Table of Cases 101051287 Saskatchewan Ltd v Saskatoon (City), 2004 SKQB 361, 253 Sask R 174, [2004] SJ 608 (QL), aff’d 2005 SKCA 137, 275 Sask R 142, 17 MPLR (4th) 72, [2005] SJ 723 (QL) ........................................................................................................................................... 6.5(r) 114957 Canada Ltée (Spraytech, Société d’arrosage) v Hudson (Town), [2001] 2 SCR 241, 200 DLR (4th) 419, 40 CELR (NS) 1 ............................................................................................... 2.5(b) 1213963 Ontario Ltd (cob Sin City Bar and Eatery) v Ontario (Alcohol and Gaming Commission), 2009 ONCA 323, 248 OAC 201, [2009] OJ 1553 (QL) ............................... 4.3(z), 4.4 1219261 Ontario Inc (cob Hidden Bay Lodge) v Canada, 2004 TCC 48, [2004] GSTC 4, [2004] TCJ 36 (QL) ....................................................................................................................... 2.4 1270627 Ontario Ltd v Kanata (City) (1998) 49 MPLR (2d) 170 (ON GD) .................................... 10.3(a) 1318706 Ontario Ltd v Niagara (Regional Municipality) (2005), 75 OR (3d) 405, 198 OAC 66, 9 MPLR (4th) 161, [2005] OJ 1907 (QL) (CA) ....................................................................... 2.6 143471 Canada Inc v Quebec (Attorney General) [1994] 2 SCR 339 ............................................... 10.6(a) 144096 Canada Ltd (USA) v Canada (Attorney General) (2003) 63 OR (3d) 172 (CA) ..... 10.5(f), 10.6(a) 1515545 Ontario Ltd v Niagara Falls (City) [2006] OJ 70 (QL) (CA) .................................... 10.6(e), 10.7 1747114 Ontario Inc v Mississauga (City), 2013 ONCJ 623, 17 MPLR (5th) 296, 58 MVR (6th) 281, [2013] OJ 5344 (QL) .......................................................................................................... 8.2(c) 2300246 Ontario Ltd, v Ontario (Minister of Health and Lon-Term Care), 2014 ONSC 6958, 123 OR (3d) 513, [2014] OJ 6030 (QL) ..................................................................................... 6.5(bb) 504174 NB Ltd (cob Choo Choo’s) v New Brunswick (Minister of Public Safety), 2005 NBCA 18, 279 NBR (2d) 307, [2005] NBJ 55 (QL) ............................................................. 2.1(b), 2.4, 11.5 532871 BC Ltd (cob The Urban Well) v British Columbia (Liquor Control and Licensing Branch General Manager), 2004 BCSC 127, 25 BCLR (4th) 353, 12 Admin LR (4th) 203, [2004] BCJ 169 (QL), rev’d 2005 BCCA 416, 215 BCAC 265, 43 BCLR (4th) 293, 34 Admin LR (4th) 185, [2005] BCJ 1821 (QL) ........................................................ 2.1(b), 2.4, 11.5 538745 Ontario Inc v Windsor (City) (1988) 64 OR (2d) 38 (CA), leave to appeal refused (1988) 65 OR (2d) x (SCC) ........................................................................................................ 10.16 620247 Ontario Ltd v Canada, [1995] GSTC 22, 3 GTC 2065 (TCC) ................................................... 2.4 65302 British Columbia Ltd v Canada, [1999] 3 SCR 804, 179 DLR (4th) 577, 99 DTC 5799 ........... 11.5 679619 Ontario Ltd (cob Silvers Lounge) v Windsor (City), 2007 ONCA 7, 219 OAC 37, 278 DLR (4th) 292, 31 MPLR (4th) 1, [2007] OJ 39 (QL), leave to appeal dismissed, [2007] SCCA 114 (QL) ......................................................................................................................... 2.5(h) 697578 Ontario Inc (cob Hotel Europa) v Niagara Falls (City) (2001) 28 MPLR (3d) 266 (SCJ), affd (2002) 168 OAC 229 (CA) .................................................................................... 10.3(a) A v Ontario Securities Commission [2006] OJ 1768 (QL) (SCJ) .................................................... 10.11(a) A v Ontario Securities Commission [2006] OJ 2647 (QL) (SCJ) .................................................... 10.11(a) Adult Entertainment Association of Canada v Ottawa (City) 2007 ONCA 389 .................... 2.5(h), 10.3(a) AHI Operations Ltd v Department of Labour, [1986] 1 NZLR 645 (HC) ......... 7.3(b), 7.3(h), 7.3(i), 7.3(o) Ahmad v Canada (Minister of National Revenue) (1998) 153 FTR 65 ....... 10.5(e), 10.6(d), 10.11(a), 10.12 Air Canada c Canada (Procureur général) (2003), 222 DLR (4th) 385, 23 CPR (4th) 129, 46 Admin LR (3d) 283, application for leave to appeal allowed, [2003] CSCR No 111 (QL) .......... 11.5 Ajax (Town) v Haydon Youth Services Inc, 2007 ONCJ 114, [2007] OJ 999 (QL) ...................................................................................................... 6.5(r), 7.3(g), 7.3(l), 7.3(o), 11.2(b) Ajax (Town) v Wong, 2011 ONCJ 352, [2011] OJ 3167 (QL) ........................................................... 11.2(p) Alberta (Driver Control Board) v Lupien (2001) 295 AR 291 (QB) .................................... 