EXHIBIT LIST Reference No: HOL/00600 Petitioner: Robert Dixon and Mrs Sara Dixon Published to Collaboration Area: Tuesday 01-Nov-2016 Page 1 of 240 No Exhibit Name Page 1 A496_2nd Nov Slides for London Road Wendover HoL.pdf (A496) 2 - 25 2 A497_Combined petition asks and location in hearing.pdf (A497) 26 - 27 3 A498_CML witness p48 onwards.pdf (A498) 28 - 119 4 A516_HOC_ Sara Dixon and Others 873.pdf (A516) 120 - 160 5 A517_Transcript_HOC_17 Sept Thurs Morning.pdf (A517) 161 - 240 HOL/00600/0001 London Road, Wendover HP22 6PN Petitions numbered: 370 – Chisholm; 378 – Adam and others; 600 – Dixon; 822 - Ansell Sara Dixon Roll B agent A496 (1) HOL/00600/0002 Appendices/Evidence/How we’ve tried to save the court’s time in hearing… Overview of all 4 petition ‘asks’ and where they are in this presentation (attached) House of Commons transcript and slides from hearing on 17 September 2015 (attached) Assurance re Footway (HS2 doc) Assurance re Service Road (HS2 doc) Assurance re Viaduct Maintenance and Graffiti clearance (HS2 doc) 1st Special Report House of Commons December 2015 (extract included in these slides) Mortgage rejections (available if needed) 23rd November 2015 Council of Mortgage Lenders (attached) DfT Response to SC March 2016 (extract included in these slides) A496 (2) HOL/00600/0003 3 main ‘asks’: 1. Minimise problems of being a ‘cut off community’ 2. Minimise the environmental impact of (1) the construction route and ‘compounds’ and (2) the railway line 3. Make the compensation scheme fit for purpose for us Acknowledge: House of Commons Select Committee David Walker Clerk’s Office HS2 team Bucks County Council team A496 (3) HOL/00600/0004 About Us A496 (4) HOL/00600/0005 Our situation – geographic and human Wendover End – 285m from line Missenden • 3 - under 20; 2 - 40-50; end – 400m 8 – 50–60; 11 – 60-70; 14 – 70 + Garage side – excluding Vince and Mandy – 280m-300m range. • Self-employed; Retired; Volunteers Topographical impact… • Nurses, engineers, lawyers, consultants, builders, carpenters, Wendover End – 65m from Small Dean Launch teachers, charity workers, pub Satellite Compound landlords, football managers, metal Hawthorn – 325m Middle industry… ETC. Bottom Houses (4) – 310m from the Rocky Lane • 5 houses – 31-50 years Compound About Us A496 (5) HOL/00600/0006 About Us A496 (6) HOL/00600/0007 ‘Construction site’ A496 (7)About Us HOL/00600/0008 Views post construction 8 A496 (8)About Us HOL/00600/0009 A: Cut off community A496 (9) HOL/00600/0010 Time North To North To South To South To Wendover all Wendover Missenden all Missenden 13th August – brown vehicles excluding Emergency vehicles excluding Emergency Emergency vehicles vehicles Emergency vehicles vehicles 16,979 in total 1,415/hour 7.00 to 8.00 525/655 - - 1265/1532 - 1 24/minute 1 every 4 seconds 8.00 to 9.00 666/788 - 3 1155/1287 1/1 th 9.00 to 10.00 8 September - blue - 566/637 - - 744/890 - - 18,796 1,565/hour 26/minute 10.00 to 11.00 467/455 1/2 538/492 - - 1 every 2.30 seconds 11.00 to 12.00 506/532 -/2 535/534 - 1 12.00 to 1.00 589/512 3/3 527/477 3/2 HS2 predictions - green – 20,447 Add Rocky Lane combined 1.00 to 2.00 586/560 1/2 523/511 2/1 north and south (1271 in 2.00 to 3.00 582/540 1/- 579/700 1/2 and out of lane, assuming 3.00 to 4.00 678/774 -/2 478/626 - 2 not included by HS2 in A413 figures) 4.00 to 5.00 1003/1038 3/1 716/690 2/1 5.00 to 6.00 1340/1395 3/4 750/849 4/2 21,718 – predicted 6.00 to 7.00 1048/1203 1/1 582/616 5/2 growth of just over Total 8556/9080 13/20 8392/9671 18/15 1000 over 6 years. HS2 2021 10,252 predictions 10,195 without haulage Cut off 10 A496community (10) HOL/00600/0011 Histograms: Please put up: P8144(1) P8144 (2) P8144 (3) Cut off community A496 (11) HOL/00600/0012 How frequently we cross the road Severa Severa Once a Every Every Less Activity l times Daily l times week two three Monthly often a day a week weeks weeks To visit neighbours 1 11111 1 111 1111 11 To use the bus service 1 1 111111 111111 To visit the garage for 1111111111 11 1 1 newspapers 1 To visit the garage for fuel 11111 11111 111 1 11 1 To visit the garage to shop 11111 1 1 11 11111 11 To use the postbox 11 11 111 111 In a car to travel to other 11111111111 1111 1 destinations 111 Cut off community A496 (12) HOL/00600/0013 Rocky Lane/Dunsmore Lane End 13 A496 (13)Cut off community HOL/00600/0014 As things are… Cut off community A496 (14) HOL/00600/0015 A496 Cut(15) off community HOL/00600/0016 We have…. We would like… Assurance – footway Accessibility measures as part of HS2 plan – e.g. route diversion Assessment – cut off/severed From both sides – notices/traffic controls/pedestrian safety warnings To the road – pedestrian safety areas Cut off community A496 (16) HOL/00600/0017 B: Environmental factors A496 (17) HOL/00600/0018 ‘Nuisances’ – it’s about trust and communication Construction Operation Dust Noise Noise Light Light Vibration Vibration Visual – viaduct/embankment Visual (Assurance for viaduct) Environmental Factors A496 (18) HOL/00600/0019 C: Compensation A496 (19) HOL/00600/0020 Compensation Schemes Due to the road – construction focus Currently: -Code of Construction Practice Safeguarded – 1 in part -Right to litigate for general Express purchase – none nuisances Rural Support Zone (Cash/VP)Voluntary CP – none Homeowner Payment – 3 or 4? Due to the line – operation focus -LCA NTS: 1 (HofC supported); 5 more -Right to litigate for general nuisances Mortgage/security rejections – 2015 1 house (10); 1 house (H of C supported) - numerous; 2016 1 house (1) Compensation Scheme A496 (20)Compensation HOL/00600/0021 We would like: Basics of compensation Using our equity To be measured for compensation Underwrite/guarantee for those from the real nuisance – the seeking a charge road/the construction route and the various sites Or forced to seek NTS… unintended consequences? Reflecting actual loss not arbitrary focus Compensation A496 (21) HOL/00600/0022 CML so far? “Although some conversations have taken place between the Council and its members, and the CML Valuation Panel has confirmed that there is no blanket policy of refusing lending in cases of blight, we were disappointed not to have had more open and effective cooperation on this. We welcome the discussions that have taken place between the Council and HS2 to share information. We welcome too the Council’s recommendation to its members to review their policies. We hope that more will be forthcoming.” The Promoter is committed to working with Council of Mortgage Lenders and its members on a long term basis to better share information on order to help minimise cases of lending refusals.’ HS2 Ltd say that they continue their dialogue with the CML and with individual mortgage providers and are looking to work collaboratively with them to ensure that decisions in respect of individual properties are made with the benefit of all the available information so as to minimise the instances of lending refusals. A496 (22) HOL/00600/0023 NTS • Remove ‘compelling reason’ • To have our unique situation acknowledged and declared a • OR… While we recognise that the special case for Express Purchase scheme should not incentivise flight from an area, exposure to particularly intensive and prolonged construction may well provide another valid reason to want to move, or for there to be alternative alleviation. Compensation A496 (23) HOL/00600/0024 In summary: Help us continue as a community – part of Help us seek the reasonable compensation Wendover but also part of our little to which we believe we should be entitled community. Don’t cut us off either along or - Draw the right to compensation from the across. road as well as the line - Accessibility - Remove the ‘need’ to be proven for us – - Safety construction zone should be enough…. - Underwrite any need for security to be Help us live our daily lives safe from given over our homes construction and operational harm - Special case for Express Purchase because - Environmental factors of all our issues - Trust and communication – make us a Key Stakeholder where possible in Focus Groups/Consultation/Communication with contractors A496 (24) HOL/00600/0025 Petitions: 370 Chisholm; 378 Adam and others; 600 Dixon; 822 Ansell Hearing categories: (A) Cut off community (B) Environmental factors (C) Compensation issues 370 Chisholm – all petition ‘asks’ are for a fully bored tunnel. Focusing therefore on issues: Property blight - C: compensation Dust pollution – B: Environmental factors/Support Parish Council? Noise Nuisance and vibration – Support The Wendover Society Access to and from property – A: Cut off community No personal benefits – not a focus for hearing Disruption of power supply – Support Parish Council? Management of Water System – Support Parish Council? AONB – not a focus for the hearing Wildlife sustainability and conservation – Support Bucks County Council 378/822 – Adam and others; Ansell (the petitions are the same as each other) Construction traffic working hours limitation – accept already catered for but Assurance re key stakeholder request as part of B: Environmental Limit number of construction vehicles – accept re already catered for but Assurance re key stakeholder request as part of B: Environmental Arisings by rail not road – accept already catered for but Assurance re key stakeholder request as part of B: Environmental Traffic Management Plan – accept already catered for so not a focus.