Is a Horizontal Tail Necessary?

Is a Horizontal Tail Necessary?

IO A LJ/'M-MTr/'MkJT A I All I I AMU Kl ADX/O Beginning digesta elementary ofthe basicand functions oftaila whether it is positioned at the front or rear or even hiding somewhere disguisedas something else. Parti FigurEquilibriu— 1 e1- m series, they may not be the only ones wing lift would change and the GeorgeBy CollingeB. aroun plain t thesi dbu e n e ar Englis h exactly counterpoised vectors would (EAA 67, Lifetime) and will mesh readily with observa- be disarranged. 5037 MarlinWay tions of other related aerodynamic e anglIth f f attaco e k alterse th , Oxnard, 93030CA phenomena without revamping the- cente f lifo r t (cp) begin movo st e for- ories midstream. ward or backward (more on this Illustrations by the Author The business of a tail is in large later) o unlesS . s somehow con- part, concerned with longitudinal sta- strained a runawa, p coulc y d com- bility which conventionally is ex- pletely toppl e airplaneth e reaA . r amine itselfn di , separate from both tail prevents this from happening and IT IS ANTICIPATED that even the lateral and directional stability. n extremela n doei t i s y simpld an e most knowledgeable will give assent To start, airplane'n a f i s four princi- elegant fashion, which might hel- pex to a review of some fundamental as- pal forces were hypothetically bal s beeo -s ha nr t i witplaifo y s hu nwh pects of why there are tails, how they anced through a single point at a long. wor don'd kan t work, especiallo s s ya steady speed, there would be no need An airplane is conventionally made many different shapes of airplanes for a tailplane (Figure 1-1). Of course, stable by the use of "aerodynamic de- are now coming onto the aeronautical this condition evef i , r achieved, could calage" (Ref. 1) or "Longitudinal di- scene. not remain long. For if the speed hedral" (Ref show) 2 . n exaggeraten di As with all explanations in this should change jus a littlt e bite th , Figure 1-2 certain O . n machinee sth Figure 1-2 — Most Airplanes SPORT AVIATION 27 The airplane is again balanced, but in a glide. To climb throttle ,th openes ei d dan the slipstream and downwash in- crease the stab down-force to cause a nose-up condition. Thus, longitudinal dihedral makes an airplane seek to initialln a flt a y y programmed angle of attack. If opening the throttle cause abrup muco o to sto r h o noseta - up movement, a possible alleviating remed sligha s yi t down-thrust built into the motor mount (Figure 1-3). distressins i tha t w I tfe thia o sgt conventional airplane has to carry an PietenpoFigur— 3 1- e r Campe Ai l r induced tail-down-load, however 1932 small. Yet, a look at the whole picture shows that the commonly used "un- stable-type" airfoil generates quite high values of lift and can very easily sacrific tinea y percentag taie th l o et return i thir nfo s most conveniend tan highly practical system of stabiliza- tion. Innutshella e degreth , pitcf eo h stability is governed by the CG loca- tion stae ,th b area angle ,th whict ea h sets ii t s aspecit , dise t th rati - d oan tance from the CG. Tails also function in other ways. The tailplane along d ruddean n rfi wit serve th h e like feathers on an arrow, to quickly point airplane th directioe th n eactui s i t ni - ally going, after a large disturbance such as a lomcevak or tail slide (Fig- FigurArro— 4 we1- Stability Goino gT ure 1-4). The tail's chord is often Work large, to benefit from as high a Reynolds number as possible. Addi- tionally, low-aspect ratio helps the tai resiso lt t separation (stallingd )an to remain effective at high angles, especially after the main wing is stalle r malpositioneddo . Tail cross- section symmetrif o e sar c proportions if they are to operate equally well, negatively positivelyr o . On most airplanes, more up than down elevator is provided, to be able to rais nose eth e adequately duringa flar landinr t a fo e s i gG wheC e nth the full-forward limit and the speed is low. Elevator down-travel is based on Figure 1-5 — A Pitts it ain't. safe stall recovery when at full-aft CG limit "normalf I . " airplanes were made to do aerobatics and inverted flight, their elevators migh havt no t e incidence setting tailplane ofth e will s (toer r some reason e speeth )- in d enough powe hol o t re nos dth e "up" be positive, wit o geometrin h c lon- creases. This