,'g4I ut {<^-,lt^.iD (,/"' -:-{*Q, - .GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAL OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER JALPAIGURI DIVISION JALPAIGURI tRbecember, 2011 Memo No' 3 61 I nstn" Dated JalPaiguri, the o i D'-- From : Commissioner Jalpaiguri Division Jalpaiguri. ml t.fi^'' To The Assistant Secretary & S.P'l'O., Chief Minister's Office, Writers' Buildings, Kolkata - 700 001. :Netaji RTI Act., 2005 by Shri Partha: Sarkar of *uo, : lnformation sought for under Nagar, P.S. Jadavpur, Kolkata- 700 092. 16lOEl2O11- Ref : Your No. 1009-CMO dated Sir, s.D.o., Balurghat has issued a scheduled caste (Jalia Kaibarta) Certificate to Smt. Alpana Das on 07lOBt1997(Copy enclosed)' Z) I have seenn thefhe petitionsnetitions arand documentary e'vidence submitted by Shri Partha Sarkar, the comPlainant. * 3) The points in favour of Smt. Alpana Das are a) lt has been issued by s.D.o., Balurghat on 07/0811997 (Copy enclosed)' b) His brother Shri Nishith Ranjan Das has also got Scheduled Caste Certificate from S.D.O., Balurghat on the same date' c) she got appoir*ment as G.D."P.O. out of scheduled caste quota in 2002 and her brother has also been appointed as a primary school teacher in Balurghat out of scheduled caste quota. She is working as cDPO, Kumarganj' Dist" Dakshin Dinajpur, Balurghat. \7 I issued Scheduled Caste Nirod Ran'ian Das was also Her father' Shri *l d) ,:.{ on 25103/1969 (Copy enclosed). lertificate by A D M ' Balurghat iib field inquiry and has taken has recenily caused a .18 S.D.O., Balurghat has been e) to Scheduled Caste' lt \' persons that she belongs (r declaration from a few l enclosed)' I D M'' Balurghat' (Copy l forwarded to me by Y\r D ,!B Das are - ffi favour of Smt' Alpana 4) The points not in 'a $ i has mentioned that I and he Complainant is her husband a) Shri Partha Sarkar' hebelongsto'Mahishya'communitywhichfallsundergeneralcategory'Hehasabout her Das after necessary inquiry married to Smt Alpana further stated that he :l] vital evidence' general caste' This is a Hence' the ,l is not available' of S'D'O," t1"t:n:loffice b) Case records of 1997 is not ascertained' Scheduled Caste Certiflcate basis of issuance of CounterfileofA.D.M.,Balurghatcertificateinfavouro{hisfatheralsocouldis not of issuance of the certificate the authenticity and basis not be found. Hence, ascertained' So Z6E dated 14tO112011 and Memo ':ateO c) 2 letters' Memo No 57 04/03/2011(copyenclosed)ofAssistantDirectorofAgriculture(Admn),Raiganjin his of Scheduled Caste category that there is no marking wherein it is mentioned ServiceBookorinhispromotionalorders.!amalsoenclosinggradationlistinwhich hehasnotbeenmentionedasScheduledCastewhileSC/STismentionedagainsi manyothernames'Thoughhisfather'sS'C'Certificateisaproofbutashedidnot mentionitinhisservicetenureoTto2tlg66to3l/01/2006hencethiscertificatemay uPon' not ne conclusivelY relied Dakra' P S Balurghat from was first settled at village d) Her father and it is one Das famlly was there came out because only Bangladesh' Nothing they.TheyShifiedtoHazipuraroundlgT4whichis2/3k.m.fromBalurghaitown.onfound that to S C lt has been also that they did not belong secret inquiry' it revealed ti il rll L)I noneofthemhasseenthemadopting/adoptedthecustomof.JaliaKaibarta' :I "4 communitY i.e' fi sherman' # 5)Therefore,thereremainssomedoubtaboutthecastestaiusofSmt.AlpanaDas.ln p& deals this facts, it wiil be appropriate if the s.D.o., Balurghat (r view of the above stated I matteraspersectiongofWBs.c.&S.T.(ldentification)Act.,1994andRule3ofWBS.C. \r',it the certificate is confirmed or cancelled l /) & s.T. (ldentification) Rule, 1995 so that either hrc *?s accordingly' S-D.O., Balurghat to proceed ylEs am advising lt' Yours faithfullY, t : Commissioner, Jalpaiguri Division I ! Encls : As stated. 12.t2.2all t $ € i 1 { i, ii i i! :l:i lt J l .t ,1 l l il.