Add Few Lines of Text Mentioning Threshold Setting Method

March 2011 IEEE P802IEEE P802.22 Wireless RANsProposed resolution to comment no. 60 on D2: Smart Threshold Setting for DVB-T SensingDate: 2011-03-16Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email 3-4 Hikari no oka, Yokosuka, Chunyi Song NICT +81-46-847-5095 [email protected] Kanagawa, Japan M. Azizur 3-4 Hikari no oka, Yokosuka, NICT Rahman Kanagawa, Japan Hiroshi 3-4 Hikari no oka, Yokosuka, NICT Harada Kanagawa, JapanAbstract This document adds new text to IEEE 802.22-11-15r1 for smart threshold setting for DVB-T sensing. The newly added text is shown in red.Notice: This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 802.22. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 802.22.Patent Policy and Procedures: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE 802 Patent Policy and Procedures <http://standards.ieee.org/guides/bylaws/sb-bylaws.pdf>, including the statement "IEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s), including patent applications, provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder or applicant with respect to patents essential for compliance with both mandatory and optional portions of the standard." Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in the development process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication. Please notify the Chair Apurva Mody <[email protected]> as early as possible, in written or electronic form, if patented technology (or technology under patent application) might be incorporated into a draft standard being developed within the IEEE 802.22 Working Group. If you have questions, contact the IEEE Patent Committee Administrator at <[email protected]>. page 1 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P802The CommentThe sensing methods for DVB-T don’t work well enough without smart threshold setting.Add few lines of text mentioning threshold setting method.Proposed Resolution :This document adds new text to IEEE 802.22-11-15r1 for smart threshold setting for DVB-T sensing. The newly added text is shown in red, at the end of the document.1. DVB-T Signal SpecificationThe DVB-T standard was developed by European Telecommunications Standards Union (ETSI) for the terrestrial broadcasting of digital TV. It is currently widely adopted by more than 30 countries. The DVB-T uses orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) modulation and is organized in frames. One DVB-T signal super frame consists of 4 consecutive frames, each frame consisting of 68 OFDM symbols. In DVB-T signals, pilots consist of around 10% of the total used subcarriers. Pilots are transmitted at a higher power by about 2.5dB compared to the data subcarriers. These boosted pilots include continual pilots (CP) and scattered pilots (SP). The CPs are placed at fixed sub-carrier locations and their locations do not vary from symbol to symbol, while the SPs are distributed at the positions if k-3×(l mod 4) (the operation ‘mod’ calculates the modulus after division) is divisible by 12, where k is the subcarrier location and l is the symbol number. In consequence, as shown in Fig.1, the pattern of boosted pilots (CPs and SPs) repeats every four OFDM symbols. The features of boosted pilot sub-carriers as shown in the Fig.1 are exploited to achieve reliable detection of DVB-T signals. We generate a reference sequence by conducting inverse Fourier transform (IFFT) of a vector that is only composed of such pilot sub-carriers, defined as sp(t). Let us define the sequence achieved by sampling the sp(t) over 4T (T: one OFDM symbol duration) as s p [n]  s p (nTsp ) , n=0,1,…NCPPP-1 (1) where 1/Tsp is the sampling rate, and NCPPP is the sequence length of one cycle period of pilot pattern. km ax=1704 if 2K kmin=0 Sub-carrier Number km ax=6816 if 8K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 0 ······ 1 ······ r ······ e 2 b 3 ······ m u 4 N ······ l · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · o · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ······ · · · · · · · · · · b m 64 ······ yS 65 ······ 66 ······ 67TPS pilots are not indicated Boosted pilot DataFig.1 Locations of scattered boosted sub-carriers in DVB-T OFDM symbols. The horizontal axis represents the sub-carrier number (frequency) and the vertical axis represents the symbol number (time).2. Improved cross correlation method page 2 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P8022.1 Description of the method The system block diagram is as shown in Fig.2. Sensing is achieved through following the steps as shown below:1) The received DVB-T signal that also contains noise is passed through RF front end and LNA; 2) The above signal is sampled and converted to digital sequence by ADC; 3) The above sequence is stored in a buffer; 4) Averaging of the samples is done over a time span equal to multiple of NCPPP As described in Fig.1 and (1), the pilot pattern of DVB-T sequence repeats with a periodicity of NCPPP; we then average the received DVB-T sequence based on NCPPP, as1 L1 x (n)  x(n  l  N ) L  CPPP , n= 0,…, NCPPP. (2) L l0 5) Frequency offset estimation and correction is performed. This is an optional step and the block is shown using dotted lines 6) Time offset estimation and correction are done; The purpose of conducting time offset correction is to find the same starting point of the DVB-T sequence and the pilot sequence that is used as a reference in a latter step. Assuming the estimation result shows that the synchronization point locates between the M1-th sample and the M2-th sample (M2≥M1) of the NCPPP samples, i.e. locates inside the window of [M1, M2], then the window size represents the time synchronization level and it is expressed using a metric, Γ, as:M 2  M 1  1  1 . N CPPP (3)7) According to the synchronization level, either correlation or sliding correlation over a specific window is applied: when the time synchronization level Γ=1 ,i.e. M1=M2, correlation is applied, as:NCPPP 1 R  s (n)x* (n) xp  p , (4) n0 otherwise (Γ<1), sliding correlation is applied over the window of [M1, M2], as:NCPPP 1 R (m)  s (n)x* (n  m) xp  p , m= M1,…, M2 . (5) n0 where x is the DVB-T sequence and sp(n) is the pilot sequence obtained in (1). The computation in (5) is called the selective sliding correlation here since the sliding window of [M1, M2] is selectively decided according to synchronization level achieved in (2).8) Compare the correlation output (if Γ=1) or the maximum of the M2-M1+1 correlation outputs (if Γ<1) with pre-decided threshold and judge presence/absence of TV signal: if the output is above the threshold, the presence of DVB-T signal is judged.2.2 Simulation resultsClean DVB-T signals (SNR>30dB) generated by DVB-T signal generator (SG) are used as source data in page 3 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P802 the computer simulation. The DVB-T is the 2K mode with TCP=T/32 (TCP is the cyclic prefix duration).Fig.3 shows the Probability of Detection (PD) vs. SNR by fixing False Alarm Probability (PFA) to 0.01and Fig.4 shows the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. Sensing performance of the improved cross correlation detection is directly proportional to the time synchronization level, Γ; it can also be improved by averaging the received DVB-T sequence over the duration of NCPPP. To achieve the sensing performance ofPD≥0.9 and PFA=0.01 at SNR=-20dB in AWGN, the improved cross correlation at both Γ=0.975 and Γ=1.0 requires the same sensing time of 4 OFDM symbol duration, which is around 1.2 ms.Fig.2 Simplified block diagram of the improved cross correlation method. The pilot sequence is the clean sp(n) generated in (1).Fig.3 Probability of Detection (PD) vs. SNR in AWGN: PFA=0.01. The Γ is the time synchronization level defined in (3), L is the conducted number of average operation defined in (2). page 4 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P802 n 1 o i t c e t e D f o0.9 y t i l i b a b o rP 0.8 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 False Alarm ProbabilityFig.4 ROC curve in AWGN: the improved cross correlation: Γ=0.975, SNR=- 20dB. 3. Combined feature and energy detection3.1 Description of the methodAs shown in Fig.5, the combined feature and energy detection method consists of following steps:1) The received DVB-T signal that also contains noise is passed through RF front end and LNA; 2) The above signal is sampled and converted to digital sequence by an ADC; 3) Frequency offset correction is performed. This is an optional step the block is shown using dotted lines;4) The sequences with length of NCPPP are firstly multiplied with the pilot sequence generated in (1) and then their absolute products are