KCL-2020-56 Imprints of Axion Superradiance in the CMB Diego Blas1, ∗ and Samuel J. Witte2, y 1Theoretical Particle Physics and Cosmology Group, Department of Physics, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, UK 2Instituto de F´ısica Corpuscular (IFIC), CSIC-Universitat de Val`encia,Spain −10 Light axions (ma . 10 eV) can form dense clouds around rapidly rotating astrophysical black holes via a mechanism known as rotational superradiance. The coupling between axions and photons induces a parametric resonance, arising from the stimulated decay of the axion cloud, which can rapidly convert regions of large axion number densities into an enormous flux of low-energy photons. In this work we consider the phenomenological implications of a superradiant axion cloud undergoing resonant decay. We show that the low energy photons produced from such events will be absorbed over cosmologically short distances, potentially inducing massive shockwaves that heat and ionize the IGM over Mpc scales. These shockwaves may leave observable imprints in the form of anisotropic spectral distortions or inhomogeneous features in the optical depth. I. INTRODUCTION slowly decay via the emission of gravitational waves, with amplitudes that may be detectable in future ex- The evidence for the existence of dark matter is abun- periments [20{25]. Observations of highly rotating black dant in both cosmology and astrophysics, however its un- holes have consequently been used to probe and con- derlying nature has evaded detection efforts for decades. strain light non-interacting bosons with masses in the −21 −10 The axion, a pseudo goldstone boson arising from the range 10 . mφ . 10 eV [9, 20, 21, 24{28]. The existence of self-interactions or couplings to other breaking of a global UPQ(1) symmetry, has recently emerged as one of the most favored dark matter candi- particles may complicate and quench the superradiant dates. Originally introduced as a solution to the strong- growth; for example, in the case of the axion, self- CP problem [1{4], it was soon realized that light axions interactions become important when the field value a −3 approaches the axion decay constant f , and may pro- ma . 10 eV were both cosmologically stable and could a be abundantly produced in the early Universe via the duce an explosion known as a `bosenova' [9, 20]. Particle misalignment mechanism [5{8]. Ultralight bosonic fields production and scattering processes may dramatically in- have also been predicted to naturally appear from moduli crease the characteristic timescale required to extract the compactification in string theory [9, 10]; while these par- black hole's angular momentum, and thus provide a natu- ticles do not solve the strong-CP problem, they behave ral way for evading current superradiant constraints [29{ in a comparable manner to the QCD axion, and thus 31]. More recently, it has been pointed out that the are frequently referred to as axion-like particles. In what parametric resonance arising from the repeated stimu- follows, we will use the word `axion' interchangeably to lated decay of a superradiant axion cloud may quench refer to both. the growth, producing in the process an enormous flux −10 of low energy photons [26, 32{34]. While initial stud- Light axions with masses ma . 10 eV are known to trigger instabilities around rotating astrophysical black ies of this phenomenon assumed adiabatic evolution in a holes, even if their initial abundance is negligibly small. flat-spacetime, recent work has demonstrated that axion This processes, known as black hole superradiance, pro- fields coupled to electromagnetism in Kerr background duces an exponentially growing boson cloud at the robustly exhibit this phenomenon, so long as the axion- expense of the black hole's rotational energy [11{16] photon coupling exceeds a threshold value [33, 34]. (see [17] for a recent review on rotational superradiance In this work we investigate the phenomenological im- and its application to black hole physics). In the limit plications that would arise from the resonant decay of a that the axion's interactions can be neglected (that is, superradiant axion cloud. We show that the low energy arXiv:2009.10074v2 [astro-ph.CO] 3 Nov 2020 the limit that the axion's equation of motion is governed photons produced in the resonant decay have short cos- by the Klein-Gordon equation), the axion cloud will grow mological mean free paths, and are typically absorbed until either the superradiant condition, given by ! < mΩ over ∼ O(pc) scales. This leads to enormous pressure { with ! the energy of the mode, m the azimuthal quan- gradients, which can induce a shockwave thats heats tum number and Ω the rotational frequency{ is vio- and ionizes the surrounding medium as the shock front lated or a significant fraction of the black hole's rota- pushes outward. We show that these shockwaves leave tional energy has been extracted1; this cloud will then anisotropic features in the spectrum and optical depth of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB); individual ∗ e-mail: [email protected] y e-mail: [email protected] bility is robust against gravitational emission, back-reaction on 1 Current work suggests the appearance and growth of the insta- the metric, and the presence of accretion disks [18, 19]. 