Evaluation of the European Union’s Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian people 2008 – 2013 Final Report Volume 2 May 2014 ___________ Evaluation carried out on behalf of the European Commission Development and Cooperation EuropeAid Consortium composed by Development Researcher’s Network, ECDPM, ECORYS, PARTICIP Leader of the Consortium: DRN Contact Person: Marco Palmini [email protected] Contract No 2012/307554 Version 1 This evaluation was commissioned by the Evaluation Unit of the Directorate General for Development and Cooperation – EuropeAid (European Commission) The opinions expressed in this document represent the authors’ points of view which are not necessarily shared by the European Commission or by the authorities of the concerned countries Evaluation Team Team Leader: Joe Saba Deputy Team Leader: Paolo Scalia Social Expert: Nick Krafft Water and Sanitation Expert: Jean-Claude Ceuppens National Expert: Omar Shaban Research Assistant: Silvia Cifarelli Quality Advisor: Jean Bossuyt DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People The evaluation is being managed by the Evaluation Unit of DG DEVCO. The authors accept sole responsibility for this report, drawn up on behalf of the Commission of the European Communities. The report does not necessarily reflect the views of the Commission. Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ANNEX 1: TERMS OF REFERENCES .............................................................................................................. 4 ANNEX 2: BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................................ 31 ANNEX 3: LIST OF PEOPLE INTERVIEWED ................................................................................................ 41 ANNEX 4: EVALUATION METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................... 54 ANNEX 5: DATA EVALUATION GRID ........................................................................................................... 64 ANNEX 6: NATIONAL CONTEXT ................................................................................................................... 76 ANNEX 7: INVENTORY OF DEVCO AND ECHO INTERVENTIONS .......................................................... 105 ANNEX 8: OTHERS DONORS’ COOPERATION ......................................................................................... 124 ANNEX 9: LIST OF DEVCO INTERVENTIONS IN PALESTINE .................................................................. 126 ANNEX 10: LIST OF ECHO INTERVENTIONS IN PALESTINE .................................................................. 164 ANNEX 11: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF PROJECTS “RESULT-ORIENTED MONITORING” ............ 175 ANNEX 12: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS MATRIX ........................................................... 183 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People ANNEX 1: TERMS OF REFERENCES Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 4 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 5 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 6 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 7 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 8 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 9 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 10 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 11 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 12 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 13 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 14 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 15 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 16 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 17 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 18 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 19 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 20 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 21 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 22 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 23 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 24 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 25 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 26 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 27 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 28 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 29 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People Final Report –Volume 2 Annexes May 2014 Page 30 DRN-ECDPM-ECORYS-PARTICIP Evaluation of the EU Cooperation with the occupied Palestinian territory and support to the Palestinian People ANNEX 2: BIBLIOGRAPHY DOCUMENT ON GENERAL DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION POLICY - Barcelona Declaration 1995 - Oslo II (1995) Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, Washington, D.C.