1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 30 TH DAY OF JUNE, 2017 PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE JAYANT PATEL AND THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE B. VEERAPPA REVIEW PETITION Nos.352/2016 & 437-454/2016 BETWEEN: 1. B.N. Gopalaswamy S/o Nanjappa Aged about 52 years Now Working as Assistant Director of Treasuries Sub-Treasury, Kadur Chikamagalur Dist.-577548 2. T Ramprasad S/o Krishna Shastry Aged about 46 years Now Working as Accounts Officer Taluk Panchayath Devanahalli-562 110 3. B.B. Siddalingaswamy S/o Late K.S. Basavalingappa Aged about 47 years Working as Asst. Director of Treasuries Sub-Treasury, Malavalli Mandya District-571432 4. Arun Kumar Sangavi S/o Basavanatappa Aged about 41 years Now Deputy Director of Food & Civil Supplies Yadgir-585105 .. Petitioners (By Sri. Narayana Bhat M., Adv.) 2 AND: 1. Khaleel Ahmed K.R., S/o Late Rasool Sab Aged about 48 years, C/o Azeez Khan No.2584, Idgah Mohalla Chikkaballapur-562 101. 2. Veeranna S/o Ramaiah V., Aged about 43 years, Sasalu Post-572 122 Honnudike, Tumkur District. Tumkur 3. Shameer K. Gaonkar S/o Kamalakar Gaonkar Aged about 41 years, Behind KPTCL, Post Vandige Ankola-581 315, Uttara Kannada District. Karwar 4. Jayashekharappa S/o Halage Gowda Aged about 41 years, Machenahalli Post Chikkamagalur Taluk & District. Chikkamagaluru 5. Rajkumar Naik S/o Late Monappa Naik Aged about 42 years, Plot No.87, NGO Colony, Jewargi Road, Gulbarga-585 102. Kalaburagi 6. K.S.Dakshayani Devi D/o Sidda Shetty K.S. Aged about 41 years, No.191, LIG 2 ND Stage, Kuvempunagara, Mysore-570 073. 7. Subraya Shambhu Hegde S/o Shambhu S. Hegde Aged about 41 years, Mudakani Post, Honnavara, Uttara Kannada – 581 395. 3 8. Khaleel Ahamed S/o Late Khalendar Saheb Aged about 43 years, No. 697/75, East End, Tilkanagar, Bangalore-560 011. 9. Leelavathi T. Raju D/o T.Kondaiah Aged about 46 years, Balaji Nivas, S.S.Puram, Tumkur. 10. D.Lakshminarayana S/o Devendrappa Aged about 41 years, No.77, Sri Ganesha, Gandhibazaar, Shimoga-577 202. 11. M.N.Krishnachar S/o Late Narsimhachar Aged about 41 years, D.M.Palya, Don Basco Road Sira Gate Post, Tumkur. 12. Ravishankar K. S/o Jayarama Rao S. Aged about 40 years, Shettyhalli Road Fort Malavalli-571 430, Mandya District. 13. Chandrahasa H.R. S/o Rudrappa Aged about 43 years, Mugabla Village & Post Hosakote Taluk, Bangalore-562 114. 14. V.Vijaykumar S/o Late M.Venkataramana Aged about 45 years, No.413/16, 13 th Main, Lakkasandra Layout, Bangalore-560 030. 15. R.Venkatesh Reddy S/o Ramappa, 4 Aged about 42 years, Nayandanahalli, Herikattigenahalli, Chitamani Chikkaballapura District-563 128. 16. Shivamurthy B.T. S/o Simha Shetty B.T. Aged about 43 years, S.Bidare Post, Kadur Taluk Chikkamagalur District. 17. Hanumatharaya T.V. S/o Late Eranna Aged about 49 years, No.2988, 1st Main, ‘C’ Block, Rajajiangar, Bangalore-560 021. 18. H.S.Veena D/o H.B.Shivanna Aged about 41 years, No.40, Nalme, 3 rd Main Vidyanagar, Tumkur-572 103. 19. Kalefulla H.S. S/o Late Shafifullah Aged about 47 years, No.612/1, 15 th Cross, K.T.J.Nagar Davanagere-577 002. 