Indiscriminate Fire RIGHTS Palestinian Rocket Attacks on Israel and Israeli Artillery Shelling in the Gaza Strip WATCH July 2007 Volume 19, N0

Indiscriminate Fire RIGHTS Palestinian Rocket Attacks on Israel and Israeli Artillery Shelling in the Gaza Strip WATCH July 2007 Volume 19, N0

Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories HUMAN Indiscriminate Fire RIGHTS Palestinian Rocket Attacks on Israel and Israeli Artillery Shelling in the Gaza Strip WATCH July 2007 volume 19, N0. 1(E) Indiscriminate Fire Palestinian Rocket Attacks on Israel and Israeli Artillery Shelling in the Gaza Strip Map of Gaza Strip..................................................................................................... 1 I. Summary...............................................................................................................3 Palestinian Rocket Attacks ..................................................................................4 Israeli Artillery Shelling ...................................................................................... 6 Case Studies..................................................................................................... 13 Methodology..................................................................................................... 15 II. Recommendations ............................................................................................. 16 III. International Humanitarian Law ........................................................................ 19 IV. Background.......................................................................................................25 Palestinian Armed Attacks from Gaza................................................................27 V. Palestinian Rocket Attacks since the IDF Withdrawal ......................................... 31 Weapon Used and Method of Attack ................................................................. 31 Civilian Harm ....................................................................................................35 Deploying Military Objectives in Densely Populated Areas................................. 41 Palestinian Justifications...................................................................................42 Role of Palestinian Security Forces ....................................................................46 Legal Conclusions.............................................................................................47 VI. Israeli Artillery Shelling Since the IDF Withdrawal.............................................49 Weapon Used and Method of Attack ................................................................. 51 Civilian Harm ....................................................................................................58 Strikes Hitting Residential Areas................................................................. 60 Other Strikes Harming Civilians .................................................................. 68 Impact on Palestinian Livelihoods ...............................................................75 IDF Justifications ...............................................................................................77 Legal Conclusions.............................................................................................82 Appendix I. Case Study: The Gaza Beach Incident ..................................................84 Eyewitness Accounts.........................................................................................84 Analysis........................................................................................................... 89 Shrapnel.......................................................................................................... 90 Artillery Shell Craters.........................................................................................91 Injuries .............................................................................................................91 Timing ..............................................................................................................92 IDF Explanations ...............................................................................................93 Appendix II. Case Study: Palestinian Rockets Attacks from and IDF Shelling of the Nada Apartments Complex ...........................................................................99 The Nada Apartments Complex .......................................................................100 Prelude to IDF Artillery Shelling of the Nada Apartments..................................102 Early Afternoon of July 24, 2006 ...................................................................... 104 Afternoon and Evening of July 24, 2006...........................................................106 Events of Wednesday, July 26, 2006................................................................108 Events of Friday, July 28, 2006 ........................................................................ 110 IDF Warnings and Liaison with Palestinian Security Forces................................111 IDF Explanations ..............................................................................................114 Appendix III. Locally Made Rockets Entering Israel from Gaza...............................117 Appendix IV. Israeli Artillery Shells Entering Gaza ............................................... 118 Appendix V. Locally Made Rocket and Artillery Casualties.....................................119 Appendix VI. Human Rights Watch Letters and IDF Responses ............................. 120 Acknowledgments................................................................................................ 143 Map of Gaza Strip Indiscriminate Fire 1 2 Human rights watch July 2007 I. Summary In the northern Gaza Strip and adjoining areas of Israel, attacks by Palestinian armed groups launching locally made rockets known as Qassams and attacks by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) firing 155mm artillery shells have together killed dozens of civilians, wounded hundreds, and greatly disrupted civilian life. After Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza in September 2005, Palestinian rocket attacks continued sporadically, spiking in late September, late October and again in December, with Israeli artillery fire following suit beginning in late October. Initially civilian casualties on both sides were light, but the casualties rose dramatically starting in April 2006, when Israel sharply increased its artillery attacks on alleged Palestinian rocket launch sites and also fired closer to residential areas. Both sides have shown disregard for civilian loss of life in violation of international humanitarian law (IHL): Palestinian armed groups have directed their rockets at Israeli towns; Israeli artillery shelling near populated areas has caused considerable civilian casualties for uncertain military gain as well as at least one serious incident of indiscriminate shelling. There is an opportunity today to put an end to this needless loss of civilian life: in November 2006, after an artillery attack that killed 23 civilians, the IDF placed a moratorium on use of artillery to respond to rocket attacks in Gaza, and a five-month ceasefire on the part of Hamas the same month led to a decrease in Palestinian rocket attacks in 2007, meaning that for a time rocket attacks were largely limited to the Islamic Jihad organization. Hamas ended its ceasefire on April 24, 2007, firing rockets once again into Israeli territory.1 Israel has not resumed its use of artillery, responding instead with more precise air-fired missiles to hit targets, but it is unclear how firm this change of practice is. The conduct of Palestinian armed groups and the IDF that led to the spike in civilian casualties in mid-2006 is likely to resume unless the parties learn the lessons of 2006 and definitively change military policies and practices in accordance with their independent obligations under international humanitarian law. 1 See, for example, Isabel Kershner, “Attack by Hamas Casts Doubt on Future of Cease-Fire in Gaza,” New York Times, April 25, 2007. Indiscriminate Fire 3 This report is based on on-the-ground assessments of Palestinian armed group rocket attacks and IDF artillery attacks, focusing on the period from the beginning of September 2005 through May 2007. It sets forth recommendations aimed at ending practices that have led to unnecessary civilian death and injury. This report does not address other important issues affecting civilians in Gaza, including deteriorating humanitarian conditions, internecine fighting between Palestinian factions, Israel’s destruction of Gaza’s sole electrical power plant, and IDF and armed group clashes that have claimed civilian casualties separate from the rocket/artillery attacks. Palestinian Rocket Attacks From September 2005 through May 2007, Palestinian armed groups fired almost 2,700 rockets into Israel, killing 4 Israeli civilians, and injuring 75 civilians and at least 9 soldiers, according to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA) (see Appendices III-V for casualty and weapons numbers). Two of those deaths occurred in the last two weeks of May 2007. An additional six civilians died in rocket attacks from mid-2004 through August 2005. Palestinian rockets have also killed at least two and injured at least 21 Palestinian civilians when they landed short of the Israeli border. The rockets, made in Gaza and generically known as “Qassams” after the name of the armed wing of Hamas, the Islamic Resistance Movement, are highly inaccurate and cannot be directed at a specific target. Communities in the western Negev in Israel, in particular the city of Sderot, have suffered from these attacks. The 10 Israeli

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    147 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us