Repositorium für die Medienwissenschaft Justin Clemens; Dominic Pettman Avoiding the Subject: Media, Culture and the Object 2004 https://doi.org/10.25969/mediarep/4103 Veröffentlichungsversion / published version Buch / book Empfohlene Zitierung / Suggested Citation: Clemens, Justin; Pettman, Dominic: Avoiding the Subject: Media, Culture and the Object. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press 2004. DOI: https://doi.org/10.25969/mediarep/4103. Erstmalig hier erschienen / Initial publication here: https://doi.org/10.5117/9789053567166 Nutzungsbedingungen: Terms of use: Dieser Text wird unter einer Creative Commons - This document is made available under a creative commons - Namensnennung - Nicht kommerziell 3.0/ Lizenz zur Verfügung Attribution - Non Commercial 3.0/ License. For more information gestellt. Nähere Auskünfte zu dieser Lizenz finden Sie hier: see: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/ aup_avoiding.def 29-09-2004 10:06 Pagina 1 Clemens | Pettman Justin Clemens lectures in the Department of English, Deakin University, Australia. His publications include The Mundiad (Black Inc, 2004) and The Romanticism of Contemporary Theory (Ashgate, 2003). He is the co-editor, with Oliver Feltham, of Alain Badiou’s Infinite What can Roger Rabbit tell Thought (Continuum, 2003). us about the Second Gulf Dominic Pettman is currently teaching War? What can a woman within the Masters of Digital Media program married to the Berlin Wall at the Polytechnic University, Brooklyn. He has tell us about post-human- held previous appointments in the English Department of the University of Geneva, and ism and inter-subjectivity? the Media and Culture Department of the Avoiding the Subject What can DJ Shadow tell us University of Amsterdam. He is the author of After the Orgy: Toward a Politics of Exhaustion about the end of history? (SUNY Press, 2002). What can our local bus route tell us about the fortifi- Cover illustration: Merritt Symes cation of the West? What can Reality TV tell us about the crisis of contemporary community? And what can unauthorized pictures of Osama bin Laden tell us about new methods of popu- lar propaganda? These are only some of the thought-provoking questions raised in this lively and erudite collection of inter-related essays on the postmillennial mediascape. Focusing on the neglected signifi- cance of the object within today’s discourse networks, Avoiding the Subject extends the formal possibilities of cultural criticism Avoiding the Subject by highlighting feedback loops between philosophy, technology, and politics. Students and teachers of visual culture, critical MEDIA, CULTURE AND THE OBJECT theory, cultural studies, film theory, and new media will find a wealth of ideas and insights in this fresh approach to the electronic environment. Justin Clemens | Dominic Pettman www.aup.nl A U P A U P pg Avoiding the Subject pg pg Avoiding the Subject Media, Culture and the Object Justin Clemens Dominic Pettman AMSTERDAM UNIVERSITY PRESS pg Cover illustration: Merritt Symes Cover design: Sabine Mannel, N.A.P., Amsterdam Lay-out: PROgrafici, Goes ISBN 90 5356 716 X NUR 736 © Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam 2004 All rights reserved. Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part of this book may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval sys- tem, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photo- copying, recording or otherwise) without the written permission of both the copy- right owner and the author of the book. pg Table of Contents 5 Acknowledgments / 7 Introduction / 9 The Influence of Anxiety / 11 Chapter 1: The Aesthetic Object / 23 A Break in Transmission: Art, Appropriation and Accumulation / 25 Chapter 2: The Love Object / 37 Relations with Concrete Others / 39 (or, How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Berlin Wall) Chapter 3: The Elusive Object / 57 “Look at the Bunny”: The Rabbit as Virtual Totem / 59 (or, What Roger Rabbit Can Teach Us About the Second Gulf War) Chapter 4: The Media(ted) Object / 81 From September 11 to the 7-11: Popular Propaganda and the Internet’s War on Terrorism / 83 Chapter 5: The Shared Object / 93 Abandoned Commonplaces: Some Belated Thoughts on Big Brother / 95 Chapter 6: The Moveable Object / 109 Public Transport: Jaunting from the Spaceship Nomad to the HSS Tampa / 111 pg Table op Contents 6 Chapter 7: The Foreign Object / 129 The Floating Life of Fallen Angels: Unsettled Communities and Hong Kong Cinema / 131 Chapter 8: The Abject Object / 145 Sovereignty, Sacrifice and the Sacred in Contemporary Australian Politics / 147 Conclusion / 177 A Spanner in the Works / 179 Notes / 185 Index / 212 pg Acknowledgments 7 Some of these chapters have appeared in different incarnations in different jour- nals and forums: “A Break in Transmission: Art, Appropriation and Accumulation,” first appeared in GENRE (a publication of the English Department, University of Oklahoma), vol. 34, no.3/4, Fall/Winter 2001, pp. 279-90. A much shorter version of “Relations with