Comparative analysis of acoel embryonic development Viviana Cetrangolo Thesis for the degree of Philosophiae Doctor (PhD) University of Bergen, Norway 2020 Comparative analysis of acoel embryonic development Viviana Cetrangolo ThesisAvhandling for the for degree graden of philosophiaePhilosophiae doctorDoctor (ph.d (PhD). ) atved the Universitetet University of i BergenBergen Date of defense:2017 02.10.2020 Dato for disputas: 1111 © Copyright Viviana Cetrangolo The material in this publication is covered by the provisions of the Copyright Act. Year: 2020 Title: Comparative analysis of acoel embryonic development Name: Viviana Cetrangolo Print: Skipnes Kommunikasjon / University of Bergen ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!"##!$%&$!'()!$()*%!! +()!,%&-./0! !"##!$%&$!'()!,%&-./! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!,%&-./1!'()0! !!!!!!!!!!!!!2%/!(-#'!#&1$3-.!$4)$%! !!!!!!!!!!!!51!,%&-./0! !!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'%!()$*+,! ! ! ! ! ""! "#$%&'$($#!%&)$*+&,%&'! #$%!&'()!*(%+%,-%.!",!-$"+!-$%+"+!&/+!0',.10-%.!",!-$%!2/3'(/-'(4!'5!-$%!6('57!8(!9%:,'2;!/-! </(+!=,-%(,/-"',/2!>%,-(%!5'(!?/(",%!?'2%012/(!@"'2'A4;!B,"C%(+"-4!'5!@%(A%,;!D'(&/47!#$%! -$%+"+!"+!*/(-!'5!-$%!6$8!*('A(/E!'5!-$%!8%*/(-E%,-!'5!@"'2'A"0/2!<0"%,0%+!'5!-$%!B,"C%(+"-4! '5!@%(A%,7! ! ! """! -#.&+/0%12%,%&'3! =!&'12.!2")%!-'!+-/(-!-'!-$/,)!E4!+1*%(C"+'(!6('57!8(!F,.(%/+!9%:,'27!G"(+-24;!5'(!A"C",A!E%! -$%!'**'(-1,"-4!-'!0'E%!-'!$"+!2/3!&$%,!=!&/+!/!5(%+$24!A(/.1/-%.!/,.!,/HC%!+-1.%,-;!/,.! +%0',./("24!5'(!-%/0$",A!E%!-$/-!-$%!6$8!0/,!3%!/!(%/224!$/(.!-"E%!'5!4'1(!2"5%;!31-!"5!4'1!/(%! E'-"C/-%.!%,'1A$!/,.!*1+$!4'1(+%25!-$('1A$!-$%!."55"012-"%+;!"-!5",/224!0'E%+!-'!/,!%,.I!<';! -$/,)+!5'(!-$%+%!6$8!4%/(+!&$"0$!&%(%!/!A(%/-!2"5%!%J*%("%,0%!-$/-!=!&"22!/2&/4+!0/((4!&"-$! E%7!! =!/2+'!&/,-!-'!-$/,)!6('57!K/25!<0$,/3%2!/,.!$"+!2/3;!&$'!$'+-%.!E%!",!L%(E/,4!/,.!-/1A$-! E%!/22!-$%!+%0(%-+!'5!E"0('+0'*4!