[06/01/2012 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED. THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in INDEX PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS----------> J-1 TO J-6 REGULAR MATTERS --------------------> R-1 TO R-35 FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ------> F-1 TO F-10 APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 67 TO 74 (FIRST PART) APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 75 TO 83 (SECOND PART) COMPANY ----------------------------> 84 TO 84 ORIGINAL SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY I)-----> 85 TO 92 SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY----------------> 93 TO 102 THIRD SUPPLEMENTARY-----------------> 103 TO 104 NOTES 1. Following directions are issued by Hon'ble DB-II in urgent mentioning matters w.e.f. 14.10.2011: i) No urgent mentioning shall be entertained, except at 10.30 A.M. ii)Urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in respect of matters of Detention and Personal Liberty and matters which cannot brook delay till the normal next day of listing. It has further been directed by Hon'ble DB-II that urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in such cases which are accompanied by duly filled in “Form For Urgent (Mentioning) Cases For Listing/Accommodation” in duplicate. Such forms can be obtained from window No.4 of the Filing Counter with effect from 24th November 2011. A Specimen of the form is available on the website under the heading “Download”. 2. Regular Matters listed before Hon'ble DB-III will be heard subject- wise and day-wise in the following manner:- i)Civil Writ(CAT,SERVICE & ADMINISTRATIVE SIDE) -- Monday, Tuesday, Thursday & Friday ii)Income Tax Matters(Part-II) -- Wednesday 3. Regular Matters listed before Hon'ble DB-VIII will be heard subject- wise and day-wise in the following manner w.e.f. 09.01.2012 :- i)PART-I -- Civil Writ(Tax) -- Monday, Tuesday ii)PART-II -- Income Tax Appeals,etc -- Wednesday,Thursday & Friday 4. All Admission/After Notice Misc. Matters listed before Hon'ble Ms. Justice Hima Kohli will be heard subject-wise and day-wise in the following manner: i) Civil Writs (Electricity,DDA & Education) ---------- Monday ii) Civil Writs (MCD & Education) ---------- Tuesday iii)Civil Writs (NDMC,Education,DJB & MTNL) ---------- Wednesday iv) Civil Writs (DDA & Education) ---------- Thursday v) Civil Writs (MCD,Electricity & Education) ---------- Friday 5. As directed by Hon'ble Ms. Justice Hima Kohli, on every Thursday, the oldest matters in the category of 'Regular Matters' will be taken up on a chronological basis, irrespective of their categories and the Court shall not entertain any request for adjournment. However, for the rest of the week, the list of Regular Matters will be maintained on a category-wise basis, as was being done earlier. This is in supersession of the earlier note given on 05.01.2012. 6. Hon'ble Mr. Justice V.K. Shali will sit singly to hear single bench matters listed before his Lordship in Court No. 32. 7. Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw will sit singly to hear single bench matters listed before his Lordship in Court No. 8. 8. Hon'ble Mr. Justice J.R. Midha will sit singly to hear single bench matters listed before his Lordship in Court No. 12. 9. The following categories of admitted cases relating to MACT (MAC Appeals) shall be listed for hearing before Hon'ble Mr. Justice J.R. Midha as ”Regular Matters” on every Friday at 12.00 Noon. i) PART-I APPEALS IN WHICH EARLY HEARING ALLOWED ii) PART-II CASES DISMISSED BY THE TRIBUNAL iii)PART-III APPEALS BY INSURANCE COMPANY FOR THE REDUCTION OF AWARD AMOUNT DELETIONS 1. CRL.M.C. 1324/2011 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice V.K. Shali at item no. 3 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sudershan Kumar Misra. 2. Crl.R. 6/2012 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Suresh Kait at item no. 26 is deleted as the same is returned to Filing Counter. 3. CRL.MB 41/2012 in WP(CRL.) 35/2012 listed before Hon'ble Ms. Justice Mukta Gupta at item No. 47 is deleted. NOMINATED COUSNEL [Central Excise, Customs Shri Satish Kumar, Advocate & Service Tax] Senior Standing Counsel Customs & Central Excise Chamber No. 705 Commissionerate, C.G.O. Complex-II, Block-III, Delhi High Court Kamla Nehru Nagar, Ghaziabad New Delhi-110003 Ph. 9810419742 REGISTRAR (LISTING)] 06.01.2012 J-1 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS FOR 06.01.2012 06.01.2012 COURT NO. 1 (DIVISION BENCH-1) HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SIDDHARTH MRIDUL AT 2.15 P.M. 1. FAO(OS)433-435/2011 INDIAN RAILWAYS CATERING & TOURISM GOOLAM E. VAHANVATI,AG, CM APPL.16875/2011 CORP.LTD. A.S.CHANDHIHOK,ASG,ABHIJEET SINHA, CM APPL.17808/2011 VS.COX & KINGS INDIA LTD. & ANR. SAURAV AGRAWAL,BHAGAT SINGH, CM APPL.18815/2011 VIDIT GUPTA, YASH WARDHAN TEWARI, CM APPL.20897-98/2011 TITASH,ASHOK DESAI,RAJIV NAYYAR, RISHI AGARWALA,PETER LOBO, AKSHAY RINGE,MISHA ROHTAGI, SANDEEP SETHI, ABHIMANYU MAHAJAN,C.A.SUNDARAM, RISHI KAPOOR,EKTA KAPIL, 2. CONT.CAS (C)770/2011 INDIAN RAILWAYS CATERING & TOURISM GOOLAM E. VAHANVATI,AG, CM APPL.18882/2011 CORP.LTD. A.S.CHANDHIHOK,ASG,ABHIJEET SINHA, VS.ARUP SEN & ANR. SAURAV AGRAWAL,BHAGAT SINGH, VIDIT GUPTA, YASH WARDHAN TEWARI, TITASH COURT NO. 7 