January 28, 2015 Paramount Law Times Issue No - 11 (For up-to-dating law and events) 2015 OUR ELEVENTH CHIEF JUSTICE Happy New Year Paramount Law Consultants Wish you all Happy and prosprous New Year. Let Truth be upheld and Justice to prevail. PARAMOUNT LAW CONSULTANTS WELCOME ANNOUNCEMENT State Judicial Services preparations Guidance facility Finding necessity for guidance for all those preparing for State Judicial Services Competitions Examinations, Paramount HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE Law Consultants Ltd. has decided to help MOHAMMAD HIDAYATULLAH with valuable guidance. Interested persons are welcome. Former Chief Justice of India Legal Audit and Moral Audit Services 25-02-1968 till 16-12-1970 Paramount Law Consultants Ltd., Delhi has PROFILE as on Supreme court website completed its research and is taking up legal (http://supremecourtofindia.nic.in/judges/r audit and moral audit services for the cji.htm) Corporates. Subhash Nagpal, o The Hon'ble Mr. Mohammad Chairman Hidayatullah, B.A. (Nagpur) : M.A. Paramount Law Consultants Ltd., Delhi (Cantab); Barrister-at-Law, O.B.E. (1946) : Judge, Supreme Court from Dec. 1, 1958.b. Dec. 17,1905; Educ. : Govt. High School, Raipur (1922) ; Phillip's Scholar, Morris College, For previous issues and more information go to www.paramountlaw.in Page - 1 January 28, 2015 Paramount Law Times Issue No - 11 Nagpur (1926) ; B.A. 2nd order of 2 Title-Ishwardas Vs. Maharashtra merit Malak Gold Medalist, Trinity Revenue Tribunal & Ors.-Coram- College, Cambridge (1927-30), English Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., and Law Tripos, Lincoln's Inn, Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Barrister-at-Law (1930), President, Grover, A.N. Indian Majlis, Cambridge (1929) ; Date of Judgement-13/03/1968 Advocate, Nagpur High Court (1930- 46); Lecturer, University College of 3 Title-Ayodhya Prasad Vajpai Vs. State Law (1935-43) ; Government Pleader Of U.P. & Anr.-Coram-Hidayatullah, (1942-43) ; Advocate-General, Central M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., Provinces & Berar (1943-46); Puisne Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Judge (1946-54) ; Chief Justice, Nagpur Grover, A.N. High Court (1954-56); Chief Justice, Date of Judgement-13/03/1968 High Court of Madhya Pradesh, 4 Title-State Of Madhya Pradesh Vs. November 1, 1956 to November 28, Ranojirao Shinde & Anr.-Coram- 1958 ; Member, Nagpur Municipal Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., Committee (1931-33) ; Nagpur Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Improvement Trust (1943-45), Nagpur Grover, A.N. University Executive and Academic Date of Judgement-21/03/1968 Councils, Court etc. (1934-53) ; Dean of the Faculty of Law, (1949-53) ; 5 Title-T. K. Lakshmana Iyer & Ors. Vs. Member, Faculty of Law Saugar State Of Madras & Ors.-Coram- University ; Court Vikram University Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., and Aligarh Muslim University ; (1954) Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., ; Member, Nagpur Bar Council (1943- Grover, A.N. 46); Chief Commissioner, Madhya Date of Judgement-26/03/1968 Pradesh Bharat Scouts and Guides (1950-53); Vice-President, National 6 Title-Lakhan Lal And Others Etc. Vs. Council Bharat Scouts and Guides The State Of Bihar And Others Etc.- (1950-52). Awarded the highest award Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Silver Elephant (1950); Adviser, Bachawat, R.S., Vaidyialingam, C.A., International Fellowship of Former Hegde, K.S., Grover, A.N. Scouts and Guides.Appointed as Chief Date of Judgement-26/03/1968 Justice of India on 25.02.1968. Retired on 16.12.1970 7 Title-B. S. Vadera Vs. Union Of India & Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), JUDGEMENTS DELIEVERED BY HON’BLE Bachawat, R.S., Vaidyialingam, C.A., MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD Hegde, K.S., Grover, A.N. HIDAYATULLAH Date of Judgement-27/03/1968 8 Title-Kishanchand Narsinghdas Bhatia Vs. State Transport Appellate Sn. Title, Coram and Date of Judgment Authority & Ors.-Coram- Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., 1 Title-Tukaram G.Gaokar Vs. R. N. Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Shukla & Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, Grover, A.N. M. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., Date of Judgement-28/03/1968 Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Grover, A.N. 9 Title-Keshavlal Jethalal Shah Vs. Date of Judgement-08/03/1968 Mohanlal Bhagwandas & Anr.- Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, For previous issues and more information go to www.paramountlaw.in Page - 2 January 28, 2015 Paramount Law Times Issue No - 11 J.C., Sikri, S.M., Bachawat, R.S. & J.C., Ramaswami, V., Bhargava, Mitter, G.K., Vaidyialingam, C.A. & Vishishtha, Vaidyialingam, C.A. Hegde, K.S. Date of Judgement-18/07/1968 Date of Judgement-02/04/1968 17 Title-State Of Punjab Vs. Sat Pal Dang 10 Title-Statesman (Private) Ltd. Vs. H. & Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), R. Deb & Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, Shah, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, M. (Cj), Ramaswami, V., G.K., Grover, A.N. Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S., Date of Judgement-30/07/1968 Grover, A.N. Date of Judgement-02/04/1968 18 Title-Bidya Deb Barma Etc. Vs. District Magistrate, Tripura, Agartala- 11 Title-Dhulabhai And Others Vs. The Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shelat, State Of Madhya Pradesh And J.M., Bhargava, Vishishtha, Mitter, Another-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. G.K., Vaidyialingam, C.A. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., Vaidyialingam, Date of Judgement-06/08/1968 C.A., Hegde, K.S., Grover, A.N. Date of Judgement-05/04/1968 19 Title-Rev. Father W. Proost And Ors. Vs. The State Of Bihar & Ors.- 12 Title-State Of Gujarat Etc. Vs. Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, Vakhtsinghji Sursinghji Vaghela & J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Ors. Etc.-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. Grover, A.N. (Cj), Bachawat, R.S., Mitter, G.K., Date of Judgement-13/09/1968 Vaidyialingam, C.A., Hegde, K.S. Date of Judgement-08/04/1968 20 Title-Som Datt Datta Vs. Union Of India And Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, 13 Title-State Of Maharashtra Etc. Vs. M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Madhavrao Damodar Patilchand Ors. Mitter, G.K., Grover, A.N. Etc.-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Date of Judgement-20/09/1968 Shah, J.C., Sikri, S.M., Bachawat, R.S. & Mitter, G.K., Vaidyialingam, C.A. 21 Title-Sampat Prakash Vs. State Of & Hegde, K.S. Jammu & Kashmir & Anr.-Coram- Date of Judgement-10/04/1968 Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shelat, J.M., Bhargava, Vishishtha, Mitter, G.K., 14 Title-Ramanlal Gulab Chand Shah Vaidyialingam, C.A. Etc. Vs. State Of Gujarat & Ors., Etc.- Date of Judgement-10/10/1968 Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Sikri, S.M., Bachawat, R.S. & 22 Title-Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd. Mitter, G.K., Vaidyialingam, C.A. & Vs. Commissioner Of Excise, Bihar & Hegde, K.S. Ors.-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Date of Judgement-19/04/1968 Sikri, S.M., Bachawat, R.S., Mitter, G.K., Hegde, K.S. 15 Title-Triloki Nath & Anr. Vs. State Of Date of Judgement-17/10/1968 Jammu & Kashmir & Ors.-Coram- Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., 23 Title-Rattan Lal & Co. & Anr. Vs. The Sikri, S.M., Ramaswami, V., Assessing Authority & Anr.-Coram- Bhargava, Vishishtha Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Date of Judgement-23/04/1968 Ramaswami, V., Hegde, K.S., Grover, A.N. 16 Title-Krishna Ballabh Sahay And Ors. Date of Judgement-29/10/1968 Vs. Commission Of Enquiry & Ors.- Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, 24 Title-Nishi Kant Jha Vs. State Of For previous issues and more information go to www.paramountlaw.in Page - 3 January 28, 2015 Paramount Law Times Issue No - 11 Blihar-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Grover, A.N. Shah, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, Date of Judgement-01/04/1969 G.K., Grover, A.N. Date of Judgement-02/12/1968 33 Title-Mohd. Faruk Vs. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others-Coram- 25 Title-B. Shankara Rao Badami & Ors. Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Vs. State Of Mysore & Anr.-Coram- Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Grover, Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., A.N. Date of Judgement-01/04/1969 Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Grover, A.N. Date of Judgement-04/12/1968 34 Title-Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro & Ors. Vs. State Of Bihar & Ors.- 26 Title-Maganbhai Ishwarbhai Patel Vs. Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, Union Of India And Anr.-Coram- J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Grover, A.N. Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Grover, Date of Judgement-02/04/1969 A.N. Date of Judgement-09/01/1969 35 Title-Assistant Commissioner Of 27 Title-State Of Gujarat Vs. Shri Urban Land Taxand Others Vs. The Shantilal Mangaldas & Ors.-Coram- Buckingham & Carnatic Co. Ltd., Etc.- Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Grover, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., A.N. Date of Judgement-13/01/1969 Grover, A.N. Date of Judgement-11/04/1969 28 Title-Rashbihari Panda Etc. Vs. State Of Orissa-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. 36 Title-Venkatarao Esajirao Limbekar & (Cj), Shah, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Ors. Vs. The State Of Bombay & Ors.- Mitter, G.K., Grover, A.N. Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, Date of Judgement-16/01/1969 J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, G.K., Grover, A.N. 29 Title-Mohammad Ismail, Vs. Nanney Date of Judgement-15/04/1969 Lal-Coram-Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shah, J.C., Ramaswami, V., Mitter, 37 Title-Chithra Ghosh & Another Vs. G.K., Grover, A.N. Union Of India And Others-Coram- Date of Judgement-07/03/1969 Hidayatullah, M. (Cj), Shelat, J.M., Bhargava, Vishishtha, Hegde, K.S., 30 Title-Rev. Mons. Sebastiao Francisco Grover, A.N. Xavier Dos.Remedios Monte Vs. State Date of Judgement-25/04/1969 Of Goa-Coram-Hidayatullah, M.