The ABC's changing role as a provider of education television programs Grahame Ramsay School of Humanities and Applied Social Sciences Nepean College of Advanced Education The ABC's role as a telecaster of educational programs has undergone fundamental change since it became a corporation. Yet these changes have not attracted the publicity and debate that alterations to the ABC Television's evening schedule have. TV transmission that was once tailored to State needs is now beamed nationally by satellite. Advisory links between the ABC and State Education Departments have been severed. Copyright continues to present problems and the provision of entertainment and education programs for children has been merged under the control of one department. This paper examines the ABC's former role as a producer of educational television programs, looks at the recent policy changes, and suggests some possibilities for the future. It also considers the rise of alternatives to the ABC in education program making and distribution. The provision of educational programs for schools has always been a major component of the Australian Broadcasting Commission's daytime television scheduling. These programs demonstrate a distinctive feature of the ABC as a public service broadcaster and represent an obvious difference from commercial television where daytime offerings have been dominated by chat shows and soap operas. But since the ABC became a Corporation, there have been changes in the structure, philosophy and approach of the ABC to educational programs. The ABC Education Department has been abolished and replaced by a hybrid Department called "Children's and Education (TV)". National satellite transmission has replaced state-based programming. Repeats of evening programs are a 32 Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 1988, 4(1) feature at midday and the number of new education programs produced for schools has dropped. These changes have not occasioned the public discussion which was produced by alterations to the evening schedule. Yet the long-term implications are no less dramatic and crucial to the shape of Australian public service broadcasting. In January 1987, the ABC launched a new program guide called ABC Daytime. It replaced previous guides to ABC television and radio education programs. The change was more than cosmetic. For the first time programs from "Infants" to "Adult" were included in the one publication. The change meant that education programs were no longer provided to each State at times to suit variations in that State's school holidays. In the past, separate program guides were introduced which reflected those differences between States. In the past some programs, such as Perth's Here in the West, had been designed for transmission in only one State, but now the output of programs has been centralised. This also mirrors the organisational centralism of the new ABC. Educational program making had always been an important function of the B.A.P.H. (Brisbane, Adelaide, Perth, Hobart) States. Television crews in these smaller States could expect to do items for news and current affairs and education. The education programs often provided opportunities for creative work beyond the more routine news tasks. The award-winning educational series Six Australians was produced in Adelaide. Hobart produced a long-running series of science programs called Hunter, Queensland Education produced Northern Australian Documentaries and Perth produced programs in the For the Juniors series. The diversity of locations reflected Australia's geographical diversity. This approach has not been completely abandoned, but the new Children's and Education Department (TV) locates all Executive Producer authority and supervision in Melbourne and Sydney. These changes have not come about because of any detailed judgment of a need to radically alter education program-making. Some reappraisal of the place of educational television in the ABC may indeed be necessary, but the radical reoganisation of ABC Education has preceded rather than followed such a review. The Dix Committee (1981) saw no need to combine the operation of the Children's and Education Departments recognising the need for their separate roles within the ABC (Dix, 1981, 11.219). Thus taking thc word "education" out of the Logo ABC Daytime is no mere publicity push, but represents a major shift in the ABC's commitment to education program production, especially programs for schools. This Ramsay 33 development raises basic questions about the appropriate role of the ABC in providing education programs. The debate has raged within the ABC for some years under different guises. The ABC Education Department has been viewed as a low priority area in terms of resources because it did not offer programs to the adult evening audience. Public discussion of educational television has been limited. Such programs as Playschool have been singled out for praise, but for the most part ABC educational programs have been accepted without comment as part of the ABC's output. There is, however, an important national audience for programs. It does not show up as television ratings because it's not an audience watching at home. ABC surveys have indicated that ABC education programs are being used by teachers throughout Australia. The popularity of programs varies but the most popular program, according to the latest research, was Behind the News. This was used by more than two thirds of primary teachers in Australia in 1986 and reached an estimated 900,000 primary children. (Palmer & Black, 1987b, p21). These audiences will be at risk if the quality or quantity of education programs diminishes. The effect of the reorganisation of ABC Education has been masked by the large number of repeat programs still filling the daytime schedule. As the years go on, the amount of new ABC-produced material will drop to be replaced by overseas programs and dual purpose/co-productions aimed at a nebulous adult/upper secondary audience. This is despite the fact that primary programs have attracted the ABC's largest school audiences. The response of the State Education Departments has been tempered by their own budget restraints. When cutbacks to the ABC education service were mooted in June 1985, the NSW Education Department responded by threatening to reduce its liaison services to the ABC. In practice this threat has become a reality with the reduction nationally of liaison officers seconded from Education to the ABC. The relationship between the ABC and State Education systems is an interesting issue. The Dix Committee, noting that Schools were primarily a State and not a Federal responsibility, recommended that the provision of funds and other forms of support for any major expansion of ABC education broadcasts should be a matter for negotiations between the ABC and the appropriate State education authorities (Dix, 1981, 15.164). Senator Evans 1988 discussion retains "Education" as a core charter activity of the ABC but the service to schools is still at risk with further budget cuts. The new Corporation Act contained a clause requiring the ABC to "take account of the responsibilities of the States in relation to education" (ABC Act, 1983, 6: 2). The ABC Corporate Plan (1985) simply avoided the issue, stating that there would be no increase in education or children's programming in the immediate future (p 12). 34 Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 1988, 4(1) This paper, as a way of placing recent events into context, will consider the way educational television developed in the ABC. This will involve some clarification of the nature of educational television programs. It also requires the study of the evolution of ABC Education until the ABC became a Corporation, and the consideration of the internal reorganisation in recent years. 1. The nature of education television The use of the term "education" and "educational" applied to television programs presents peculiar problems. A common theme that has been found is that a popular view of educational programs is "those programs made for schools" (Bates, 1977, p8). Yet at the International Conference on Education and Research in Educational Television and Radio at the Open University in 1976 there were papers on educational broadcasting for Universities and Colleges as well as schools (Bates, 1977, 1). The Dix Committee (1981) felt the need to indicate that its use of the term "education", in a chapter on the ABC's educational programs, was "material designed for specific learning purposes rather than material of a generally educative nature" (15 2). This is an important distinction. The rescheduling of programs such as Four Corners and Big Country in daytime viewing and their popularity in schools surveys (Palmer & Black, 1987a, p20) indicates that general programming can be used for "educational" purposes. This does not negate the need for series designed specifically with a schools audience in mind. The Gilmour Committee (1979) noted the importance of "series" in its definition of educational programs: Educational broadcasting, is broadcasting with predetermined educational objectives, normally planned in a series, which are designed to lead to the mastery of a body of knowledge (p2). All these definitions fit the pattern of development of educational series within the ABC until 1984. Since that time structural change and the policy of senior management have led to the production of some programs designed more to meet co-production objectives than educational ones. It is, however, important to go beyond these definitions to look at the kind of programs produced in the pre-1980 period, "Educational television" conjures up, for some, images of direct teaching by a television lecturer. In fact this approach had not been used by the ABC since 1968 (Dix Ramsay 35 Committee, 1881, 15.8), but old images die hard. When Richard Thomas, then Head of ABC Television, first met a group of educational television producers he told them that "he was not familiar with ABC education programs but he hoped they did not include any teachers and blackboards" (Meeting of staff, 13th September, 1984).