/,.!2/+%(!+4+-%E7!=!$/C%!%,:'4%.!-$%!+0"%,-"5"0!0'55%%!3(%/)+! /,.!=!&"22!E"++!-$%E7! =!/E!%J-(%E%24!A(/-%512!-'!8(!>$%E/!?/(-M,N81(O,;!&$'!$%2*%.!E%!",!/22!-$%!+-%*+!-$('1A$! -$%+%!6$8!4%/(+7!F+!/!2/3!E/-%!/,.!/+!/!5("%,.;!$%!/2&/4+!+1**'(-%.!E%;!/2&/4+!3%2"%C%.!",! E%!/,.!/2+'!$%2*%.!E%!-$('1A$!-$%!*/",!'5!-$%!-$%+"+!&("-",A!E'E%,-7!P'1(!$%2*!E%/,-!-$%! &'(2.!5'(!E%!/,.!=!&"22!3%!/2&/4+!C%(4!A(/-%512!-'!4'17!! #'!5'(E%(!/,.!*(%+%,-!<QR>8@!2/3!E%E3%(+;!>/(E%,;!8/,"%2;!F,.(%/;!S%C",;!>$%E/;!@(1,';! 6%-(/;!T1.&");!G%(%,0;!#+/";!D/C%%,;!F",/!/,.!F,,"%;!=!'&,!/!A(%/-!-$/,)7!U/0$!'5!4'1;!$/C%! 0',-("31-%.!",!4'1(!'&,!/,.!+*%0"/2!&/4;!-'!E/)%!-$%+%!-$%!A(%/-%+-!/,.!51,,"%+-!4%/(+7!=! /**(%0"/-%! %C%(4! +0"%,-"5"0! /,.! ,',N+0"%,-"5"0! /.C"0%;! %C%(4! 0'55%%! /,.! 0/)%! 3(%/)+;! %C%(4! G("./4!+$'-+;!/,.!%/0$!/,.!%C%(4!+",A2%!2/1A$!/,.!+E/22!-/2)+!",!-$%!2/37!P'1!$/C%!E/.%!E4! %C%(4N./4!2"5%!3%--%(7! =!%+*%0"/224!-$/,)!>/(E%,!/,.!D/C%%,!5'(!*(''5(%/.",A!/,.!"E*('C",A!-$%!","-"/2!C%(+"',!'5! -$%!-$%+"+7!F2-$'1A$!31+4!&"-$!4'1(!-$",A+;!4'1!$/C%!/2&/4+!5'1,.!/!E'E%,-!5'(!E%;!+'!-$/,)! 4'17! #'!>$%E/;!</(/;!?/(-/;!>2%E%,+;!F,.(%/!/,.!>/(E%,;!-$/,)!4'1!5'(!3%",A!E4!@%(A%,!5/E"24! /,.!5'(!/2&/4+!3%",A!-$%(%!&$%,!=!,%%.%.7!=!'&,!4'1!%C%(4-$",A7! =!&/,-!-'!-$/,)!/22!</(+!>%,-(%!*%'*2%!5'(!-$%!,"0%!%,C"(',E%,-!/,.!-$%!A(%/-!&'()!/-E'+*$%(%7!! F!+*%0"/2!-$/,)+!-'!E4!VU,A2"+$!-&",W!@%0)4!5'(!*(''5(%/.",A!-$"+!-$%+"+!/,.!-$%!E/,1+0("*-+7! P'1(!0',-("31-"',!&/+!%++%,-"/2!5'(!-$"+!-$%+"+7!! T/+-!31-!,'-!2%/+-;!=!-$/,)!E4!5/E"24!5'(!/2&/4+!3%",A!+1**'(-"C%!/,.!/2&/4+!3%2"%C",A!",!E%! /,.!E4!.(%/E+!%C%,!&$%,!-$%4!$/C%!3('1A$-!E%!5/(!5('E!$'E%7!! G",/224;!=!/E!.%%*24!-$/,)512!-'!K"00/(.'7!P'1!&%(%!/2&/4+!-$%(%!5'(!E%;!/2&/4+!0/(",A;! 5%%.",A;!+1**'(-",A!/,.!*1+$",A;!&$%,%C%(!=!,%%.%.!"-7!P'1!-(124!/(%!-$%!2'C%!'5!E4!2"5%;!/,.! =!/E!%J-(%E%24!A(/-%512!-'!$/C%!4'1!",!E4!2"5%7! ! "C! -4'5+*!#+&'*$64'$+&3! =!$%(%34!.%02/(%!-$/-!=!$/C%!&("--%,!-$"+!