www.vidhigya.in LEGAL READING SUPPLEMENTS SEPTEMBER 2020 MUST READ ARTICLES FOR LAW ASPIRANTS COMPILED BY Vidhigya is a Great Institute to prepare for a Glorious Career in Law. -Legal Legend Late Mr. Ram Jethmalani OUR INCEPTION Vidhigya is a venture by NLU alumni team working under guidance of Judges and internationally renowned academicians. It is Central India's premier Law Entrance Exam Preps institute for Judicial Services Exam (Civil Judge) and CLAT. Vidhigya is undisputed leader with Central India's Biggest Faculty Team dedicated to our only center in India at Indore. At Vidhigya, our passion and dedication is not just to teach but to nurture LAW, LIFE & LEADERSHIP in you. We have been producing Mr. Ram Jethmalani interacting with Director Mr. Bahul Shastri while launching Vidhigya Online phenomenal results for last 7 years in exams like Portal at Vidhigya Campus various Law Entrance Exams. VIDHIGYA is proud producer of CLAT 2020 MP & Chhattisgarh State Rank -1, Aman Patidar (Exclusive Classroom Student of Vidhigya). In CLAT 2019, we produced 73 NLU selections including 20 in Top 3 NLUs which is highest ever in history of Indore. Vidhigya is not merely a Coaching, it is a GURUKUL FOR LAW ASPIRANTS Prof. (Dr.) R. Venkata Rao, Ex Vice Chancellor, NLSIU Bengaluru Inaugurating Vidhigya Campus. Developing LAWsense Nurturing CLANurturing LAWTtitudetitude Shaping CarW eers in Laeers in LA w Shaping Car Nurturing Law Life Leadership CLATST s at I am thankful to my mentor Vidhigya for filling me with confidence and capability.ever to I will be indebted for 1 STATE them. To all the champions out RANK there have faith and patience, keep working for your ultimate MP & CG goal. As Bahul Sir says k Works". "Only Wor AIR 14 Aman Padar St. Paul H.S. School, Indore NLSIU, Bengaluru VIDHIGYANS MAKING IT LARGE @ NLSIU, BENGALURU Tanay Kaushal Jerrin Mathew Siddhant Bahe Nayan Anand Akshat Baldawa Ashi Gautam IBP Global Academy St. Arnold's HS. School The Emerald Heights Brilliant Academy, Subhash H.S. School, St. Raphael's H.S. School Ujjain Indore Internaonal School, Indore Indore Indore Indore VIDHIGYANS MAKING IT LARGE @ NLU, DELHI 1 CITY RANK AILET Sanika Gadgil NLU Delhi Chelsea Sawlani Vaidehi Pendam Lavesh Verma Amit Malviya Akshat Baldawa Jerrin Mathew Tanay Kaushal St. Raphaels HS. School Choithram School Delhi Public School St. Paul HS School MG Convent HS School Subhash HS School St. Arnold's HS School IBP Global Academy Indore Indore Indore Indore Sajapur Indore Indore Ujjain VIDHIGYANS MAKING IT LARGE @ VIDHIGYANS MAKING IT LARGE @ NALSAR, HYDERABAD WBNUJS, KOLKATA Tanu Rajangaokar Minal Nihore Krupashankar Damade Hemant Chouhan Vaidehi Pendam Mantasha Khaishagi Srish Solanki The Shishukunj School St. Raphael's School St. Mary's School JNV Delhi Public School Shri Kanwartara School Gyansagar Academy Indore Indore Harda Ujjain Indore Mandleshwar Ujjain MUMBAI HIGHEST NLU SELECTIONS SYMBIOSIS MHCET NMIMS from INDORE CLASSROOM Programme year on year STATE CITY RANK1 RANK1 AIR 2 2018 2019 2020 Siddharth Shambhavi Parv Sisodiya Shani Pancholi Choithram School, St. Raphael’s School, St. Paul School, 73 69 Indore Indore Indore 55 EVERY 8TH STUDENT OF RD 197 NLU SELECTIONS IN EVERY 3 VIDHIGYAN (YLP) CLAT 2018, 2019 & 2020 NLIU, Bhopal 2019 is a Vidhigyan made it to NLUs in CLAT 2019 (Highest ever in the history of Indore) * All Genuine Selecons from Vidhigya Classroom Programme CLAT 2020 VIDHIGYANS MAKING IT LARGE @ NLIU, BHOPAL AKSHITA DHAWAN PRABHAV SHARMA MUSKAN CHOURASIA HARSHIT AGNIHOTRI NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal St. Raphael’s HS School Indore St. Thomas HS. School Badnagar Laurel's International Indore Govt. Excellence School Rewa SALONI AGRAWAL SIDDHARTH SISODIYA VIBHA THAKUR SHILPA RAWAT NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal St. Raphael’s HS School Indore Choithram School Indore Kendriya Vidhyalaya, Dhar Catholic Mission, Jhabua KAMINI MORE ASHUTOSH DUHAREY RADHA CHARPOTA ARYAN JAIN MP RANK-1 NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal AIR-14 Queens' College Indore CSC School Ujjain Sri Guru Tegbahadur Academy Ratlam St. Micheal's Sr. Secondary School AMAN PATIDAR St. Paul H. S School, Indore NLSIU, Bengaluru GEETIKA MANDLOI MAYANK JOSHI SANIKA GADGIL AURA PANDEY NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal Sophia Convent School Khandwa SICA School Indore St. Rapheals HS. School Indore Shishukunj School Indore MP RANK-10 MP RANK-14 AIR-77 AIR-110 SIDDHANT BAHETI TANU RAJANGAOKAR The Emerald Heights School, Indore The Shishukunj International, Indore NLSIU, Bengaluru NALSAR, Hyderabad HIMANSHI MAHAJAN UDDHAV TIWARI ADHIR LOT DIVYANI SOLANKI NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal St. Marry's Convent School Dewas Vindhyachal Academy Dewas St Paul HS School Indore Queens' College Indore MP RANK-21 MP RANK-24 AIR-187 AIR-212 MANTASHA KHAISHAGI RISHITA SETHI Shri Kanwartara School, Mandleshwar Choithram School, Indore WBNUJS, Kolkata NLIU, Bhopal