to 1 February 2013 Development Panel Will meet on Tuesday 12 February 2013 at 1.00 pm in The Wave - Maryport Membership: Councillor Peter Bales (Chairman) Councillor John (Binky) Armstrong Councillor Carole Armstrong Councillor Bill Bacon Councillor Nicky Cockburn Councillor John Crouch Councillor Len Davies Councillor Bill Finlay Councillor Chris Garrard Councillor Joe Holliday Councillor Margaret Jackson Councillor William Jefferson Councillor Peter Kendall Councillor Jim Lister Councillor Billy Miskelly Councillor Ron Munby Councillor Margaret Snaith Councillor Sam Standage Councillor Martin Wood Councillor Joan Wright Members of the public are welcome to attend the meeting. If you ha ve any questions or queries contact Paula McKenzie on 01900 702557. The following Site Visits will take place: 2/2012/0601 – New 2/3 bedroom dwelling, rear of Hollybank, Gilcrux, Wigton. 2/2012/0789 – Change of use of land to provide community garden area, site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. 2/2012/0823 – Erection of raised patio, external staircase and boundary wall (Retrospective), 52 High Street, Maryport. Members of the Development Panel will be picked up from The Wave Centre, Maryport and the bus will leave at 10.10am prompt. Lunch will be provided at The Wave Centre, Maryport for Members of the Panel. Agenda 1. Minute s (Pages 1 - 20) To sign as a correct record the minutes of the meeting held on Tuesday 8 January 2013. 2. Apologies for absence 3. Declaration of Interest Councillors/Staff to give notice of any disclosable pecuniary interest, other registrable interest or any other interest and the nature of that interest relating to any item on the agenda in accordance with the adopted Code of Conduct. 4. Questions To answer questions from members of the public – 2 days notice of which must have been given in writing or by electronic mail. 5. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0823 - Raised patio, staircase and wall - 52 High Street, Maryport (Pages 21 - 32) 6. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0789 - Community garden area - Garth Road, Westfield, Workington (Pages 33 - 42) 7. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0601 - Dwelling - Rear of Hollybank, Gilcrux (Pages 43 - 52) 8. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0837 - Outline for 74 dwellings - Land adjoining King Street, Wigton (Pages 53 - 78) 9. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0594 - 3 Wind Turbines - Land at Potato Pot, Branthwaite (Pages 79 - 124) 10. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0603 - Wind Turbine - Prospect House, High Scales, Aspatria (Pages 125 - 148) 11. Development Panel - 2-2012 -0700 - Wind Turbine - How End Farm, Thursby (Pages 149 - 172) 12. Development Panel - 02 -2012 -9011 - 4 Turbines - Lillyhall Landfill Site, Workington (Pages 173 - 186) 13. Appeal Decision - 2-2012 -0371 - 2 Pairs Semi Detached Dwellings - Gavel Street/Sandy Lonning, Maryport (Pages 187 - 188) 14. Appeal Decision - 2-2011 -0745 - Dwelling - Rear of 129 Main Street, Dearham, Maryport (Pages 189 - 192) 15. Appeal Decision - 2-2012 -0699 - Proposed extension - 6 Moorfields, Broughton Moor, Maryport (Pages 193 - 196) 16. Appeal Decision - 2-2012 -0437 - Extension - 8 Heatherfields, Broughton Moor, Maryport (Pages 197 - 198) Corporate Director Date of next meeting Tuesday 26 February 2013 at 1.00 pm The Wave - Maryport This page is intentionally left blank Agenda Item 1 At a meeting of the Development Panel held in The Wave - Maryport on Tuesday 8 January 2013 at 1.00 pm Members P Bales (Chairman) J Armstrong C M Jackson C M Armstrong W H Jefferson B Bacon P G Kendall N Cockburn J Lister J Crouch B Miskelly L Davies R Munby B Finlay S Standage C Garrard M G Wood J Holliday J Wright Apologies for absence were received from Councillors M A Snaith. Staff Present A Dennett, K Kerrigan, S Long and P McKenzie. 439 Minutes The minutes of the meeting held on Tuesday 11 December 2012 were signed as a correct record subject to the following amendments; Councillor Kendall be added to the attendance, Councillor J Lister be added to the site visit attendance and minute 428 reason for refusal which reads A5096 be amended to read A596. 440 Declaration of Interest 5. Development Panel - 2/2012/0683 - Householder alterations - Strand House, 5 Strand Street, Maryport. Councillors Peter Kendall and Martin Wood; Other Registrable Interests; 2/2012/0683 - Due to being members of Maryport Town Council. 6. Development Panel - 2/2012/0770 - Listed building consent for alterations to domestic dwelling - Strand House, 5 Strand Street, Maryport. Councillors Peter Kendall and Martin Wood; Other Registrable Interests; 2/2012/0770 - Due to being members of Maryport Town Council. 