Summary of Studies Evaluating the Malaria Diagnostic Accuracy of Cell-Dyn Series Analysers

Summary of Studies Evaluating the Malaria Diagnostic Accuracy of Cell-Dyn Series Analysers

<p>Summary of studies evaluating the malaria diagnostic accuracy of Cell-Dyn series analysers using the side-scatter/depolarized side-scatter plot abnormal depolarizing events criterion – Including observations for each study and blinding. First author, year Number of participants and Standard reference Sensitivity Specificity ¶ Blinding Observations and country diagnoses test Index test criterion % % Total: 224 directed samples from 175 Mendelow, 1999, Microscopy*, PfHRP2 CD** 3500 Race differences, probably in patients, P. falciparum: 93, Species + 72 96 South Africa [18] (Para-sight F) relation to immunity. not specified: 2 ≥1 depolarizing events‡ Hänscheid, 2001, Total: 174, P. falciparum: 48, P. CD 3500 † Microscopy + 95 88 Portugal [39] vivax: 6, P. ovale: 1, P. malariae: 2 ≥2 depolarizing events Depolarizing purple events above Total: 113, P. falciparum: 46, P. CD 3500 a line that starts horizontally Wever, 2002, The vivax: 5, P. ovale: 4, no Microscopy, QBC Either ≥1 depolarizing + 62 96 through granularity signal channel Netherlands† [36] differentiation for P. vivax or P. events or 25 and then continues at 22.5° ovale: 3 pseudoreticulocytosis angle with the x axis. </p><p>Grobusch, 2003, Total: 403, P. falciparum: 87, P. Semi-immune sensitivity: 73.7% Microscopy, PCR CD 3000 + 48.6 96.2 Germany† [27] vivax: 13, P. ovale: 5, P. malariae: 2 ≥1 depolarizing events No- immune sensitivity: 28.6% Depolarizing purple events above Total: 831, P. falciparum: 334, P. Microscopy, HRP2 Scott , 2003, South CD 4000 channel 25 and within the side- vivax: 7, P. ovale: 1, P. malariae: 2, (Pf/Pv ICT), P-LDH + 80.2 87.3 Africa [35] scatter/depolarized side-scatter mixed or unspecified: 6 (OptiMAL), PCR ≥1 depolarizing events boundary shown in Figure 1 Suh, 2003, South Considered black or green coded Total: 168, P. vivax: 68 Microscopy CD 4000 - 91.2 100 Korea [32] ≥1 depolarizing events events Total: 799 (directed: suspected of QBC, PfHRP2 Directed Directed Depolarizing events above Dromigny, 2005, malaria 123, non-suspected random (MAKROmed), channel 50 and within the side- CD 3200 - 92.9 93.8 Senegal [30] samples 676) P. falciparum: 68, Microscopy, nested ≥1 depolarizing events Random Random scatter/depolarized side-scatter treated or subclinical: 83 PCR 90.2 96.7 boundary shown in Figure 1 Padial, 2005, Total: 411, P. falciparum: 35 , P. no exact definition of CD positive Equatorial Guinea Microscopy, PCR - 72 98 ovale: 3, mixed: 1 CD 4000 criterion given [41] Josephine, 2005, Total: 889, P. vivax: 12, P. malariae: Microscopy (peripheral no exact definition of CD positive - 100 100 Malaysia [40] 3, P. falciparum: 1 blood smear) CD 4000 criterion given de Langen, 2006, Microscopy , PfHRP2 CD 3700 no exact definition of CD positive Total: 208, P. falciparum: 90 - 93 97 Namibia [42] (Immuno-Mal) ≥1 depolarizing events criterion given CD 3000*** Hänscheid, 2008, Children, total: 368, P. falciparum: Specialized strategy for each type Microscopy ≥1 depolarizing purple - a) 96% a) 96% Gabon [34] 152 events of event*** Green-coded events b) 85% b) 96% Hänscheid, 2009, Pregnant patients, total 685, P. CD 3000 Microscopy - 86.8 78.5 Gabon [43] falciparum: 86 ≥1 depolarizing events Rathod, 2009, India Total: 523, P. falciparum :73, P. CD 3200 P. vivax :sensitivity: 63.0%, Microscopy - 62.2 25.3 [33] vivax: 62 ≥1 depolarizing events specificity:61.3% ¶Index diagnostic test: abnormal depolarizing events in the side-scatter/depolarized side-scatter plot. ‡All studies use the instrument’s diagonal separation line for eosinophils and neutrophils in the side-scatter/depolarized side-scatter plot , unless otherwise specified. *Microscopy for all studies corresponds to thick film evaluation except where otherwise specified. **CD: Cell-Dyn. IFAT: indirect fluorescence antibody test. QBC: Quantitative buffy coat. PCR: Polymerase chain reaction. ICT: immunochromatography. †Imported malaria. ***For purple events, these were considered positive if present above a line traced at 5 pixels from the x axis. For green events, a special gate was created to identify haemozoin-laden granulocytes, with the intention to exclude eosinophils. In accordance with studies using flow cytometric cell sorting [27], the largest possible gate to the left and above the usual location of the eosinophil population was created which did not contain any eosinophils [34]. For this, CBC analyses from children without malaria or pseudoreticulocytosis were used [34].</p>

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    3 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us