TUM-HEP-1169/18 Axion Stars Eric Braaten Department of Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA Hong Zhang Physik Department T31, Technische Universit¨atM¨unchen, D-85748 Garching, Germany (Dated: October 30, 2018) The particle that makes up the dark matter of the universe could be an axion or axion- like particle. A collection of axions can condense into a bound Bose-Einstein condensate called an axion star. It is possible that a significant fraction of the axion dark matter is in the form of axion stars. This would make some efforts to identify the axion as the dark matter particle more challenging, but it would also open up new possibilities. We summarize the basic properties of isolated axion stars, which can be gravitationally bound or bound by self-interactions. Axions are naturally described by a relativistic field theory with a real scalar field, but low-energy axions can be described more simply by a classical nonrelativistic effective field theory with a complex scalar field. CONTENTS D. Higher Harmonics 20 E. Rotating Axion Stars 20 I. INTRODUCTION 1 VIII. Acknowledgments 20 II. AXION FIELD THEORY 2 A. Fundamental Theory 2 References 20 B. Real Scalar Field Theory 3 C. Axion Potential 3 D. Coupling to Photons 4 E. General Relativity 4 I. INTRODUCTION III. AXION DARK MATTER 5 A. Production in the Early Universe 5 The QCD axion is one of the best motivated candidates B. Axion Miniclusters 6 for the particle that makes up the dark matter of the uni- C. Thermalization 7 verse, because its existence would reveal the solution to IV. NONRELATIVISTIC EFFECTIVE FIELD THEORY 7 the strong CP problem of QCD. (For a recent review, see A. Complex Field 7 Ref. (Kim and Carosi, 2010).) The QCD axion is a spin-0 B. Effective Lagrangian 8 particle with very small mass and extremely weak self- C. Effective Potential 9 arXiv:1810.11473v1 [hep-ph] 26 Oct 2018 interactions as well as extremely weak interactions with D. Axion Loss Terms 10 E. Newtonian Gravity 10 Standard Model particles. One might therefore expect the physics of axion dark matter to be relatively simple. V. SELF-BOUND SYSTEMS 11 The reason axion dark matter is not so simple is that A. Self-bound Fluids 11 B. Oscillons 12 axions are identical bosons, and the axion states in dark C. Axitons 13 matter may have extremely high occupation numbers. The axions can therefore form a Bose-Einstein conden- VI. GRAVITATIONALLY BOUND SYSTEMS 14 sate (BEC), whose collective behavior can be quite differ- A. Boson Stars 14 B. Dilute Axion Stars 15 ent from an ideal gas of bosons. The axion BEC can form C. Dense Axion Stars 16 gravitationally bound configurations called axion stars, and it can also form self-bound configurations called axi- VII. THEORETICAL ISSUES 17 tons. If a significant fraction of the axion dark matter is A. Emission of Relativistic Axions from Axion Stars 18 B. Collapse of Dilute Axion Star 18 in such bound configurations, it could dramatically affect C. Relativistic Corrections 19 experimental searches for axion dark matter. 2 We present a review of bound configurations of the 1978). The explicit breaking of the U(1) symmetry from axion BEC. Axion stars and axitons could be observed the chiral anomaly of QCD implies that the axion is a through their interactions with other astronomical ob- pseudo-Goldstone boson with nonzero mass ma. jects, such as neutron stars. However we focus in this review on the simpler problem of isolated axion stars. The fundamental quantum field theory for the axion Understanding their properties is a prerequisite for un- is a renormalizable extension of the Standard Model in derstanding some aspects of their interactions with other which the Peccei-Quinn symmetry is spontaneously bro- objects. ken by the ground state of a complex Lorentz-scalar field. There are strong constraints on the most important pa- The minima of its potential form a circle whose radius rameters that describe the QCD axion (Kim and Carosi, fa is called the axion decay constant. At momentum 2010). The window for the axion mass has been reduced scales of order fa, the axion field can be identified with to within one or two orders of magnitude of 10−4 eV. It the Goldstone mode corresponding to excitations of the should therefore be possible to understand the behavior scalar field along that circle. of QCD axion dark matter in enough detail to definitively At momentum scales much smaller than fa, the axion confirm its existence or rule it out. Understanding bound can be described by an elementary real Lorentz-scalar configurations of the axion BEC may be essential for this