7. Development Panel - 2/2012/0759 - Outline for erection of 3 dwellings - Land Adjacent to Hillside, Plumbland, Aspatria. Councillor Jim Lister; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0759 - Due to being a member of Cumbria County Council. Page 1 8. Development Panel - 2/2012/0810 - Change of use from laundrette to pizza/burger take-away - 79 Harrington Road, Workington. Councillors Carole Armstrong; Bill Bacon; Peter Bales; Billy Miskelly and Joan Wright; Other Registrable Interests; 2/2012/0810 - Due to being members of Workington Town Council. 8. Development Panel - 2/2012/0810 - Change of use from laundrette to pizza/burger take-away - 79 Harrington Road, Workington. Councillor Joe Holliday; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0810 - Due to being the Ward Councillor and living in the area. 9. Development Panel - 2/2012/0601 - Erection of 3 bed dwelling - Land to rear of Hollybank House, Gilcrux. Councillor Jim Lister; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0601 - Due to being a member of Cumbria County Council. 10. Development Panel - 2/2012/0740 - Outline for residential development - Land at Brough Hill, Bolton Low Houses. Councillor Jim Lister; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0740 - Due to being a member of Cumbria County Council. 10. Development Panel - 2/2012/0740 - Outline for residential development - Land at Brough Hill, Bolton Low Houses. Councillor John (Binky) Armstrong; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0740 - Due to knowing the applicant. 11. Development Panel - 2/2012/0823 - Erection of raised patio, external staircase and boundary wall - 52 High Street, Maryport. Councillors Peter Kendall and Martin Wood; Other Registrable Interests; 2/2012/0823 - Due to being members of Maryport Town Council. 13. Development Panel - 2/2012/0789 - Change of use of land to provide community garden area - Site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. Councillors Bill Bacon and Billy Miskelly; Other Registrable Interests; 2/2012/0789 - Due to being members of Workington Town Council. 13. Development Panel - 2/2012/0789 - Change of use of land to provide community garden area - Site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. Councillor Carole Armstrong; Disclosable Pecuniary Interest; 2/2012/0789 - Due to being a member of Workington Town Council and being part of the original bid. 13. Development Panel - 2/2012/0789 - Change of use of land to provide community garden area - Site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. Councillor Joan Wright; Disclosable Pecuniary Interest; 2/2012/0789 - Due to being a member of Westfield Housing Association. 13. Development Panel - 2/2012/0789 - Change of use of land to provide community garden area - Site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. Page 2 Councillor Peter Bales; Disclosable Pecuniary Interest; 2/2012/0789 - Due to being a member of Workington Town Council and Westfield Housing Association. 13. Development Panel - 2/2012/0789 - Change of use of land to provide community garden area - Site at Garth Road, Westfield, Workington. Councillor Ron Munby; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0789 - Due to being a member of Cumbria County Council. 15. Development Panel - 2/2012/0859 - Extension to porch - 1 St Kentigerns Way, Aspatria. Councillor Bill Finlay; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0859 - Due to being the Ward Councillor. 15. Development Panel - 2/2012/0859 - Extension to porch - 1 St Kentigerns Way, Aspatria. Councillor Jim Lister; Other Registrable Interest; 2/2012/0859 - Due to being a member of Cumbria County Council. 441 Questions None received. 442 Site Visits The following Councillors were present at the site inspections, planning references 2/2012/0683 and 2/2012/0770, Strand House, 5 Strand Street, Maryport. J Armstrong, C Armstrong, B Bacon, P Bales, N Cockburn, L Davies, B Finlay, C Garrard, J Holliday, W Jefferson, M Jackson, P Kendall, J Lister, B Miskelly, S Standage, M Wood and J Wright. 443 Development Panel - 2/2012/0683 - Householder alterations - Strand House, 5 Strand Street, Maryport The application: Remove existing roof, velux windows and chimney stacks, replace roof and incorporate 3 dormer windows and chimney. Replace all windows with white upvc double glazed. Black composite door to rear. Demolish rear boundary wall and garage and build new garage, Strand House, 5 Strand Street, Maryport. The Principal Planning Officer recommended refusal. The Principal Planning Officer outlined the application and detailed the main issues within the report. Councillor W Jefferson moved refusal. This was seconded by Councillor M Jackson. Councillor P Kendall moved approval. This was seconded by Councillor M Wood. Page 3 A vote was taken, 7 in favour of approval, 12 against and 0 abstentions. The motion in favour of approval was lost. A vote was taken, 12 in favour of refusal, 7 against and 0 abstentions. The motion in favour of refusal was carried. The decision: Refused. Reason: 1. The proposed dormer windows would constitute an unsympathetic