[27/09/2011 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED. THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in INDEX PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS J-1 TO J- REGULAR MATTERS --------------------> R-1 TO R-38 FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ------> F-1 TO F- 9 APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST) 67 TO 74 (FIRST PART) APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST) 75 TO 80 (SECOND PART) COMPANY ----------------------------> 81 TO 81 ORIGINAL SIDE Supplementary (I)-----> 82 TO 95 SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY----------------> 96 TO 106 THIRD SUPPLEMENTARY-----------------> - TO - NOTES 1. There is no item no. 52 in the Cause list of Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw 2. Regular Matters listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Valmiki J. Mehta will be heard Subject-wise in the following manner : LIST-I -- RFA -- FIRST & THIRD WEEK OF THE MONTH LIST-II -- FAO -- SECOND & FOURTH WEEK OF THE MONTH 3. Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ajit Bharihoke will not be holding Court today. Dates will be given by the Court Master. DELETIONS 1. CONT.CASE APPL. 15/2011 listed before Hon'ble DB-III at item no.4 is deleted as the same is a decided matter. 2. W.P.(C)2164/2010 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Kailash Gambhir at item no.13 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw with W.P.(C)11348/2009 3. MAC. APPEAL 320/2009 listed before Hon'ble Ms. Justice Indermeet Kaur at item no.39 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.L. Mehta. 4. CRL.A. 968/2008 listed before Sh. P.S.Chaggar, Registrar(O) at item no. 17 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble DB-VII. REGISTRAR (LISTING)] 27.09.2011 J - 1 FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS(APPLT. JURISDICTION) 27.09.2011 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS ON 27.09.2011 COURT NO. 30 EXTENSION BLOCK (FIRST FLOOR) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VALMIKI J.MEHTA AT 10.30 AM 1. RFA 393/2002 JAI PARKASH GUPTA SAMEER DEWAN VS ORIENTAL BANK GUNJAN KUMAR OF COMMERCE SARAN SURI HIGH COURT OF DELHI 26TH SEPTEMBER,2011 REGISTRAR (LISTING) 27.09.2011 R-1 ( Regular Matters) 27.09.2011 REGULAR MATTERS COURT NO. 1 (DIVISION BENCH-1) HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA [Note: This list will remain in operation for the whole week from Monday to Friday.] CASES OF PERSONS ABOVE 65 YRS. OF AGE (SENIOR CITIZENS) 1. W.P.(C) 6907/2002 ALL INDIA RETD.BANK MANOJ SWARUP,R.P. VIRES EMP.ASSOC. KAPUR,ARCHANA GAUR,YASHRAJ NO. 1 SUB TO O/N PH Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS SINGH DEORA 1A. RFA(OS) 39/2002 AIR MARSHAL SATISH C.LAL AND ANR. ZUBEDA BEGUM, RAJIV WITH RFA(OS) 18./2003 Vs. J.J.SINGH AND ORS. BEHL,RAJIV BEHL 1B. RFA(OS) 93/2009 SARVAJIT SINGH SAREEN AKSHAY MAKHIJA,SK BHADURI,S P Vs. RITU MENON AND ORS PANDEY REGULAR MATTERS NO.72A.W.P.(C) 1974/2011,NO.72B.W.P.