AMERICAN POLITICAL THOUGHT Spring 2018 Government 2230 Professor Yarbrough Hubbard Tower ext. 3296 Office Hours: Tu-Th 4-5:30 pm and by appointment [email protected] This course focuses on the political thought of American statesmen, writers, and prominent citizens from the Founding up to the twentieth century, with special emphasis on three critical “moments”: 1) the Founding, 2) the Crisis of the House Divided, meaning the battle over slavery and the nature of the Union, and 3) the impact of evolutionary biology (in the forms of social Darwinism and pragmatism), historicism, and idealism on the development of American political thought and practice from the late 19th century to the present. The course concludes with a brief examination of contemporary liberalism and conservatism after 2016 and their place in the American political tradition. The following books are required and are available for purchase or rent through Bowdoin’s textbook partner, Chegg, at www.chegg.com/bookstore/bowdoin: *Hamilton, Madison, Jay, The Federalist Papers, ed. Rossiter, with introduction by Charles R. Kesler (Mentor) *The Anti-Federalist Papers, ed. Herbert Storing (Chicago) *The Essential Jefferson, ed. Jean M. Yarbrough (Hackett) *Steven B. Smith, The Writings of Abraham Lincoln (Yale) *Herbert Croly, The Promise of American Life (Northeastern) In addition, I have placed a number of short essays on electronic reserve and/or paper reserve in the library. Note: these are on the LIBRARY reserves (not Blackboard). They are marked on your syllabus. COURSE REQUIREMENTS: Students are required to write three three-page thought papers. The first will be on the Anti- federalist-Federalist debates. The second paper will be on Abraham Lincoln, and the third on Herbert Croly, one of the great theoreticians of progressivism. There will also be a comprehensive final, consisting of a series of short to medium length essay questions. Grades will be determined in the following manner: Papers 20% x 3 = 60% Final 35% Class participation 5% (Thoughtful and sustained class participation can, and frequently does, make the difference in your final grade.) Gov 2230 Spring 2018 1 READING ASSIGNMENTS: Jan. 23 Is there such a thing as American Political Thought? I. THE FOUNDING Jan. 25 Principles of Liberal Republicanism The First Founding: - Mayflower Compact (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) The Second Founding: - John Locke, Selections from Second Treatise of Government (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) - Declaration of Independence (in Kesler edition of Federalist Papers) and compare the final draft of the Declaration with Jefferson’s version in The Essential Jefferson, pp. 18-22 Tocqueville and the Dynamic of Democracy: - Part 2, chs. 1, 10, 13 from Democracy in America (ELECRONIC RESERVE) Jan. 30 Constituting the Liberal Republic - Articles of Confederation - Constitution of the United States (Both in Kesler edition of Federalist Papers) Republicanism: Three Views - Montesquieu, Selections from The Spirit of the Laws - David Hume, “Idea of a Perfect Commonwealth” - Alexis de Tocqueville, “the spirit of religion” and the “spirit of liberty” (All on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Feb. 1 Anti-Federalists: What is Their Legacy Today? “Brutus,” in Storing, # 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, pp. 108-126, 138-150 Feb. 6 “Federal Farmer,” Storing, # 2, 6, 7, 16, pp. 39-43, 65-86; Patrick Henry, pp. 310- 311 and 315-321 Feb. 8 “Report of the Pennsylvania Minority,” Storing, pp. 202-222 “Brutus,” # 11, 12, 15, pp. 162-170, 182-187 Gov 2230 Spring 2018 2 Feb. 13 The Federalist Defense of the Extended Commercial Republic Federalist Papers # 1, 9, 10, 11, 15, 23 Feb. 15 Federalist Papers # 37, 39, 47, 48, 49, 51 Feb. 20 Federalist Papers # 55, 57, 58, 62, 63 Feb. 22 Federalist Papers # 68, 70, 71, 72, 78, 84 Feb. 27 Hamilton and the Federalist Program - Excerpts from Report on Credit - Report on Manufactures - Argument for the Constitutionality of the Bank (All on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Mar. 1 - Pacificus (Hamilton)-Helvidius (Madison) Debate over which branch of government has primary responsibility for foreign affairs (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Jefferson and the Republican Program (in Essential Jefferson): - Notes on Virginia, Query 17, 18, 19, pp. 125-133 - Opinion on the Constitutionality of the Bank, 1791, pp. 32-36 Mar. 5 PAPERS DUE Mar. 6 - Kentucky Resolutions, 1798, pp. 