The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Implementation Status & Results Nigeria THIRD NATIONAL FADAMA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT (FADAMA III) (P096572) Operation Name: THIRD NATIONAL FADAMA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT Project Stage: Implementation Seq.No: 7 Status: ARCHIVED Archive Date: (FADAMA III) (P096572) Country: Nigeria Approval FY: 2009 Product Line:IBRD/IDA Region: AFRICA Lending Instrument: Specific Investment Loan Implementing Agency(ies): National Fadama Coordination Office(NFCO) Key Dates Public Disclosure Copy Board Approval Date 01-Jul-2008 Original Closing Date 31-Dec-2013 Planned Mid Term Review Date 07-Nov-2011 Last Archived ISR Date 11-Feb-2011 Effectiveness Date 23-Mar-2009 Revised Closing Date 31-Dec-2013 Actual Mid Term Review Date Project Development Objectives Component(s) Component Name Component Cost Capacity Building, Local Government, and Communications and Information Support 87.50 Small-Scale Community-owned Infrastructure 75.00 Advisory Services and Input Support 39.50 Support to the ADPs and Adaptive Research 36.50 Asset Acquisition 150.00 Project Administration, Monitoring and Evaluation 58.80 Overall Ratings Previous Rating Current Rating Progress towards achievement of PDO Satisfactory Satisfactory Overall Implementation Progress (IP) Satisfactory Satisfactory Overall Risk Rating Low Low Implementation Status Overview As at August 19, 2011, disbursement status of the project stands at 46.87%. All the states have disbursed to most of the FCAs/FUGs except Jigawa and Edo where disbursement was delayed for political reasons. The savings in FUEF accounts has increased to a total ofN66,133,814.76. 75% of the SFCOs have federated their FCAs up to the state level while FCAs in 8 states have only been federated up to the Local Government levels. There has been close collaboration with the Local Government through the Local Fadama Desk Officers in the delivery of the project. This has been demonstrated by the Desk Officers working closely with the facilitators, FCAs and FUGs. It is expected that this will ensure the sustainability of the project. The States have calibrated their GPS except Kogi which is yet to procure its GPS equipment. A total number of 6,600 sub-projects have been geo- Public Disclosure Copy referenced in 27 states. There has been a tremendous improvement in the number of SFCOs using the voucher system for input delivery from five in the last mission to 22 as at the just concluded mission. Innovations are continuously being introduced across the SFCOs. There are thirty identified innovative activities already introduced into the project Page 1 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 implementation across the SFCOs. These activities increase the level of benefits to FCAs/FUGs, enhances the achievement of the PDO and also ensure sustainability of sub- projects. These innovative activities can be categorized as collaboration/partnership and sole initiatives. Such collaborations are with research institutes, farms, ministries etc. The sole initiatives include bio-gas production, improved use of ICT services, value addition production and marketing of agricultural produce by Federated FCAs. The Bank, National and State Fadama offices are actively engaging Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) in the assessment and monitoring of Fadama III. The project's openness and transparency towards CSOs has been highly commended. The project piloted independent third party monitoring and their report is attached which covered only selected project sites. However, in response to the observations, the project is increasing it's focus and empowerment of women, vulnerable and youth groups and also plans to have a workshop to review its social accountability mechanism, while the Bank's environmental specialist is building capacity of specific states on safeguard issues. Locations Country First Administrative Division Location Planned Actual Nigeria Sokoto State Yabo Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Niger State Wushishi Nigeria Sokoto State Wurno Nigeria Sokoto State Wamako Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Uyo Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Utu Etim Ekpo Nigeria Abia State Umuahia Nigeria Not Entered Ukum Nigeria Anambra Ukpo-Akpu Nigeria Sokoto State Tureta Nigeria Kano State Tudun Wada Nigeria Kano State Tsanyawa Nigeria Not Entered Tede Nigeria Benue State Tarka Nigeria Sokoto State Tambawel Nigeria Kano State Sumaila Nigeria Not Entered Abuja Nigeria Sokoto State Silame Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Niger State Shiroro Page 2 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Country First Administrative Division Location Planned Actual Nigeria Kano State Shanono Nigeria Sokoto State Shagari Nigeria Delta State Sapele Nigeria Sokoto State Sabon Birni Nigeria Kano State Rogo Nigeria Katsina State Rimi Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Niger State Rijau Nigeria Sokoto State Rabah Nigeria Rivers State Port Harcourt Nigeria Plateau State Plateau State Nigeria Delta