(C) 2280/2011---FOR 31.10.11 (NO.2 TO 69-----PART HEARD MATTERS) 2 . ITA 348/2009--------| THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX RASHMI CHOPRA PH Vs. RAJENDER KUMAR AGGARWAL 3 . ITA 586/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX PREM LATA BANSAL, SALIL Vs. SANDEEP GULATI KAPOOR 4 . ITA 588/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX PREM LATA BANSAL, SALIL DELHI VIII KAPOOR, SANJEEV SABHARWAL | Vs. MANIT GULATI 5 . ITA 597/2009 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX PREM LATA BANSAL, SALIL Vs. SANDEEP GULATI KAPOOR, SANJEEV SABHARWAL 6 . ITA 598/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX PREM LATA BANSAL, SALIL DELHI VIII KAPOOR Vs. MANTI GULATI 7 . ITA 908/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI RASHMI CHOPRA Vs. BEMCOM JEWELLERS P.LTD. SANJEEV SABHARWAL 8 . ITA 1090/2009 | THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME SONIA MATHUR CM APPL. 15482/2009 TAX XIII SANJEEV SABHARWAL Vs. RAJENDER KUMAR AGGARWAL 9 . ITA 1164/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX SUBHASHH BANSAL Vs. S.S. CORPORATE SANJEEV SABHARWAL SECURITIES LTD. 10. ITA 1268/2009 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX SANJEEV SABHARWAL | Vs. PREM SINGH 11. ITA 1384/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L. BANSAL, P NAGESH CM APPL. 17909/2009 DELHI SANJEEV SABHARWAL Vs. CSL SECURITIES PVT. LTD. 12. ITA 1054/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L. BANSAL, P NAGESH, DELHI SANJEEV SABHARWAL | Vs. CSL SECURITIES PVT. LTD. 13. ITA 1144/2009 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L. BANSAL, SALIL KAPOOR, Vs. JAOGINDER KAPOOR SANJEEV SABHARWAL 14. ITA 26/2010 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX RASHMI CHOPRA Vs.GREEN SHIEL PLANTATION LTD. 27.09.2011 R-2 ( Regular Matters) 15. ITA 127/2010 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX SONIA MATHUR, PC YADAV, CM APPL. 1314/2010 | Vs. KUNAL RASTOGI SANJEEV SABHARWAL 16. ITA 515/2010 | THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX RASHMI CHOPRA Vs. ANIL KUMAR 17. ITA 1434/2010 | CIT PL BANSAL,RANI KIYALA & OTHER CONNECTED Vs. BONANZA PORTFOLIO LTD CASES Note:For remaining regular matters please see list dt. 13.09.11. PART-I(CAT) 70A.W.P.(C) 1293/2011 UOI AND ANR RV SINHA,DINESH AGNANI TOP Vs. SC SURLIYA AND ORS PART-II 124A. W.P.(C) 2741/2011 V A JOSHI AND ORS SANJEEV NARULA,SACHIN DATTA VIRES Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ANR IST 5 CASES COURT NO. 2 (DIVISION BENCH-2) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SIDDHARTH MRIDUL [ Note: In regular matters & final hearing matters , the parties should keep ready,short synopsis running into not more than 3 pages each. NOTE:Regular Matters will be heard day-wise in the following manner: i) PART – I -------- MONDAY,TUESDAY & FRIDAY . ii) PART – II ------- THURSDAY. iii)PART – III ------ WEDNESDAY.] PART - I REGULAR MATTERS NO.4 TO 10----NOT THIS WEEK 1 . ITA 486/2011-----------| DIRECTOR INCOME TAX SANJEEV SABHARWAL,SALIL NO.1/SUB TO O/N/PH Vs. RIO TINTO TECHNICAL KAPOOR | SERVICES | 2 . ITA 491/2011 | DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX SANJEEV SABHARWAL,SALIL NO.1/SUB TO O/N/PH | Vs. RIO TINTO TECHNICAL KAPOOR SERVICES | 3 . ITA 492/2011 | DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX SANJEEV SABHARWAL,SALIL NO.1/SUB TO O/N/PH---| Vs. RIO TINTO TECHNICAL KAPOOR SERVICES 11. RFA(OS) 7/2008-----| SAHNI INTERNATIONAL P. LTD. P.R.AGGARWAL,SANJEEV IST 5 CASES Vs. NISHA RAJ AND ORS. ANAND,DIBYA NISHANT,KAJAL | CHANDRA,RAJIV K. NANDA 12. RFA(OS) 8/2008 VARINDER SAHNI DALPEE K.DHAYANI,SANJEEV IST 5 CASES----| Vs. NISHA RAJ AND ORS. ANAND,KAJAL CHANDRA,D. NISHANT,PR AGGARWAL,Y.S.SHARMA 13. W.P.