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K. BHASIN AT 2.15 P.M. 1. RSA 186/2005 KEWAL KRISHAN JAITLY G.P.THEREJA,NEERAJ CHAUDHARY VS. ASCHARAJ RAM KAPUR THR.LRs. RESPONDENT NO. 3 IN PERSON COURT NO. 14 HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SUNIL GAUR AT 2.15 P.M. 1. LA.APP.1195/2008 (VILLAGE-BHARTHAL) RANBIR SHARMA ..... Appellant Through: Mr.B.S.Maan, Mr.Amit Maan, Mr.Jai Prakash, Ms.Smita Maan, Mr.R.S.Verma, Mr.Jitin Tewathia, Advocates Mr.Anand Yadav and Ms.Anita Tomar, Advocates. Mr.Rohtas, Advocate. Mr.Raghuvinder Godana, Advocate Mr.N.S.Negi and Mr.H.S.Rautela, Advocate Mr.S.K.Rout and Mr.B.K.Routray, Mr.M.Azam Ansari, Advocates. Mr.Pankaj Vivek, Advocate Mr.Rajesh Yadav, Mr.Deepak Khosla, Mr.Samit Khosla and Mr.Dhananjay Mehlawat, Advocates 06.01.2012 J-2 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS FOR 06.01.2012 Mr.H.S.Rautela, Advocate Mr.I.S.Dahiya, Advocate Mr.Sandeep Thakhur, Advocate Mr.Atul Tripathi, Advocate. Mr.N.S.Negi and Mr.H.S.Rautela, (Advocates for respondent in appeals filed by UOI) versus UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Senior Advocate with Mr.Sanjay Pathak, Mr.Mohitrao Jadhav and Ms.Navlin Swain, Ms.K.Kaumudi Kiran, Advocates for LAC/UOI Mr.Ajay Verma, Ms.Beenashaw Soni, Mr.Mukesh Kumar, Mr.S.K.Sethi, Mr.Pawan Mathur, Mr.Kunal Sharma, Advocate for DDA LA.APP.412/2008 & CM.No.4096/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.452/2008; LA.APP.453/2008; LA.APP.688/2008 & CM.No.5990/2010 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.697/2008 & CM.No.433/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.701/2008 & CM.No.510/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.768/2008; LA.APP.770/2008; LA.APP.771/2008 & CM.No.425/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.772/2008; LA.APP.773/2008 & CM.No.3835/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.774/2008 & CM.No.611/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.775/2008; LA.APP.776/2008; LA.APP.777/2008; LA.APP.782/2008 & CM.No.940/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.783/2008; LA.APP.784/2008; LA.APP.785/2008; LA.APP.798/2008 & CM.No.615/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.799/2008 & CM.No.931/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.805/2008; LA.APP.806/2008; LA.APP.813/2008 & CM.No.1795/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.814/2008 & CM.No.806/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.818/2008; LA.APP.819/2008; LA.APP.820/2008; LA.APP.829/2008; LA.APP.830/2008; LA.APP.832/2008; LA.APP.833/2008; LA.APP.844/2008; LA.APP.845/2008; LA.APP.873/2008 & CM.No.779/2011 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.892/2008 & CM.No.799/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.899/2008; LA.APP.901/2008; LA.APP.915/2008; LA.APP.951/2008 & CM.No.709/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.959/2008; LA.APP.973/2008; LA.APP.974/2008 & CM.No.519/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.975/2008; LA.APP.976/2008; LA.APP.978/2008; LA.APP.986/2008 & CM.No.572/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.993/2008; LA.APP.1029/2008 & CM.No.17340/2008 (Cross-Objections); 06.01.2012 J-3 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS FOR 06.01.2012 LA.APP.1031/2008 & CM.No.17335/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1032/2008 & CM.No.599/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1046/2008; LA.APP.1047/2008; LA.APP.1048/2008 & CM.No.7851/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1049/2008 & CM.No.420/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1050/2008; LA.APP.1051/2008 & CM.No.17262/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1052/2008; LA.APP.1053/2008 & CM.No.416/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1054/2008 & CM.No.1766/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1055/2008; LA.APP.1057/2008 & CM.No.752/2011 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1058/2008 & CM.No.1557/2011 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1059/2008 & CM.No.17259/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1060/2008; LA.APP.1062/2008 & CM.No.546/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1073/2008; LA.APP.1074/2008 & CM.No.623/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1075/2008; LA.APP.1081/2008 & CM.No.462/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1084/2008 & CM.No.17302/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1086/2008 & CM.No.2448/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1087/2008 & CM.No.619/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1093/2008; LA.APP.1094/2008; LA.APP.1095/2008; LA.APP.1103/2008 & CM.No.441/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1108/2008 & CM.No.3839/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1109/2008; LA.APP.1110/2008 & CM.No.3828/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1111/2008; LA.APP.1112/2008 & CM.No.3831/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1113/2008 & CM.No.3826/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1115/2008; LA.APP.1116/2008; LA.APP.1121/2008; LA.APP.1126/2008; LA.APP.1129/2008 & CM.No.550/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1130/2008; LA.APP.1131/2008 & CM.No.566/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.1133/2008; LA.APP.1135/2008