TRANSFORMATIVE LEARNING: BECOMING AWARE OF POSSIBLE WORLDS By JANE ANNE TAYLOR B.A., The University of Manitoba, 1965 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES Department of Administrative, Adult and Higher Education We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA February 1988 (r?)Jane Anne Taylor, 1989 In presenting this thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements for an advanced degree at the University of British Columbia, I agree that the Library shall make it freely available for reference and study. I further agree that permission for extensive copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the head of my department or by his or her representatives. It is understood that copying or publication of this thesis for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. Department of The University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada DE-6 (2/88) ABSTRACT Human learning is a complex multidimensional phenomenon many aspects of which continue to elude understanding and explanation. One facet of the learning puzzle that has not been adequately explored is the role that individual consciousness plays in human learning. Adult education has been instrumental in shifting the focus in studies of learning from an emphasis on the material to be learned to an emphasis on the experience of the individual in the learning transaction. This shift in focus has brought more attention to the processes of individual consciousness as a critical factor in the learning process. In adult education a sense of urgency about the importance of broadening the concept of learning, and a growing awareness of the importance of consciousness, and changes or transformations in consciousness as aspects of a more comprehensive concept of learning, are beginning to merge. The course of human history and culture speaks eloquently of the transformative powers of the human mind to amplify and extend knowledge by transcending what is already known. While current learning literature stresses learning as the process of facilitating changes in behaviour or the acquisition, organization, retention and retrieval of knowledge, little attention has been given to learning as a process of creative transformation of knowledge. This study arose out of a desire i i to explore the ramifications of transformations within the consciousness of the individual as a major aspect of learning, and to integrate literature on this topic as a means of extending understanding of learning as a transformative process. The study began with explorations in two directions stimulated and directed by the qualitative method of constant comparative analysis. One was the development of the case study of Sara which supplied a slice of experiential data. Sara's case illustrates learning experiences from a personal point of view which emphasizes changes in consciousness as a central dynamic of those experiences. The second direction for exploration was a search of the literature for sources which might account for this type of learning. An analysis and integration of the writings of selected authors supplied the foundation for the development of a model of transformative learning. Finally, this model was applied to Sara's case as a means of clarifying her personal learning experience and illustrating the usefulness of the model as a tool for understanding learning as a process of creative transformation of consciousness. TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract ii Table of Contents iv List of Figures viii Acknowledgements ix I. Background to the study 1 A. Introduction 1 B. Statement of the problem 8 C. Purpose of the study 10 D. Definitions 12 E. Methodology 13 1 . Introduction 13 2. Adaption of constant comparative method 14 3. Application of constant comparative method ....16 F. Research questions 21 G. Significance of the study 22 II. An individual's perception of her own learning experience: The case history of Sara 25 A. Introduction , 25 B. Background to the case study 25 C. Sara's account of her personal learning experience 27 1. Introduction 27 2. The first course 28 3. The second course 38 4. The third course 43 5. Conclusion 47 D. Notes on Sara's case in relation to the concept of transformative learning 48 III. Literature review ..51 A. Introduction 51 B. Bruner: Contextual background for an understanding of transformative learning 54 1. Introduction 54 2. Mind and consciousness 56 3. Modes of thought 58 4. Human development 61 5. Changing conception of learning ..62 6. The transactional self 65 7. Powers of language 69 8. Culture 73 9. The influence of Vygotsky and Goodman 76 a. Vygotsky 76 b. Goodman 81 10. Mind, consciousness and world-making ....83 iv 11. Developmental theory as culture 88 12. Conclusion 91 C. Freire: Conscientization 91 1 . Introduction 91 2. Philosophical assumptions 92 3. Education and consciousness 98 4. Levels of consciousness 99 5. Consciousness and learning 102 6. Conclusion 105 D. Kelly: Personal construct theory 106 1. Introduction 106 2. The role of learning, transformation, consciousness and changes in