The Online Library of Liberty A Project Of Liberty Fund, Inc. Yves Guyot, Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed [1912] The Online Library Of Liberty This E-Book (PDF format) is published by Liberty Fund, Inc., a private, non-profit, educational foundation established in 1960 to encourage study of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals. 2010 was the 50th anniversary year of the founding of Liberty Fund. It is part of the Online Library of Liberty web site http://oll.libertyfund.org, which was established in 2004 in order to further the educational goals of Liberty Fund, Inc. To find out more about the author or title, to use the site's powerful search engine, to see other titles in other formats (HTML, facsimile PDF), or to make use of the hundreds of essays, educational aids, and study guides, please visit the OLL web site. This title is also part of the Portable Library of Liberty DVD which contains over 1,000 books and quotes about liberty and power, and is available free of charge upon request. The cuneiform inscription that appears in the logo and serves as a design element in all Liberty Fund books and web sites is the earliest-known written appearance of the word “freedom” (amagi), or “liberty.” It is taken from a clay document written about 2300 B.C. in the Sumerian city-state of Lagash, in present day Iraq. To find out more about Liberty Fund, Inc., or the Online Library of Liberty Project, please contact the Director at [email protected]. LIBERTY FUND, INC. 8335 Allison Pointe Trail, Suite 300 Indianapolis, Indiana 46250-1684 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed Edition Used: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed, trans. H.F. Baker (London: Macmillan, 1914). Author: Yves Guyot Translator: Harriet Franc Baker About This Title: One of several books Guyot wrote attacking socialism in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. In this volume, drawing upon his experience as the French Minister for Public Works, Guyot discusses the differences between public and private trading, with reference to railways, trams, public housing, and various government monopolies, and examines the negative financial, administrative, political, and social consequeces, such as disorder, corruption, and waste. PLL v6.0 (generated September, 2011) 2 http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/326 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed About Liberty Fund: Liberty Fund, Inc. is a private, educational foundation established to encourage the study of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals. Copyright Information: The text is in the public domain. Fair Use Statement: This material is put online to further the educational goals of Liberty Fund, Inc. Unless otherwise stated in the Copyright Information section above, this material may be used freely for educational and academic purposes. It may not be used in any way for profit. PLL v6.0 (generated September, 2011) 3 http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/326 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed Table Of Contents Preface Translator's Note Where and Why Public Ownership Has Failed Book I: Public and Private Trading Operations Chapter I: Two Precepts Chapter II: The Three Mainsprings of Human Action Chapter III: Determining Motives of Private As Against Public Enterprises Chapter IV: Government and Municipal Trading Operations Book II: Financial Results of Government and Municipal Ownership Chapter I: Bookkeeping In State and Municipal Trading Enterprises Chapter II: The Belgian State Railroads Chapter III: Prussian Railroads Chapter IV: State Railways of Austria and Hungary Chapter V: Italian Railways Chapter VII: Railways of New Zealand Chapter VIII: Government Railroads In France Chapter IX: Public Vs. Private Operation Chapter X: The Holy Cities of Municipal Operation Chapter XI: Operation of Gas and Electricity In the United Kingdom Chapter XII: Tramways In Great Britain Chapter XIII: Housing of the Working Classes and Public Ownership In Great Britain Chapter XIV: Housing of the Working Classes On the Continent Chapter XV: Government Control of Food Supplies Chapter XVI: Victims of Government Ownership Chapter XVII: Charges, Debts and Credit Chapter XVIII: Fictitious Profits Chapter XIX: Fiscal Monopolies Chapter XX: The Alcohol Monopoly In Switzerland and Russia Chapter XXI: Financial Disorder Chapter XXII: The Purchase Price Chapter XXIII: Delusions of Profit and the Life Insurance Monopoly In Italy Chapter XXIV: The Fiscal Mines of the Saar District Chapter XXV: Public Versus Private Enterprise Book III: Administrative Results Chapter I: Administrative Results Chapter II: The Safety of Travelers Upon State and Private Railway Lines Chapter III: Disorders, Delays and Errors Chapter IV: Official Conservatism Chapter V: Labor Chapter VI: The Consumer Chapter VII: Programs of Organization and Regulation Book IV: Political and Social Consequences of Public Operation Chapter I: Socialist Programs and the Facts PLL v6.0 (generated September, 2011) 4 http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/326 