20. Vijayakumar Reddy B.R. S/o Ramakrishna Reddy Aged about 37 years, No.38, 1st Floor, 11 th Cross 16 th Main, BTM Layout, Bangalore-560 029. 21. Vijaykumar Naik S/o Nonaya Naik Aged about 39 years, R/o Bailu House Kadandale Village & Post , Karkala Taluk – 574 277. 22. A.Ananda S/o Annegowda Aged 42 years, Kalkere Village, Doddabelalu Post, Piriyapatna, Mysore District. 5 23. S.Devaraju S/o L.Shivashankar Aged about 44 years, PNR Palya, Sira Gate Post, Tumkur-572 016. 24. Chandregowda S/o Late Jogi Gowda Aged about 49 years, Badur Post, Arsikere Taluk, Hassan District. 25. Liaqat Ali H.R., S/o Abdul Gaffar Sab Aged about 44 years, Haralipura Village Marabana Halli Post, Channagiri Taluk Davanagere – 577 551. 26. The State of Karnataka Rep. by its Chief Secretary Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. 27. The Principal Secretary Department of Personnel & Administrative Reforms (DPAR) Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. 28. The Karnataka Public Service Commission Udyoga Soudha, Bangalore-560 001 29. Sri Hidayatullah, Officer of Special Duty Department of Health & Family Welfare, Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. 30. Sri Mohamed Rafi Pasha S/o Mohamed Yusuf Khan Aged about 33 years, No.4/1, Kareem Enclave, Flat No.2B, 2nd Floor, 13 th Cross, Jayanagar, Bangalore-560 011 (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 31. Sri Bhaskar Naik S/o Late Neelakant S. Naik 6 Aged about 44 years, No.153, 5th ‘A’ Cross, Yelahanka New Town Bangalore-560 064. (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 32. Smt.Salma Firdose W/o Jameel Ahamed Pasha Aged about 40 years, Assistant Registrar of Co-operative Societies Bangalore (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 33. Smt.Asha Parveen D/o Mohammed Pasha Aged about 39 years, No.62, 2nd Cross, J.S.Nagar Saraswathipura, M.Nandini Layout, Bangalore -560 096 34. Sri Natesh D.B. S/o Basavarajappa Aged about 38 years, No.3/1, 7th A Main Road, Muthyalanagar, Bangalore-560 054 (Impleaded vide order Dated 20.08.2014). 35. Satheesha B.C. Veterinary Officer Canine Rabies Control Unit, Dhanvantri Road Mysore – 570 001. 36. Nagaraju N.R. C/o Dr. S.M.Byregowda No.20/2, Krishna Kuvempu Road, Hebbal Kempapura, Bangalore-560 024. 37. Basavarajendra H., No.382, 13 th Main, RMV Extn., Sadashivanagar, Bangalore-560 080. 38. Gopalakrishna H.N. C/o Rajanna R., Door No.74, Behind Subramanya Temple, Banagiri Nagar, BSK 3 rd Stage, Bangalore-560 085. 7 39. Raghavendra Suhasaa H.G. S/o H.T.Govinda Gowda 250, 3 rd Main, 1 st Cross, BHCS Layout, Chikkalasandra Bangalore-560 061. 40. Shivashankara N., C/o Rame Gowda No.40, 5 th B Cross, 1 st Main, Defence Colony, Hesaraghatta Road, T.Dasarahalli, Bangalore-560 073. 41. Arundati Chandrashekar D/o Dr. T.Chandrashekar No.22, “Anugraha”, 2 nd Main, Muneshwara Block, Harinagar Cross, Konankunte Bangalore-560 062. 42. Ravi M.R. No.271, Belaku, Behind Water Tank, Alanahalli Extension, Mysore-570 011. 43. Ravindra P.N. S/o P.H.Ningappa A.M.G.H.P.S., Kallenahalli, Thyagadhakatte Post Tarikere Taluk-577 549. 