Alabama Law Scholarly Commons Articles Faculty Scholarship 2010 The Bible as a Law Book - Thomas Aquinas on the Juridical Uses of Scripture William S. Brewbaker III University of Alabama - School of Law, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.ua.edu/fac_articles Recommended Citation William S. Brewbaker III, The Bible as a Law Book - Thomas Aquinas on the Juridical Uses of Scripture, 12 Rutgers J. L. & Religion 76 (2010). Available at: https://scholarship.law.ua.edu/fac_articles/60 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Alabama Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Articles by an authorized administrator of Alabama Law Scholarly Commons. VOLUME 12 FALL 2010 PART 1 RUTGERS JOURNAL OF LAW & RELIGION -ARTICLE- THE BIBLE AS A LAW BOOK? THOMAS AQUINAS ON THE JURIDICAL USES OF SCRIPTURE William S. Brewbaker I1 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction........................................................... 78 II. Reason, Revelation and Law: Setting the Stage ............................ 83 A. Natural Law, Human Law and Determinations ........................ 84 B. Human Finitude and Fallenness .......................................... 85 1. Human Finitude ....................................... ........... 86 2. Human Fallenness................................................. 89 III. The Rest of the Treatise: the Uses of Scripture in Human Law.................... 92 A. Law as Divine Instruction .............................................. 92 B. Scripture as "Higher Law" ............................................. 96 1. Scripture and the Divine Good ................................. 96 2. Scripture, Natural Law and the Human Good ....................... ..... 98 a. Thomas's Analytical Toolkit .............................. 98 b. The Old Law and the New Law ................................... 100 c. The Old Law's Precepts: Ceremonial, Judicial and Moral ............... 101 i. Ceremonial ........................................ 101O...... ii. Judicial .............................................. .... 102 iii. Moral ......................................................... 105 IV. Getting Specific: The Use of the Moral Precepts in Lawmaking ................... 111 William Alfred Rose Professor of Law and Associate Dean for Special Projects, University of Alabama. I am grateful to Patrick Brennan and Paul Horwitz for helpful comments on earlier versions of this paper. Any remaining errors are my own. I am also grateful to Dean Ken Randall and the University of Alabama Law School Foundation for generous research support and to Jenny Rieth for secretarial assistance. RUTGERS JOURNAL OF LAW AND RELIGION VOLUME 12 FALL 2010 PART 1 Abstract Thomas Aquinas's Treatise on Law (hereinafter "Treatise ") is enjoying a resurgence of interest among legal scholars. It is excerpted in leading legal philosophy texts, assigned in jurisprudence courses and even cited in law journal articles and legal monographs on a wide range of subjects. Although the Treatise consists of nineteen chapters ("questions"), the average student of legal philosophy is likely to have been exposed only to portions of the first eight and little, if any, of the last eleven. The Treatise is not a short work, and most of the editorial decisions are both practically necessary and pedagogically understandable. Nevertheless, omitting the "rest" of the Treatise has had some unfortunate consequences. The omitted questions include the bulk of Thomas's account of the relationship of theological revelation to human law, a subject of increasing importance in contemporary debates about religion and politics. The omissions also tend to reinforce the impression that Thomas's natural law system can be hived off from his religious and cultural context. To be sure, Thomas does make the familiar natural law claim that there are moral truths that all human beings must know merely by virtue of being human. However, the deeper one goes into the Treatise, the clearer it becomes that Thomas's treatment of natural law is part of a complex and theologically-informed understanding of nature, reason, revelation and the unfolding story of God's action in the world. This article expounds and analyzes the role of Scripture in Thomas's account of legislation and judging, arguing that Thomas leaves only modest room for the Bible to influence human law directly. After explaining some key theological presuppositions that underpin Thomas's account of law generally, the article shows how Thomas divides the laws found in Scripture into several overlapping categories, only one of which (the "moral law" found in the Old Testament) has any direct continuing relevance for the Thomistic jurist. Even here, Scripture serves mostly