Shillito L-M, Blong J, Jenkins D, Stafford TW, Whelton H, McDonough K, Bull I. New Research at Paisley Caves: Applying New Integrated Analytical Approaches to Understanding Stratigraphy, Taphonomy and Site Formation Processes. PaleoAmerica 2018 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/20555563.2017.1396167 Copyright: © 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited DOI link to article: https://doi.org/10.1080/20555563.2017.1396167 Date deposited: 23/10/2017 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Newcastle University ePrints - eprint.ncl.ac.uk PaleoAmerica A journal of early human migration and dispersal ISSN: 2055-5563 (Print) 2055-5571 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/ypal20 New Research at Paisley Caves: Applying New Integrated Analytical Approaches to Understanding Stratigraphy, Taphonomy and Site Formation Processes Lisa-Marie Shillito, John C. Blong, Dennis L. Jenkins, Thomas W. Stafford Jr, Helen Whelton, Katelyn McDonough & Ian D. Bull To cite this article: Lisa-Marie Shillito, John C. Blong, Dennis L. Jenkins, Thomas W. Stafford Jr, Helen Whelton, Katelyn McDonough & Ian D. Bull (2018): New Research at Paisley Caves: Applying New Integrated Analytical Approaches to Understanding Stratigraphy, Taphonomy and Site Formation Processes, PaleoAmerica, DOI: 10.1080/20555563.2017.1396167 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/20555563.2017.1396167 © 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group Published online: 09 Jan 2018. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 88 View related articles View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=ypal20 Download by: [Newcastle University] Date: 12 January 2018, At: 00:50 PALEOAMERICA, 2018 Center for the Study of the First Americans https://doi.org/10.1080/20555563.2017.1396167 Texas A&M University RESEARCH BRIEF New Research at Paisley Caves: Applying New Integrated Analytical Approaches to Understanding Stratigraphy, Taphonomy and Site Formation Processes Lisa-Marie Shillito a, John C. Blong a, Dennis L. Jenkinsb, Thomas W. Stafford Jrc, Helen Wheltond, Katelyn McDonough e, and Ian D. Bulld aSchool of History, Classics and Archaeology, Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK; bMuseum of Natural and Cultural History, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR, USA; cStafford Research, Denver, CO, USA; dOrganic Geochemistry Unit, School of Chemistry, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK; eDepartment of Anthropology, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA ABSTRACT KEYWORDS Paisley Caves in Oregon has become well known due to early dates, and human presence in the Micromorphology; form of coprolites, found to contain ancient human DNA. Questions remain over whether the biomarkers; Paisley Caves; coprolites themselves are human, or whether the DNA is mobile in the sediments. This brief Great Basin introduces new research applying an integrated analytical approach combining sediment micromorphology and lipid biomarker analysis, which aims to resolve these problems. The Five Mile Point Paisley Caves are located in south- methods are not a reliable way of identifying the species central Oregon in the northern Great Basin (Jenkins of coprolites; prehistoric coprolites from Turkey, ident- 2007). Research conducted there provides the earliest ified as animal on the basis of inclusions (i.e., bone frag- well-accepted evidence for human settlement of the ments and plant tissues), in fact contained distributions Great Basin, including culturally modified bone, lithic of sterols and bile acids indicative of a human source tools, and human coprolites recovered in association (Shillito et al. 2011). with Pleistocene large mammal remains. Radiocarbon In our ongoing study, we are using sterols and bile analysis of the coprolites indicates humans occupied acids (lipids) as a species indicator, as the sterol profile the cave as early as 14,300 cal yr BP (Gilbert et al. varies according to whether an organism has a meat- 2008; Hockett and Jenkins 2013; Jenkins 2007), with per- dominant, omnivorous, or herbivorous diet, whilst the iodic occupation from 14,300 cal yr BP through the his- bile acid profile is distinct to particular species. toric period (Jenkins 2007; Jenkins et al. 2012, 2013). Human coprolites are distinguished by the presence of The earliest date was obtained from a coprolite dated