(C) 13392/2009----| HEMINDER KUMARI PRAKASH KUMAR,SONIA MATHUR IST 5 CASES | Vs. DEPUTY COMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 14 .W.P.(C) 13769/2009 | SEHGAL CONSULTANTS MADHAV KHANNA,A. MARATHA IST 5 CASES Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 27.09.2011 R-3 ( Regular Matters) 15 .W.P.(C) 13775/2009 | HAMDAAN EXPORTS NEW DELHI MADHAV KHURANA,A. MARATHA IST 5 CASES Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 16 .W.P.(C) 13812/2009 | JAGAT SINGH PRAKASH KUMAR,A. MARATHA IST 5 CASES Vs. ASSISTANT COMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 17 .W.P.(C) 14042/2009 | ADITYA KHANNA BN GOSWAMI,A. MARATHA IST 5 CASES Vs. ASST COMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 18 .W.P.(C) 6837/2010 | HEMINDER KUMARI PRAKASH KUMAR IST 5 CASES Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 19 .W.P.(C) 6843/2010 | JAGAT SINGH PRAKASH KUMAR IST 5 CASES Vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF | INCOME TAX 20 .W.P.(C) 8243/2010 | K.NATWAR SINGH PRAKASH KUMAR IST 5 CASES | Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX | CIRCLE-40(1),NEW DELHI 21 .W.P.(C) 6344/2011-----| K. NATWAR SINGH PRAKASH KUMAR,RASHMI CHOPRA IST 5 CASES Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 22 .ITR 49-50/1996------| C.I.T. BABITA, J.R. GOEL IST 10 CASES | Vs. DELHI PRESS PATRA PRAKASHAN LTD. AND ANR. | 23 .ITA 151/2002 | CIT PL BANSAL,MEERA BHATIA,JAYAA IST 10 CASES | Vs. DELHI PRESS PATRA VERMA PRAKASHAN LTD | 24 .ITA 302/2002 | CIT SUBHASH C SHARMA,OP DUA SR. IST 10 CASES Vs. DELHI PRESS PATRA ADV,RITU MEHTA,JAYAA VERMA PRAKASHAN LTD | 25 .ITA 480/2005 | THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L.BANSAL CM APPL. 9540/2005 Vs. DELHI PRESS PATRA IST 10 CASES PRAKASHAN LT 26 .ITA 1732/2006 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L.BANSAL,VISHNU SHARMA, IST 10 CASES Vs.DELH PRESS PATRA PRAKASHAN BABITA,O.P.DUA,BABITA,JAYAA VERMA 27 .ITA 1733/2006 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DEL P.L.BANSAL,VISHNU SHARMA, IST 10 CASES Vs.DELHI PRESS PATRA PRAKASHAN BABITA,O.P.DUA,JAYAA VERMA 28 .ITA 1734/2006 | COMMISSIONEER OF INCOME TAX P L BANSAL,VISHNU SHARMA, IST 10 CASES | Vs.DELHI PRESS PATRA PRAKASHAN BABITA,O P DUA,JAYAA VERMA 29 .ITA 451/2010 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX PRAKASH YADAV AND NP IST 10 CASES | Vs. DELHI PRESS PATRA SAHNI,UTPAL SAHA,JAYAA VERMA PRAKASHAN LTD | 30 .ITA 779/2010 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX N.P. SAHNI AND PRAKASH CHAND IST 10 CASES-----| Vs. M/S DELHI PRESS PATRA YADAV,UTPAL SAHA,JAYAA VEMA PRAKASHAN LTD. 31 .W.P.(C) 5216/2010 VINOD GOEL RK GUPTA,AMANPREET RAHI,DP IST 10 CASES Vs. HIGH COURT OF DELHI GUPTA,SNIGDHA SARVARIA,RK THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR GENERAL SAINI,SATYA MITRA GARG AND ORS 32 .ITA 562/2008--------| COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX P.L.BANSAL,BHAKTI PASRIJA, IST 20 CASES DELHI SANJEEV SABHARWAL,BHARAT TYAGI | Vs. SUNAERO LTD. | 27.09.2011 R-4 ( Regular Matters) 33 .ITA 867/2008 | COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI P.L.BANSAL,BHAKTI PASRIJ IST 20 CASES Vs.