The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Gerard 't Hooft Institute for Theoretical Physics Utrecht University Postbox 80.195 3508 TD Utrecht, the Netherlands e-mail: [email protected] internet: http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/˜hooft101/ When investigating theories at the tiniest conceivable scales in nature, almost all researchers today revert to the quantum language, accepting the verdict from the Copenhagen doctrine that the only way to describe what is going on will always involve states in Hilbert space, controlled by operator equations. Returning to classical, that is, non quantum mechanical, descriptions will be forever impossible, unless one accepts some extremely contrived theoretical constructions that may or may not reproduce the quantum mechanical phenomena observed in experiments. Dissatisfied, this author investigated how one can look at things differently. This book is an overview of older material, but also contains many new observations and calculations. Quantum mechanics is looked upon as a tool, not as a theory. Examples are displayed of models that are classical in essence, but can be analysed by the use of quantum techniques, and we argue that even the Standard Model, together with gravitational interactions, might be viewed as a quantum mechanical approach to analyse a system that could be classical at its core. We explain how such thoughts can conceivably be reconciled with Bell's theorem, and how the usual ob- jections voiced against the notion of `superdeterminism' can be overcome, at least in principle. Our proposal would eradicate the collapse problem and the measurement problem. Even the arXiv:1405.1548v3 [quant-ph] 21 Dec 2015 existence of an \arrow of time" can perhaps be explained in a more elegant way than usual. Version December, 2015 (extensively modified) 1 Contents I The Cellular Automaton Interpretation as a general doctrine 9 1 Motivation for this work 9 1.1 Why an interpretation is needed . 11 1.2 Outline of the ideas exposed in part I . 14 1.3 A 19 th century philosophy . 18 1.4 Notation . 19 2 Deterministic models in quantum notation 21 2.1 The basic structure of deterministic models . 21 2.1.1 Operators: Beables, Changeables and Superimposables . 23 2.2 The Cogwheel Model . 23 2.2.1 Generalisations of the cogwheel model: cogwheels with N teeth . 25 2.2.2 The most general deterministic, time reversible, finite model . 27 3 Interpreting quantum mechanics 28 3.1 The Copenhagen Doctrine . 29 3.2 The Einsteinian view . 31 3.3 Notions not admitted in the C.A.I. 33 3.4 The collapsing wave function and Schr¨odinger'scat . 34 3.5 Decoherence and Born's probability axiom . 36 3.6 Bell's theorem, Bell's inequalities and the CHSH inequality. 37 3.6.1 The mouse dropping function . 42 3.6.2 Ontology conservation and hidden information . 44 4 Deterministic quantum mechanics 45 4.1 Introduction . 45 4.2 The classical limit revisited . 47 4.3 Born's probability rule . 49 4.3.1 The use of templates . 49 4.3.2 Probabilities . 51 2 5 Concise description of the CA Interpretation 52 5.1 Time reversible cellular automata . 52 5.2 The CAT and the CAI . 54 5.3 Motivation . 56 5.3.1 The wave function of the universe . 58 5.4 The rules . 59 5.5 Features of the Cellular Automaton Interpretation (CAI) . 62 5.5.1 Beables, changeables and superimposables . 63 5.5.2 Observers and the observed . 65 5.5.3 Inner products of template states . 65 5.5.4 Density matrices . 66 5.6 The Hamiltonian . 67 5.6.1 Locality . 67 5.6.2 The double role of the Hamiltonian . 69 5.6.3 The energy basis . 70 5.7 Miscellaneous . 70 5.7.1 The Earth{Mars interchange operator . 70 5.7.2 Rejecting local counterfactual definiteness and free will . 72 5.7.3 Entanglement and superdeterminism . 73 5.7.4 The superposition principle in Quantum Mechanics . 75 5.7.5 The vacuum state . 76 5.7.6 Exponential decay . 77 5.7.7 A single photon passing through a sequence of polarisers . 78 5.8 The quantum computer . 