Concrete Others (or How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Berlin Wall)” is slated for the 21(5) issue of Theory, Culture and Society, October 2004. “From September 11 to the 7-11: Popular Propaganda and the Internet’s War on Terrorism,” was published online in a somewhat different form at both Largeur magazine (translated into French by P. Grosjean, December 2001), and Crikey mag- azine, Australia – where it endured the title “Jihad for Dummies.” “The Floating Life of Fallen Angels: Unsettled Communities and Hong Kong Cinema,” was first published in Postcolonial Studies, vol. 3, no.1, April 2000, pp. 69-80. An earlier version of “Abandoned Commonplaces: Some Belated Thoughts on Big Brother” was first published as a catalogue essay to Poly-Articulate, a collabora- tive exhibition by J. Clemens, C. Henschke, J. Meade, and A. Trevillian at WestSpace Gallery Melbourne, October 2002. An earlier version of “Sovereignty, Sacrifice and the Sacred in Contemporary Australian Politics” was presented at the Post Colonial Institute, University of Melbourne, May 25, 2000. pg Acknowledgments 8 We gratefully acknowledge the financial assistance provided by an Australian Research Council Grant for Justin Clemens, Russell Grigg and Henry Krips; by the School of Communication and Creative Arts at Deakin University; by the Department of English with Cultural Studies at the University of Melbourne; and by the Australian Academy of the Humanities. Dominic would like to thank “friends in deed” in vague spatio-temporal clusters. In Amsterdam, Thomas Elsaesser, Joost Bolten (and family), Wim Staat, Jan Simons, Catherine Lord, Richard Rogers and the AUP team. In Geneva, Rick Waswo, Michael Röösli, Pierrine Jan, Pierre Grosjean, Gabrielle Sigrist, and Charles Antoine- Courcoux. There is also an “un-” or “dis-”placed group who serve as constant compan- ions (actual and/or virtual) and regular sources of inspiration, including Wanda Strauven, Malte Hagener, Drehli Robnick, Gabu Heindl, Francesco Pitassio, Eddie Maloney, Kylie Matulick, Todd Mueller, Rob Crompton, Ned Rossiter, David Odell, and Steven Shaviro. People in or around the academy who have shown generous and unflinching support include Geert Lovink, McKenzie Wark, Toby Miller, Simon During, and Wlad Godzich. Notwithstanding the generosity of the aforementioned persons, journals, galleries and institutions, Justin would, above all, like to thank Rachel Hughes. If people still thought of texts as symbolic acts susceptible to varieties of human intervention, he would dedicate this book to her. He would also like to thank Geoff Boucher, Chris Feik, Oliver Feltham, Russell Grigg, Chris Henschke, Ann McCulloch, Henry Krips, John Meade, Michael Meehan, Peter Otto, Brian Stagoll and Andy Trevillian. Others, who have not been listed here for a variety of reasons, are no doubt grate- ful that they have escaped this shame-by-association. It does not mean, however, that we are any less grateful to them. pg Introduction The Influence of Anxiety pg pg Introduction: The Influence of Anxiety 11 We now know that future presents will bring other things than the present future can express, and when we speak of the future we express this dis- crepancy by dealing only with probabilities or improbabilities. NIKLAS LUHMANN1 1. I Object This is a book about objects. More precisely, it is about the fate of objects in the contemporary world. Such objects are extraordinarily peculiar, volatile cocktails of media, genres, things, forms, materials, fantasies and phantasms. This book tries to confront these objects with three sets of interrelated questions. First, what is the status of objects in a “virtual” world? How are they produced, distributed and con- sumed? How do they differ from previous “epochs of objectness”? Second, how is the status of affect transformed by these objects? What sorts of subjective invest- ments in objects are now possible or impossible? And how are these affects medi- ated and dispersed across communities? Third, what are the emergent possibilities for thought and action given these new relations between objects and affects – especially when considered under the intersecting signs of “art,” “politics” and “media”? We are, in other words, interested in the possibilities of tracking the mutations of contemporary objects and in discerning the political and aesthetic consequences of such mutations for and on human subjects. But we try to begin with the object. “Object” is a peculiar word, and what it purports to designate is no less pecu- liar. Deriving from the Latin obicere – to throw against, to expose, to present, to cast, to hold up as a defence – the modern English object, as both noun and verb, retains the traces of this etymology. An object can be a thing presented or a thing external to the mind, an oppositional statement, a charge or accusation, an aim or goal, something upon which one operates, a grammatical category, an obstacle, and so on. This polyvalency entails both a certain incoherence and the prolifera- tion of intransitive specializations.