integrated, as:NCPPP 1 Rxp   s p (n)x(n) . (6) n05) Conduct computation of (6) for κ (κ≥1) times while shifting the sequence timing by a random interval, τ, and calculates the average value, as:N 1   CPPP  J   1   Rxp   s p nx n   i        , (7) J 1  n0  i1   subjects to  i   4T . (8) i16) Compare the output in (7) with pre-decided threshold and judge presence/absence of DVB-T signal: if the output is above the threshold, the presence of DVB-T signal is judged.3.2 Simulation Results Clean DVB-T signals (SNR>30dB) generated by DVB-T SG are used as source data in the computer simulation. The DVB-T is the 8K mode with TCP=T/8.Fig.6 shows PD vs. SNR by fixing PFA to 0. 1. The sensing performance is significantly improved by increasing operation times, κ, defined in (7). This feature is attractive since as shown in (8), the increase of κ page 5 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P802 may not increase the sensing time considerably. Therefore, to achieve the sensing performance of PD≥0.9 andPFA=0.1 at SNR=-20dB in AWGN, the sensing technique requires sensing time of 8 OFDM symbol duration (κ≥8), which is equivalent of around 8 ms.Fig.5 Simplified block diagram of the combined feature and energy detection.1 n 0.8 o i t c e t e 0.6 D f o y t i l 0.4 i b a b o r 0.2 P0 -25 -24 -23 -22 -21 -20 -19 -18 -17 -16 -15 SNR [dB] κ=1 κ=2 κ=8 κ=16Fig.6 PD vs.SNR in AWGN: PFA=0.1. The κ is the operation times defined in (7). 3.3 Test results of hardware sensing prototypeSensing performance of the combined feature and energy detection is also verified by hardware tests. In the hardware tests, the 8K mode DVB-T signals (TCP=T/8) generated by SG are tuned to -120dBm/8MHz using attenuators and then input into the hardware sensing prototype through a cable. We conducted 5,000 runs of tests for each PFA shown in Fig.7. Although the results are degraded in comparison with simulation results shown in Fig.6, they have verified that using the combined feature and energy detection we can achieve PD≥0.9 and PFA=0.1 in the very low SNR regime. Please note that the κ=32 operations are conducted for DVB-T sequence of 8 OFDM symbol duration as shown in (7)-(8). page 6 Chunyi Song, NICT March 2011 IEEE P802 n 1 o i t 0.9 c e t e 0.8 D f 0.7 o y 0.6 t i l i 0.5 b a b 0.4 o r 0.3 P 0.01 0.1 1 False Alarm ProbabilityFig.7 Hardware test results: ROC curve: DVB-T input level=-120dBm/8MHz, κ=32.4. Smart Threshold Setting4.1 Dynamic Threshold Selection (DTS)Dynamic threshold selection (DTS) can be applied to extend sensing capability to lower SNR regime by partially overcoming the limitation due to environment and system noise variance. The DTS is realized through following two steps: 1) Develop a threshold table. Measure the system noise variance and threshold statistics for extended period of time. Divide the captured whole noise variance range into a number of narrower and non-overlapping ranges and for each range, divide the threshold statistics in similar groups and for each range/group, define a threshold corresponding to a target detection level. Especially, using relaxed target detection level would be useful for sensing in the presence of interference. 2) Measure system noise variance immediate prior to the sensing and select appropriate threshold by mapping the noise variance to the threshold table. For example, it can be done by using a programmable switched isolator behind the antenna with impedance that matches the inside RF part. Switching off of the isolators isolates the RF part and the noise variance can be measured.4.2 Real-time Threshold SettingIf the system is equipped with a switched isolator as mentioned in the previous sub-clause, the necessity of a threshold table can be relaxed. In such a case, the isolator can be switched off and threshold can be set on real- time basis immediate prior to the sensing. References:1. C. Song, M. A. Rahman, R. Funada and H. Harada, "Robust Spectrum Sensing of DVB-T Signals," IEICE Technical Report, SR2010-63, pp. 161-168, Oct. 29, 2010. 2. ETSI EN 300 744 V1.6 .1 (2009-01), "Digital video broadcasting (DVB) ; framing structure, channel coding and modulation for digital terrestrial television ," ETSI, Tech. Rep., 2009. page 7 Chunyi Song, NICT

Add Few Lines of Text Mentioning Threshold Setting Method

Details

Download

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

Support