State Patani Nigeria Benue State Oturkpo Nigeria Osun State Osogbo Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Oduko Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Oron Nigeria Not Entered Orolu Nigeria Anambra Onitsha Nigeria Ondo State Ondo State Nigeria Rivers State Okrika Nigeria Delta State Okpe Nigeria Benue State Oju Nigeria Abia State Ohafia Nigeria Imo State Oguta Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Ogun State Ogun State Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Obot-Akara Page 3 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Anambra Nnewi Nigeria Imo State Nkwerre Nigeria Kano State Minjibir Nigeria Katsina State Matasu Nigeria Niger State Mariga Nigeria Katsina State Mani Nigeria Benue State Makurdi Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Kano State Makuda Nigeria Kogi State Lokoja Nigeria Not Entered Lapai Nigeria Lagos Lagos State Nigeria Sokoto State Kware Nigeria Kwara State Kwara State Nigeria Not Entered Kwande Nigeria Katsina State Kurfi Nigeria Kano State Kura Nigeria Kano State Kunchi Nigeria Kano State Kumbotso Nigeria Niger State Kontagora Nigeria Sokoto State Kebbi Nigeria Not Entered Katsina Ala Nigeria Katsina State Katsina Nigeria Kano State Karaye Nigeria Katsina State Kankara Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Katsina State Kaita Page 4 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Katsina State Kafur Nigeria Kaduna State Kaduna State Nigeria Not Entered Iwo Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Itu Nigeria Not Entered Iseyin Nigeria Zamfara State Isa Nigeria Zamfara State Ini Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Katsina State Ingawa Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Ikot-Ekpene Nigeria Imo State Ihitte Ogwa Nigeria Anambra Ihiala Nigeria Kogi State Idah Nigeria Sokoto State Gwadabawa Nigeria Sokoto State Goronyo Nigeria Kano State Gezawa Nigeria Not Entered Gburuku Nigeria Benue State Gboko Nigeria Kano State Garko Nigeria Sokoto State Gada Nigeria Katsina State Faskari Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Etinan Nigeria Rivers State Emohua Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Eman Uruan Nigeria Anambra Ekwulobia Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Eket Page 5 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Katsina State Dutsin Ma Nigeria Kogi State Dekina Nigeria Rivers State Degema Nigeria Kano State Dawaki Nigeria Katsina State Daura Nigeria Cross River State Cross River State Nigeria Katsina State Cheranchi Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Kano State Bunkure Nigeria Sokoto State Binji Nigeria Katsina State Bindawa Nigeria Abia State Bende Nigeria Kano State Bebeji Nigeria Katsina State Baure Nigeria Bauchi Bauchi State Nigeria Katsina State Batagarawa Nigeria Katsina State Bakori Nigeria Kano State Bagwai Nigeria Abia State Arochukwu Nigeria Kogi State Ankpa Nigeria Kano State Albasu Nigeria Oyo State Akinyele Nigeria Kogi State Ajaokuta Nigeria Rivers State Ahoada Nigeria Anambra Aguata Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Abuja Federal Capital Territory Abuja Federal Capital Territory Page 6 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Rivers State Abua Nigeria Rivers State Abonnema Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Abak Nigeria Adamawa State Adamawa State Nigeria Ekpoma Ekpoma Nigeria Enugu State Enugu State Nigeria Jigawa State Jigawa State Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Oyo State Egbeda Nigeria Bayelsa State Bayelsa State Nigeria Ebonyi State Ebonyi State Nigeria Ekiti State Ekiti State Nigeria Gombe State Gombe State Nigeria Zamfara State Zamfara State Nigeria Kebbi State Kebbi State Nigeria Taraba State Taraba State Nigeria Yobe State Yobe State Nigeria Benue State Okpokwu Nigeria Imo State Isu Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Ibesikpo Nigeria Abia State Osisioma Nigeria Plateau State Nasarawa State Nigeria Imo State Aba North Nigeria Abia State Aba South Nigeria Abia State Ikwuano Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Abia State Isiala-Ngwa North Page 7 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Abia State Isuikwato Nigeria Abia State Ukwa East Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Mkpat-Enin Nigeria Akwa Ibom State Oruk Anam Nigeria Enugu State Anambra East Nigeria Anambra Anaocha Nigeria Anambra Awka North Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Anambra Awka South Nigeria Enugu State Ayamelum Nigeria Kano State Tofa Nigeria Kogi State Ogori/Mangongo Nigeria Niger State Katcha Nigeria Niger State Magama Nigeria Niger State Mokwa Nigeria Niger State Rafi Nigeria Osun State Ede North Nigeria Osun State Egbedore Nigeria Osun State Ife Central Nigeria Osun State Ife East Nigeria Osun State Ife South Nigeria Osun State Ifelodun Nigeria Osun State Ila Nigeria Osun State Irepodun Nigeria Osun State Irewole Public Disclosure Copy Nigeria Osun State Isokan Page 8 of 24 The World Bank Report No: ISR4370 Nigeria Osun State Odo-Otin Nigeria Osun State Ola-Oluwa Nigeria Osun State Olorunda Nigeria Osun State Oriade Nigeria Oyo