to confirm the moral truths that human beings (at least the "wise" ones) already know. Nevertheless, it would be an overstatement to conclude that the Bible is completely irrelevant to the Thomistic jurist. The Scriptures bear witness to the grace of Christ, which, in Thomas's account, is critical to the jurist's proper exercise of his or her vocation. Moreover, the Thomistic jurist's understanding of law is shaped by Scripture's account of nature, the human person and ethics. While these theological starting points may not always make much difference in legal 77 RUTGERS JOURNAL OF LAW AND RELIGION VOLUME 12 FALL 2010 PART 1 details, they do lead Thomas (and presumably his followers) to a vision of law that is famously at odds with many modern accounts. I. INTRODUCTION In the past few decades, Thomas Aquinas's Treatise on Law has made a surprising comeback among legal scholars. It is now excerpted in leading legal philosophy texts,2 assigned in jurisprudence courses and even cited in law journal articles on a wide range of subjects. The Treatise, which is a section of Thomas's Summa Theologiae, consists of nineteen questions dealing with various aspects of, and kinds of, law. Thomas's definition of law is expansive enough to include civil laws (which Thomas calls "human law"), Scriptural commands ("divine law"), God's design and governance of the universe ("eternal law") and the law of nature. Despite the resurgence of interest in the Treatise, however, the average student of legal philosophy is likely to have been exposed to portions of its first eight questions (Questions 90- 97) but little, if any, of the last eleven. This editorial selection is entirely understandable and can even be seen in anthologies that appear to have been compiled by Thomas's admirers. Questions 90 through 97 provide the reader whose primary interest is jurisprudence with Thomas's famous definition of law, a survey of the various types of law Thomas recognizes, his 2 See, e.g., GEORGE C. CHRISTIE & PATRICK MARTIN, JURISPRUDENCE: TEXT AND READINGS ON THE PHILOSOPHY OF LAW 86-133 (1st ed. 1995); M.D.A. FREEMAN, LLOYD'S INTRODUCTION TO JURISPRUDENCE 132-37 (6 th ed. 1994); STEPHEN E. GOTTLEB, BRIAN H. BIX, TIMOTHY D. LYTTON & ROBIN L. WEST, JURISPRUDENCE CASES AND MATERIALS: AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PHILOSOPIHY OF LAW AND ITS APPLICATIONS 183-88 (2d ed. 2006). 3 See, e.g., the following articles published in the first half of 2009: Gregory S. Alexander, The Social Obligation Norm in American Property Law, 94 CORNELL L. REV. 745 (2009); Eduardo Penalver, Land Virtues, 94 Cornell L. Rev. 821 (2009); Lee J. Strang, Originalism and the "Challenge Of Change": Abduced-Principle Originalism and Other Mechanisms by Which OriginalismSufficiently Accommodates Changed Social Conditions, 60 HASTINGS L.J. 927 (2009); John M. Breen, Neutrality in Liberal Legal Theory and Catholic Social Thought, 32 HARV. J.L. & PUB. POL'Y 513 (2009); Ronald J. Colombo, Book Review, Exposing The Myth ofHomo Economicus Moral Markets: The Critical Role qf Values in the Economy. Paul J. Zak, ed., 32 HARV. J.L. & PUB. POL'Y 737 (2009); Kevin Jon Heller, The Cognitive Psychology qfMens Rea, 99 J. CRIM. L. & CRIMINOLOGY 317-18 (2009); Neil Duxbury, Golden Rule Reasoning, Moral Judgment, and Law, 84 NOTRE DAME L. REV. 1529, 1566 (2009); Brian M. McCall, From Our History: Evaluating the Modern Housing Finance Market in Light of Ancient Principles of Justice, 60 S.C. L. REV. 707, 715, 718, 726 (2009); Frederick Mark Gedicks, An OriginalistDefense qf Substantive Due Process: Magna Carta, Higher-Law Constitutionalism, and the Fifth Amendment, 58 EMORY L.J. 585, 643 (2009); Jeremy Waldron, Can There Be A DemocraticJurisprudence?,58 EMORY L.J. 675, 685 (2009). 4 See, e.g., SAINT THOMAS AQUINAS, ON LAW, MORALITY, AND POLITICS (William P. Baumgarth & Richard J. Regan, S.J. eds. 1988) (including QQ. 90-97, 100 and Article 1 of Q. 105); ST. THOMAS AQUINAS, TREATISE ON LAW, (Regnery Publ'g, Inc. 2001) (1956) (including QQ. 90-97). In defense of these editions, some of the material covered in QQ. 98-108 is covered briefly in Q. 91. 78 RUTGERS JOURNAL OF LAW AND RELIGION VOLUME 12 FALL 2010 PART 1 classic exposition of natural law and its relationship to human law and Thomas's primary comments on the form, function and limits of human law. By contrast, questions 98-108 focus on issues that are not only more obviously theological and biblical, but also treat subjects that are far more obscure to modern readers and far less relevant to contemporary legal theory and practice: What is the purpose of the Old Testament's legal system (the "Old Law")? To what extent are Christians bound to observe the Old Law? How does the law set forth in the New Testament (the