48-54 - First and Second Inaugural Addresses, pp. 55-58, 60-64 Letters (in Essential Jefferson): TJ to Messrs. Nehemiah Dodge and others, p. 59 TJ to William S. Smith, Nov. 13, 1787, pp. 166-167 TJ to Madison, Sept. 6, 1789, pp. 176-180 Mar. 8 Letters TJ to Benjamin Banneker, Aug. 30, 1791, p. 181 TJ to William Green Munford, June 18, 1799 TJ to Henri Gregoire, Feb. 25, 1809, p. 205 TJ to John Colvin, Sept. 20, 1810, pp. 208-210 Gov 2230 Spring 2018 3 TJ to John Adams, Oct. 28, 1813, pp. 214-219 TJ to John Taylor, May 28, 1816, pp. 233-236 TJ to Samuel Kercheval, July 12, 1816, pp. 239-245 SPRING BREAK - No classes Mar. 13-22 II. CRISIS OF THE HOUSE DIVIDED “No policy that does not rest upon some philosophical public opinion can be permanently maintained.” Abraham Lincoln, 1860 Mar. 27 Calhoun, Disquisition on Government from Union and Liberty, pp. 5-51 (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Mar. 29 Lincoln (in Smith): Introduction, xi-xxiii Lyceum Speech, Jan. 27, 1838, pp. 7-14 Temperance Address, Feb. 22, 1842, pp. 14-22 Eulogy on Henry Clay, July 6, 1852, pp. 43-54 Address from Wisconsin State Agricultural Society, Sept. 30, 1859, pp. 268-278 Apr. 3 Steven Douglas from Lincoln-Douglas Debate, July 9, 1858 (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Lincoln (in Smith): Fragments on Slavery, [1854?] p. 58 Peoria Speech, Oct. 16, 1854, pp. 59-92 Dred Scott Speech, June 26, 1857, pp. 108-119 Apr. 5 Lincoln (in Smith): House Divided Speech, June 16, 1858, pp. 126-133 On Slavery and Democracy, p. 150 Pro-Slavery Theology, [1858?] p. 189 Letter to H.L. Pierce, and Others, Apr. 6, 1859, pp. 243-244 Fragment, [1861?] pp. 321-322 Cooper Institute Speech, Feb. 27, 1860, pp. 283-298 Speech at New Haven, Mar. 6, 1860, pp. 299-314 Gov 2230 Spring 2018 4 Apr. 10 Lincoln (in Smith): First Inaugural, Mar. 4, 1861, pp. 324-332 Meditation on Divine Will, pp. 362-363 Annual Message, Dec. 1, 1862, beginning at bottom of p. 384 to 392 Final Emancipation Proclamation, Jan. 1, 1863, pp. 395-396 Gettysburg Address, Nov. 19, 1863, p. 417 Letter to Albert Hodges, Apr. 4, 1864, pp. 418-419 Second Inaugural, Mar. 4, 1865, pp. 428-430 Speech on Reconstruction, Apr. 11, 1865, pp. 431-434 Walt Whitman on the death of Lincoln: (April 15, 1865) “When lilacs last in the door-yard bloom’d, And the great star early droop’d in the western sky in the night, I mourn’d—and yet shall mourn with ever-returning spring. O ever-returning spring! trinity sure to me you bring; Lilac blooming perennial, and drooping star in the west, And thought of him I love.” III. EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY, HISTORICISM, IDEALISM, PROGRESS, AND THE RISE OF THE MODERN ADMINISTRATIVE STATE Apr. 12 Darwinism: Right and Left - William Graham Sumner, “Socialism” - John Dewey, “The Influence of Darwinism on Philosophy” (Both on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Apr. 16 PAPERS DUE Apr. 17 - William Graham Sumner, “The Forgotten Man” (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) - Herbert Croly, Promise of American Life, ch. 1 Apr. 19 Croly, ch. 7, ch. 9 Apr. 24 Croly, ch. 11 (pp. 369-381), ch. 13 (pp. 409-421) Gov 2230 Spring 2018 5 Apr. 26 The New Freedom and The New Nationalism - Woodrow Wilson, “What is Progress?” and “The Meaning of Democracy” - Theodore Roosevelt, “The New Nationalism” (All on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) Apr. 30 PAPERS DUE May 1 From Progressivism to Modern Liberalism—and Back - John Dewey, “The Future of Liberalism” - FDR, “The Commonwealth Club Address”; Selections 1944 SOTU - Students for a Democratic Society, (SDS) “Port Huron Statement” - Lyndon Baines Johnson, “The Great Society,” 1964 - Barack Obama, First and Second Inaugural Messages (All on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) May 3 - Richard Rorty, selection from Achieving Our Country (ELECTRONIC RESERVE) The Conservative Counter-Revolution: a roadmap - James W. Ceaser, “Four Heads and One Heart: The American Conservative Movement” and “What Next for the Left?” (Both on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) May 8 The Conservative Counter-Revolution and the Trump Phenomenon - Ronald Reagan, First Inaugural, 1981; Farewell Address, Jan. 11, 1989 - Milton Friedman, “Defining Principles: Capitalism and Freedom” - Tocqueville, “The Kind of Despotism Democratic Nations Have to Fear” - “Publius Decius Mus,” “The Flight 93 Election” (All on ELECTRONIC RESERVE) FINAL EXAM, Monday May 14, 2pm. Gov 2230 Spring 2018 6 .