-$%+"+!E4+%25;!&"-$!-$%!0',-("31-"',!'5!'-$%(!*%'*2%! ",!5'(E!'5!0'EE%,-+!/,.!5'(E/2!0'((%0-"',+7!! =!/2+'!.%02/(%!-$/-!=!&/+!",C'2C%.!",!-$%!.%+"A,;!",!E'+-!'5!-$%!%J*%("E%,-+!/,.!",!-$%!/,/24+%+! '5! -$%! E/,1+0("*-+! =! /,.! ==! /,.! =! $/C%! &("--%,! E4+%25! -$%! E/,1+0("*-+! =! /,.! ==7! #$%! 0',-("31-"',+!'5!-$%!'-$%(!/1-$'(+!-'!E/,1+0("*-+!=!/,.!==!/(%!/+!5'22'&X! 8(! ?/()! Y7! ?/(-",./2%! /,.! 8(! U2/",%! >7! <%/C%(! Z#$%! [$"-,%4! T/3'(/-'(4! 5'(! ?/(",%! @"'+0"%,0%;!<7!F1A1+-",%;!G2'("./\!*%(5'(E%.!-$%!",:%0-"',+!'5!521'(%+0%,-!2",/A%!-(/0%(!',! !"#$%&'()*&+,-./0*&!%E3(4'+!/,.!-'')!-$%!0',5'0/2!"E/A%+!'5!-$%!:1C%,"2%+7! 6('57!8(!K/25!<0$,/3%2!ZB,"C%(+"-4!'5!@(/1,+0$&%"A;!L%(E/,4\!$'+-%.!E%!",!$"+!2/3!5'(!/! *%("'.!'5!]!E',-$+!/,.!-/1A$-!E%!$'&!-'!1+%!-$%!2/+%(!+4+-%E!/,.!-'!*%(5'(E!2/+%(!/32/-"',! ',!!"#$%&'()*&+,-./0*&!%E3(4'+7! 6('57!8(!F,.(%/+!9%:,'2!ZB,"C%(+"-4!'5!@%(A%,;!D'(&/4\;!/+!E4!+1*%(C"+'(;!&/+!",C'2C%.!",! -$%! .%+"A,! /,.! -$%! +1*%(C"+"',! '5! -$%! *(':%0-+! /,.! 0'EE%,-%.! ',! -$%! -$%+"+! /,.! -$%! E/,1+0("*-+7! ?/,1+0("*-!===!&/+!&("--%,!34!8(!^'+%!?7!?/(-M,!81(O,!ZY1%%,!?/(4!B,"C%(+"-4!'5!T',.',\7! =! 0',-("31-%.! 34! 02',",A! -$%! 9'J! A%,%+! /,.! *%(5'(E",A! -$%! %1+ "%)-! $43("."_/-"',! ',! -$%! %E3(4'+;!:1C%,"2%+!/,.!/.12-+!'5!-$%!/,,%2".!2%'#*,0%.-"+34*#/%.%&)-"7!=!$/C%!/2+'!(%/.!/,.! 0'EE%,-%.!',!-$%!E/,1+0("*-!.(/5-7! ! ! C! -63'*7#'! F0'%2+!/(%!3"2/-%(/224!+4EE%-("0!/`1/-"0!&'(E+;!-$/-!2/0)!/!-$('1A$!A1-!/,.!$/C%!/!+",A2%! 3'.4! '*%,",A! -'! -$%"(! ."A%+-"C%! +4,04-"1E7! F2-$'1A$! -$%4! &%(%! ","-"/224! *2/0%.! &"-$",! +*"(/2"/,+;!3%0/1+%!'5!-$%"(!E'(*$'2'A"0/2!/55","-"%+!&"-$!-1(3%22/("/,+;!/0'%2+;!-'A%-$%(!&"-$! ,%E%(-'.%(E/-".+!/,.!5(1#)-*6(..&!Za%,/0'%2'E'(*$/\;!/(%!,'&!*2/0%.!/+!+"+-%(!A('1*!'5! /22!-$%!(%E/",",A!3"2/-%("/,+!ZD%*$('_'/!b!6('-'+-'E"/!c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de!.%C%2'*E%,-/2!A%,%+;!.1(",A!-$%! %/(24!.%C%2'*E%,-!'5!-$%!/0'%2!79+'&/*#,43&7!