44. Jyothi K. No.823, 6 th Cross, 5th Main, M.C. Layout, Vijayanagar, Bangalore-560 040. 45. Meena Nagaraj C.N. No.606/614, New Kamakshi Layout 1st Stage, 1 st ‘A’ Main Road, Basaveshwara Nagar Bangalore-560 079. 46. Akram Pasha S/o Nanne Jan, C/o Riyaz Basha, No.564, Darga Mohalla Chickballapur-562 101. 47. Leelavathy K. D/o G.N.Kamanna 8 No.61, 3 rd Cross, Nanjareddy Colony HAL Post, Bangalore-560 017. 48. Vasanthakumar P., S/o Puttamadaiah No.1718/A, 11 th Main, Bayyanna Garden, Prakash Nagar Bangalore-560 021. 49. Karee Gowda, S/o Sidde Gowda Chikkona Hally, Kelaghatta Post, Maddur Taluk, Mandya District – 571 419. 50. Shivanand Kapashi S/o Bhimappa Kapashi Guru Kripa, Basavanagar, Gokak, Belgaum District-591 307. 51. Gangubai Ramesh Manakar D/o Ramesh Manakar Near Bus Stand, Sindagi Bijapur District – 586 128. 52. Kavitha S. Mannikeri No.191, 8 th Cross, Shakthiganapathi Nagar Basaveshwaranagara, Bangalore-560 079. 53. Peddappaiah R.S. S/o Sanjeevarayappa Ramachandra Pura P.O., Gowribidanur Taluk, Kolar District. 54. Rushibendra Murthy G.C., No.91/A, MES Colony, Konena Agrahara, HAL Bangalore-560 017. 55. Hanumanthegowda T.S. S/o Sambulinge Gowda T.Gollahalli, Kodihalli Post, Kanakapura Taluk, Bangalore District-562119. 9 56. Shivanand G. Navi S/o Gurupadappa Y. Navi, At Post Yadhalli, Bilgi Taluk, Bagalkot District-587 117. 57. Kankaraja D. No.5, “Shreyas Nilaya”, Padma Film Theatre Road Amruthahalli, Sahakara Nagar Post, Bangalore-560 092. 58. Sidrameshwar Ukkali S/o Mahadev Bapuri Lane, At PO Rabkavi, Bagalkot-587314. 59. Raghu G.P., S/o Puttegowda G.A. Boovanahally Post, Hassan Taluk & District-573 201. 60. Khadar Pasha A. S/o Ahmed Hussain MIG-II, 454, 1 st Stage, 3 rd Cross, Rajeev Nagar, Mysore-570 019. 61. Srikanth Rao K. C/o Shivashankar Rao Excel ELEL, No. C-142, Near Post Office, Peenya 2 nd Stage Bangalore – 560 058. 62. Vasantha Kumar B.V. S/o Venkataramanappa Bendiganahalli, Hoskote Taluk, Bangalore Rural District-562 129. 63. Manjunatha Swamy G.N. C/o Rangaswamy, No.375, 8th Block, Mallappa Reddy Layout Koramangala, Bangalore-560 095. 64. Revanna R. S/o Ramakrishnappa Nagannana Palya, Sira Gate, Tumkur-572 106. 65. Roopashree B.V. No.92, II Main, Binny R.P.C. Layout Vijayanagar II Stage, Bangalore-560 040. 10 66. Raghavendra V. S/o S.Venkatraman, No.51, 16 th Cross, 33 rd Main Road, J.P.Nagar 6 th Phase, Bangaore-560 078. 67. Sangappa Upase, At Post Anjutagi, Indi Taluk, Bijapur District-586 204. 68. Sheik Lathief, S/o Sheik Pakir Sahib Odala House, Ujire Post, Belthangady Tq., D.K. District-574240. 69. Ramesha Reddy B. S/o Bali Reddy N., Digavachinatapalli, Addagal P.O., Srinivasapura Taluk, Kolar District-563 134. 70. Mahantesh S., C/o Gangadhar, Advocate, 2nd Main, Near Jain Temple, Hosadurga – 577527. 71. Gangadhara B.K. S/o Kempegowda Bandihalli, Sulekere Post Arasikere Taluk, Hassan District-573 103. 72. Santhavva Kadi D/o Basalingappa Kadi C/o T.Shivalingappa State Bank Colony, Near KEB, Badami, Bagalkot-587 201. 73. Mohammed Iqbal M. Mirza S/o Mohammed Baig G. Mirza PHC K., Salwadagi P.O., B.Bagewadi Taluk, Bijapur District-586 208.