A, 4 Scott Road; 18,20, Lot 33 DP 447211; Clarks' Pottery and Brickworks, Carder/Vazey's 5498-4; 5716- Joane Hodge and 22, 24, 26, 28A, 28B Lot 39 DP 447211; 00002 Brickworks, Robert Holland Pottery and A* Entire extent of place A,D,H Refer to planning maps Yes 520; 5716- Robert McLeod; Bannings Way, Lot 38 DP 447211; Brickworks R11_1508 527 Auckland Council Hobsonville Lot 37 DP 447211; Lot 36 DP 447211; Lot 35 DP 447211; Lot 34 DP 447211 Piha tramway (Anawhata to Piha section) 00003 Piha B D To be defined# Yes Tramway remains Mander Stream, Pt Allotment 92 PSH Mander and Bradley's Mill Waitakere Ranges OF Waitakere; 00004 Timber mill site with dam, sawdust heaps and start B D Refer to planning maps Yes Regional Park, Piha Allotment 91 PSH of tramline Road, Waiatarua OF Waitakere Pt Allotment 7A PSH OF Waipareira; Lot Driving Stream rafter dam Driving Stream, Forest 00005 4 DP 102197; Pt Lot B D Refer to planning maps Yes Timber rafter dam site Hill Road, Waiatarua 3 DP 1266; Pt Lot 2 DP 1266 Auckland Brick and Tile Co brickworks R11_1724 465 Te Atatu Road, Te Pt Lot 1 DP 44055; 00006 Site and remnants of brickworks and associated B A,D,E Refer to planning maps Yes Atatu Peninsula CMA wharf Lot 3 DP 100813; Lot 101 DP 378286; Wisely Esplanade, Lot 3 DP 408422; Bannings Way, Lot 4 DP 408422; Carder/Vazey's Brickworks R11_1508 Hobsonville; 44C, 44D, Lot 63 DP 398799; 00007 Brickworks site Carder/Vazey pottery and B A* Entire extent of place A,D,H Refer to planning maps Yes 5716-526 Auckland Council 56, 58, 64, 66 & 72 Lot 77 DP 398799; brickworks R11_1508 Bannings Way, Lot 75 DP 398799; Hobsonville Lot 74 DP 398799; Lot 69 DP 378286; CMA Pt Allotment 9 PSH Waitakere Ranges OF Karangahape; Pt Gibbons' Huia Mill 00008 Regional