<p> WIRRAL TENNIS LEAGUE Problem and Action Catalogue 2010 Blue=to be resolved/ratified by next WTL CM Red=waiting for response Purple=Correction/change after WTL CM Nb Problems Action / Decision / Penalty WEEK 1 1. COULD NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Prenton 1 v Hooton 1: Hooton 1 CM1: Men: Hooton 1 pen 4pts could not fulfil fixture. Email received from Hooton. Prenton 1 awarded match 8-0. 2. INCORRECT CARD: N Cheshire 2 v Birkenhead 4: No Match Number, CM1: N Cheshire 2 pen 1pt Division, Date Birkenhead 4 pen 1pt 3. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Thorndale 2 v Alderley 2: Joe Lamb won 4 CM1: Alderley 2 pen 2pts. sets. Rubbers in which JL played awarded to Thorndale 2 6/0 6/0. Result Result card changed from 9-9 card changed from 9-9 to 12-5 to 12-5 4. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED (Wrong name): Birkenhead 1 v C Oaks 1: CM1: Penalty applied but no Rosie Davies was entered on the card as Rosie Hoyle (she wants to revert change to result. C Oaks 1 pen to her maiden name). Telephone call followed by email received Wed am 1pt from C Oaks. Logged as a problem for WTL CM1 5. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED (registered late): Oxton 2 v Neston 3: CM1: Penalty applied but no Fionuala Robinson registered day after match but played 4th in Neston 3. change to result. Neston 3 pen Email explanation (other player in car accident) received. Logged as a 1pt problem for WTL CM1. 6. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Pinewood 2 v Upton 4: Ryan Harvey won 0 CM1: Upton 4 pen 2pts sets. Rubbers in which RH played awarded to Pinewood 2 6/0 6/0. Result card unchanged at 11-5. Misread by FS L read as H. Name is Lavery 7. DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Pinewood 2 v Upton 4: Upton 1 gent & CM1: Upton 4 pen 3pts 1 lady short. 3 rubbers awarded to Pinewood 2 6/0 6/0. 8. INCORRECT CARD: Men: Thorndale 1 v Neston 1: Initials but no CM1: Thorndale 1 Men pen forenames for Neston 1pt. Neston 1 Men pen 1pt WEEK 2 9. LATE CARD: Men: Alderley 1 v Thorndale 1: Match 2 May, PM 6 May 1st CM1: Men Alderley 1 pen 1pt. class Received 7 May 10. LATE CARD: Upton 3 v Prenton 4: Match 4 May, PM 5 May 1st class CM1: No penalty Received 7 May. Posted in time. PO delivered late. No penalty 11. LATE CARD (NOT RECEIVED): Men: Bertram 2 v Hoylake: Match 2 May. CM1: Explanation accepted Email from Dave Martin (Bertram) stating he definitely posted the card on therefore no penalty time and attaching a scanned copy of result card. 12. INCORRECT CARD: Upton 3 v Prenton 4: Wrong division: States 4 s/b 5 CM1: Upton 3 pen 1pt. Prenton 4 pen 1pt 13. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Alderley 2 v P Sunlight 3: Joe Lamb won 3 CM1: Alderley 2 pen 3pts (2nd sets. Rubbers in which JL played not awarded to P Sunlight 3 6/0 6/0. time). No change to Result Result card not changed from 8-7 to 5-9 WEEK 3 14. LATE CARD: Neston 5 v Upton 4: Match 11 May, PM 13 May 1st class CM1: Neston 5 pen 1pt Received 14 May. 15. RANKING (playing out of position): C Oaks 2 v P Sunlight 2: Rob Slade (9) CM1: C Oaks 2 pen 2pts. played 4 positions below Kieron McGinley (10). RS won 2 sets. Rubbers in Result card changed from 6-12 which RS played awarded to P Sunlight 2 6-0 6-0 to 4-13 16. RANKING (playing out of position): Heswall 4 v N Cheshire 1: Ann Forester CM1: Heswall 4 pen 2pts. (15) played 2 positions below Lynn O’Brien (16). AF won 3 sets. Rubbers Result card changed from 9-11 in which AF played awarded to N Cheshire 1 6-0 6-0 to 6-12 17. