INFSO-RI-223782 Competitor Analysis An ETICS study Adriano Rippa and Isabel Matranga Engineering Ingegneria Informatica S.p.A. INFSO-RI-223782 Summary • Chosen competitors and motivations • Features: Comparing with the other tools • Summary 2 INFSO-RI-223782 Chosen competitors and motivations Similar Licenses (Free/OS) , more used, “more chatted” *** • CruiseControl • Hudson Features • Bamboo • AntHillPro (25% of the top 100 fortune companies use it) • Hudson + Sonar: it is developed as a Maven plug-in but it can be integrated into Hudson “Family” • Cruise (is the non free version of CruiseControl) *** http://www.developer.com/java/ent/article.php/10933_3803646_1 http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/forum-replies-archive.cfm/1086359.html 3 INFSO-RI-223782 Build Features Table Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar Support for any X build tool Dependencies (interproject) X X X N/A X X Management Historical data X X X X X X Distributed builds X X X X X X Split builds X X X Multiplatform X X X X X X Third party tools X DB Multilanguage X X X 4 INFSO-RI-223782 Build Features Summary Basic • Dependencies (interproject) Management • Historical data • Distributed builds • Multiplatform Advanced • Multilanguage Unique • Support for build tools • Split builds • Third party tools DB 5 INFSO-RI-223782 Security and Privacy Features Table Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar Role based X X X N/A X X Username and XXXXX password Certificate X Public availability of X artefacts and code 6 INFSO-RI-223782 Security and Privacy Features Summary Basic • Role based ( actions - limited visibility) • Username and password Advanced Unique • Public availability of artefacts and code • Certificate 7 INFSO-RI-223782 Plug-ins Features Table and Summary Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar Plug-ins X XX API X XX Basic Advanced • Plug-ins • API Unique 8 INFSO-RI-223782 Infrastructure Features Table and Summary Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar Infrastructure X Cloud ready X Basic Must Have Unique • Infrastructure • Cloud Ready 9 INFSO-RI-223782 User Support Features Table Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar User Support X X X N/A X X Email X X X N/A X X Payment Paymen Phone N/A license t Forum/Mailing/ X X N/A X IRC Payment 24/7 license 10 INFSO-RI-223782 User Support Features Summary Basic • User Support • E-mail Advanced • Phone • Forum/Mailing/IRC Unique • 24/7 11 INFSO-RI-223782 Testing and Quality Features Table Ant Hill Cruise Hudson ETICS Cruise Bamboo Pro Control + Sonar Basic Testing X X N/A X XX Advanced Testing X X Quality Metrics X XX Structured model X *** Graphs X XXX 12 INFSO-RI-223782 Testing Quality Features Summary Basic • Basic Testing Advanced • Graphics • Quality Metrics Unique • Structured Model • Advanced Testing *** http://nemo.sonar.codehaus.org/project/index/org.apache.axis2:axis2 13 INFSO-RI-223782 Business Model Features Table Cruise Hudson ETICS Ant Hill Pro Cruise Bamboo Control + Sonar Free license X X X Proprietary License Dual XXX License $1250 per committer + Cost max $8000 22% annual maintenance License is Apach GNU #developers #Agents BDS #Agents based on e 2.0 LGPL In the in the In the In the Other followin followin followin following g g g 14 INFSO-RI-223782 Business Model Features Specific Information AntHillPro • Base price is $1250 USD per committer. This is a perpetual use license. • Annual maintenance is 22% of current licensing costs. • There is a 10% discount available for volume, beginning at 50 committers; this applies only to the license cost. Cruise • Cruise is free for up to 2 agents. The 1-year license can be downloaded directly on the homesite. • For commercial licenses it is mandatory to take contacts with them. • Non-profits and open source projects can apply for a license to use Cruise with more than 2 agents for free. Besides the approval of this request is at discretion of the Cruise team. Annual renewals are provided on request. 15 INFSO-RI-223782 Business Model Features Specific Information Bamboo including 12 months maintenance of updates and support. Renewing maintenance is entirely optional • Bamboo is free for use by official non-profit organisations and charities (proof of non-profit status is required). • Community licenses are designed for organisations which are: • non-profit, non-government, non-academic, non-commercial, non-political and secular • Bamboo is free for any Open Source project to use 16 INFSO-RI-223782 Business Model Features Specific Information Sonar • Open Source. • They charge people on commercial support and commercial extensions as follows: The free support to communities is given for free through a mailing list. Specific commercial plugin for PLSQL: 2,000€ per instance of Sonar and per year. Hudson Offers just commercial support 17 INFSO-RI-223782 Summary Basic Advanced Unique Support for any X build tools Split builds X Third party tools X DB Role based X Username and X password Public X availability Plug-ins X Infrastructur X e Cloud Ready X 18 INFSO-RI-223782 Summary Basic Advanced Unique Phone X Support Forum/Maili X ng/ Support 24/7 Support X Graphics X Quality Metrics X Structured X Quality Model Advanced X Testing 19 INFSO-RI-223782 Q&A http://www.eticsproject.eu/ 20.