EBU – TECH 3343 Practical guidelines for Production and Implementation in accordance with EBU R 128 Supplementary information for EBU R 128 Status: Version 2.0 Geneva August 2011 1 *Page intentionally left blank. This document is paginated for two sided printing Tech 3343v2 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Conformance Notation This document contains both normative text and informative text. All text is normative except for that in the Introduction, any § explicitly labelled as ‘Informative’ or individual paragraphs that start with ‘Note:’. Normative text describes indispensable or mandatory elements. It contains the conformance keywords ‘shall’, ‘should’ or ‘may’, defined as follows: ‘Shall’ and ‘shall not’: Indicate requirements to be followed strictly and from which no deviation is permitted in order to conform to the document. ‘Should’ and ‘should not’: Indicate that, among several possibilities, one is recommended as particularly suitable, without mentioning or excluding others. OR indicate that a certain course of action is preferred but not necessarily required. OR indicate that (in the negative form) a certain possibility or course of action is deprecated but not prohibited. ‘May’ and ‘need not’ Indicate a course of action permissible within the limits of the document. Default identifies mandatory (in phrases containing “shall”) or recommended (in phrases containing “should”) presets that can, optionally, be overwritten by user action or supplemented with other options in advanced applications. Mandatory defaults must be supported. The support of recommended defaults is preferred, but not necessarily required. Informative text is potentially helpful to the user, but it is not indispensable and it can be removed, changed or added editorially without affecting the normative text. Informative text does not contain any conformance keywords. A conformant implementation is one that includes all mandatory provisions (‘shall’) and, if implemented, all recommended provisions (‘should’) as described. A conformant implementation need not implement optional provisions (‘may’) and need not implement them as described. 3 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Tech 3343v2 4 Tech 3343v2 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Contents 1. Introduction ..................................................................................... 7 2. EBU R 128, ITU-R BS.1770.................................................................... 9 2.1 Programme Loudness...............................................................................................11 2.2 Loudness Range .....................................................................................................12 2.3 True Peak Level (TPL), Maximum Permitted TPL..............................................................13 2.4 R 128 Logo ...........................................................................................................15 3. General Concept of Loudness Normalisation ........................................... 15 3.1 Peak vs. Loudness...................................................................................................15 3.2 Normalisation of the Signal vs. Metadata .......................................................................16 3.3 Using the Measure Loudness Range ..............................................................................19 3.4 Climbing the True Peak ............................................................................................20 4. Strategies for Loudness Normalisation................................................... 21 4.1 Production, Post-Production ......................................................................................21 4.2 Loudness Metering for Production and Post-Production ......................................................23 4.3 “Ready, Set (Levels), GO!”........................................................................................24 4.4 Loudness Range for Production and Post-Production .........................................................26 5. What to Measure in Production and Post-Production................................. 28 5.1 Signal-Independent vs. Anchor-Based Normalisation..........................................................28 5.2 Low Frequency Effects (LFE) Channel ...........................................................................29 6. File-Based Production and Playout ....................................................... 30 6.1 Building Blocks ......................................................................................................31 6.2 Generic Loudness Levelling Strategies - Processing ...........................................................32 7. Metadata ....................................................................................... 34 7.1 Programme Loudness Metadata ..................................................................................35 7.2 Dynamic Range Control Metadata ................................................................................35 7.3 Downmix Coefficients ..............................................................................................37 8. Alignment of Signals in the Light of Loudness Normalisation ....................... 38 8.1 Alignment Signal and Level........................................................................................38 8.2 Listening Level ......................................................................................................39 9. Implementation and Migration ............................................................ 40 9.1 Generic Migration and Implementation Advice ................................................................40 9.2 10 Points of Action for Migration and Implementation .......................................................41 5 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Tech 3343v2 10. Genre-specific Issues ........................................................................ 41 10.1 Commercials (Advertisements) and Trailers....................................................................42 10.2 Music..................................................................................................................43 11. References..................................................................................... 44 Acknowledgements Although this document is the result of much collaborative work within the EBU’s PLOUD group, it is the long-suffering chairman of this group, Florian Camerer, who has first written, collated, enriched and distilled the text into its publication form over many, many weeks and months of effort. Dedication This document is dedicated to two great audio engineers; Gerhard Stoll and Gerhard Steinke. 6 Tech 3343v2 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Practical guidelines for Production and Implementation in accordance with EBU R 128 EBU Committee First Issued Revised Re-issued Technical Committee 2011 Aug. 2011 Keywords: Audio, Loudness, normalisation, production, implementation. 1. Introduction This document describes in practical detail one of the most fundamental changes in the history of audio in broadcasting; the change of the levelling paradigm from peak normalisation to loudness normalisation. It cannot be emphasized enough that loudness metering and loudness normalisation signify a true audio levelling revolution. This change is vital because of the problem which has become a major source of irritation for television and radio audiences around the world; that of the jump in audio levels at the breaks in programmes, between programmes and between channels (see footnote 2 for a definition of ‘programme’). The loudness-levelling paradigm affects all stages of an audio broadcast signal, from production to distribution and transmission. Thus, the ultimate goal is to harmonise audio loudness levels to achieve an equal universal loudness level for the benefit of the listener. It must be emphasised right away that this does not mean that the loudness level shall be all the time constant and uniform within a programme, on the contrary! Loudness normalisation shall ensure that the average loudness of the whole programme is the same for all programmes; within a programme the loudness level can of course vary according to artistic and technical needs. With a new (true) peak level and the (for most cases) lower average loudness level the possible dynamic range (or rather ‘Loudness Range’; see § 2.2) is actually greater than with current peak normalisation and mixing practices in broadcasting. The basis of the concept of loudness normalisation is a combination of EBU Technical Recommendation R 128 ‘Loudness normalisation and permitted maximum level of audio signals’ [1] and Recommendation ITU-R BS.1770 ‘Algorithms to measure audio programme loudness and true-peak audio level’ [2]. 7 Practical guidelines for Production & Implementation in accordance with R 128 Tech 3343v2 In addition to R 128, the EBU PLOUD group has published four other documents: EBU Tech Doc 3341 ‘Loudness Metering: ‘EBU Mode’ metering to supplement loudness normalisation in accordance with EBU R 128’ [3] EBU Tech Doc 3342 ‘Loudness Range: A measure to supplement loudness normalisation in accordance with EBU R 128’ [4] EBU Tech Doc 3343 ‘Practical guidelines for Production and Implementation in accordance