create strongesa r down- (Figure 1-5). This lac f controo k l gitudinal dihedral. However, there e stabilizerth forc n o e , which con- woul particularle db y evidene th f i t should still be effective dihedral be- sequently bring e nosth s e bac, up k wing airfoil was highly cambered, as caus taie operatins eth i l downn gi - reducin e presee speeth th g o t td this type becomes inordinately stable was thid causn han sca e actua eth l value nose th ef I .shoul displacee db d when inverted. It doesn't lift well angle of attack to be less than the upward, the airplane slows and the either, upside down, necessitating a angle of incidence. stab down-force lessens sufficiently to high angle of attack to support the A rear tail function followe th n i s- allow the CG to lower the nose. e weighairplaneth f o t . Therefore, ing manner a selecte t A . d speeda , e enginIth f e stops e airplanth , e greater elevato rneede e poweb y drma deliberate nose-down couple, com- slows and the stab down-force di- just when there might not be any weighd an p c t prise(CGe th f s )i do minishe befores sa t thisBu . time eth more. equalize smala y db l downloae th n do nose lowers and stays down. Speed On the other hand, inverted flight stabilizer. This arrangement per- increases until countere orige th -y db woulprobleo n e airplane th db mf i e forms automatically nose th ef I . low- inally established stab down-force. was expressly designed, with a sym- APRI8 2 L 1984 reduction correspondingly demands a pull force. And this elevator displace- men again ca t n resule parn th i t f o t tail pushing dow pard nan t pushing up. For example: during an approach, speee th decreases di applyiny db ga gradually stronger pull, deflecting e elevatoth . - Initiallyup up r e th , elevator combines wit longitudie hth - nal dihedral to intensify the dwin- dling tail-dow nspeedsw forcelo t A ,. Figure 1-6 — Much better. the aft end is down so far that the normal stab down-load diminisheo st zero fact n sta e I .star n th ,b ca t lifting, tryin movo gt nose eth e downwardo ,t dutifully recover the original angle of attac airspeedd kan opposinn I . e gth stab with up-elevator the pilot once more sets up contrary reactions over the tail (Figure 1-8). A high-positioned tailplane cannot benefit greatly from downwash. Therefore, a one-piece design may be appreciably more efficien n thii t s case, presentin a gsingle , uninter- rupted surfac singla d ean reaction. Next month . more on pitch sta- bility. References: . Aerodynami1 c Decalage, Aerodynamics of the Airplane by Clark B. Milikan, TaiFigur— l7 plan1- e t crosa e s pur- John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, divea posen I . s.. 1941, page 145. 2. Longitudinal Dihedral, Mechanics of . KermodeC . FlighA r y Isaab Si ,t c Pitman & Sons, Ltd., London, 1942, page 152. ABOU AUTHOE TTH R George Collinge eon s (EAi ) A67 of the earliest EAA members . early enough that he was the de- signer of the EAA logo. A native of Canada enlistee h ,e RCA th n di F in 1940, learned to fly in the sys- tem, then became an instructor approachn a n O Figur— .8 e1- eventualld an ye attaineth f o e don top military flight instructional (a- 1) certificates. Most type f airo s - metrical main-wing airfoi witd an lh Accordingly, if a pilot wishes to dive e inventorcrafth n i t y were flown elevators of ample travel, both up and muse h t provid oppositn ea e forcd ean regularly, from Tiger Motho t s down. Wing and tail would be set at pus hcontinud intan t oi e pushino gt Lancasters. Also during World zero degrees incidence. Longitudinal hold it in (Figure 1-7). Stick force War II, he lectured on aerody- dihedral would pertai o matten n r should naturally increase with speed. namics, engine handling and downwaso t e du , hup s whicwa s hwa If he releases the pressure, the nose range/endurance at CFS Trenton from the front wing flowing over the immediately rises. and ECFS Hullavington. tail (Figure 1-6)therd An .e shoule db Normal use of trimming devices in From 1947 to 1951 George was a little trim change f i any, , when altery n inherenoe wa sth t stabilizing t fighteje r pilot wit Canadiae hth n switching from upright to inverted mechanism. However, its employ- 400 Squadron, after which he and vicd an e versa.

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    24 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us