Deliverable Title: D2.2 - Report on R&I ecosystem mapping of the territories from a comparative perspective Work Package: WP2 – Active mapping of SeeRRI territorial R&I ecosystems and the inclusion of RRI Lead beneficiary: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology GmbH Date: 31.08.2019 Nature: Report | Diss. level: PU (Public) D2.2 - Report on R&I ecosystem mapping of the territories from a comparative perspective Security: PU (Public) // Author: AIT // Version: Final TABLE OF CONTENTS DOCUMENT INFORMATION .................................................................................................................................. 6 DOCUMENT HISTORY ............................................................................................................................................ 7 DEFINITIONS & ACRONYMS ................................................................................................................................. 8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................................... 9 1. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................................12 2. CONCEPTUAL AND METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH ............................................................................14 3. DATA DESCRIPTION ...................................................................................................................................17 3.1 GLOBAL R&I DATA SETS.....................................................................................................................17 3.2 TERRITORY-SPECIFIC DATA SETS ...................................................................................................19 4. MAPPING OF THE SEERRI R&I ECOSYSTEMS ........................................................................................21 4.1 NORDLAND ..........................................................................................................................................21 4.2 LOWER AUSTRIA .................................................................................................................................40 4.3 B30 ........................................................................................................................................................61 4.4 COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE ON KEY FINDINGS .........................................................................................84 5. OUTLOOK .....................................................................................................................................................87 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................................................88 ANNEXES ..............................................................................................................................................................89 ............................................................................................................................................................................89 ANNEX I – NETWORK OF AFFILIATED TERRITORIES (NAT) ..........................................................................90 AI.1 HAIFA ......................................................................................................................................................90 AI.2 OSTROBOTHNIA .......................................................................................................................................95 AI.3 MONTENEGRO .......................................................................................................................................100 ANNEX II – GENERAL ADDITIONAL INFORMATION .......................................................................................103 ANNEX III – ADDITIONAL AND UNDERLYING INFORMATION OF THE THREE TERRITORIES ..................105 NORDLAND ..........................................................................................................................................................105 LOWER AUSTRIA ...................................................................................................................................................116 B30 ...................................................................................................................................................................129 This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement nº 824588. 2 D2.2 - Report on R&I ecosystem mapping of the territories from a comparative perspective Security: PU (Public) // Author: AIT // Version: Final TABLE OF FIGURES – Main part FIGURE 1. SECTORAL DISTRIBUTION OF PATENTS.................................................................................................................................. 23 FIGURE 2. DISTRIBUTION OF PUBLICATIONS ACROSS SCIENCE DISCIPLINES ................................................................................................. 24 FIGURE 3. COOCCURRENCE NETWORK OF SCIENCE CATEGORIES IN PUBLICATIONS ........................................................................................ 25 FIGURE 4. SECTORAL SPECIALIZATION AND GROWTH ............................................................................................................................. 26 FIGURE 5. NATIONAL PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS .......................................................................................... 31 FIGURE 6. EUROPEAN PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS ......................................................................................... 32 FIGURE 7. ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES & ECOLOGY WITH COOCCURRING SCIENCE CATEGORIES ...................................................................... 34 FIGURE 8. 3D SCIENCE MAP OF PUBLICATIONS IN RESEARCH FIELDS .......................................................................................................... 35 FIGURE 9. CO-WORD MAP OF MANUALLY ASSIGNED KEYWORDS TO PROJECTS ............................................................................................ 38 FIGURE 10. SECTORAL DISTRIBUTION OF PATENTS ................................................................................................................................ 42 FIGURE 11. DISTRIBUTION OF PUBLICATIONS ACROSS SCIENCE DISCIPLINES ............................................................................................... 43 FIGURE 12. COOCCURRENCE NETWORK OF SCIENCE CATEGORIES IN PUBLICATIONS ...................................................................................... 44 FIGURE 13. SECTORAL SPECIALIZATION AND GROWTH ........................................................................................................................... 45 FIGURE 14. NATIONAL PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS ........................................................................................ 50 FIGURE 15. EUROPEAN PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS ....................................................................................... 51 FIGURE 16. DISCIPLINES OF PUBLICATIONS WITH RELEVANCE FOR 3D PRINTING AND ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING .............................................. 54 FIGURE 17. 3D SCIENCE MAP OF PUBLICATIONS IN RESEARCH FIELDS ........................................................................................................ 55 FIGURE 18. CO-WORD MAP OF MANUALLY ASSIGNED KEYWORDS TO PROJECTS .......................................................................................... 58 FIGURE 19. SECTORAL DISTRIBUTION OF PATENTS ................................................................................................................................ 63 FIGURE 20. DISTRIBUTION OF PUBLICATIONS ACROSS SCIENCE DISCIPLINES ............................................................................................... 64 FIGURE 21. COOCCURRENCE NETWORK OF SCIENCE CATEGORIES IN PUBLICATIONS ...................................................................................... 65 FIGURE 22. SECTORAL SPECIALIZATION AND GROWTH ........................................................................................................................... 66 FIGURE 23. NATIONAL PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS ........................................................................................ 71 FIGURE 24. EUROPEAN PROJECT COLLABORATIONS OF TERRITORIES’ R&I ACTORS ....................................................................................... 72 FIGURE 25. 3D SCIENCE MAP OF PUBLICATIONS IN RESEARCH FIELDS ........................................................................................................ 76 FIGURE 26. IDENTIFIED SEARCH KEYWORDS FOR “ZERO WASTE” IN THE CO-WORD MAP ................................................................................ 79 FIGURE 27. CONTENT BASED AGGLOMERATION OF PROJECTS ................................................................................................................. 80 TABLE OF FIGURES - Appendices FIGURE AI 1. SECTORAL DISTRIBUTION OF PATENTS .............................................................................................................................. 91 FIGURE AI 2. CORE NETWORK OF NATIONAL PROJECT COLLABORATIONS