10.5(d), 10.6(i) TC-1 (Update 30 – August 2020) LIBMAN ON REGULATORY OFFENCES IN CANADA Alberta (Energy Resources Conservation Board) v Sarg Oils Ltd, [2002] 10 WWR 217, 312 AR 79, 45 Admin LR (3d) 94, [2002] AJ 938 (QL) (CA), leave to appeal dismissed, [2002] SCCA 371 (QL) .................................................................................................................. 7.9 Alberta (Securities Commission) v Brost 2008 ABCA 326 ................................ 10.5(a), 10.12, 10.14, 11.5 Alberta (Securities Commission) v Workum 2010 ABCA 405 ............................. 10.5(a), 10.12, 10.14, 11.5 Allstate Insurance Company of Canada v Toronto (City) (2001) 57 OR (3d) 191 (CA) .................... 10.3(a) Amway of Canada, Ltd v Canada (1996), 193 NR 381, [1996] 2 CTC 162, 96 DTC 6135, [1996] FCJ 1026 (QL) (CA) ......................................................................................................... 11.5 Anderson v British Columbia (Securities Commission), 2004 BCCA 7, [2004] 4 WWR 81, 23 BCLR (4th) 182, leave to appeal dismissed, [2004] SCCA 81 (QL) .............................................. 7.2 Anderson v Victoria (City) (2002), 9 BCLR (4th) 75, 34 MPLR (3d) 77, 32 MVR (4th) 14 (SC) ........ 3.3(j) Re Anderson-Davis (1997) 43 CRR (2d) 356 (BC SC) ........................................... 10.6(a), 10.6(d), 10.6(f) Andrews v Law Society of British Columbia [1989] 1 SCR 21............................................................. 10.16 Angle v Minister of National Revenue, [1975] 2 SCR 248, 47 DLR (3d) 544, 74 DTC 6278 ........... 8.10(f) Ardekany v Dominion of Canada General Insurance Company (1985), 67 BCLR 162, 20 CCLI 37 (SC), aff’d (1987), 32 DLR (4th) 23, 7 BCLR (2d) 1, 22 CCLI 221 (CA) ........................... 6.5(d) Armstrong v Canada (2002), 286 NR 322, 2000 DTC 6780 (Fed CA) ............................................. 8.10(f) Arnold v Harris (1993) 107 DLR (4th) 88 (ON GD) ........................................ 4.2, 4.3(r), 10.5(a), 10.11(a) Arsic v Canada, 2010 TCC 423, 2010 CCI 423, 2010 GST 85, [2010] TCJ 324 (QL) ........................... 7.2 Assured Towing Ltd v Toronto (City), [2002] OTC 296, 32 MPLR (3d) 172 (SCJ) .................... 7.9, 8.10(f) Auckland City Council v North Power Ltd, [2004] NZRMA 354 (DC) ................. 11.2(k), 11.2(s), 11.2(x) Auckland City Council v Selwyn Mews Ltd, [2003] DCR 671 (DC) ....................................................... 7.9 Aurora Quarrying Ltd v Catherwood, [1982] 6 WWR 517, 18 Man R (2d) 63 (Co Ct) .................................................................................................................................. 6.7, 7.3(l), 7.3(o) Autorité des marchés financiers v Greeley, 2010 QCCQ 2879, [2010] QJ 3391 (QL) ..................................................................................................................................... 11.2(a), 11.2(b) Autorité des marchés financiers v Lacroix, 2008 QCCQ 234, [2008] QJ 346 (QL) .......................... 11.2(a) Authorite des marches financiers v Patry, 2015 QCCA 1993, 26 CR (7th) 166, [2015] QJ 12668 (QL) ..................................................................................................................................... Intro, 8.17 Axworthy v Prince Edward Island (Registrar of Motor Vehicles) (1999) 179 Nfld & PEIR 166 (PE SC) ................................................................................................................. 2.5(e), 9.2, 10.5(d) Aztec Properties Co (cob Bimini Neighbourhood Pub) v British Columbia (General Manager, Liquor Control and Licensing Branch), 2005 BCSC 1465, [2005] BCJ 2231 (QL) ............ 6.5(q), 6.7 Babka v Gauthier (1981), 5 WCB 417 (Ont Dist Ct) ......................................................................... 4.3(p) Baker v Alberta (Transportation Safety Board) 2004 ABQB 244 ................................... 2.5(e), 9.2, 10.5(d) Baker v British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals 2006 BCSC 1982......... 10.6(o) Barnes v British Columbia (Ministry of Environment) (2005), 17 CELR (3d) 238 (BC Env Appl Bd) .............................................................................................. 8.10(a), 8.10(c), 8.12(b), 11.5 Barry v Alberta (Securities Commission) (1986) 25 DLR (4th) 730 (AB CA), affd [1989] 1 SCR 301 ...................................................................................................................................... 10.14 Bathurst Machine Shop v Canada [2006] 3 CTC 2287 (TC) .......................................................... 10.11(a) Batty v Toronto (City) 2011 ONSC 6862 ............................................................................................10.3(a) Beaconsfield