PRAGATI MANDLOI ANUSHREE BHALAVI ANUGYA MUKATI PRATEEK TAYAL NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal Queens' College Indore Kendriya Vidhyalay, Seoni St. Raphael’s H.S. School Sanmati H.S. School MP RANK-25 MP RANK-30 AIR-222 AIR-285 SRISHTI SOLANKI SARISHA VERMA SHIVAM RATHORE RAKESH MALVIYA CHELSEA SAWLANI Gyansagar Academy, Ujjain The Shishukunj International, Indore NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal NLIU Bhopal WBNUJS, Kolkata NLIU, Bhopal St. Marry's Convent School Harda Pushpa H.S. School, Astha Choithram School, Indore READING SUPPLEMENT LEGAL REASONING – Sept. 2020 TOPICS 1. Privacy Versus Morality: An Indian Gordian Knot *By Faisal C K 2. Sub-Classification and Reservation *By Dr. Abhinav Chandrachud 3. Justice Arun Mishra's Controversial Tenure Leaves Questions on Public Confidence in Judiciary *By Manu Sebastian 4. Why The Default Sentence In Prashant Bhushan's Contempt Case Is Erroneous? *By Tahir Ashraf Siddiqui 5. Parliamentary Privileges and the Fundamental Right to Free Speech: A Conundrum of the Conflicting Entitlements *By Masoom Reza 6. Can the Govt. Unilaterally Scrap Question Hour During the Entire Parliament Session? *By P.D.T. Achary 7. Ruth Bader Ginsberg: The Greatest Liberal Judge of Our Times *By Santosh Paul 8. Is the Central Government Bound To Pay GST Compensation To The States? *By Rabindra Kumar Mitra 9. Taking Misuse of National Security Act Seriously *By Dr. Lokendra Malik 10. Self-Regulation Code for OTT Platforms, A Need Of The Hour VIDHIGYA - CLAT Tutorials| Indore | online.vidhigya.in | 9039799000 1 READING SUPPLEMENT LEGAL REASONING – Sept. 2020 *By Eshvar Girish & Kritika Trivedi 11. Vodafone v. India – End of a Saga? *By Pushkar Anand 12. A wage code that is a hasty composition *By K. Chandru 13. Stop press: On blanket gag order against the media *By The Hindu Editorial 14. A demarcation in the interest of public order *By Mukul Sanwal 15. Official Secrets Act: Colonial Hangover or Protection for Nation? *By Shreyashi Roy 16. Where Does Press Freedom End and Trial by Media Begin? *By Raghav Tankha 17. Electronic Gazette Will Take Effect Only After It Is Uploaded: Centre Loses Appeal in SC *By V. Venkatesan 18. The Supreme Court's Greatest Gift Is the PIL and It Is Here to Stay, Whatever Critics May Say *By Dushyant Dave 19. Why the offences of Cheating and Breach of Trust are antithetical to each other *By Bhomesh R Bellam VIDHIGYA - CLAT Tutorials| Indore | online.vidhigya.in | 9039799000 2 READING SUPPLEMENT LEGAL REASONING – Sept. 2020 20. NCLAT at a Glance: August 2020 *By Swaroop George 21. Validity of split or hybrid arbitration agreement used by banks and financial institutions: Two possible views and foreseeable issues *By Aaditya Vijaykumar VIDHIGYA - CLAT Tutorials| Indore | online.vidhigya.in | 9039799000 3 READING SUPPLEMENT LEGAL REASONING – Sept. 2020 Sneak Peek: No. of words: 1258 words Note: In this article author is critically analyzing the historic Judgement of Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India. The Author establishes the nexus between law and morality with the help of various Court decisions. As a CLAT aspirant, you should have a fair idea about it. Article: 1 Privacy Versus Morality: An Indian Gordian Knot Two years after historic judgment in Navtej Singh Johar case, an age-old debate in legal philosophy is revisited Sir Edward Coke, in his The Institutes of the Laws of England, (1628) famously said: "a man's house is his castle" What was meant by 'castle' was defined in 1763 by the British Prime Minister Sir William Pitt: "The poorest man may in his cottage bid defiance to all the forces of the crown. It may be frail - its roof may shake - the wind may blow through it - the storm may enter - the rain may enter - but the King of England cannot enter." These pronouncements constitute the embryonic form of the concept of privacy. John Stuart Mill philosophically elaborated the right to privacy. According to Mill, both state and society posed threat to individual autonomy and the right to make choice and privacy. Mill defended the right of the individual to freedom. "it is being left to oneself; all restraints qua restraints is an evil". In its positive sense, it meant the grant of the largest and the greatest possible amount of freedom for the pursuit of the individual's happiness, creative impulses, energies, and for self-development. Thus, Mill excellently conceived the right to privacy, individual autonomy and rational choice. He reiterated the dichotomy of self- regarding and the other-regarding actions of individual. As far as self-regarding actions are concerned, an individual is sovereign. He argued that each individual has liberty to live as he pleased. Each individual is the best judge to assess his own interests and diversity should be honored. J.S. Mill vehemently opposed moral policing. Majority in state and society tend to project itself as the controller of social opinion and an agent of social tyranny.