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Prenton 4 v Hoylake 4: Alex White won 3 CM1: Hoylake 4 pen 2pts. sets. Rubbers in which AW played awarded to Prenton 4 6/0 6/0. Result card changed from 3-15 to 6-11 18. RANKING (playing out of position): Neston 2 v Alderley 1: Steve Sutton (9) CM1: Neston 2 pen 2pts. played 2 positions above Elliot Sutton(8). ES won 4 sets. Rubbers in which Result card changed from 16-0 ES played awarded to Alderley 1 6-0 6-0 to 12-4 19. RANKING (playing out of position): Bertram 2 v Neston 3: Tony Lydiate (14) CM1: Neston 3 pen 2pts (2nd played 2 positions above Mike Merry (13). MM won 2 sets. Rubbers in time but on same night). Result which MM played awarded to Bertram 2 6-0 6-0 card changed from 6-10 to 7-8 20. INCORRECT CARD: N Cheshire 2 v Oxton 3: Initials but no forename for 3 CM1: N Cheshire 2 pen 1pt. Oxton men Oxton 3 pen 1pt 21. DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Neston 5 v Upton 4: Upton 1 lady short. CM1: Upton 4 pen 2pts 2 rubbers awarded to Neston 5 6/0 6/0. 22. INCORRECT CARD: Men: Alderley 2 v Hoylake: No team number for CM1: Men Alderley 2 pen 1pt. Alderley 2 Hoylake pen 1pt 23. INCORRECT CARD & LATE CARD: Men: Helsby v Prenton 2: No date. CM1: Men: Helsby pen 2pts Match scheduled for 12 May, PM 17 May 1st class Received 18 May. Prenton 2 pen 1pt 24. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Alderley 2 v P Sunlight 3: Joe Lamb won 4 CM1: Alderley 2 pen 4pts (3rd sets. Rubbers in which JL played not awarded to P Sunlight 3 6/0 6/0. time). No change to Result Result card not changed from 14-3 to 10-4 WEEK 4 25. INCORRECT CARD: Wallasey M 2 v Upton 1: No team number for CM1: Wallasey M 2 pen 1pt Wallasey M 2 Upton 1 pen 1pt 26. INCORRECT CARD: Upton 3 V Thorndale 2: States Div 4. S/B Div 5 CM1: Upton 3 pen 2pts (2nd time) Thorndale 2 pen 1pt 27. COULD NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Prenton 1 v Neston 1: Neston 1 CM1: Men: Neston 1 pen 4pts could not fulfil fixture. Prenton 1 awarded match 8-0. 28. RANKING (playing out of position): Upton 4 v N Cheshire 2: Robert CM1: N Cheshire 2 pen 2pts. Ashworth (13) played 2 positions below Peter Ferrett (16). RA won 0 sets. Result card unchanged Rubbers in which RA played awarded to Upton 4 6-0 6-0 29. RANKING (playing out of position): Pinewood 2 v Birkenhead 3: Jan CM1: Pinewood 2 pen 2pts. Jones(5) played 2 positions below Kelly Smith (6). JJ won 1 set. Rubbers in Result card changed from 5-13 which JJ played awarded to Birkenhead 3 6-0 6-0 to 4-13 WEEK 5 30. RANKING (playing out of position): Cheshire Oaks 2 v Heswall 3: Rob CM1: Cheshire Oaks 2 pen Slade (11) played 2 positions below Kieron McGinley (12). RS won 3 sets. 3pts (2nd time). Result card Rubbers in which RS played awarded to Heswall 3 6-0 6-0 changed from 15-5 to 12-6 WEEK 6 31. RANKING (playing out of position): Cheshire Oaks 1 v Hoylake 1: Neil CM1: Cheshire Oaks 1 pen Blacklock (4) played 2 positions below Brad Keenan (5). NB won 0 sets. 4pts (3rd time). Result card Rubbers in which NB played awarded to Hoylake 1 6-0 6-0 unchanged 32. RANKING (playing out of position): Hoylake 3 v Cheshire Oaks 2: Rob CM1: Cheshire Oaks 2 pen Slade (11) played 4 positions below Kieron McGinley (12) and 2 positions 5pts (4th time). Result card below Steve Lambourn (13). RS won 4 sets. Rubbers in which RS played changed from 5-13 to 9-9 awarded to Hoylake 3 6-0 6-0 33. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Thorndale 3 v N Cheshire 2: Alysoun CM1: N Cheshire 2 pen 2pts. Chadwick. AC won 0 sets. Rubbers in which AC played awarded to Result card unchanged. Thorndale 3 6/0 6/0. WEEK 7 34. INCORRECT CARD: Alderley 2 v Upton 3: States Div 4. S/B Div 5 CM1: Alderley 2 pen 1pt Upton 3 pen 3pts (3rd time) 35. DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Birkenhead 4 v Upton 4: Upton 2 ladies CM1: Upton 4 pen 3pts short. 