lithocholic acid and deoxycholic acid, with a dominance between 14,170 to 14,340 cal yr BP, which was found to of the former (Bull et al. 2002). Sistiaga et al. (2014) contain ancient human DNA (Gilbert et al. 2008); how- analyzed one coprolite from Paisley Caves and argued ever, questions have been raised over the aDNA recovery that the sterol profile was consistent with an animal ori- Downloaded by [Newcastle University] at 00:50 12 January 2018 and stratigraphic integrity (Poinar et al. 2009). It has also gin, but their analysis neglected to make a parallel been argued that microscopically, the coprolites analysis of bile acids, which are necessary for separating resembled animal rather than human feces (Goldberg, humans from other omnivores and herbivores. Their Berna, and Macphail 2009). The latter was based on conclusion also does not take into account the fact comparison of the Paisley coprolites with those of Viking that meat may have been a minor or seasonally variable humans and modern camels. With a subject that attracts dietary component of early populations. Moreover, great academic and public interest, it is important that results from a single coprolite cannot be extrapolated such evidence is scrutinized, but there are aspects of to the entire occupational history of the caves. An this criticism which are flawed. Comparing Palaeoindian archive of over 1800 coprolites throughout the Paisley and Viking samples does not take into account major Caves sequence provides an opportunity to examine dietary differences between these populations, or the changes in diet at a high resolution, as well as to pro- different preservation contexts and diagenetic processes. vide information on species lipid biomarkers in copro- Previous research has demonstrated that microscopic lites, in combination with microfossil analyses, allowing CONTACT Lisa-Marie Shillito [email protected] © 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. 2 L.-M. SHILLITO ET AL. Figure 1 Profile from Cave 2 of the Paisley Caves, Unit 2/4C, showing location of pilot study micromorphology blocks (adapted from Jenkins et al. 2012). inferences on dietary inputs. Recent investigations of provide a better indicator of dietary composition. The microfossils including phytoliths and starch grains earliest subsistence data for the Great Basin indicates have shown promise for providing detail on the plant that Pleistocene foragers had a diverse diet consisting component of diet in this region (Herzog 2014; Louder- of a variety of medium-sized mammals, birds, insects, back and Pavlik 2017; Morris et al. 2009). fish, shellfish, and plant resources (Goebel et al. 2011; Any study using sterols as dietary indicators must take Hockett 2007; Rhode and Louderback 2007). Pleistocene into account dietary composition. Sterols by themselves foragers in the Great Basin may have targeted lower- only give an indication of the broad dietary inputs, i.e., ranking resources such as plants and seeds when whether there is an emphasis on plants or meat. A higher-ranking foods were unavailable, and there were more holistic approach, incorporating the analysis of likely periods when their diet consisted mostly of plant Downloaded by [Newcastle University] at 00:50 12 January 2018 other lipid compounds extant within the coprolite, will resources (Grayson 2011, 302). Table 1 Micromorphology samples collected from Cave 2, Unit 2/4C. Associated date (cal yr BP, approximate; from Jenkins et al. Slide Field description Preliminary micromorphology summary observations 2012) 2 Mazama ash and underlying layers Biogenic with mix of plant tissues, micro bone fragments, with 6790 discontinuous lenses of water laid sediments in lower part 3 Silt lenses, softer top layers, firm middle Alternating mixed windblown debris and alluvial lenses, increased 7490–8180 lenses, softer lower layers with hard biogenic component in lower part “fleks” 4 Underlying slide 3, hard “fleks”, looser Continues biogenic material from base of slide 3, shifts to mixed 8180 at base microfaunal pellets with larger mammal pellet present 5 Continues sequence between 4 and 6 Majority of deposit microfaunal pellets, occasional plant tissues and 8180–9565 bone with areas showing calcite coatings. Shifts to mixed pellet/ windblown sediments at base 6 Another silt lens Shift to fine grained silts and clay mixed with sub-rounded sand grains 9480–9565 and basalt from cave wall/roof