#$%!%J*(%++"',!'5!+%C%(/2!%0-'.%(E/2!E/()%(+! Z$.<=+('<=+3&)&>?@?A=+#)<=+,&<@?B?C=+"%<A?D=+/,.+1E@9>\!",!-$%!E"0('E%(%!2",%/A%+!(%C%/2%.!-$%! %0-'.%(E/2!".%,-"-4!'5!-$%!%/(24!E"0('E%(%+;!&$"2%!-$%!%J*(%++"',!'5!-$%!%,.'E%+'.%(E/2! E/()%(+!Z3&)&F?B?D;!;#<+G+/,.!;#<H\!",!-$%!E/0('E%(%!2",%/A%+!(%C%/2%.!-$%!%,.'E%+'.%(E/2! ".%,-"-4!'5!-$%!%/(24!E/0('E%(%+7!#$%!0$/(/0-%("+%.!E'2%012/(!5/-%+!'5!-$%!%/(24!32/+-'E%(%+! ! C"! /(%! 0',+"+-%,-! &"-$! -$%! /0'%2! 5/-%! E/*! /,.! *('C".%! -$%! 5"(+-! %/(24! %J*(%++"',! /,/24+"+! '5! (%A12/-'(4!A%,%+!",!/,!/0'%2!+*%0"%+7!#$"+!-$%+"+!%J*/,.+!-$%!),'&2%.A%!',!-$%!%E3(4',"0! .%C%2'*E%,-! '5! /0'%2+;! 0'E3",",A! 02/++"0/2! %E3(4'2'A"0/2! +-1."%+;! +10$! /+! -$%! 5/-%! E/*! /,/24+%+!/,.!-$%!*%(-1(3/-"',!%J*%("E%,-+;!&"-$!E'.%(,!E'2%012/(!/**('/0$%+;!+10$!/+!&$'2%! E'1,-!%1+"%)-!$43("."_/-"',!Z[?=<9\7!! ! ! ! ! ! C""! 8$3'!+(!9460$#7'$+&3! !"#$%&'()*+,-$-'()'./$'./$&(&0' #$%!5'22'&",A!*/*%(+!/(%!*/(-!'5!-$%!-$%+"+X! 6/*%(!=X!>%-(/,A'2'!f7;!?/(-",./2%!?7Y7;!<%/C%(!U7;!<0$,/3%2!K7;!9%:,'2!F7!1/$'2".$'3"#' ")-' %$4,+".(5$' -$5$+6#3$).' ")"+7&$&' 62' ./$' "*6$+' !"#$%&'()*&+ ,-./0*&8' 9?/,1+0("*-!",!*(%*/(/-"',\' 6/*%(!==X!>%-(/,A'2'!f7;!9%:,'2!F7!:"%+7';+"&.63$%$'(-$).(.7'%$5$"+$-';7'4$)$'$<#%$&&(6)' ()'./$'"*6$+'1#23#.-)*%.#4&+'&/*#,56&7+Z?/,1+0("*-!",!*(%*/(/-"',\+ 81(",A!E4!-(/",",A!=!0',-("31-%.!-'!-$%!*/*%(X!! ?/(-M,N81(O,!^7?7;!f%221-","!@7>7;!?/(2g-/_!G7;!>%-(/,A'2'!f7=!>C%-%+"0!D7;!#$"%2!87;! 9%,("%-!<7;!L(/1N@'Cg!a7;!>/(("22'N@/2-'./,'!F7;![%,:"/!L7;!S%(32!F7;!@%))'10$%!D;! >$'1(('1-!87;!LhE%_N<)/(E%-/!^7T7;!=("E"/!?7;!T%,$/(.-!@7;!['(+//%!S7;!9%:,'2!F7! >6)&$%5".(5$' %6,.$' .6' $<.%$3$' 4$)63(*' *63#"*.(6)' ()' "' 3()(".,%$' "))$+(-8' Z?/,1+0("*-!+13E"--%.\! ! ! ! ! ! C"""! :+&'%&'3! ! -!./$,01)#$'0/!2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222!-! !"!#$%&#&'()*+#,-.#/01#.&2&3+4'&-05#%+6#0+#7+)'#,#-&6#+)8,-/1'##""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#!#