Supplementary Data S2a: Summary of Evidence Table Primary Outcome (BMD)

Supplementary Data S2a: Summary of Evidence Table Primary Outcome (BMD)

<p> Supplementary Data S2a: Summary of Evidence Table Primary outcome (BMD)</p><p>Study (first Study design Study population Test used O Compared to Results author, year) ut c o m e s Numbe Sex Age r Doulgeraki Cross- 14 8 male 13.16 (6.17-16.58) yrs BMD Z-score BMD Z-scores (median, 2014 sectional 6 range): study female Lumbar spine, total body Lumbar spine: -0.65 (-2.5 to 1.4) Total body: -0.3 (-1.7 to 0.6)</p><p>Overall, median BMD Z- scores within normal range.</p><p>5 patients low-normal lumbar spine Z-score (between -1 and -2), whereas total body Z-scores were normal.</p><p>BMD Z-scores (mean±SD) Lumbar spine: -0.58 ±1.29 Total body: -0.6 ±0.9</p><p>1 Study (first Study design Study population Test used O Compared to Results author, year) ut c o m e s Panis 2004 Cross- 40 13 3.0-17.3 yrs Absolute BMD, BMD Z-score BMD Z-score femoral neck sectional male (mean±SD): study 27 Mean: Lumbar spine, femoral neck -0.3±0.9 (-1.6 to 1.4) female 8.9±4.1 yrs BMD Z-score lumbar spine (mean±SD): -0.6±0.8 (-2.2 to 1.4)</p><p>Mean BMD Z-score of lumbar spine significantly decreased when compared to reference data (p<0.001). Rubio- Cross- 11 5 male 2.5-18.0 yrs BMD Z-score BMD Z-score total body Gozalbo sectional 6 (mean, range): 2002 study female Total body -0.99 (-0.5 to -1.4) (p<0.05).</p><p>2 Study (first Study design Study population Test used O Compared to Results author, year) ut c o m e s Tan 2014 Retrospectiv 25 15 5-41 yrs BMD Z-score 70% of patients >10 yrs of e case series male age had a normal bone (conference 10 Mean: 13.5±7.1 yrs Lumbar spine, total hip density. abstract) female BMD Z-score entire cohort (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -0.80 ±0.99 Total hip: -0.76 ±1.19 BMD Z-score children (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -0.78 ±1.04 Total hip: -0.84 ±1.18 BMD Z-score adults (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -1.00 ±0.60 Total hip: -0.20 ±1.35 BMD Z-score adult males (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -0.70 ±0.42 Total hip: 0.35±1.35</p><p>3 Study (first Study design Study population Test used O Compared to Results author, year) ut c o m e s Waisbren Cross- 33 17 18-59 yrs BMD Z-score Bone density on average 2012 sectional male greater than one SD below study 16 Mean: Hip, femoral neck, spine the mean (Z-score= -1.1). female 32.6±11.7 yrs 8/33 (24%) had Z-score greater than 2 SD below the mean.</p><p>15 subjects (45%) had history of fractures; 6 during childhood, 9 at ages 20-46 yrs.</p><p>BMD Z-score adults (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -0.91 ±1.26 Total hip: -0.94 ±0.86 Femoral neck: -0.97 ±0.82 BMD Z-score males (mean±SD): Lumbar spine: -0.80 ±1.28 Total hip: -0.81 ±0.70 Femoral neck: -0.89 ±0.66 BMD Z-score females (mean±SD):</p><p>4 5 Supplementary Data S2b: Summary of Evidence Table Secondary outcomes (BMC, BTM, vitamins, minerals and hormones)</p><p>Abbreviation list</p><p>1.25OHD = 1,25-dihydroxy vitamin D Mg = magnesium 25-OH-D vitamin = 25-hydroxycholecalciferol NA = not applicable AP = alkaline phosphatase NTX = amino terminal telopeptide of type I collagen BAP = bone-specific alkaline phosphatase OC = osteocalcin Ca= calcium P = phosphate cOC = carboxylated osteocalcin PTH = parathormone CTX = carboxy-terminal telopeptide of type 1 collagen ucOC =under-carboxylated osteocalcin ERT = estrogen replacement therapy Z= zinc IGF-1 = insulin-like growth factor-1</p><p>Study (first Study design Study population Outcomes Compared to Results author, year) Numbe Sex Age r Gajewska Cross- 35 17 1-10 yrs Serum Ca, P, 25(OH)D, AP, CTX 20% lower than controls, 2006 sectional male OC, BAP, CTX p<0.001. study 18 Mean: female 5.0 yrs All other values similar to controls or within reference range.</p><p>6 Study (first Study design Study population Outcomes Compared to Results author, year) Gajewska Cross- 62 32 2-20 yrs Serum Ca, P, 25(OH)D, OC, Substantial overlap in 2008 sectional male BAP, CTX-I patients with 2006 study. study 30 Group female children: CG children: CTX-I is about N=32 20% lower than in controls 17 male (p<0.001). BAP and OC not 15 female significantly different. 2-9 yrs CG adolescents: BAP is about Group 30% higher than in controls adolescents (p<0.05), OC is about 35% : higher than in controls N=30 (p<0.02). CTX-I not 15 male significantly different. 15 female 10-20 yrs Healthy adolescents have significantly lower levels of CTX-I, BAP and OC than healthy children.</p><p>Ca, P, 25(OH)D in CG patients within normal ranges. Panis 2004 Cross- 40 13 3.0-17.3 yrs Serum Ca, P, Mg, Zn, Significantly decreased: cOC, sectional male 1.25OHD, PTH, 17-beta NTX, CTX, IGF-1 Z-scores. study 27 Mean: estradiol, IGF-1 Z-score, female 8.9±4.1 yrs CTX, BAP, cOC, ucOC, All other outcomes within ucOC/cOC ratio, NTX reference range.</p><p>7 Study (first Study design Study population Outcomes Compared to Results author, year) Panis 2006 Randomized- 40 13 3-17 yrs DXA Pediatric reference data controlled male trial on effect 27 of calcium, female vitamin K1 and D3 supplementat ion on bone mineral content Rubio- Cross- 11 5 male 2.5-18.0 yrs Serum Ca, P, PTH, AP, NTX significantly lower than in Gozalbo sectional 6 25(OH)D, 1.25OHD, cOC, controls (p<0.001). 2002 study female ucOC, NTX, BAP There was no correlation between BMD results and dietary calcium intake. </p><p>Sirrs 2010 Retrospectiv 16 9 male 17-55 yrs 25(OH)D 9 patients had 25(OH)D levels e case series 7 in insufficient range, 1 patient (conference female Mean: in deficient range, despite half abstract) 26.6±9 yrs of them having moderate- good compliance to supplements (total daily vitamin D intake ≥400 IU).</p><p>8 Study (first Study design Study population Outcomes Compared to Results author, year) Waisbren Cross- 33 17 18-59 yrs Plasma 25(OH)D 80% has 25(OH)D level below 2012 sectional male the sufficient range. study 16 mean: female 32.6±11.7 Mean plasma 25(OH)D 27±11 yrs ng/mL, reference range 32- 100 ng/mL.</p><p>9</p>

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    9 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us