79 6 Quantum gravity 80 7 Information loss 81 7.1 Cogwheels with information loss . 81 7.2 Time reversibility of theories with information loss . 84 7.3 The arrow of time . 85 7.4 Information loss and thermodynamics . 86 8 More problems 87 3 8.1 What will be the CA for the SM? . 87 8.2 The Hierarchy Problem . 88 9 Alleys to be further investigated, and open questions 89 9.1 Positivity of the Hamiltonian . 89 9.2 Second quantisation in a deterministic theory . 91 9.3 Information loss and time inversion . 93 9.4 Holography and Hawking radiation . 94 10 Conclusions 96 10.1 The CAI . 97 10.2 Counterfactual definiteness . 99 10.3 Superdeterminism and conspiracy . 99 10.3.1 The role of entanglement . 100 10.3.2 Choosing a basis . 101 10.3.3 Correlations and hidden information . 102 10.3.4 Free Will . 102 10.4 The importance of second quantisation . 103 II Calculation Techniques 105 11 Introduction to part II 105 11.1 Outline of part II . 105 11.2 Notation . 108 11.3 More on Dirac's notation for quantum mechanics . 109 12 More on cogwheels 111 12.1 the group SU(2) , and the harmonic rotator . 111 12.2 Infinite, discrete cogwheels . 113 12.3 Automata that are continuous in time . 114 13 The continuum limit of cogwheels, harmonic rotators and oscillators 117 13.1 The operator 'op in the harmonic rotator . 119 13.2 The harmonic rotator in the x frame . 120 4 14 Locality 121 15 Fermions 126 15.1 The Jordan-Wigner transformation . 126 15.2 `Neutrinos' in three space dimensions . 129 15.2.1 Algebra of the beable `neutrino' operators . 136 15.2.2 Orthonormality and transformations of the `neutrino' beable states 140 15.2.3 Second quantisation of the `neutrinos' . 142 15.3 The `neutrino' vacuum correlations . 144 16 PQ theory 146 16.1 The algebra of finite displacements . 147 16.1.1 From the one-dimensional infinite line to the two-dimensional torus 148 16.1.2 The states jQ; P i in the q basis . 151 16.2 Transformations in the PQ theory . 151 16.3 Resume of the quasi-periodic phase function φ(ξ; κ) . 154 16.4 The wave function of the state j0; 0i . 155 17 Models in two space-time dimensions without interactions 156 17.1 Two dimensional model of massless bosons . 156 17.1.1 Second-quantised massless bosons in two dimensions . 157 17.1.2 The cellular automaton with integers in 2 dimensions . 161 17.1.3 The mapping between the boson theory and the automaton . 163 17.1.4 An alternative ontological basis: the compactified model . 166 17.1.5 The quantum ground state . 168 17.2 Bosonic theories in higher dimensions? . 169 17.2.1 Instability . 169 17.2.2 Abstract formalism for the multidimensional harmonic oscillator . 171 17.3 (Super)strings . 174 17.3.1 String basics . 175 17.3.2 Strings on a lattice . 178 17.3.3 The lowest string excitations . 181 17.3.4 The Superstring . 181 17.3.5 Deterministic strings and the longitudinal modes . 185 5 17.3.6 Some brief remarks on (super) string interactions . 187 18 Symmetries 189 18.1 Classical and quantum symmetries . 189 18.2 Continuous transformations on a lattice . 190 18.2.1 Continuous translations . 190 18.2.2 Continuous rotations 1: Covering the Brillouin zone with circular regions . 192 18.2.3 Continuous rotations 2: Using Noether charges and a discrete sub group . 195 18.2.4 Continuous rotations 3: Using the real number operators p and q constructed out of P and Q . 196 18.2.5 Quantum symmetries and classical evolution . 197 18.2.6 Quantum symmetries and classical evolution 2 . 198 18.3 Large symmetry groups in the CAI . 199 19 The discretised Hamiltonian formalism in PQ theory 200 19.1 The vacuum state, and the double role of the Hamiltonian (cont'd) . 200 19.2 The Hamilton problem for discrete deterministic systems . 202 19.3 Conserved classical energy in PQ theory . 203 19.3.1 Multi-dimensional harmonic oscillator . 204 19.4 More general, integer-valued Hamiltonian models with interactions . 205 19.4.1 One-dimensional system: a single Q; P pair . 208 19.4.2 The multi dimensional case . 212 19.4.3 The Lagrangian . ..