consciousness 107 3. Constructive alternativsm 111 4. A summary of the theory of personal constructs 113 5. Constructs and construct systems 118 6. Determinism and freedom 121 7. Reconstruction, transformation, learning and experience 122 8. Facilitating reconstruction 124 9. Conditions favorable to the formation of new constructs .....127 10. Conditions unfavorable to formation of new constructs 130 11. Barriers to reconstruction 132 1 2 . Conclusion 137 E. Mezirow: Perspective transformation 137 1. Introduction 137 2. Meaning schemes and perspectives in relation to human development 138 3. Learning domains and learning processes 140 a. Learning domains 140 b. Learning processes 142 4. Meaning schemes and meaning perspectives: Definition and development 143 a. Definition 143 b. Development 144 5. Critical reflectivity 147 6. Perspective transformation 150 7. Perspective transformation and adult development 152 8. The dynamics of perspective transformation 154 9. Inhibiting and facilitating factors in perspective transformation 157 a. Influential factors ..157 b. The educator's role 159 10. Current approach to learning 160 1 1 . Conclusion 163 F. Nichol: Paradigm-Transition Learning 165 v 1. Introduction 165 2. Knowledge development and learning: Revolutionary processes 166 3. Paradigm-transition learning 168 4. Personal development and paradigm-transition 176 5. Tracing some implications of paradigm-transition learning 178 6. Conclusion .182 G. Conclusion of literature review 183 IV. Integration of literature .....185 A. Introduction 185 B. Common or compatible elements 185 1 . Characteristics and functions of consciousness 186 2. The nature of reality 189 3. Transformative learning (Learning involving changes in consciousness) 191 C. The Proposal of a model of transformative learning: Developing and extending the concept of transformative learning 195 1. A model of transformative learning 195 a. Phase one: Generation of consciousness 196 b. Phase two: Transformation of consciousness 201 c. Phase three: Integration of consciousness 203 2. Contributing elements 206 a. Facilitating factors 206 b. The power of reflectivity 208 c. Possible results or end-products 212 D. The roots of the transformative learning model 215 1. The roots of the generation phase 216 2. The roots of the transformation phase 218 3. The roots of the integration phase 220 4. The roots of facilitating factors 221 E. Conclusion 223 V. Findings and conclusions: Revisiting Sara's case 225 A. Introduction 225 B. Phase one: Generation of consciousness 226 1. Encountering trigger events 227 2. Confronting reality 230 C. Phase two: Transformation of consciousness 240 1. Reaching the transition point 241 2. Leap or shift of transcendence 243 D. Phase three: Integration of consciousness 245 1. Personal Commitment 247 2. Grounding and Development 248 E. Conclusion 250 vi References 253 Appendix A: Analysis of selected authors 257 Appendix B: A profile of the basic process of transformative learning 287 vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Essential elements of transformative learning ...197 Figure 2: Model of transformative learning 217 Figure 3: Background of selected authors 259 viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express my appreciation to all of the people who supported, challenged and encouraged me in the creation of this thesis. All of my colleagues, friends and family have my heartfelt thanks for their patience as I struggled with the rigors of this exercise. I acknowledge especially Dr. Dan Pratt, my advisor, who had enough faith in me to allow me freedom to follow my own path, and who helped me find my way when the going got rough. Louise Shores and Leah Seaman spent long evenings in stimulating conversation with me, particularly in the beginning phases of the work. I have been sustained by the warmth of many friends who have understood and made allowances for my relative isolation during the writing process. Special thanks and hugs go to all of my family, only a few of which I can acknowledge specifically here, for their enduring love, support and faith in me. My grandfather, Robert Franklin, taught me about joy and looking beyond things that are immediately apparent. My mother, Jane Manshreck, instilled in me a deep love of learning and positive enthusiasm about life. My daughters, Lydia and Jillian, warmed and inspired me with their bright energy, wisdom and love. My husband, Mitch, has taught me much of what I know about the potential and power of transformative learning and continues to teach me in love. To all of these special people I dedicate this thesis. ix TRANSFORMATIVE LEARNING: BECOMING AWARE OF POSSIBLE WORLDS I. BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY A. INTRODUCTION The learning society is growing because it must...the world changes faster than the generations, and individuals must live in several different worlds during their lifetimes (Cross, 1980, p.1). In our world human affairs are beset by rapidly accelerating social change and complexity which are ranging far beyond our individual and social capacity to cope (Toffler,1979).