3 rubbers awarded to Birkenhead 4 6/0 6/0. 36. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Birkenhead 3 v Neston 5: Sue Howarth. SH CM1: Neston 5 pen 2pts. won 1 set. Rubbers in which SH played awarded to Birkenhead 3 6/0 6/0. Result card changed from 11-9 to 11-8. WEEK 8 37. LATE CARD: Pinewood 1 v C Oaks 2: Match 15 Jun PM 17 Jun 1st class CM1: Pinewood 1 pen 1pt Received 18 Jun 38. CARD NOT RECEIVED: Heswall 4 v Birkenhead 2: Match 15 Jun. Half off CM1: No penalty card received 23 Jun from Royal Mail. They had torn it. No penalty 39. COULD NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Oxton 1 v N Cheshire 1: Oxton 1 CM1: Men: Oxton 1 pen 4pts could not fulfil fixture. N Cheshire 1 awarded match 8-0. 40. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Upton 4 v Pinewood 2: Jordan Baksh . JB CM2: Pinewood 2 pen 2pts. won 0 sets. Rubbers in which JB played awarded to Upton 4 6/0 6/0. Result card unchanged from 4- 12. WEEK 9 41. COULD NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Thorndale 3 v Upton 4: Upton 4 CM2: Upton 4 pen 6pts were 4 ladies short. Thorndale 3 awarded unplayed rubbers 6/0 6/0. Also see problem 41 42. PLAYER NOT TRANSFERRED IN TIME: Thorndale 3 v Upton 4: Sam CM2: Thorndale 3 pen 2pts. Saville. SS won 1 set 0 sets. Mens rubbers in which SS played awarded to Result card changed from 15-2 Upton 4 6/0 6/0. Mixed rubber declared null. Also see problem 40 to 12-2. WEEK 10 43. COULD NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Upton 3 v Wallasey M 3: Wallasey CM2: Wallasey M 3 pen 3pts M 3 were 2 ladies short. Upton 3 awarded unplayed rubbers 6/0 6/0. 44. INCORRECT CARD: Pinewood 2 v Thorndale 3: No team number for CM2: Pinewood 2 pen 1pt Pinewood, no date Thorndale 3 pen 1pt 45. INCORRECT CARD: Men Oxton 1 v Hooton 1: Player names wrong way CM2: Oxton 1 men pen 1pt round: Hooton 1 team specified as Oxton 1 team and vice versa Hooton 1 Men pen 1pt 46. INCORRECT CARD: Men Bertram 1 v Thorndale 1: No forename (only CM2: Bertram 1 Men pen 1pt initials for Thorndale 1) Thorndale 1 Men pen 2pts (2nd time) 47. INELIGIBLE PLAYER: Men Thorndale 2 v Bertram 2: Matthew Hay played CM2: Bertram 2 Men pen 2pts for Bertram 1 in week 10 and then Bertram 2 in week 10. It is not allowed to Result changed from 4-2 to 6-0 play for 2 teams in the same week. Treated as unregistered player MH won 2 sets. Sets in which MH played awarded to Thorndale 2 6/0 6/0 (also notified of rule contravention by Bertram) 48. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Birkenhead 3 v Birkenhead 4: Caluti Nolan. CM2: Birkenhead 4 pen 2pts. CN won 0 sets. Rubbers in which CN played awarded to Birkenhead 3 6/0 Result card unchanged from 6/0. 14-3. 49. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Pinewood 2 v Thorndale 3: John CM2: Thorndale 3 pen 2pts. McNicholas. JM won 4 sets. Rubbers in which JM played awarded to Result card changed from 5-13 Pinewood 2 6/0 6/0. to 9-9. WEEK 11 50. DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Prenton 2 v Hoylake 1: Hoylake 1 did not CM2: Men: Hoylake 1 pen 4pts turn up. Prenton 2 awarded match 8-0. 51. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Birkenhead 3 v Pinewood 2: Danielle Smith. CM2: Pinewood 2 pen 3pts (2nd DS won 0 sets. Rubbers in which DS played awarded to Birkenhead 3 6/0 time). Result card unchanged 6/0. at 14-4 WEEK 12 52. DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: N Cheshire 1 v Neston 1: Neston CM2: Men: Neston 1 pen 4pts informed N Cheshire 1 they could not field a full team. N Cheshire awarded match 8-0. 