field φ(x) with a shift symmetry: the fields φ(x) and effort. φ(x) + 2πfa represent the same physical configuration. Axion can refer more generally to any light spin-0 par- The axion field has couplings to gauge fields that are de- ticle with a periodic self-interaction potential. There are termined by the anomaly, and it has derivative couplings motivations from string theory for a large number of ax- to the other fields of the Standard Model. At momentum ions with masses ranging over tens of orders of magni- scales below the weak scale, which is about 100 GeV, the tude, a possibility referred to as the axiverse (Arvanitaki terms in the effective Lagrangian that couple the axion et al., 2010). There are also astrophysical motivations for to the Standard Model fields reduce to a dark-matter particle that is an extremely light boson with mass of roughly 10−22 eV (Hui et al., 2017). We fo- cus in this review on the QCD axion, but we present our αs a ~aµν cγ0α ~µν 1 µ φ Gµν G + φ Fµν F + J @µφ, (1) results whenever possible in a form that can be applied 8πfa 8πfa 2fa to other axion-like particles. We begin the review by describing the relativistic quantum field theory for the real scalar field of the axion. a where Gµν and Fµν are the field strengths for QCD and We summarize some basic features of the evolution of ax- ~a 1 aλσ ~ QED, Gµν = 2 µνλσG and Fµν are the correspond- ion dark matter in the early universe. We then describe a ing dual field strengths, and J µ is a linear combination nonrelativistic effective field theory with a complex scalar of axial-vector quark currents that depends on the axion field that provides a simpler description of the nonrela- µν model. The coefficient cγ0 in the Fµν F~ term in Eq. (1) tivistic axions that make up dark matter. We discuss is also model dependent. The QCD field-strength term bound configurations of the axion BEC, first axitons and in Eq. (1) is proportional to the topological charge den- then axion stars. We conclude the review by discussing a ~aµν sity αsGµν G =8π. The quantization of the QCD topo- some theoretical issues involving isolated axion stars. logical charge in the Euclidean field theory guarantees consistency with the shift symmetry of φ. II. AXION FIELD THEORY In the original axion model of Peccei and Quinn, the axion decay constant fa was chosen comparable to the At momentum scales below the axion decay constant vacuum expectation value of the Higgs field, which is fa, the axion can be described by a real Lorentz-scalar about 250 GeV. This model was quickly ruled out by field in a relativistic quantum field theory. the nonobservation of the axion particle in high energy physics experiments. Models with an \invisible axion" that are not easily ruled out by high energy physics ex- A. Fundamental Theory periments were subsequently constructed, including the KSVZ model (Kim, 1979; Shifman et al., 1980) and the The most compelling solution of the strong CP prob- DFSZ model (Dine et al., 1981; Zhitnitsky, 1980). As- lem of QCD is the Peccei-Quinn mechanism, which in- trophysical constraints from the cooling of stars by the volves an anomalous U(1) symmetry of a quantum field emission of axions provide a lower bound on the axion 9 theory for physics beyond the Standard Model (Peccei decay constant: fa & 3 × 10 GeV. The cosmological and Quinn, 1977). The spontaneous breaking of the constraint that the production of axions in the early uni- Peccei-Quinn U(1) symmetry implies the existence of a verse does not overclose the universe provides a loose 12 spin-0 particle called the axion (Weinberg, 1978; Wilczek, upper bound: fa . 10 GeV. 3 B. Real Scalar Field Theory The simplest periodic spherically symmetric solutions φ(r; t) can be expanded as an odd cosine series in the At momentum scales below the confinement scale of time t: QCD, which is about 1 GeV, the self-interactions of ax- 1 X ions from their couplings to the gluon field in Eq. (1) can φ(r; t) = φ2n+1(r) cos (2n + 1)!t : (8) be described by a potential V (φ). The Lagrangian for n=0 the axion field has the form Eq. (7) reduces to an infinite set of coupled equations 1 µ for the harmonics φ2n+1(r). If the field φ(r; t) always L = 2 @µφ∂ φ − V (φ): (2) remains sufficiently small compared to fa, it can be ap- proximated by the first term in the cosine expansion: The invariance of the Lagrangian under the shift sym- metry φ(x) ! φ(x) + 2πfa requires the axion potential φ(r; t) ≈ φ1(r) cos(!t): (9) V (φ) to be a periodic function of φ: The harmonic approximation is obtained by inserting this V (φ) = V (φ + 2πfa): (3) expression into Eq.