Arxiv:1807.04520V2 [Q-Bio.NC] 16 Jul 2018 1 Introduction 2

Arxiv:1807.04520V2 [Q-Bio.NC] 16 Jul 2018 1 Introduction 2

Elements of Consciousness and Cognition. Biology, Mathematic, Physics and Panpsychism: an Information Topology Perspective Pierre Baudot Inserm UNIS UMR1072 - Universit´eAix-Marseille AMU, Facult´ede M´edecine- Secteur Nord, 51, Boulevard Pierre Dramard, 13015 Marseille, France [email protected] 16th July 2018 Abstract This review presents recent and older results on elementary quantitative and qualitative aspects of con- sciousness and cognition and tackles the question "What is consciousness?" conjointly from biological, neuroscience- cognitive, physical and mathematical points of view. It proposes to unify various results and theories by means of algebraic topology and puts forward the suggestion that information topology is a particularly appropriate formalism to achieve such an aim. The resulting discrete probabilistic and group theoretic principles and structures governing the theory of consciousness underline its Galoisian nature. The first chapter presents the postulates and results on elementary perception in psychophysics and neuro- science at various organizational scales of the nervous system and proposes the hypothesis of an electrody- namic intrinsic nature of consciousness which is sustained by an analogical code. It underlines the diversity of the learning mechanisms that sustain the dynamics of perception and consciousness, including adaptive and homeostatic processes on multiple scales, and details their current generic expression within probability and information theory. The second chapter investigates the logical aspects of cognition and consciousness and proposes an axioma- tization based on measure and probability theory. Topos and constructive logic are presented as providing an intrinsic non-deterministic-probabilistic logic, with the long-term aim of avoiding the paradoxical decom- position induced by the Axiom of Choice. Using such a basis, we sketch an elementary procedure allowing an expression of the information of a mathematical formula a la G¨odel. We then present the formalism of information topology and propose that it provides a preliminary basis for synthesizing the main models of cognition and consciousness within a formal Gestalt theory. Information topology establishes a characteriza- tion of information theory functions, allowing for a precise expression of information structures and patterns. It provides a quantification of the structure of statistical interactions and their expression in terms of sta- tistical physics and machine learning. Notably, those topological methods allow conciliation of some of the main theories of consciousness, namely integrated information theory, the global neuronal workspace model, the free energy principle and logical dynamics. The topological approach points out that consciousness is a structural phenomenon arising from collective interactions. Underlining the central role of invariance to transformation in neuroscience and perception, we further propose a possible correspondence of information topology with dynamical system theory and the related quantification of arousal states. Contents arXiv:1807.04520v2 [q-bio.NC] 16 Jul 2018 1 Introduction 2 2 Neurobiology and psychophysics, electrophysiology of elementary perception 3 2.1 "Unity and Diversity" [1] . 3 2.2 The neuronal postulate - neural assemblies - neural coding - shapes of memory and qualia . 3 2.2.1 The neuronal/biological postulate - physical reductionism . 3 2.2.2 Consciousness: the electromagnetic view - "Where is my mind?" . 4 2.2.3 Neural coding - neural assemblies - synchrony - noise . 8 2.2.4 Psychophysics - Fechner and Gestalt's heritage . 12 2.3 Active consciousness - plasticity, adaptation homeostasis - Dynamic and persistence of qualia . 15 2.3.1 Action-perception inseparability . 15 2.3.2 Plasticity - (machine) learning - Informational and Statistical physic of consciousness dynamic 15 2.3.3 Homeostatic plasticity - consciousness invariance . 18 3 Mathematic, cognition and consciousness 20 1 3.1 Mathematical nature of consciousness . 20 3.1.1 Empirical proof of the mathematical nature of consciousness: subjective axioms . 20 3.1.2 Mathematic, a model of cognition . 21 3.2 Constructive logic, information topos and e-motivs . 22 3.2.1 Measure Theory: a mathematical theory of subjective and objective experience-observation 22 3.2.2 Probability, the logic of thoughts, the geometry of beliefs . 24 3.2.3 Topos: the consistent diversity of truths and beliefs . 26 3.2.4 Information functions and set theory . 29 3.2.5 The information of a formula/thought . 31 3.3 Homology, the shapes and the language of perception . 34 3.3.1 Homological history and cognition . 34 3.3.2 Groups and action: ambiguity and uncertainty according to Galois . 35 3.3.3 What is topology? . 