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed Chapter II: Bluff Chapter III: Results of Experience Chapter IV: The State a Dishonest Man Chapter V: Corruption Chapter VI: Nationalization of Public Utilities and the Foundation of Great Fortunes Chapter VII: Disintegrating Character of Public Operation Appendix %u201ca%u201d: Alcoholism In Russia Appendix %u201cb%u201d: the Financial Year In Australia Appendix %u201cc%u201d: the Shortcomings of the Telephone In England THE MACMILLAN COMPANY new york · boston · chicago dallas · atlanta · san francisco MACMILLAN & CO., Limited london · bombay · calcutta melbourne THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, Ltd. toronto PLL v6.0 (generated September, 2011) 5 http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/326 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed [Back to Table of Contents] PREFACE The chief difficulty in preparing this book has been to make a coherent arrangement of the material, as the various sources from which it has been gathered are more or less incomplete. Indeed the obstacles in the way of presenting a true picture of industrial enterprises, as operated by states and local governments, can scarcely be exaggerated. The partisans of government and municipal ownership of every species of public utility have assumed a distinctive title. They call themselves representatives of the movement for direct operation (Représentants de la Régie Directe). Their leader in France is Edgard Milhaud, occupying the chair of Political Economy at the University of Geneva, where he makes a special point of emphasizing Socialism.1 In a little periodical, entitled Annales de la Régie Directe, he presents the case for all government and municipal undertakings, although his enthusiasm frequently receives cruel setbacks, as in the suicide of the Mayor of Elbeuf. He has also published several articles for the purpose of demonstrating that accidents are much less frequent upon government railways than upon the lines of private companies. We shall see later (Book 3, Chapter 2) the value of these attempts to justify his creed, and we may judge from them the importance that is to be attached to his other statements. For the academic year 1911–1912, L'École des Hautes Études Sociales organized a series of conferences on the subject of public operation under the direction of M. Milhaud. It was considered advisable that at the close of this series a dissenting voice should be heard—a rôle ultimately assigned to me. In addition to ten preceding lectures, wherein the whole theory and practice of Socialism had been set forth, M. Milhaud was to speak for forty minutes, after which I was to be allotted forty in which to refute the points previously developed by him during 640 minutes. Then we were both to be allowed twenty minutes in order to sum up our arguments. I had at least the satisfaction of knowing that L'Humanité1 attached sufficient importance to this conference to announce that for several days before it was to take place entrance tickets would be reserved for “comrades”; under which conditions it was not difficult to foresee that the hall would be converted into a public assembly room. His audience, thus prepared and won over, naturally gave M. Milhaud an enthusiastic welcome. However, despite some murmurs, it proved itself not unwilling to allow me to oppose my facts to his statements. I borrow from the report of the discussion, as published in L'Humanité, November 14, 1911, the following résumé of the argument of M. Milhaud: “Private monopoly, seeking nothing but maximum profit, is far more costly than public monopoly, which is not bound by the same conditions. Money costs public enterprises less, and, therefore, they can amortize their debt and thus reduce general expenses. On the other hand, heavier expenses for labor can be supported by public undertakings. The management of a public enterprise can even hope for profit, and all PLL v6.0 (generated September, 2011) 6 http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/326 Online Library of Liberty: Where and Why Public Ownership has Failed this can be accomplished within less rigid limits than those which necessarily confine private monopoly. Milhaud concluded by outlining the tendency of public enterprises to become administrative autonomies. In order that they may escape pernicious bureaucratic influences, they are being transformed into separate commercial entities. Through increased control by the consumer, on the one hand, and by labor on the other, they are being gradually but completely socialized. Through reduction in prices, these enterprises create larger bodies of consumers, and they also bring about more flexible relations between employers and employed. The representatives of collectivism, individual consumers and producers, may thus unite in behalf of social progress.” When we come to examine the assertions of the propagandists of public operation, we perceive that they are of no better quality than any other Socialist theories; but the assured manner with which these statements are declared succeeds in disturbing and intimidating many people.