53. LATE CARD: Heswall 3 v C Oaks 2: Match 13 Jul / PM 15 Jul / 1st class. CM2: Appeal accepted Heswall Received 19 Jul. Appeal that card was posted as normal on time by Sue 3 pen 1pt cancelled Davies 54. LATE CARD: Heswall 4 v Upton 2: Match 13 Jul / PM 15 Jul / 1st class. CM2: Appeal accepted Heswall Received 16 Jul. Appeal that card was posted as normal on time by Sue 4 pen 1pt cancelled Davies 55. INCORRECT CARD: Men: Hooton 1 v Thorndale 1: No Division, no date CM2: Men: Hooton 1 pen 2pts (2nd time) Thorndale 1 pen 3pts (3rd time) 56. INELIGIBLE PLAYER: Men Hooton 1 v Thorndale 1: Warren Brady played CM2: Hooton 1 Men pen 2pts for Hooton 2 in week 11 and then Hooton 1 in week 11. It is not allowed to Result unchanged at 2-7 play for 2 teams in the same week. Treated as unregistered player WB won 0 sets. Sets in which WB played awarded to Thorndale 1 6/0 6/0 57. PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Heswall 3 v C Oaks 2: Helen Hannah won 4 CM2: C Oaks 2 pen 3pts (2nd sets. Rubbers in which HH played awarded to Heswall 3 6/0 6/0. time). Result card changed from 1-16 to 5-12 WEEK 13 58. EMAIL NOT RECEIVED: Pinewood 1 v Heswall 3: Postponed match: CM2: Result changed from 0-0 Heswall 3 offered 3 dates. No email received from Heswall 3 as to which to 16-0 date selected. All unplayed rubbers awarded to Pinewood 1. Result 16-0 59. EMAIL NOT RECEIVED: Oxton 2 v Pinewood 2: Postponed match: CM2: Result changed from 0-0 Pinewood 2 offered 3 dates. No email received from Pinewood 2 as to to 16-0 which date selected. All unplayed rubbers awarded to Oxton 3. Result 16-0 60. LATE CARD: Men: Neston1 v Hooton 1: Match 22 Jul / PM 23 Jul / 1st CM2: Men: Neston 1 pen 1pt class. Received 24 Jul. No penalty 61. LATE CARD: Rearranged match 13: Hoylake 2 v P Sunlight 1: Match 22 Jul CM2: Men: Hoylake 2 pen 1pt 62. INELIGIBLE PLAYER: Men Hooton 1 v Neston 1: Warren Brady played for CM2: Hooton 1 Men pen Hooton 2 in week 13 and then Hooton 1 in week 13. It is not allowed to play 3pts(2nd time). Result for 2 teams in the same week. Treated as unregistered player WB won 0 unchanged at 7-3 sets. Sets in which WB played awarded to Neston 1 6/0 6/0 WEEK 14 63. LATE CARD: C Oaks 1 v Hoylake 2: Match 27Jul. 3 Aug: Telephone call CM2: Appeal accepted C Oaks from John Hilton saying card was posted as normal. Duplicate card 1 pen 1pt cancelled received 5 Aug. Appeal 64. LATE CARD: Heswall 3 v Hooton 1: Match 27 Jul. PM 29 Jul 1st class CM2: Heswall 3 pen 1pt Received 30 Jul (possibly 2 pts if appeal re p53 not granted) 65. DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Thorndale 3 v Oxton 3: Oxton 2 ladies CM2: Oxton 3 pen 3pts short. 3 rubbers awarded to Thorndale 3 6/0 6/0. 66. DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Upton 4 v Birkenhead 4: Upton 4 ladies CM2: Upton 4 pen 6pts short. 6 rubbers awarded to Birkenhead 4 6/0 6/0. 67. LATE CARD: Pinewood 2 v N Cheshire 2: Match 27 Jul. Received 30 Jul CM2: Pinewood 2 pen 2pts (2nd time) 68. LATE CARD: Men: Alderley 2 v Wallasey M 1: Match 26 Jul. PM 28 Jul 2nd CM2: Alderley 2 pen 1pt class Received 30 Jul 69. RANKING (playing out of position): Rearranged Upton 1 v Neston 2: In CM2: Neston 2 pen 4pts. (3rd original match Jenny Rowland (7) was top ranked. In rearranged match time) Result card changed Aimee Kaye (6) played. AK won 2 sets. Rubbers in which AK played from 11-7 to 12-5 awarded to Upton 1 6-0 6-0</p>