37 3.3.4 Information topology synthesis: consciousness's complexes and thermodynamic . 40 3.4 Dynamics, Geometries, action invariance and Homeostasis of consciousness . 46 3.4.1 The invariances to group actions of perception . 46 3.4.2 Geometrical and Topological invariance, isomorphism . 48 3.4.3 Dynamical aspects of information, isomorphism, stability, and homeostasis . 48 3.5 Computational mind - from Cybernetic and AI to biological beliefs . 50 3.5.1 Computation, machines and consciousness . 51 3.5.2 Computational hardness of consciousness . 51 4 Conclusion - the global ecological synthesis 52 A The topology of psychophysic according to Poincar´e 53 B The objective poetry 54 1 Introduction A theory of consciousness concerns anyone and should be a theory of anyone: a theory of everybody and every- body's theory. It should be consensual and hence should acknowledge and account for the diversity of all beings (bodies). It should account for and respect the consciousness of anybody, and encompass without contradiction all the hardly countable investigations that have treated consciousness in its different forms and aspects: bio- logical, physical, psychological, mathematical, computational, etc. Consciousness and qualitative perception is also one of the main topics of theology and art; hence, a theory of consciousness should also be theological and artistic, at least minimally, such that it does not contradict the diversity of theologies and art that human minds have formalized and which are some of the central forms of human consciousness and cognition. To avoid the usual dualist oppositions, it is necessary to precise that seen from the world of probability explored here, atheism is also a system or a form of human belief, which also enriches the complex landscape of diverse consciousness and thoughts. As a consequence, the road towards such a theory appears difficult, and, while we do not achieve it here, we instead propose some ideas towards what the aims of a theory of consciousness that respects and harmoniously verifies its own axioms (which we consider firstly and in a literal sense to be unity and diversity, as proposed by Tononi and Edelman [1]), would be. In the mathematical section of the paper following [2], we present the formalization of the probability theory within topos theory and constructive logic, a logic with multi-valuations in which the excluded third is not a theorem (independent). Such constructive logic could un- derline the idea that those beliefs classically considered as complementary opposite statements - dualism - may indeed refer to a diversity of beliefs - pluralism. It provides a preliminary soft non-deterministic rationality that further provides a legitimate rational status to free will. This should not be understood as a novel, personal or established theory of consciousness, and all the more a closed and definitive framework. Information topology is simply a name proposed because two existing, partially established theories, information theory and a central branch of algebraic topology appear indistinguishable, and should ultimately be, just one. Such unification is currently only partially understood. As emphasized in the ecological mind conclusion, we simply present, recycle and combine, in a consistent fashion, well-established results (which is a cognitive task of associative memory), such that the resulting theory is the least partial possible. In short, there is no claim of originality or novelty, just as in the case of consciousness itself: "Novelty is as old as the world" (Prevert); hence this paper's status as a review and perspective. An important part of the ideas presented here are inherited from Bennequin and are the result of a long-lasting collaboration. Notably, the formalization of visual processing as regards invariance is developed at length in [3]. In the world of ideas, nothing is lost, nothing is created, everything transforms. We will focus on an old intuitionist idea of a mathematical and physical nature of our subjective being, and even of our most elementary perceptions. 2 The main ideas of the review (without analytical requirements) are expressed quite synthetically in the following citations of Riemann and Poincar´ethat introduce both consciousness and a topological view on it: "When we think a given thought, then the meaning of this thought is expressed in the shape of the corresponding neurophys- iological process." Riemann [4] "Now what is science? ...it is before all a classification, a manner of bringing together facts which appear separate, though they are bound together by some natural and hidden kinship. Sci- ence, in other words, is a system of relations. ...it is in relations alone that objectivity must be sought. ...it is relations alone which can

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    73 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us