2 features for a single black hole may be detectable with is [38{40] near-future spectral distortion experiments, while large- 2 scale features arising from the cumulative distribution Ma ∼ 1600 (GM) fa ; (4) of black holes may be near current detection thresholds, we emphasize that this relation was computed for however this latter point requires a more dedicated study. G maM ∼ 0:4 only, and the scaling with this parame- This manuscript is organized as follows. We review ter has not yet been rigorously tested. Should the axion the phenomenon of axion induced black hole superradi- field grow to this point, a bosenova may ensue in which ance in Sec. II, including possible outcomes (specifically axions are partially ejected and partially absorbed by the we focus on the possibility of either a bosenova or photon black hole. Axions, however, generically couple to elec- production via resonant decay). In Sec. III we discuss the tromagnetism via propagation of the low energy photons in the IGM, and gaγγ the subsequent formation and properties of the shock- L ⊃ − a F µν F~ ; (5) 2 µν wave. Observable features arising from such shockwaves are discussed in Sec.IV. We conclude in Sec.V. where F and F~ are the electromagnetic field strength tensor and its dual; this coupling generates a two-body decay to photons, which in the case of non-relativistic II. AXION SUPERRADIANCE axions are approximately monochromatic with energies Eγ ∼ ma=2. If the axion field is sufficiently dense and the Rotational superradiance is a phenomenon that occurs energy distribution sufficiently narrow, the production of when a low energy boson with energy ! < mΩ scatters off photons at this frequency via axion decays may stimu- an absorbing surface rotating with frequency Ω (m here late the decay of the other axions in the cloud [41{48]3. being the azimuthal quantum number). In this scatter- This processes is typically suppressed in conventional as- ing process, the amplitude of the reflected boson field is trophysical and cosmological environments, due to either enhanced with respect to the incident amplitude. Should the finite width of the axion momentum distribution or there exist a confining mechanism for the reflected radi- gravitational de-tuning (see e.g. [46, 47]); superradiant ation, this process will extract the rotational energy at axion fields naturally evade these concerns, however, due an exponential rate until the growth is quenched by ad- to their enormous densities. Should the resonant decay of ditional interactions or the superradiant condition is no a superradiant axion cloud occur, an enormous burst of longer satisfied. monochromatic low-energy photons will be emitted that In the context of black hole superradiance, a non-zero will propagate away from the black hole and into the particle mass naturally acts to confine the light boson IGM. around the black hole, and exponential growth can occur. It has recently been shown numerically that an axion The timescale of the instability is directly related to the field coupled to electromagnetism in a Kerr metric does mass of boson ma and the black hole M, and for the indeed induce this parametric resonant decay, but only case of scalar particles can be as large as (in the limit if the axion-photon coupling is sufficiently large. The 2 G maM 1 )[20, 35{37] condition derived on axion-photons couplings for which this occurs is given by [33, 34] M 0:2 9 τ ∼ 102 s : (1) r M 1 sr 10 M G m M −19 −1 a gaγγ & 10 2 GeV : (6) Ma (G ma M) The size of the generated axion cloud is approximately One can compare the fractional mass in the axion cloud given by at the time of a bosenova with that at the time of the (` + n + 1)2 GM electromagnetic burst (i.e. Eq. (4) with Eq. (6)); assum- 4 rcloud ∼ 2 ; (2) ing fa ∼ 1=gaγγ one finds the axion decay occurs prior (G maM) which extends well beyond the horizon where rotational effects can be neglected. 3 It is worth mentioning that the difference between the resonant Assuming the axion potential is given by the conven- decay of the axion field (i.e. the focus of this work) and the stim- tional ulated decay discussed in [49, 50], is that the latter does not assume photons produced from the decays of axions contribute 2 2 a to the photon occupation number responsible for stimulating the V (φ) = ma fa 1 − cos ; (3) decay; rather, the photon occupation number is assumed only fa to arise from CMB photons, galactic synchrotron and free-free non-linear self-interactions of the axion may become im- emission, etc.